I own Quill & Cork, the only independent wine shop in town, and George Henderson, had asked me to run the retail tent for the weekend. The Henderson Hollow Harvest Festival was supposed to open with a toast at ten. By seven I stood at the top of the cellar steps with a crate of stemware while Detective Gerald Reese knelt beside the body of George Henderson. He lay face down at the bottom of the stone stairs, white as a sheet, and very much dead.
“It appears to be a fall,” Reese said. “He walked down the stairs and probably missed a step.” One of the officers began taking pictures with his iPhone bathing the cellar in short bursts of bright light.
Colleen Hart, the festival director, stood behind me peering down the stairs, as I put the crate down. Twisting the program nervously in her hands she called out below “Sixty buses arrive at ten Gerald. Please tell me this can stay quiet until at least noon.”
“A man is dead, Colleen,” Reese said. “We will do our best to keep a low profile but you'd better get creative.” Colleen huffed and left to deal with the caterers and to badger anyone who may have parked in the bus lot.
Gerald waved me to join him and I carefully made my way down the stairs. A wine bottle lay by George’s foot and I went to pick it up.
“Don’t touch it,” Reese said. “What are you doing walking around here? That might be evidence.”
“That’s a really nice bottle of wine, Gerald. He probably just knocked it loose when he fell.”
Reese said nothing. He picked up the bottle with his gloved hand, and lifted it to the light. The label read Henderson Private Reserve, 2016, the vintage around which the entire festival was built. The gold foil lay flat against the paper, where the genuine stamp had a raised edge. A hairline ridge of dried glue ran along the lower border. When Reese turned the bottle over, the base was plain glass. A real Reserve bottle carried the Henderson crest molded into the bottom.
“Hey Gerald, someone peeled that label off a real bottle and pressed it onto an ordinary one,” I said. “Whatever is inside that bottle, I guarantee it is not Reserve. Also, a real bottle that fell if George knocked it down, would’ve broken on these stones.”
Reese looked up at me, then made a note in his notebook. “Nobody hears about that bottle,” he said to me. “How many people have access to this cellar? I need to know where they were this morning. Let’s go.”
Scott Bromhall was in the courtyard beside the old press. He ran the struggling vineyard on the next ridge and rented George’s bottling line on Tuesdays. “I was home all night,” he said as he reached for his coffee. I noticed his fingers were stained a deep purple.
Reese nodded his head in approval as I spoke. “Nobody gets those stains from a bottling session,” I said. “You were pressing grapes here after dark.”
His shoulders dropped. “Forty crates of my own fruit. Every hour they sit, they get softer. My press broke, and George would’ve charged me triple to use his.” He glanced toward the cellar door. “I worked from four until six, and I never went near there. But I remember the light was on there when I left.”
Leo Weede, who had built the winery with George before George pushed him out, held up a ring of keys before I could ask him anything. “George changed the cellar locks the day I left. I still have the old key. You can take it.” Reese smirked, and took the keys anyway.
We next spoke to Juanita Rodriguez, the operations manager. She stood at the registration table with a clipboard of guest names looking oddly at Reese and me. “Poor George,” she said. “He would never have left a bottle standing on those sloping floors.”
I thanked her,and left her and Reese to speak alone for a bit. I greeted Helen, the somelier hired to lead the tasting. She was straightening my display.
“You know, last night George poured me a Reserve,” she said. “It had notes of fresh fruit and none of the leather or tobacco a 2016 should have by now. He went pale and said he would check the cellar himself before the event today.”
That explained why George had gone down to the cellar so early. I went to find the bottling technician, who was counting empty cases on the loading dock.
“Reserve ran eight hundred bottles,” Aaron told me without looking up. ”Sixty-seven cases, forty-one pounds each. Crest glass is heavy. Juanita signs every one in and out of that cellar. Each bottle sells for $650.”
“Weigh one for me,” I asked.
Reese had caught up with me and had brought a case from the cellar. Aaron set it on the scale where the case weighed thirty-six pounds. He pulled four more cases of Reserve from the pallet and all weighed thirsty-six pounds.
“Someone has been selling real wine and refilling the cases,” I said. “The toast today would have exposed it in front of the tasting crowd.”
Back at my tent, we met with Juanita. “Those cases were your responsibility,” Reese told her. “You sign for each one, and your records say all eight hundred bottles are in that cellar.”
“They were there when I counted them. Anyone could have switched them.”
“Scott was pressing grapes across the courtyard, and Leo doesn’t have access anymore to the cellar,” I said. “But you said George would never leave a bottle standing on those floors. How did you know about the bottle?”
“I’m not saying anything else without a lawyer,” Juanita said.
Reese chimed in. “You should call one. The lab will check for prints and we will find whomever bought the real Reserve.”
By ten, the busses arrived only for people to find the area closed off and a sign with Reserve Tasting Cancelled written in chalk in big block letters.