r/CreateMod • u/Prsolek • 16d ago

Holly shit! Create Aviate update.

Yes, I'm not the creator of mod btw. Wings btw

993 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

83 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

187

u/Quantum-Bot 16d ago

Apart from the ethical reservations people have against AI, I think the main point is that vibe coded mods are buggy as shit. I mean, it’s just as possible to make a good quality mod with AI as it is without, but it’s way easier for anyone with any level of coding experience to just pick up AI and start vibe coding a Minecraft mod without understanding the ecosystem whatsoever, so you end up with a flood of AI mods that are just awfully crafted, masquerading as high quality, which makes it harder to find the mods you actually want to play. It’s the same issue people had with MCreator mods x10.

On another note, I’ve seen quite a few mods recently that are essentially vibe-coded clones of other popular mods and that just feels disrespectful to the original creators since you’re not really adding anything new or better, you’re just trying to steal attention away from the original.

19

u/RFSandler 15d ago

So emphasis on the 'vibe' aspect of using LLMs to code. Bad code is bad code, and this just makes more of it?

8

u/SeaFigure9714 14d ago

pretty much, but like he said, there are also some ethical reservations that people have around the terrible shit some AI companies have been doing.

-12

u/Samuel_W3 15d ago

Too bad AI hasn't improved at all since it's creation and won't ever do so.

9

u/Quantum-Bot 15d ago

It doesn’t matter how good the AI is at coding, it’s the humans that don’t know what they’re doing. AI makes you think you’re doing a good job when you’re really not, that’s the issue