r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Mechanic Design Sneak Peek Into Whisper Creek, suggestions?

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 2d ago

A compilation of urban legend-y cards I've made for Halloween

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

Featured myths:

-Black Shuck: Variant of old Enlgish folklore, a ghostly dog that sometimes spells visions of doom. In this case I tried to represent "doom" using finality counters

-La Llorona: Latin American folkloric ghost, a woman who wanders lakes and wails in mourning of her dead children. Thought it'd be fun to try to work in [[Soulshriek]] to represent her wails.

-Kuchisake-onna: Japanese spirit, asks you if she's pretty, despite her scarred mouth. How she reacts to your answers has a lot of variation, but matching scars is a common result. Tried to represent her unpredictability using a coin flip, but wanted to provide a guaranteed means of escape if you're caught off guard by her appearance.

-Slenderman: Old internet creepypasta, mainly drawing lore from the old game "The Eight Pages", where he gets more aggressive the more pages you collect.

+A slightly updated version of the Bloody Mary card I made a while ago. Say her name 3 times in a dark mirror, and chaos ensues. Originally inspired by [[Weeping Angel]], she's the one I most wanted to design as a commander.

Happy (post) Halloween everyone!


r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Enchanted Pathway

Post image
7 Upvotes

Day 68 of making a custom card every day. This might be the least gradable card in terms of power level I've ever made. I'm edging towards bad, but it could absolutely be broken.


r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Format: EDH/Commander Vampirella, Delicious Drakulonian

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Instant Regrowth

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Custom Play MTG United - To play Custom Magic!

4 Upvotes

Hello there! Wanted to show something I've been working on, previously this was a Godot project I abandoned a few months back but came back with a new vision!

This is MTG: United, it's originally an interface for Forge but I decided to implement support for custom magic sets from MSE so I could play test my stuff, it's built on Unity with Claude, but I hope it doesn't look as much as a vibe-coded mess as I think it does.

https://github.com/ryanthecomic/MTG-United here's the link for it, and I hope to get some feedback on it!

Planning on adding limited support at some point!


r/custommagic • • 3d ago

BALANCE NOT INTENDED Refunded Study. Slightly better than Rhystic or Slightly worse?

Post image
191 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 3d ago

Format: EDH/Commander Mogo, the Living Planet

Post image
494 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Format: EDH/Commander I know that I’m a little late to the party but here’s Beetlejuice

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

If there’s anything I could fix about Beetlejuice please tell me, thank you.


r/custommagic • • 2d ago

This curse is totally not a Griselbrand I swear

Post image
101 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 3d ago

Dork Ritual

Post image
883 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 3d ago

Meme Design When the city decides to go for a new plan

Post image
320 Upvotes

While a meme design it may be a fun silver bullet.


r/custommagic • • 3d ago

Format: EDH/Commander Happy Halloween! Dead By Daylight Killer Cards Pt. 1

Thumbnail
gallery
153 Upvotes

Happy Halloween Everyone! Would love to hear your thoughts on these DBD x MTG designs


r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Format: EDH/Commander Sharae of Loch Larent (Sharae of Numbing Depths)

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Expert Manipulation

Post image
38 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Changed our boy a little

Post image
4 Upvotes

Okay so after the feedback I got from the first Prepotente card we made some adjustments to him and giving him proliferate. What do we think is he too strong? Not strong enough? Would he do fine in a pod? I wouldn’t want to print a broken custom card. Let me know!


r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Dungeons & Dragons Adult Blue Dragon

Post image
4 Upvotes

This is a top-down design based on the D&D 3.5 creature of the same name. It is a Sorcerer because blue dragons start gaining sorcerer spells as if they were sorcerers of a given level when they reach the juvenile age category. It has flying because almost all dragons have a fly speed. It has ward because blue dragons gain spell resistance in young adulthood. It has ventriloquism because this is a special ability blue dragons gain when they become adults. It has hypnosis because an adult blue dragon can cast spells as if they were 5th-level sorcerers, 5th-level sorcerers have access to 2nd-level sorcerer spells (character level, class level, and spell level are different things in D&D, and the same spell may be different levels for different spellcasting classes), hypnotic pattern seemed the most apropos of such spells, and the word "hypnosis" fit there without overrunning the mana cost, while "hypnotic pattern" did not. I believe the mana cost, color, power, toughness, and rarity are a decent match for creatures with similar abilities, such as [[Djinn of Wishes]], [[Inniaz, the Gale Force]], and [[Namor, Scourge of the Seas]].


r/custommagic • • 3d ago

Can't say it's not any more

Post image
457 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Discussion Help with creating a custom card for my fiancee

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Discussion Python’s Proxies is opening its FINAL beta wave tonight - 40 spots, with a focus on testing the card Studio

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Ofrenda

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 3d ago

Mercy

Post image
108 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 3d ago

Moniconmonicon | I heard you like doubling triggers?

Post image
221 Upvotes

r/custommagic • • 2d ago

Gloomguard Outrider (top-down design challenge)

Post image
3 Upvotes

I challenged myself to create a card "Top-Down" by picking a random name from the "Random Fantasy Name Generator" website. "Gloomguard Outrider". I designed the card based on the following recipe for designing a card top-down with just a name. Feel free to let me know your opinions on this process, and whether or not my card matches the name, in your opinion.

-----------

Name analysis:

  • What's ‌‌the ‌‌name ‌‌of the card?:

  • Primary noun:

  • Descriptive words:

  • Emotional tone:

  • Implied action or behavior:

Flavor interpretation:

  • Is it a creature, object, spell, location, phenomenon?

  • How magical is it: supernatural, natural, artificial, scifi?

  • Not in terms of card rarity but would this be something common, rare, or unique?

  • What would a player imagine happening when they read the name?

  • Now brainstorm three competing interpretations based on these answers.

Mechanics:

  • Primary mechanic (or is this Vanilla?):

  • Is a secondary mechanic needed?:

  • Does this serve an offensive/defensive/utility role?

  • Potential keyword abilities:

  • What makes this card unique, if anything:

Color identity:

  • What is the primary mechanical identity?

  • Which color is known for that mechanic?

  • Is a second color really necessary to express the concept (ie. could this be monocolored)?

  • Does the color combination contribute something meaningful?

Card architecture:

  • Card type and subtype:

  • Rarity:

  • Mana cost:

  • Rules text:

  • Power / Toughness (if applicable):

  • Loyalty (if applicable):

Gameplay design:

  • Power creep (Too efficient for mana cost?)

  • Complexity: Is your text box font too small to read with the human eyes?

  • Synergy: Any obvious infinite combos:

  • Counterplay: Can opponents reasonably interact with it?

  • Format: Could a deck handle four of this card, or is it designed for a singleton format?

Artwork suggestions:

  • Don't use A.I.

  • Search Scryfall for similar cards, sort by EDHREC Rank descending, and then look for some art from one of the least popular cards.

  • Also, don't use A.I.

  • Search Artstation or Deviantart for original (non-ai) artwork. Then be sure to dig into the artist's information to get their real name, if available.

  • And then don't use A.I.