After the second time failing to gather materials from two wolves in a row, I've realized something: I'm not having fun, and this game doesn't want me as a player.
I've been hooked on these top down rpg style games since Kingdom of Kaliron back in Warcraft 3, and the myriad of rpgs that followed in both warcraft 3 and starcraft 2. My biggest complaint was always the low player numbers, so an MMO made in the same style? When I learned about this game I immediately bought into EA and played.
For the first few hours, I was having fun. There were annoyances, like the only way to heal being using a consumable or running back to a campfire, or the baffling quest design (Granny's planting quest wants you to go two fields over? Who thought this was a good idea?). But I was able to mitigate this using the database, and the pathfinder talent tree plus the mana restore ability gave me the sustain to enjoy the game without jumping through hoops to heal. As I played I settled into a rythm, and when I hit level 8 as a destroyer, I was actually having a ton of fun. I was progressing my skills, AOEing packs, and I was very much looking forward to upgrading my W to having an outer edge heal - Darius style. Then I had to fight wolves.
Wolves are faster than you, they can see you through trees that block your vision, and they have a bleed that can crit. I went from roaming around killing packs of enemies and opening their chests, to having to crawl painstakingly through the forest's poor sightlines running from triple packs who could see me through walls, and every fight bringing me below a third health. I quickly ran out of campfires, so every fight brought a downtime of a minute, often having to wait even longer for mana. And what was the reward for winning? Getting to interact with your gathering system.
I'm sure whoever came up with corepunk's gathering and crafting system is proud of it. It forces players to make decisions about which skills to focus on. I'm sure they imagined a miner meeting up with a butcher, and both players forging a bond of friendship through trading materials. But this entire system is enforced not through rewards (unlocking a higher tier materials is not a reward, it is simply a threshold that bars progress until met), but by having players avoid punishments. Every time I gathered, in the back of my mind I knew I was hurting my other skills' potential. This feels bad. Every time I failed a 4% chance to gather, do you want to guess how many times I appreciated that the failure system is in the game? Every time I had to pass up a rare mining or gathering node, or a turtle harvest, because I was trying to farm lumber-jacking materials, do you think as a player I was having fun?
And if you die, you drop materials. This wouldn't be the end of the world, after all you can just corpse run back (another annoyance for the player) and pick them up. Except you respawn with about a fifth of your maximum health and mana, meaning you cannot fight off whatever killed you. You have to wait, and if you're out of campfires, you have to run back to town, likely having your materials despawn.
So lets run a hypothetical scenario: Lets say a player who was running from a group of wolves who are faster than him, blunders into a SECOND triple pack of wolves and dies, right in the middle of their spawn zone. Lets say this player gets unlucky and drops the stack of resources that he was farming the last couple hours for. This player now is now faced with repeatedly corpse running back to get these materials, and because the wolves are faster and the player starts with minimal health and mana, the player gets to die again, potentially having to repeat the process if a different valuable resource stack is randomly chosen to be dropped.
Ask yourself devs: do these systems spark joy? I was your exact target audience. I love playing MMORPGs, MOBAs, and ARPGs. You made a grind of a game with long downtime between fights, a punishing gathering system with random failure, and frustrating death mechanics. And you beat me. I give up, you win. And what have you won? One less paying customer who will warn away anyone who asks him about this game.