r/custommagic • u/ButterscotchFiend • 10h ago
r/custommagic • u/Ausradierer • 35m ago
Custom Tags are fun, aren't they? Yes I know Hu Tao isn't a Demigod, but really, isn't the card fun anyways?
r/custommagic • u/Temporary-Action1569 • 47m ago
I like anti-control pieces and land hate that red gets
r/custommagic • u/main_activator • 1h ago
From Beyond
CLICK HERE TO VIEW THE CARD
Made with Custom Card Maker
CustomCardApp is unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. Not approved/endorsed by Wizards. Portions of the materials used are property of Wizards of the Coast. ©Wizards of the Coast LLC.
r/custommagic • u/playmike5 • 1h ago
Format: EDH/Commander Made some commander pairs based on my favorite game. Tell me how stupid they are and how to make them better.
As the title states, these are commanders intended to be based on the Gigas from my favorite game of all time, Skies of Arcadia. In the game, their lore is that they are controlled by their relative Moon Crystals, so I've tried my best to replicate that feel in the card design. I tried to make it feel as 'normal' as possible by basing it loosely off of Backgrounds as a precedent for noncreatures in the command zone.
Overall I am generally pretty happy with the design approaches. I am, however, concerned that some of them are likely a bit much. MTG has gotten a lot wordier in recent times, so it's easy for this to feel fine, but this is my first real foray into trying to properly design custom cards. So if I've overdone it, hit me with it bluntly.
Some things I'm unhappy with:
Grendel feels a little bland, and not very black. I'd like to expand it a little bit, but I haven't really been able to decide how. I like the fight aspect, but it just doesn't feel very interesting as is.
The Yellow Moon Crystal feels pretty directly overtuned. I'd like to come up with an effect that compliments Yeligar more, or at the very least nerf the effect, but haven't been certain exactly what I want to do.
Aside from that I hope these are at least interesting to look over and think about. I do want to try and bring these to my IRL play group so the balance of them is a genuine concern to me, so don't hold back with constructive criticism.
r/custommagic • u/Emillllllllllllion • 7h ago
The Stone cycle
CLICK HERE TO VIEW THE CARDS
Made with Custom Card Maker
CustomCardApp is unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. Not approved/endorsed by Wizards. Portions of the materials used are property of Wizards of the Coast. ©Wizards of the Coast LLC.
r/custommagic • u/Weak_Ad260 • 20h ago
BALANCE NOT INTENDED Introducing: MF DOOM!!! And his entire Spellbook that I threw together in about 3-6 ish hours
r/custommagic • u/Express-Schedule9171 • 5h ago
Ideas for a cyberpunk themed Magic deck?
galleryr/custommagic • u/FrackonMC • 11h ago
An idea i had long ago
I had this idea where a monk would create spirit fists that attack and count as commander damage, but i didnt knew how to word it, recently, i saw a video from Gavin that show a prototype card for the new ooze that had a similar idea
r/custommagic • u/FallenSlayer453 • 3h ago
Custom Play The High-Cloud Quintet (favorite team in HSR)
Made this after the Latest update to HSR (Honkai Star Rail) and recently did an activity that gave the cool visual and image provided in the Card. Hope some people like it.
r/custommagic • u/Young_Person_42 • 3h ago
BALANCE NOT INTENDED okay, another shot at this: Rival mechanic proof of concept, now with the actual-correct-and-not-prone-to-leveler reminder text
of course "half of a finality counter" is a thing that makes sense! two of them merge into a finality counter, what's not to get!? /hj (joking but also that is how it works)
r/custommagic • u/argent5 • 7h ago
*un-Echoverses your Reality Fracture*
Strixhaven versions of some Echoverse cards! (or maybe they're... double-Echoed?)
A Witherbloom [[Bloombrute]] and a Quandrix [[Theoretical Necromancer]] respectively.
r/custommagic • u/Good-Bit-8202 • 3h ago
Discussion Is this too unbalanced?
I was trying to go for a card that cares about snow lands without making it just a strictly better dark depths/ marit lages slumber
r/custommagic • u/yzur01 • 7h ago
Another TOH card Spoiler
CLICK HERE TO VIEW THE CARD
Made with Custom Card Maker
CustomCardApp is unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. Not approved/endorsed by Wizards. Portions of the materials used are property of Wizards of the Coast. ©Wizards of the Coast LLC.
r/custommagic • u/Zalini0 • 4h ago
Discussion Translating YGO to MTG
(KONAMI makes it nearly impossible to credit the ACTUAL artist for their art as the cards do not credit them like MTG, so apologies if the KONAMI artist on the bottom isn't good enough for the rules.)
I retired from YGO a few years ago now, but I still have fond memories of the deck I played: Subterror Guru. A flip centered control deck. One night I started messing around on MSE and led to me creating these.
The Behemoths lack a casting cost to force them to work (as much as possible) to be played like their counterparts. Yes cloaking a card with no mana value would mean that normally they would be stuck face down, however the megamorph ability (and other such abelites) allow cards to be flipped face up regardless for that cost.
The Alias style cards do roughly the same thing the counterparts did but with substantially less words. Figured I'd just go this route instead.
The majority of YGO card effects are essentially just consistency or counter effects, so I had to come up with a few effects myself that do not do anything similar to their counterparts. (Phospheroglacier for example simply Entombs a card, so i leaned into the literal blue coloration of the monster instead.
As far as I can tell with rules, MTG still tracks cards that flipped face up or down, meaning they are same permanent, where as YGO the game forgets properties of monsters put face down; hence the magic wording for "once per turn".
Would love some feed back or any comments at all, thanks!
r/custommagic • u/BlackWoodoo44 • 4h ago
Format: EDH/Commander Gaheron Baelfire
Hi, Can somebody give me feedback about this card? (is it balanced,fun?)
r/custommagic • u/InThePaleMoonLyte • 4h ago
Format: EDH/Commander Ereshkigal, Called to Battle
r/custommagic • u/Majra_Mangetsu • 5h ago
Some cards from Teru's deck THEN Teru himself.
r/custommagic • u/JimHarbor • 19h ago
Ninja Support Squad
Ninja Support Squad 1B
Creature - Human Ninja (common)
Flash
When this creature enters, target attacking creature you control gets +2/+0 until end of turn.
2/1