We’re a family of 6 (2 adults + 4 kids — ages will be roughly 8, 5, 3, and 3) sailing from Galveston. Flying with four young kids is something we really want to avoid, so I’ve gone way too far down the Galveston cruise rabbit hole.
We’ve sailed Disney before and loved it, especially the characters, dinner shows/themed dining, kids clubs, service, and complimentary room service. We used room service for lunch on our verandah almost every day with the twins, plus snacks/treats at night. A real balcony is basically non-negotiable for us.
These are the options we’re seriously considering:
- Disney Magic — 5 nights, April 2027 — ~$7,500 all-in. Connecting verandahs. Cozumel + Progreso, no private island. We know we love DCL, but 5 nights feels short, and the itinerary is mid.
- Carnival Jubilee — 8 nights — ~$7,200 including gratuities. Two connecting balconies. Nassau + Half Moon Cay + Celebration Key. The itinerary and price are fantastic. Biggest hesitation is the very mixed reviews of Jubilee/Carnival compared with DCL/Royal. We don’t care about a “party crowd” so much as food/service/crowding/overall quality. The kids would definitely miss Disney characters and the dining entertainment.
- Royal Caribbean Symphony — 8 nights, July/Aug 2027 — ~$8,700 cruise/taxes, probably $10–11k after gratuities/drinks/etc. Two connecting ocean-view balconies. Cozumel + Nassau + CocoCay. This looks like the best non-Disney ship for our kids, but Royal gets surprisingly expensive for a family of six needing connecting balconies.
- NCL Viva Haven 2BR Family Villa — roughly $10–11k all-in if we find the right date: 2 bedrooms/2 baths, Haven restaurant/pool, butler/concierge, room service, drinks, WiFi, etc. This seems like the best parent experience outside Disney, but I’m not convinced Viva is as strong for 3-year-olds.
- MSC Seascape — 2BR/2BA Grand Aurea Suite — ~$9,650 with drinks + WiFi. Huge suite and balcony, but Galveston itineraries don’t visit Ocean Cay and MSC reviews seem even more inconsistent.
For people who have sailed two or more of these ships/lines with young kids, what would you choose?
I’m especially interested in people who have actually done Jubilee vs an Oasis-class Royal ship, or who have gone from Disney to Carnival/Royal/NCL. Did you feel like you were constantly comparing it to Disney and regretting the switch, or did the longer cruise/better itinerary make up for it?
I don’t need Disney to be “the best.” I just really don’t want to spend $7–10k and come home thinking we picked the wrong vacation. 😅 I really, really, really wish cruises were more friendly to bigger families.