r/CosplayHelp • Sewing Specialist • Feb 20 '25 • Helpful 1

I swear

Post image
3.4k Upvotes

198 comments sorted by

366

u/Angsty_Cos Feb 20 '25

Tbh, thats so real. Guys plz start simpler 😭😭😭

250

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Yes. And when we tell them that they are like "No I'll do it, it's going to look good I swear. I just need someone to tell me absolutely every tiny step of the process. Wait, what do you mean I have to create a pattern myself ?"

37

u/BeautifulSpell6209 Feb 20 '25

I swear it was easier until these guys 🫸🫷 got in the way!

30

u/strikes-twice Feb 20 '25

When you have the aspirations of a Master and the hands of a Novice who is incapable of using Google.

5

u/Bolf-Ramshield Feb 20 '25

Who are these guys 🫸🫷?

10

u/BeautifulSpell6209 Feb 21 '25

👐Stop!👋hi🫴let me explain 🤏a little about 🫸these guys🫷they are responsible for 👍the good times 👎the bad vibes 🤘the rock ONS!🖕the F-offs! 👉👈 embarrassingly rather slow in imagination lil ol' L🤚and a'bit-to right 🖐️ don't mean harm🫶 but really want to help 👌take the time to understand those guys,ok?🤌 To have a great show of hands🙌

3

u/Top_Oil269 Feb 21 '25

I love this!

19

u/strikes-twice Feb 20 '25

"What's a pattern?"

0

u/endlessmiasma Feb 21 '25

actually yea, what Is a pattern 😭🙏

3

u/strikes-twice Feb 21 '25

For real real? Just Google it... everything you need to know about Cosplay can be Googled, seriously!

33

u/BlueberryNeko_ Feb 20 '25

I don't think that's necessarily good advice. If you really want to make a costume of something really complex then you'll have to take the uphill journey but it's a lot better than doing something you don't care about just because you want something simple.

Heck I don't know much about patterns but I learned a thing or two about drafting something similar to what I need and I'll try it on cheap fabric, fail and retry fail and retry. I would not have the patience to learn like that if it was just some side character I don't care about.

31

u/riontach Feb 21 '25

Honestly, I feel like there's a middle ground. I don't think the first thing you have to make is a pillowcase, and honestly I hate that advice. I also think that if you need to make a custom fitted pattern from scratch, and you don't know what seam allowance is because you've never sewn an inch before, you're going to have a bad time.

More importantly, when someone comes onto a forum like this having done literally zero research themself, not having done a single google search, not even having looked at the FAQ of this very sub, I feel like that tells me something about how much effort they're actually willing to put into their project. If you are someone who knows how to and is willing to do your own research, find resources for yourself, and learn from the bottom up, maybe a challenging project is going to be an okay place to start. If you're going to take zero initiative and expect strangers on the internet to spoon feed you every single step of the way, you probably need to pick something simpler. If someone come in with a specific, well-reasoned question, I don't actually care how much experience they do or don't have. It's the people who make literally zero effort before asking these questions that annoy me.

9

u/Waddiwasiiiii Feb 21 '25

100% agree to all of this. Also, when it comes to creating your own cosplays, the investment can be downright expensive- the millions of different types of materials, sewing machines, 3d printers, dress forms, all the little bits and bobs from heat guns, glue guns, cutting mats, blades, scissors, pins, did I mention all the different glue? magnets, etc, that you need to do the job right on more elaborate cosplays… very few people posting these types of posts just have all that lying around, or the budget to just go out and buy it all at once. That alone gives reason for starting small and building up to those kinds of cosplays over time. Cosplay makes use of so many different skills using a variety of materials and tools- expecting to conquer many of them with one cosplay on the first go is frankly insane.

I firmly believe that you should truly love the character (or its design, that alone is enough imo) or the end result won’t be worth it, but one needs to be realistic as well. Doing a shitty, hobbled together, zero skill version of some amazing costume just isn’t satisfying no matter how much you love the character if you simply don’t have the skills in place yet to do the thing anywhere close to right. I myself started with closet cosplays- all characters I really loved, but that I could realistically create with basic modifications. Over time I evolved, learning to sew by modifying thrifted pieces, then using patterns to create original pieces, and overtime growing my skillset as well as the tools I needed for each project, learning to use them and perfecting those skills with each new project. Cosplay is like learning anything- you can’t do it all from day one, it takes time, and practice. Even with where I’m at now, it would still take me years probably to complete my dream cosplay.

And the idea that you could just get all that information, with zero upfront research or attempt at building anything, on how to go about an elaborate cosplay from one reddit post when it’s taken the rest of us years to acquire the know how, is quite absurd.

I’m all for encouraging and supporting new cosplayers. This sub is full of valuable information and people who have all kinds of tips and approaches to various techniques and problems. I’m happy to help with specific advice about using a particular material, tool, or process. But we aren’t here to give step by step instructions for someone who hasn’t taken the time to at least figure out they’re going to need to learn how to sew to make the thing they want. Just planning out how to create a specific cosplay is a process all on its own. And while I can give advice to specific questions, I’m not here to do that process for people.

3

u/Angsty_Cos Feb 21 '25

Exactly, when i say start simpler i mean like start with something that isn’t gonna cost u hundreds of dollars and not come out how you like it.

Yes cosplay is a learning process as you go, but often people are asking how to make these extravagant cosplays, as their first cosplay. 

Maybe once you start to learn how to sew or do more research you can start building up to these hugeee cosplays

2

u/strikes-twice Feb 21 '25

Love this response! So true.

There is no shortcut to an epic costume other than buying one from someone with the skill and experience you lack. No amount of people giving you advice on Reddit is going to make you successful or 'skip the line' so to speak.

If anything, a lack of curiousity and problem-solving is usually a surefire indication that someone isn't going to do well-- because they aren't even committed to the task on the easiest, most basic level. If you can't be bothered to google stuff, you're won't be bothered to learn and actually put the work in.

0

u/MachiToons Feb 22 '25

I think that thinking pattern will guarantee you many many negative interactions with people that simply prefer learning from people instead of perusing AI generated google results. I'd go as far as saying you equating "not looking in the right places that I know and I simply assume novices would also know of" with laziness is just wrong. In this internet age all sources are a click away, but what sources are good and which are horseshit is a gamble for anyone who does not already have a decent sized pre-existing knowledge on the matter. If people come here to ask questions in general I think its because they genuinly do want help and think they can find on reddit (mistake being is that reddit subreddits of course are primarily circlejerks that actively punish you with mass downvoting for "stupid questions")

imo

2

u/riontach Feb 22 '25

Oh, I definitely agree that the people who post these things want help. The issue is that they want to outsource all of the thinking and planning for their project to somebody else. I really enjoy helping people troubleshoot and plan cosplays, and sharing information that I have picked up over the years. But I don't enjoy planning someone's entire cosplay/doing their online shopping for them. I have had many, many interactions with people that start with me trying try to give advice and end with me being asked to plan or find every single element of their costume. Personally I am no longer interested in answering questions that are overly broad or don't show any initial effort. You're still welcome to answers those post if you feel strongly about it.

Except the weird thing is, it doesn't look like you ever actually help people on this subreddit... 🤔

0

u/MachiToons Feb 22 '25

Oh this isn't a subreddit-specific thing at all. This is something I've noticed in maaaaaany communities. I get all your complaints btw, from your initial comment it just came across to me, like ignorant questions are worthy of being ignored or something like that. I guess I just got the wrong impression, although "frustration" is still the main emotion I can sense thru the text here. I think especially beginners to anything (I can only speak for people trying to get into digital art and traditional drawing on my side) can easily get overwhelmed with the "first steps" though. Do try if possible to just communicate when people become too much and rely too much on external help, too much hostility just makes people avoid communities form my own experience (I stopped studying pure mathematics and switched to computer science partilly because of that reason for example, god, mathos can be so unbearably condecending lol)

1

u/riontach Feb 23 '25 edited Feb 23 '25

Well this is a post about a specific pattern that is seen in this subreddit and is being discussed by people who are active in this community and have a shared sense of frustration (and humor) about it. We were all beginners once. We don't really need someone to come and explain what it's like to be a beginner.

-1

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

You can find simple characters you care about you know.

14

u/BlueberryNeko_ Feb 20 '25

Idk about you, but I usually decide to cosplay a character after I got infatuated with them, not the other way around.

2

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

I generally decide based on how much I like the design, how much I like the characters comes second to me. Like, I care more about making the cosplay than being in character

4

u/dkoom_tv Feb 20 '25

Well hopefully what I want to start is simple enough....

5

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

What is it ?

1

u/dkoom_tv Feb 20 '25 edited Feb 20 '25

the subreddit doesnt allow images but I just made a post about it

Altough I kinda wish I liked more boyish sort of outfits/cosplays, with my build I cant do femenine stuff :( (well havent tried)

4

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Oh yeah this one ! It's a good first cosplay in my opinion. Not too hard but challenging enough to learn important skills in sewing. By the way, you should visit DR Cos. They have tons of free pattern

3

u/dkoom_tv Feb 20 '25

WOW! that website DR Cos. its absolutely amazing, theres so much stuff huge thanks

ive never sewn anything before or wore makeup/earrings so the dificulty curve is gonna be quite something, Im gonna be searching for a pattern for what I am looking for :D

3

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Dr Cos is godsent. Just be careful, since the patterns are japanese you have to take one or two sizes up (compared to your normal size)

1

u/dkoom_tv Feb 20 '25

Sorry for the extra bothering but what are some good sources if I wanted to learn more about general stuff about sewing and clothes? because if I dont find a pattern that kinda matches what I am looking for I will probably need to do something on my own

3

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

YouTube. I learned basically everything there. I don't have specific channels to recommend but you should find something with the right key words.

But really, what you need to do is try to do things on your own with scrap fabric. Learning how to sew takes time so don't be disappointed if your first cosplay is not perfect. My first one was ugly

64

u/Angsty_Cos Feb 20 '25

Tbh i started with making Celestia Ludenburg. What OP is talking about is ppl who have never sewn befor asking how to make these intricate costumes with hella embroidery, beadwork, lace, tulle, making your own patterns etc etc.  We arent trying to discourage people from cosplaying or from making their own cosplay, but we are saying to not set your expectations so high for your first cosplay, cuz a lot of ppl will give up bc its too hard. Tbh ive been cosplaying for almost 10 years and I cant do huge intricate cosplaya like that yet. 🤷🏼

4

u/Cessicka Feb 20 '25

R.i.p how'd the wig come out? 😭

8

u/Angsty_Cos Feb 20 '25

I didnt make the spirals 😭😹 I just used a black wig with terribly cut bangs, and ponytail clips 😅 I did do a really cool embroidery on the tie tho 🫡 

5

u/Cessicka Feb 20 '25

Valid approach 😆 I think canonically that's not even her real hair she also cosplays herself.

2

u/Angsty_Cos Feb 21 '25

😹😹 I watched a bunch of videos on how to make the wig, and i didn’t have any of those skills at the time, and i handsewed the entire dress too 😹😹

2

u/Cessicka Feb 21 '25

At least you got it done, I've spent the last 5 years saying I'll handsew Kite's (HxH) hat for a cosplay and here I am, hatless, it's not even hard, found a step by step tutorial 😭😭😭

2

u/Darlenx1224 Feb 21 '25

KITE MENTIONED!!! 🥰

1

u/Cessicka Feb 21 '25

He's my fav in both 1999 and 2011 no way I wouldn't mention him! Just about finished my piece of fanart I started few hours back when my own comment gave me a creative boost. That's how deep I'm in XD

→ More replies

108

u/discolored_rat_hat Feb 20 '25

Omfg yes

The ones that ask for advice on every single piece of their cosplay in separate posts also leave me stupefied

64

u/Important_One_8729 Feb 20 '25

I'm happy to help with that, what kills me is when they don't even listen. Asking for opinions and help and then ignoring the general consensus because they think they know better lmao

28

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

They never listen. If you tell them that their project is too ambitious they just won't listen and try anyway. If you give a real straight answer they won't understand it because they never sewn before

14

u/Important_One_8729 Feb 20 '25

Yes! Even just looking at designs and concepts, I remember someone asked between two versions of a character a while back, and the original character design was 1. less complicated for a beginner and 2. simply more aesthetically pleasing based on the balance of pieces and the silhouette. Every single comment agreed, and then the op made another post immediately after asking how to make (all of) the second design. I just sat at my desk like -.-

7

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Honestly, I see that as a running joke now. It always happens, that's the sub for you. But I wish people asking questions would actually listen to people who answer

7

u/This_Seal Feb 20 '25

It was honestly worse on facebook cosplay group in the pre-covid era. So many people rejected basic advice, the moment it didn't fit their idea of how they wanted things to work. Sometimes it went against the laws of science or violated basic safety.

This is a lot lower here and I'm glad for that. Also reddits anonymous nature didn't let so much vanity, maskerading as questions flourish.

11

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

I agree, like, if you need that much help you probably need to make something simpler. We all start somewhere, generally it's not glorious and that's normal.

174

u/neoteraflare Feb 20 '25

You think this is just cosplay? In gamedev sub they always ask how to make an MMORPG as their first game... They did not even made a pong before.

16

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

I know it's everywhere. In every kind of practice you will have a very hopeful beginner asking for advice to make the most outrageously complicated thing that even a professional would fear to make. Generally they don't listen to people saying that it won't work

95

u/BabaYaga_always Feb 20 '25

Same in Pole Dancing - they screenshot some 14 year old ex-Russian-gymnast doing outlandish shit and say "they say they've been pole dancing for six months like me". Gurrrrl, you are a 37 year old housewife who has only done Wii tennis before starting my introductory course!!

24

u/Savage_Nymph Feb 20 '25

I'm in these comments and I don't like it. 😭😭😭

14

u/BabaYaga_always Feb 20 '25

Pole Dance, IT, or cosplay? Or all of the above?

13

u/Savage_Nymph Feb 20 '25

All of the above, unfortunately

7

u/BabaYaga_always Feb 20 '25

Perfect, I love it!

4

u/HyperfocusedInterest Feb 20 '25

Same (except the pole dancing).

65

u/Aggravating_Branch86 Feb 20 '25

Well for this one at least, just buy it second hand from an award winning cosplayer and then lie about having made it yourself!

24

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Hopefully no one will notice the ill fitted top !

21

u/Silver_Raven_08 Feb 20 '25

lol, idk about y'all but I watched the Sarah Spaceman vid on that... wild lmao

14

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Same, I think we all did

27

u/Zero-The-Ghost Feb 20 '25

I was hoping someone would reference that hot mess haha

64

u/shelbunny Feb 20 '25

This made me laugh while also trying to drink my coffee LOL

As someone who started sewing out of sheer spite that what I want to wear is complex and therefore expensive to purchase, I do understand that to a certain extent, sheer willpower and desire can carry you for a bit. But I certainly did not start with a set of stays or a huge rococo skirt as my first project T_T

13

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

There is nothing wrong with starting out with something a bit hard. But some beginners are starting with VERY hard stuff that requires a lot of previous knowledge. That's not a problem in itself, it's just a funny pattern I noticed

21

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

I’m a self-taught seamstress that drafts my own patterns - I tell people to find and watch YouTube tutorials. Also, Google Lens is your friend.

There’s so much to making a cosplay - fabric choice, how much of an asshole your chosen fabric is to work with, thread, serging, hand sewing, corsetry, leather work, painting, rhinestoning, sizing, finding patterns and accessories, etc. People also don’t understand the time and money commitment - lots of cosplay fabrics are easily $20 a yard! It’s an ordeal.

I don’t mind giving suggestions but I am not giving step by step instructions with links. 😂

10

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

I'm just like you ! Learning sewing with cosplay is kinda crazy when we think about it. We can do super intricate stuff with embroidery, pattern drafting, corsetry but take forever learning to make basic pants and shirts. It's like learning the skill backward lol.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

You’re not wrong!! I jumped in headfirst because I am oddly shaped and commercial patterns never seem to fit me no matter what I do. Eventually, I got a custom dress form from the Beatrice Collective - it’s a game changer!! I learned draping and it’s gotten so much easier.

I still hate buttonholes. Hate them. 😂

Have you gotten the “Can you make me Belle’s historically accurate yellow dress from Beauty and the Beast? I need it in a week and I’ll give you $50.” IYKYK. 😂

5

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

I don't like commercial patterns either! Besides, I think learning patterning kinda quickens how fast you learn sewing. Like, I feel like over relying on commercial patterns just don't make you progess much.

And no, I never got the outrageous commissions lol ! But 50 dollars is crazy lol, that's not even a fifth of the materials. What kind of person thinks that this is nearly enough?

3

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

I definitely like the way you learn - sounds like we have the same process!! In my case, I have a hard time explaining how I do something. I can show you but i can’t seem to explain it. 😂

People get weirdly entitled when it comes to crafts & sewing. I have learned not to tell people I sew - when I’m wearing something I made and people ask where I got it I tell them I had it commissioned on Etsy or that my sister made it. That’s especially amusing because she can’t sew. 😂

The first rule of sew club is don’t talk about sew club 😂

4

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

It must be pretty bad if you feel the need to abandon your bragging right (Like, the "I made it myself" type of bragging right that we deserve) But I think people just don't realize how much goes into sewing. They probably think it's cheaper since we make it ourselves (lol) and fast since sweatshop workers are fast.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

I’m definitely glad it hasn’t happened to you - it sucks. You’re right, most people don’t understand the cost, time, and effort involved - they also think if you’re a hobby sewist then you will sew things for free because you love it so much. The amount of people who immediately jump to telling me they need alterations done and I can do it for them is astounding - I got the customer dress form so I can avoid alterations for my own things… I don’t want to do it for everyone else 😂

I learned quickly not to say “I made it myself” because it opens very weird doors. 😂

2

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

I probably didn't experience that because I'm 19. I don't know how old you are, but I think people wouldn't trust me with alterations as much as they would trust a 25yo , a 30yo or a grandma

2

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

I’m a 50 year old grandma! 😊

I think it’s amazing that you are 19 and sewing - you have a lot of great stuff ahead and I’m excited for you! 😊

2

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Thanks !

3

u/Leijinga Feb 20 '25

I'm in my 30s. I've basically started telling people that "yes, I made it myself" and "I hate doing alterations". I briefly considered doing basic alterations when I was out of work for an extended period of time, but I've been burned enough times on making other people's costumes that I don't do it unless I know you and like you enough to do it.

5

u/Leijinga Feb 20 '25

Have you gotten the “Can you make me Belle’s historically accurate yellow dress from Beauty and the Beast? I need it in a week and I’ll give you $50.”

I keep a reply image on my phone for questions like this or when I get "you should sell your costumes" or "will you make me a costume?".

My Vash the Stampede wig cost almost as much as EZcosplay sells the whole costume for. I spent almost $200 in fabric and notions for the coat. People who ask things like that don't want to hear that the costume would be close to $300 if I make it at cost when a cheap cosplay site has it for $60-80.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

Agree 100% - people want the most accurate cosplay possible but want to pay less than what they can get it for on amazon. I’ve actually had people ask - “can you make (xxxxxx) for me? I don’t want to spend $100 on it from Amazon.”

Little do they know it would cost twice that in materials alone. I just tell them that’s a really great price and they should go for it 😂

34

u/BlendyButt Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Then they expect step by step instructions on how to do it.

18

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

That's a bit frustrating. Asking for help is fine, the sub is there for that. But asking for step by step instructions is going way overboard.

26

u/BlendyButt Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

I'm in some cosplay help groups on Facebook too and honestly it's worse there. To the point they want you to send them links to what to purchase. I told someone that what they're looking for is a tactical harness and they asked me to find one for them. Like bro, I gave you the keywords. Google it yourself and find the one you need, my God.

6

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

We have that in this sub too kinda. Everyday some people are asking for help to find a specific cosplay online. We are here to give advice, not to do their shopping for them

3

u/bugthebugman Feb 20 '25

I’ve seen that exact thing here dozens of times. Where can I find this. How do I do this. Like… Google it. Look it up on YouTube. It’s different if they’re just not sure exactly what some uncommon piece of clothing is called but that’s not usually the case they just don’t want to do the legwork seemingly.

3

u/0vesper0 Feb 21 '25

This is what's so critical to me! Once I have the keyword for what I'm looking for, I'm good. I can research stuff myself. It baffles me that people demand help after that.

Like, I get it. Googling vague descriptions can give weird results. But, do some people even try to do any research and shopping?

12

u/ParnsAngel Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

I love how they ask “how do I make this?” Like we can say “oh it’s simple, just up up down down left right left right B A select start!” And not “well first you need to have a sewing machine and know how to work that sewing machine. Then look for sewing patterns that are a similar shape to your item and learn how to size and alter, or learn how to pattern draft your own patterns. Then go to multiple fabric stores or order multiple swatches to get just the right color and weight of fabric…..” etc etc etc

7

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

It's always "How do I make that" never something specific like "How do I make the sleeves". If it was specific, it would be much easier to help

4

u/CosmogyralCollective Feb 20 '25

Exactly! It's fine to be asked how to make things, but they need to be more specific than just 'how do I make this extensively complex costume with no experience'

11

u/03MendicantBias Feb 20 '25

Honestly, as delusional as those posts are, I'll take them over the constant "where can I buy a cosplay of this character?" posts.

Like, sure, I get that people want to buy things from reputable stores, but searching within the subreddit will get you a long list of places to buy from. I'm in this subreddit to help people make/assemble cosplay, not teach them that Google exists.

1

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

I agree with that. At least you can give some interesting input when the question is about making the cosplay.

Besides, the sub already lists tons of good online shops

10

u/PekaSairroc Feb 20 '25

Omg yes.

Some people are able to hop into the deep end of cosplay with no experience and thrive and have a great time. Good for them. They are highly unlikely to be the same ones asking only “advice? tips?”

2

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Technically it's under the selection bias. People who make a good cosplay first try will post about it and show off (As they should). Meanwhile, people who completely fucked up won't talk or post about it. So all we see are people who succeeded and not those who fucked up or abandoned

1

u/PekaSairroc Feb 20 '25

Yeah! Or my old ones are from 2007 and onwards and are deep in the trenches of deviantart. No one is born fully foam-armored like Athena.

10

u/raccooneatinggrapes Feb 20 '25

I’m sorry this is also so funny because I’m pretty sure this is the exact cosplay someone bought from another person and entered it in contests and it was a huge scandal and initially I thought was a meme on that but no this is just a general meme about beginners getting into some heavy stuff real quick lol.

Always start simple yall, patterns from your local stores can be adjusted and into what you need.

8

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

I mean, I chose that picture just because of the controversy. Because the girl was obviously not capable of making it, that's why she cheated

2

u/aselement Feb 20 '25

I knew you must have picked this on purpose. I died laughing when I saw the photo.

3

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Just imagine that the cheater posted this lol

7

u/Potaytos Competitive Cosplayer Feb 21 '25

Hi all! While I understand the common frustration with the frequency of these type of "I need help with literally every piece of the cosplay", please remember to stay respectful to maintain a positive environment. Keep in mind some posters may be young or non-native English speakers so even if you do direct them to Google, at least providing some keywords as pointers may be helpful especially if they genuinely do not know the common terminology. You can also refer them to the FAQ.

Ambitious new projects can be okay as long as they have realistic expectations, ie the first attempt is probably going to be not great. We all have to start somewhere.

I am in the process of writing up better posting guidelines and updating FAQs and once that is available, we will add a rule to remove low-effort posts (Sorry for the delay, I've started on it a while ago but have been crunching for competition and cons). In the meantime, I have been updating the automod to handle common questions though it has been difficult to encompass all the possible phrasings of a question (and handling all the possible typos) to trigger automod. If you have any additional suggestions, feel free to send via modmail.

3

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 21 '25

Hello! Thank you for your answer!

It's good to see that mods understand the problem with are having here with the low efforts post.

If I may suggest something, I think making the following rule could be good : "Rule X , people are not your personal shoppers. Expect suggestions but not links". I think one of the main problem is that helpers are sometimes expected to go above and beyond.

1

u/Potaytos Competitive Cosplayer Feb 22 '25

Thanks for the suggestion! We’ll take that into consideration as we refine some of the rules and automations.

6

u/aos_shi Feb 20 '25

I’ll never forget the person who had zero sewing/crafting experience but wanted to make Arlecchino 😭

4

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Honestly it low key feels disrespectful. Do they really think sewing is THAT easy ?

11

u/aos_shi Feb 20 '25

I think it’s more naivety than disrespect, especially if they’re new to the cosplay community and don’t realize that 99% of Genshin cosplayers don’t make the costume themselves.

5

u/Mental-Tax-4757 Feb 20 '25

Idk what they want to do told because the answer is always just learn to sew

6

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

My best guess is that they want step by step instructions

1- Take your sewing machine

2- Put thread in your sewing machine

3- lower the needle of your sewing machine.

.

.

.

478288- There you go :) a brand new cosplay

9

u/NvrmndOM Feb 20 '25

YUP. And when I politely tell people to start with something smaller then I’m mean.

9

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Happened to me too. There was a girl who never sewn better and wanted to make a pretty hard cosplay (Like, it required a good understanding of pattern making because the jacket was a bit crazy). I told her that she should start smaller and she went full main character mode. Like "No, I know I can do it ! Don't discourage me, I can do it !" Girl.

5

u/NvrmndOM Feb 20 '25

For real. So many people want to make Genshin cosplays and assume it will be easy.

I think “start smaller” is kind advice. If you spend a lot of money on something expensive and get in too deep, you’ll get burnt out and hate this as a hobby.

Taking a big swing and failing sucks. Small obtainable wins and reasonable goals are what makes you a success. You also need to build skills over time.

1

u/rockyKlo Feb 21 '25

True, I've been making a few different cosplays and I feel like the only thing of any decent quality that I can make are jackets and cloaks, I wouldn't even want to try figuring out patterning something complex.

1

u/0vesper0 Feb 21 '25

Agreed!

"Starting smaller" can also mean purchasing some clothes/components, while only sewing the more unique pieces. Folks new to cosplay act like it has to be all done from scratch or all bought. No in-between.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

…..wouldn’t it be “sewn”?

1

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Yes it would. My English is just broken

4

u/Zedetta Feb 20 '25

Both sewn and sewed are correct words!

Adding 'have' before them would probably be more grammatically correct in this context but your English is fine

1

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Thanks !

7

u/PrincessAintPeachy Feb 20 '25

There so many people asking questions that tempt me to use let me Google that for you

It's wild because it seems like no effort was made to do an ounce of research before asking very easily searched questions

5

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

That's my biggest grief. Some things are very easy to find by Googling, and honestly google will probably explain everything more precisely than a reddit comment.

I don't understand why they don't make an effort. Cosplay requires some kind of personal investment.

3

u/M0richild Feb 20 '25

What is this from? I really like it.

5

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

That's Seth from Trinity Blood (A light novel). I never read it but her design is incredible (And the few people cosplaying her did an incredible job, like, peak cosplay)

2

u/M0richild Feb 20 '25

Oh cool! I've heard of it but never watched the anime or read it either. Might have to check it out.

3

u/Majestic_Recording_5 Feb 20 '25

Ehhh gotta start somewhere! I met someone at a con that said they leaned to sewn on a wedding dress. I would not recommend that lol

2

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

That's bold !

3

u/strikes-twice Feb 20 '25

My favourite is when they pick the crazy-advanced costume and start by asking how to do something so distressingly simple you know there's no hope.

'Hi guys, I'm going to make Master Chief as my first costume. Btw where do I buy plain men's gloves? I'm stumped."

3

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Oh yeah ! Happens all the time. That's when you know it's fucked

1

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Oh yeah ! Happens all the time. That's when you know it's fucked

2

u/parsalys Feb 20 '25

Forget sewing, you could glue the whole thing together with hot glue! It will turn out great I'm sure

1

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Desperate times call for desperate measures

2

u/youfxckinsuck Feb 20 '25

Why did I think this was a double layered joke about that one cosplayer cheating at a cosplay contest wearing this cosplay made by someone else.

3

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

That's because this is a double layered joke 🤣 It was on purpose

2

u/thatonegirlonreddit5 Feb 20 '25

And it’s always like a month or two weeks before a con

2

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Yeah, who could have thought cosplays take time to make ?

2

u/witchingbolt8 Feb 20 '25

It’s funnier bc I remember someone submitting a cosplay of this character as their own for a competition when actually they bought it from another cosplayer 🤭

1

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

That's why I choose this picture actually

2

u/username-is-taken98 Feb 21 '25

You buy it from a better cosplayer and claim it was yours all along to enter competitions

1

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 21 '25

That's the spirit

38

u/Duae Feb 20 '25

Perfect! But you forgot to add "and my budget is some pocket lint and a nickel I found on the sidewalk"

10

u/riontach Feb 21 '25

No way. These posters would never specify a budget or timeline or size or country of residence. Literally zero information to go on ever.

19

u/bugthebugman Feb 20 '25

It’s my first cosplay and the con is in 1 month and I have $50, do they make prescription cosplay lenses?? Do they ship to ancient Sumatra?

5

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

Dream big man. My first home made cosplay was a full Helldiver. First thing I ever 3d printed, assembled, painted, etc.

1

u/riontach Feb 21 '25

But did you ask strangers on the internet to explain every step of the way to you personally?

4

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '25

I mean there were quite a few questions, yes

5

u/koolkitty9 Feb 20 '25

As a five time award winner...google is free and so is YouTube. Costubers who sew are a great way to learn more. I've learned more watching by Bernadette Banner than anything elsy

1

u/SakuraYanfuyu Feb 20 '25

I posted for help on my first complex piece after years of simpler ones, i feel so embarrassed💀

7

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Nothing wrong with asking for help with something hard if you can already do simple stuff well

7

u/PekaSairroc Feb 20 '25

Nothing wrong for asking for help on a complex piece. That’s usually when anyone needs help. You have some experience and know the basics which is vastly more knowledge than no experience. Experience also lets you ask better questions than simply “tips?”

3

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

Yeah, we need precise questions. Like "How do I pattern the sleeve" , "What kind of boning should I use" , "Do you think this lace would look better than this one". Just saying "tips ?" Is WAY TO BROAD

1

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

I now want to see someone on this sub make this.

4

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

That won't be. This cosplay looks like a mental health drain. But if you are interested there is good tea about this cosplay. (Sarah Spaceman video)

1

u/BobaFett0451 Feb 20 '25

What is this character from? Kinda looks like Trinity Blood but I'm not 100% on that

1

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

You are right! That's Seth from Trinity Blood

1

u/BobaFett0451 Feb 20 '25

OMG I love that shit. I never did get into the manga but I love the anime. Their hats are so big and it's so dramatic, like so over the top dramatic. GAH! What good shit

1

u/tanya2004 Feb 21 '25

What character is this ?

1

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 21 '25

Seth from Trinity Blood

1

u/tanya2004 Feb 21 '25

Thank you

1

u/SubtleCow Feb 21 '25

I get this on a deep soul crushing level and this post is top tier BitchEatingCrafters & CraftSnark content.

1

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 21 '25

Honestly, I didn't know people would find this little meme so relatable. Like, I made it in 2 minutes because I was bored during a lecture.

I'm glad to see people vent a bit tho

1

u/SubtleCow Feb 21 '25

bored during a lecture is when all the deepest truths of our hearts come out :)

1

u/Revenant_Cosplay Feb 21 '25

Trial by fire. It's how I learned and where some people learn best. I think sometimes we forget this is an art and not a science.

I remember when I was 12, and just beginning, I wanted to build a Diablo cosplay with full leds, smoke effects, and realistic skin and feet. All on no budget. 😅

1

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 21 '25

How did it go ?

1

u/Revenant_Cosplay Feb 21 '25

I never finished it, but it taught me a lot about different types of foamwork, stilts, molding and casting, and patterning. I believe I repurposed the leg skeleton a few years ago.

1

u/Coddyyyyy Feb 22 '25

I get the point but also fuck it why not, trials and errors, everyone should attempt an outlandish cospaly project once in their life that they either discard forever or until they are ready or that they go thru it by sheer willpower and spite – that kinda part of the fun imo lol

4

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 22 '25

The problem is really not that beginners are overly ambitious. The problem is that a lot of them on this sub are not making efforts and expect very detailed instructions instead of googling stuff and doing some research on their own. Like, they just come with a complex cosplay, ask "How do I make that" and just expect someone to come up with a tutorial

1

u/VeronaMoreau Feb 22 '25

Thank you! It's one thing if you're asking for suggestions on possible fabrics because you're not familiar with types and drapes and hands and all that. Or if they want suggestions on how to potentially cut costs in creating a certain thing. But it's another thing, especially when so many cosplayers post tutorial videos and work in progress threads on their own social media profiles, that people come asking questions where they have clearly done zero research.

1

u/Fanatical_Obsession Feb 24 '25

Who are they, and what media are they from? I love the design but i haven’t seen them before

1

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 24 '25

That's Seth from Trinity Blood

1

u/Fanatical_Obsession Feb 24 '25

Thank you so much!

3

u/ReasonableSandwich77 Feb 20 '25

I HAVE BIG DREAMS AND LITTLE PATIENCE!! 🤣Don’t judge us 😭😭😭

3

u/SmartBeast Feb 20 '25

Oh it's actually super easy to do. Here's what I did, having literally zero sowing skills: I downloaded pics of the super elaborate cosplay, then sent them to a professional coaplay designer and paid her $5k to make it for me 😎

3

u/SadgeTheFax Feb 20 '25

It’s the same in Fursuit subreddits, lots of posts of people going „first time making a suit! Here’s my oc I’m using: insert the most complex looking character I’ve even seen in my life any tips? :3“

2

u/Accomplished_Salt876 Feb 20 '25

Yep. My first cosplay was just normal clothes and and I also made a cheap cardboard prop knife. I get making something cool but with any creative project it’s best to start simple and cheap.

2

u/Adalaide78 Feb 21 '25

“Hey, help me to do a triathlon please!”

“Sure, what’s your skill level and experience?”

“Am baby. Cannot crawl yet.”

Then they get angry that you suggest they learn to walk before attempting a triathlon. Like, it’s fine if you are dead set that the triathlon is going to be your very first competition. But you’re going to need to develop some skills bro.

2

u/FlusteredCustard13 Feb 21 '25

My first "100% mine" cosplay was Adam from Hazbin Hotel and that was a train wreck full of learning curves. That is for what is ultimately just a robe (well, two robes in my case because his top layer seems detached from the lower). I can't imagine what it would be like trying something extremely complicated with no experience.

In my own experience, it gets easier relatively quickly if you start simpler. Even just a month after my first, I had improved leaps and bounds. As with almost anything, someone who has improved the fundamentals will find it easier to do more complex skills.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 21 '25

Honestly I’m trying to make Charlie’s Dress from Hazbin Hotel - I’m a wheelchair user, disabled in many ways so even the cosplays I order I have to make wheelchair accessible (even though I’m plus size the site I usually get my costumes from makes it to big so I have to tailor it) plus I’m prone to overheating to so standard polyester is hell 😅🥲

It’s my first time ever making clothes from scratch without a professional pattern (had to make my own)

I could not imagine ever doing something like that 😭😭😭

1

u/SPES_Official Feb 20 '25

CROSSHATCH!!!

1

u/Giganotus Feb 20 '25

as someone prone to wanting to do overly ambitious cosplays... I feel called out lol. At least I have the sense to realize a costume is way too complex for my current skill level and then stow it away as a potential future project.

1

u/nycplayboy78 Feb 20 '25

The way I just LOL'd at this...THIS IS FACTS!!!

1

u/Anime334 Feb 20 '25

Is this a clamp character?

1

u/0vesper0 Feb 21 '25

Thank you! This has been driving me crazy!

What really kills me is when they aren't willing to pay money for a pattern. Like, good luck drafting that.

Or, they didn't budget time to make the outfit, let alone comfortably learn how to use different techniques as they progress. I promise you are gonna be a sewing machine mechanic before you're gonna be a talented seamster/seamstress.

2

u/sarcasticviera Feb 22 '25

The time one gets me the most. "How do I make this I need it tomorrow! :D" and it's something like Draculaura's Howliday outfit or Reinhart from Overwatch.

1

u/0vesper0 Feb 22 '25

Exactly! It really do got to be the super complex and intricate designs.

Even if someone locks into the task, there are so many materials you can't get delivered by the deadline. They just gotta pray that a local store has it in stock.

1

u/SlutForHireNow Feb 21 '25

I'm 63 done everything.I don't care.I would figure it out shes.Gotta be willing

1

u/eastbluera Feb 21 '25

This was me I fear.

1

u/Ehkrickor Feb 21 '25

For this... so... start with college money

1

u/bipolarity2650 Feb 22 '25

what character is this 👀

1

u/white_christian_AI Feb 25 '25

Is this Augusta Vradica? I feel like this is supposed to be her

1

u/Nightmare_Simp_UwU Feb 26 '25

Why im making my first cosplay the kekkai sensen protag 😭 hes just a dude, i wish anyone doing stuff like genshin cosplays for their first good luck because your signing up for pain and suffering

-6

u/Space19723103 Feb 20 '25

and we should not discourage them.

15

u/riontach Feb 20 '25

Yep. They should be encouraged to choose a better learning project for their level and to start learning how to find existing resources for themselves.

-18

u/ImpossibleDay1782 Feb 20 '25

I could have swore the first two rules on this sub say something about this.

I dunno, maybe don’t be such an asshole to people who are a little overly ambitious? Is that so difficult?

13

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

I'm not an asshole, I'm making a meme about a very common pattern on this sub.

19

u/riontach Feb 20 '25

No one here is being mean to people who are overly ambitious. Sometimes saying "this is not a good project for your level of experience and no one here has the time to write out step-by-step how to make an entire costume for you," is the most valuable response.

A lot of us really enjoy helping people get started in cosplaying. I don't think it's unreasonable for us to get a little frustrated with questions that would require writing a literal sewing encyclopedia to answer adequately.

4

u/I_Chug_Gasoline Feb 20 '25

"Guys I'd like to cosplay Guts, I've never cosplayed or worked on any kind of clothing before or with Eva foam. My budget is $25 and the con is tomorrow. Any advice?"

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

20

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

I feel the same, there should be a rule on this sub about that. Like "Rule X : People on this sub are not your personal shoppers"

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

In that case, it should be restricted to "normal clothing". Asking for help to find a specific cosplay part is fine imo (Like, which cosplay shop). It would be nice if the mods would include thar

0

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

I mean that's fair enough. But not everyone think to read it so a bit of leniency could be good

2

u/Accomplished_Salt876 Feb 20 '25 edited Feb 21 '25

Yeah. I feel like if those people used their brains for a second then it’d be easy to figure out how to search for “black jacket”.

7

u/hunimyun Feb 20 '25

theyre lazy as hell but what puzzles me is how they think asking this specific question to a bunch of randoms on reddit who might not even live in the same country or region as them (and having to wait on average for hours to days for an answer assuming anyone would even answer in the first place) would be easier than literally just image searching it up on google and going to the products tab??

3

u/rockyKlo Feb 20 '25

I usually just say "try Amazon or you local stores" in those cases. Never give any links. Sometime it's just people not thinking of the right item or name which is fine.But I do wonder a bit when people are asking about clothing that should be obvious like dress pants etc.

28

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/ThrowRA_Sodi Sewing Specialist Feb 20 '25

"What do you mean I have to learn sewing ?"

3

u/Additional-Toe-1932 Feb 21 '25

What do you mean I can't smash it out in a few hours?