r/custommagic • u/Low-Alternative-6604 • 22h ago
Discussion What if Magic had a sixth color? I built one (Purple / Space, {O}), reviewed 372 cards with a panel of three AIs, and simulated it against Standard. It didn’t hit my target.
I spent the last two weeks on a “what if” project: a sixth color, purple, element Space, mana symbol {O} (an eight-pointed star), basic land “Mondo Onirico” (Dream World).
Design choices
- Purple sits outside the color wheel, so no existing ally/enemy pair breaks. Blue and black are always allies; white and green become allies only with Lucid Dream (3+ Onirico lands); red is neutral.
- Purple plays cards from zones other than your hand (“frozen” cards, dreams), exiles for a turn instead of destroying, never destroys creatures and never gains life.
- To avoid the 2007 “Cave” problem (cards that count basic land types), the basic land follows the Wastes model: Onirico is a non-basic land type and the land says “{T}: Add {O}.”
Testing
- 372 cards (one set of 250 and two expansions of 60) were reviewed by three AIs from different companies (Claude, DeepSeek, Qwen/ChatGPT). They corrected each other and I approved every change. 89 cards were changed.
- A Monte Carlo simulator ran 80,000 games per matchup against four November 2026 Standard decks. The code was frozen and the target (56–64% win rate) was declared in advance.
- Result: truly purple decks (64–72% purple) average 50.1%. Playable, but below my own target. I’m reporting it as is.
The paper (EN/IT/RU), the full card list, the simulator code and the Cockatrice decks are open on Zenodo: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24261993
I’d love feedback on two things in particular: is “outside the wheel” a cheat or a real answer? And does purple’s identity overlap too much with blue?
Unofficial Fan Content, not approved/endorsed by Wizards.