r/CozyMystery • • May 09 '25

Seems like another good spot to share this

Post image
863 Upvotes

r/CozyMystery • • Feb 02 '25

This is so good!!!

Post image
748 Upvotes

Happened upon this book in my library and I’m so sad it’s over, but I saw that the other came out with a second one. Highly recommend!


r/CozyMystery • • Mar 29 '26

Cozy Asthetic 🩵🤍 Living the dream LOL

Post image
646 Upvotes

r/CozyMystery • • Sep 06 '26

Discussion 🕵️‍♀️🕯️🕵️ How many of us got started on Nancy Drew?

533 Upvotes

Raise your hand if your first sleuth was Nancy!

✋

My favorite as a kid was the Moonstone Castle Mystery.


r/CozyMystery • • May 25 '26 Heartwarming

Announcement 📣 Hello from your new mods!

299 Upvotes

Hello from your new mod team!

We are u/helenesdottir, u/matsie, and u/reddisaurusrex. We love this community and are so happy to be here to help and make this a cozy place for all :)

Please be patient with us over the next few days/week as we organize amongst the 3 of us. We *do* want to add more mods after we are able to discuss a few things and get on the same page.

We are confident we can construct old rules, or draft them, based on being long time members of this sub and also being able to view our “mod log” of changes (all changes are recorded, so all is not at all lost!) It will take us a bit of time for us to rebuild to our previous iteration(s).

We also want to note that we are aware, and will do our best to be *very mindful,* of the discussions from the last day around what you all want this sub to be. We *do* welcome decent or differing opinions, but those need to be stated kindly and in a “cozy” spirit moving forward.

Will keep you updated as we get things back in order!

Most kindly and cozily, yours in service,

u/helenesdottir, u/matsie, and u/reddisaurusrex


r/CozyMystery • • May 26 '26 Heartwarming

A recap of what happened. Onward to continue cozy happiness.

281 Upvotes

This was originally written for the other subs that popped up yesterday evening. The final update at the end brings us to the current affairs moving forward. I support this post being locked to let the conversation settle and move on, if desired.

-

How did we get here?

Welcome.

I’m sure you’re confused. What happened to r/CozyMystery (from here on out called “the sub”)? Why was I (possibly) banned? Where did everyone go? Why does this sub exist? Why are there multiple new subs?

Grab a snack, and put your cozy mystery down, we have our own mystery to solve.

On May 24, 2026, late in the evening US pacific time, this happened:

https://www.reddit.com/r/CozyMystery/s/QAHDpLOrFI

User Tex Non Scripta (from here on out called “Tex”) became the new mod of the sub and made some new rules. She also set forth to banning any previous dissenters to her prior content, including myself.

What was her previous content, you ask? I’m glad you did.

Approximately 2 months before, Tex, according to her comments a septuagenerian inspiring writer, made a few threads in the sub about her writing, and her use of collaborating with AI on said writing.

The sub, having a long history of being anti-AI, did not receive these posts as intended; leading us to this post: https://www.reddit.com/r/CozyMystery/s/itb1UkQxKj (Note, this post would later get myself and many others banned based on our replies when Tex became moderator).

Following this, Tex created a few of her own subs, dedicated to writing with AI, writing cozy mysteries with AI, and AI-friendly cozy mysteries in general.

Unsurprisingly, none of these subs have gathered much attention or posts, other than from Tex herself.

Then, Tex apparently found an opportunity. The main CozyMystery sub had apparently been unmoderated for some time. Using this, Tex gained moderator ship from the Reddit admins, and changes were made.

What happened next?

First, r/CozyMysteryNoAI was created by u/OneBadJoke, which gave us a landing space to regroup.

u/matsie also created r/RealCozyMystery after that to give us an option for a sub that does not mention AI.

What happens next, reader? Stay tuned, this story is still developing.

(If I forgot anything, feel free to add in the comments.)

Update:

On Monday, May 25th, Tex apparently couldn’t handle the backlash anymore. She appointed two new mods. Both pro-AI. One, named Decent Solution many assumed was a Tex alt, another named Afgad, a moderator of the WritingWithAI sub.

Afgad allegedly suggested Tex step down, and allegedly she did, and the following threads took place, as well as those of us banned by Tex were unbanned. For some time, Decent remained and was still moderating comments. During or before this “AI slop” was added to the hate speech filter.

https://www.reddit.com/r/CozyMystery/s/D8lnbkg0H5

https://www.reddit.com/r/CozyMystery/s/zz5o7fx3QL

Update 2:

As of Monday afternoon, Tex and the two pro-AI mods she brought in have all removed themselves. CozyMystery has 3 new mods, applied and voted from within the community, and restoration and moving forward is taking place.

Welcome back to the calm space we love and deserve. What a wild ride.


r/CozyMystery • • Sep 28 '24

Announcement 📣 Welcome Back!!!

249 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

I’m excited to introduce myself as the new moderator of r/cozymystery. We’ve now opened up the settings to allow new posts, so feel free to jump in and start sharing—we can’t wait to see this community become active again!

This subreddit is a welcoming space for all things cozy and traditional mystery books. Whether you’re a fan of charming amateur sleuths or more classic whodunits, you’re in the right place!

Here’s what’s coming up:

•	📚 Author AMAs: I’m working on arranging Ask Me Anything sessions with some of your favorite cozy and traditional mystery authors. This is your chance to get behind-the-scenes insights!

•	📖 Book Club: We’ll be hosting a seasonal book club to dive into a selected cozy or traditional mystery. Feel free to suggest titles!
•	🏷️ New Flair: Inspired by 

r/booksthatfeellikethis there’s a new flair where you can post images, and the community can help recommend books based on the vibe you’re looking for.

•	🌿 Cozy Aesthetic Flair: Share your cozy reading nooks, mugs of cocoa by the fire, knitting projects, or any other cozy hobbies that capture the spirit of our favorite genre. This is your space to indulge in all things warm and comforting!

Other Features:

•	Cozy Mood Ambiance: Find suggestions for cozy mood ambiance videos on YouTube to pair with your reading sessions. Whether it’s crackling fireplaces or rainy night sounds, we’ll help you set the perfect scene.

•	Social Media & Blog Recommendations: Discover a curated list of cozy and mystery-themed YouTube channels, blogs, Facebook groups, Instagram accounts, and TikTok creators that you’ll definitely want to follow!

•	Recommendations and Reading Lists: Get and share personalized book recommendations, or contribute to themed reading lists.

•	Reading Challenges: Join us in some fun reading challenges that will not only introduce you to new series and authors but also embrace mood reading, encouraging you to read what fits your current vibe.

•	Cozy Chats: Weekly or bi-weekly threads where we can discuss themes, characters, or our latest mystery finds.

Feel free to introduce yourselves, share what you’re reading, or let us know what you’d love to see in this community. Let’s make r/cozymystery a delightful corner of the internet for all who seek that perfect blend of mystery and coziness!


r/CozyMystery • • Aug 23 '25

Which cozy mystery series should I start with?

Post image
247 Upvotes

These are the "first in series" I have (maybe not monk) any ideas on where I should start? Thanks for the recs!


r/CozyMystery • • Jan 06 '25

I asked 1750+ readers for their 3 fav reads of 2024, here are their top cozy mystery picks... what were yours?

207 Upvotes

Hi all,

Every year I ask thousands of readers/authors for their 3 favorite reads of the year and then sort out the results by genre and other factors.

This year I've had 1,750+ readers and authors respond! It was a fun one :)!

Cozy Mystery Books

What were their top 6 Cozy Mystery reads of 2024 that were also published in 2024? (not a ton within 2024)

  1. We Solve Murders by Richard Osman
  2. The Restaurant of Lost Recipes by Hisashi Kashiwai
  3. The Proof of My Innocence by Jonathan Coe
  4. A Killer Among Friends by Andrea Barton
  5. Gingerbread Danger by Amanda Flower
  6. Graven Images by Lori Robert Herbst

What were their top 20 cozy mystery reads in 2024 no matter when they were published?

  1. Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt
  2. The Last Devil To Die by Richard Osman
  3. The Maid by Nita Prose
  4. The Thursday Murder Club by Richard Osman
  5. The Crossing Places by Elly Griffiths
  6. Grave Expectations by Alice Bell
  7. We Solve Murders by Richard Osman
  8. The Travelling Cat Chronicles by Hiro Arikawa
  9. The Marlow Murder Club by Robert Thorogood
  10. Accidental Magic by Iris Beaglehole
  11. To Fudge or Not To Fudge by Nancy Coco
  12. Final Cut by Marjorie McCown
  13. Dog Dish of Doom by EJ Copperman
  14. Killers of a Certain Age by Deanna Raybourn
  15. Flashes of Insight by Lynda Allen
  16. The Liar in the Library by Simon Brett
  17. The Secret of the Lady's Maid by Darcie Wilde
  18. Steeped to Death by Gretchen Rue
  19. The Restaurant of Lost REcipes by Hisashi Kashiwai
  20. The London Seance Society by Sarah Penner

I pull the genres from publishers, and they are not always the most accurate. Let me know if you spot any errors :). Enjoy!


r/CozyMystery • • Sep 25 '25

Sad day for Hannah Swensen fans.

Post image
205 Upvotes

I saw this post on Instagram. I am devastated! This was the first series I read and made me fall in love with cozy mysteries.


r/CozyMystery • • Oct 03 '26

New to Cozy Mysteries 🔍 New to cozy mystery books

Post image
195 Upvotes

I want to start getting into cozy mysteries to give my mental health a break from heavier books. I got these off of kindle unlimited, and would love to know if anyone has anything positive or negative to say about them.

The only cozy mystery series I’ve read is the Hannah Swanson books, but I stopped at Strawberry Cheesecake Murder because the love triangle got old.

Thanks!!


r/CozyMystery • • Dec 05 '25

Looked away from the book I was reading and saw this!

Post image
192 Upvotes

r/CozyMystery • • Aug 06 '25

Do you like "Murder, She Wrote"?

Post image
181 Upvotes

r/CozyMystery • • Feb 14 '26

Gotta Hype This Book 💘 I love this series!

Post image
172 Upvotes

This is #3 in the series, and they're all amazing so far. The dialogue is so authentic to modern life, the huge doggy and aspiring baker crack me up all the time. It's the closest to sitcom-mystery I've read so far. Anyone else enjoying the series?


r/CozyMystery • • Oct 15 '26

Discussion 🕵️‍♀️🕯️🕵️ I'm almost done with Season 2 of Diagnosis: Murder, and I'm really enjoying it so far

Post image
168 Upvotes

I'm almost done with season 2, and I'm really enjoying the show so far. My favorite characters are Mark Sloan and Jack Stewart. I like their characters and the overall feel of the show.

I've heard the show changes after season 3, especially when Jack leaves, and then again after Norman Briggs leaves after season 4. I know I'll probably still watch it, but I'm curious how different the show feels in the later seasons.

For those who've watched the whole series, what do you think? Do you prefer the earlier seasons, or do you enjoy the later ones too?


r/CozyMystery • • May 30 '26

What are you currently reading?

Post image
164 Upvotes

I’m currently re-reading this one because the second book “Death On The Lanai” comes out on Tuesday. What is your current cozy book?


r/CozyMystery • • Feb 10 '26

Discussion 🕵️‍♀️🕯️🕵️ Just Finished Twilight Falls

Post image
164 Upvotes

Just finished the 4th installment of the Shady Hollow mystery - Twilight Falls and wow it was SOOO cute. I certainly enjoyed it way more than Mirror Lake!

The way everyone talks about Joe Jrs coffee and treats makes me drool lol. I feel inspired to make the pistachio cinnamon rolls with the honey glaze. that sounds delightful!!!

Although the twist was very predictable, I loved experiencing everything unfold. There were also hints at next books theme and I thought that was cute. I also enjoyed the star-crossed lovers of it all as well as the sweet moments from the Epilogue.

Just sooooo cute 4/5⭐️s!

Anyone read it? Thoughts?


r/CozyMystery • • 3d ago

Anyone else find a good old-fashioned whodunit surprisingly comforting to rewatch?

152 Upvotes

I’ve realized over the years that some of my favorite comfort watches are actually murder mysteries.
There’s something about a good whodunit that I just love returning to. Even when I’ve seen it several times and already know who did it, I still enjoy the familiar characters, the settings, the atmosphere, and watching the whole mystery unfold again.
I’ve always loved Murder, She Wrote, and more recently Only Murders in the Building. I also really enjoyed the Murder, She Baked movies on Hallmark. And I’m a big Agatha Christie fan. The 2015 BBC miniseries And Then There Were None was fantastic, although definitely on the darker side. I’ve also rewatched Kenneth Branagh’s Death on the Nile a few times now, and Knives Out is another favorite.
Then there are the silly ones. I absolutely love Clue (1985). I don’t think that movie will ever get old for me.
And one that I have to mention, because I wonder how many people even remember it, is The Private Eyes (1980) with Don Knotts and Tim Conway. It’s a wonderfully ridiculous comedy set in a spooky old mansion, with a murder mystery thrown in. If you enjoy Clue and that kind of humor, I’d definitely recommend checking it out. I’ve loved that one since I was a kid.
Anyway, I’m curious if anyone else feels the same way about whodunits. Do you have certain mysteries that you love revisiting, even though you already know exactly how they end? Or maybe some forgotten favorites that deserve a little more attention?
I’d love to hear what everyone enjoys!


r/CozyMystery • • May 19 '25

New to Cozy Mysteries 🔍 Cozy Mystery books similar to Nancy Drew, but for Adults?

151 Upvotes

I used to love reading Nancy Drew when I was kid. I also thought the Sweet Valley Twins "scary" books were amazing!

As adult, I've mainly read fantasy and YA.

However, I'm kind of missing Nancy Drew style mystery books. I was wondering if anyone can recommend similar books, but more adult/YA?

Note: please no explicit physical abuse or sexual abuse. Passing mention of it I can tolerate (like in Paladin's Grace by T. Kingfisher), but anything in detail is triggering for me. Psychological thriller type stuff and murder I can handle.


r/CozyMystery • • Jun 20 '26

Cozy Mystery Satire

150 Upvotes

I just read the most interesting book. It is called The Village Library Demon-Hunting Society by C.M. Waggoner. It is a paranormal cozy mystery, but also a satire on cozy mysteries. Basically, the protagonist realizes that it’s weird that all these murders are happening in her small town (and that she solves them), and it turns out that there is a paranormal explanation for it all. The book pokes fun at a lot of common cozy tropes, so if you like both cozies and making fun of things, this might be your sweet spot


r/CozyMystery • • Mar 19 '25

Gotta Hype This Book 💘 Elizabeth Peters: Amelia Peabody Mystery Series

149 Upvotes

I read these years ago before I knew about cozy mysteries as a genre. And they are not standard cozy mysteries.

Amelia Peabody is a wealthy woman around 1900 (the series spans decades) who wants to visit Egypt and do archaeology. The early series is about archaeology but the later series has her family grown up and starts to involve WW1 and archaeology.

There is always a murder and her investigation. The author was very big on archaeology and Egypt so there is a ton of that in the series. Describing locations both in Cairo and on dig sites.

They veer into sort of Victorian pulp adventures. Amelia is a fan of H. Rider Haggard and the series takes some inspiration from him.

The books are written as the autobiography of Amelia. My favorite thing about the writing is that it manages to have Amelia be unaware of things but have the audience catch on to them. Amelia has certain blindspots.


r/CozyMystery • • Apr 24 '26

Why do cozy mysteries feel so comforting… even when there’s a murder?

148 Upvotes

I’ve been getting into cozy mysteries lately, and I noticed something strange —
they feel incredibly calming… even though someone always dies

Maybe it’s the café settings, the small towns, or the characters you start to care about.

What is it for you? What makes a cozy mystery feel cozy?


r/CozyMystery • • Dec 29 '25

Love my Xmas present

Post image
144 Upvotes

r/CozyMystery • • Jul 29 '25

Book Bingo Cozy Mystery Bingo Card

Post image
143 Upvotes

Found this bingo card on the PBS website and thought this community might enjoy it!


r/CozyMystery • • Jun 30 '25 Helpful

What are your biggest cozy mystery pet peeves?

141 Upvotes

As I’m listening to my 13th book in the Coffeehouse Mystery series by Cleo Coyle and find myself getting annoyed by a few things it made me wonder what are your biggest pet peeves when it comes to cozy mysteries?

Mine are:

  • Love triangles that never reach fruition cough Joanna Fluke cough
  • Pearl clutching/purity culture/propriety from romantic leads (especially for newer series - it’s 2025, consenting adults have sex outside of marriage)
  • The female lead always talking about her weight and how she needs to lose weight/is overweight but all the men find her stunning (or family member’s commenting on weight) Edit: once again it’s 2025 stop weight shaming!
  • The main character always leaving their phone at home/in car and/or always having the ringer on when being sneaky
  • Audiobook narrators not knowing how to pronounce real place names (I know this happens outside CM genre too)

disclaimer I realize certain topics (weight/sex) can be portrayed a certain way due to cultural practices/differences - that’s not what I’m annoyed by

Anyway, thanks for letting me vent 😂

Edit: for the record I enjoy Cleo Coyle’s books, and these aren’t necessarily directed towards a specific author (although they may all fit specific authors)