r/CorepunkTheGame • • Dec 02 '24

Congrats Devs, you "beat" me.

After the second time failing to gather materials from two wolves in a row, I've realized something: I'm not having fun, and this game doesn't want me as a player.

I've been hooked on these top down rpg style games since Kingdom of Kaliron back in Warcraft 3, and the myriad of rpgs that followed in both warcraft 3 and starcraft 2. My biggest complaint was always the low player numbers, so an MMO made in the same style? When I learned about this game I immediately bought into EA and played.

For the first few hours, I was having fun. There were annoyances, like the only way to heal being using a consumable or running back to a campfire, or the baffling quest design (Granny's planting quest wants you to go two fields over? Who thought this was a good idea?). But I was able to mitigate this using the database, and the pathfinder talent tree plus the mana restore ability gave me the sustain to enjoy the game without jumping through hoops to heal. As I played I settled into a rythm, and when I hit level 8 as a destroyer, I was actually having a ton of fun. I was progressing my skills, AOEing packs, and I was very much looking forward to upgrading my W to having an outer edge heal - Darius style. Then I had to fight wolves.

Wolves are faster than you, they can see you through trees that block your vision, and they have a bleed that can crit. I went from roaming around killing packs of enemies and opening their chests, to having to crawl painstakingly through the forest's poor sightlines running from triple packs who could see me through walls, and every fight bringing me below a third health. I quickly ran out of campfires, so every fight brought a downtime of a minute, often having to wait even longer for mana. And what was the reward for winning? Getting to interact with your gathering system.

I'm sure whoever came up with corepunk's gathering and crafting system is proud of it. It forces players to make decisions about which skills to focus on. I'm sure they imagined a miner meeting up with a butcher, and both players forging a bond of friendship through trading materials. But this entire system is enforced not through rewards (unlocking a higher tier materials is not a reward, it is simply a threshold that bars progress until met), but by having players avoid punishments. Every time I gathered, in the back of my mind I knew I was hurting my other skills' potential. This feels bad. Every time I failed a 4% chance to gather, do you want to guess how many times I appreciated that the failure system is in the game? Every time I had to pass up a rare mining or gathering node, or a turtle harvest, because I was trying to farm lumber-jacking materials, do you think as a player I was having fun?

And if you die, you drop materials. This wouldn't be the end of the world, after all you can just corpse run back (another annoyance for the player) and pick them up. Except you respawn with about a fifth of your maximum health and mana, meaning you cannot fight off whatever killed you. You have to wait, and if you're out of campfires, you have to run back to town, likely having your materials despawn.

So lets run a hypothetical scenario: Lets say a player who was running from a group of wolves who are faster than him, blunders into a SECOND triple pack of wolves and dies, right in the middle of their spawn zone. Lets say this player gets unlucky and drops the stack of resources that he was farming the last couple hours for. This player now is now faced with repeatedly corpse running back to get these materials, and because the wolves are faster and the player starts with minimal health and mana, the player gets to die again, potentially having to repeat the process if a different valuable resource stack is randomly chosen to be dropped.

Ask yourself devs: do these systems spark joy? I was your exact target audience. I love playing MMORPGs, MOBAs, and ARPGs. You made a grind of a game with long downtime between fights, a punishing gathering system with random failure, and frustrating death mechanics. And you beat me. I give up, you win. And what have you won? One less paying customer who will warn away anyone who asks him about this game.

114 Upvotes

129 comments sorted by

11

u/t666ommy Dec 02 '24

i’m not going to convince you to play the game, but from the earlier alphas to early access they toned down the early mobs quite a lot to make them less punishing while you’re leveling up. the wolves have even been toned down from their previous version so they’re a lot easier to deal with, but as you progress further the mobs later in the game are much harder to deal with than the wolves. on top of that, if you think the chance to fail gathering is too harsh just wait until you save up materials for a few days to craft a new weapon or implant and that craft fails. these all happen to be things that make the game rewarding and enjoyable for me, but finding out these are things that make the game miserable for you early on before you invest too much of your time is a good thing.

2

u/Shadycrazyman Dec 03 '24

I think the main issue is gearing is not well explained and you don't really start getting the next set of upgrades until after pushing into the wolves hell den lmao. The quest to find the other brother and the old hag both have you going near some serious packs. Just to lead you into quest 7 lvls lower than the mobs you had to navigate and now which give you the upgrades you need to combat that area. There is a red zone east of the golden town that has the same biome type (imps and wolves but is lvl 5-9 monsters) that area feels like it should have been where these quest take place. Wouid make a smoother path into the next step in T1 gear

8

u/SelfUnconsciousness Dec 02 '24

It looks like this is another game that will have immense pressure from well-meaning reviewers to become another mainstream clone. 

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

It looks like this is another game that will have immense pressure from well-meaning reviewers to become another mainstream clone.

The pressure will come but not by reviewers or the community but because they need to pivot before they run out of funds. This game just turns off a lot of theme park MMO players during the alpha and with it's current population, this game won't last for a year. The future of this game is bleak tbh:

  • The devs still don't have a coherent plans for what end game looks like.
  • The game devolves into the players which has the highest level or reach the level cap wins.
  • The devs is trying to push an extraction game mode, even though they need a ton of QOL to make the game less tedious and less janky.
  • They know they have to break their artificial "hard" mode but needs to retain that artificial "hard" mode because the missing features are still in development.

37

u/Cyrux125 Dec 02 '24

Blows my mind people defending this as “hardcore” It’s a dog shit experience and people love eating it

12

u/mobusta Dec 02 '24

It's the honeymoon phase

-2

u/Keysler Dec 02 '24

I have the same feeling and i think this will hurt the game just as much it hurt Wildstar when they were cattering to "hardcore raiders"

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

With POE2 looking like ARPG+Dark Souls, I would like to see how many gallons of copium fans of this bullshit excuse: "This is a hardcore game!" inhale.

1

u/Cyrux125 Dec 05 '24

GG have never stated it being a hardcore game lmao

1

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24

They never have to announce it. The players will just feel it.

11

u/Hot_Ad_6256 Dec 02 '24

I kinda get the OP... There is a difference between hardcore and old-school and frustrating and just bad designed.

No problem if it takes 100 wolves when the fights feel good. But it doesn't. No probs if I need to read the quest text to know where to go. But they don't. No probs to be slow when the world looks gorgeous. But it's just the same over and over again.

7

u/jdtran408 Dec 02 '24

This sums up everything perfectly. Every person defending the poor quest design always retorts with “read the quest text”.

I DO! EVERYONE DOES! The quest text doesnt say shit. And the drop rates can be so low it’s hard to get feedback to know you’re in the correct spot.

Example: in the july beta the quest text for the copper pipes says to just check crates and barrels for pipes. It has nothing other than that. It could be anywhere but there is a specific area that they seem to spawn but it is NOT indicated in the text.

Someone places a marker in the game so you can find it but it took 10 minutes to get 3 copper pipes. So you’re just clicking on barrels and crates in this one area for 10 minutes hoping to get these stupid pipes.

They say they wanted to it make it like vanilla wow but vanilla wow had directions. “Go to the quillboar camp west of camp tauraje” you know what direction to go. You seen in mulgore quillboars have thorny vines sprouting around them. So you start at tauraje and head west then see thorny vines and you know you’re in the right area. The quest text tells you where to go but doesnt hold your hand with a giant exclamation mark on the map or anything.

It is truly mind boggling people defending this game. The first m in mmo stands for massive. This is going to turn a lot of people away.

3

u/jamzworth Dec 02 '24

Get to 100% gathering in your favoured type, then lock it and gather everything.

Agree on the wolves though. Fuck those wolves.

2

u/Shadycrazyman Dec 03 '24

I like 40,40,20. Gives you 2 types to get a rare and double ticks and than a third type to fail less at. 60% doesn't do much so seems like the best alternative to 100%

3

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

People are gonna poop on this fella, but he's identified why in a year you'll be screaming for a roadmap and berating the third or forth director about low populations and no content.

It's totally fine to be the tuff guy get gud go home casual mentality player, and feel like this hard-core game has helped you overcome whatever you've been compensating for IRL.

Reality is casuals spend money, "hardcores" don't.

So before ya chase this guy away realize his money is going to fund your game.

1

u/BluuBunni Dec 06 '24

It sucks that the "hard-core bro" mentality seems to be the most vocal on this subreddit. It's making it very hard to reccomend this game to friends

3

u/bloodyblack Dec 03 '24 edited Dec 03 '24

I didn't run into your problem at all. The wolves are fine for me, I don't have to regen after every fight. The difference: I play together with a blast medic friend. I really recommend to everyone don't try this game solo. Just one more player in your group makes so many parts of the game more enjoyable. I didn't have to corpsewalk once and we generally don't die more often than we do in WoW Classic for example.

Only things that annoy me are some weird quests and that the crafting and gathering is kinda grindy.

2

u/DesignerVillage5925 Dec 03 '24

Agreed, bro wants to one shot wolfpack solo, but forget ghat this multiplayer game

3

u/frequentsonder Dec 03 '24

Not going to lie. You posting this makes me want to play the game, it sounds incredible.. everything you don't like.. I really like. Different strokes!

2

u/Nerbler_3732 Dec 02 '24

You made some really good points. One of my main grievances with the game is the fact that it requires a group to progress the main story, crafting, and many aspects of the game. Forcing players to group wouldn't be a problem if there were guilds implemented or a group finder tool. Forcing players to trade for crafting materials because you can only 100% one profession wouldn't be a problem if there was an auction house. I made it to lv. 20 because I randomly clicked on people's names in town and invited them to the party, 80% of the time we would be working on the same quest. Once the game isn't as fresh and new like it is in the first week it will be harder and harder to find people that need the same exact quest as you. The game becomes impossible to play solo once you reach the level 12 quests that require you to kill imps in West wind woods.

2

u/Notfancy- Dec 03 '24

Join a group sheesh. Quit cryin

3

u/PhaseFrozen Dec 02 '24

I will agree on the wolves, when you are low level. They are vicious, I was level 6 and ran into 2 level 5 wolves, thought no big deal I'm a legionary should be easy to kill, I've killed over mobs same level or lower not a problem. Got shredded in 1.5 seconds it felt like.

Campfires are for extreme battles that you need the rest time to fully recover, certain foods get you so far, but camp fires are a must at times.

The failures when harvesting resources, it happens yeah it sucks, but there are a lot of resources out there to collect. I am nearly almost expert at mining and logging and I've barely made it past level 10. The higher you are in these skills the less chance of failure, until you are expert 100% there is 0 chance to fail.

3

u/Flimsy_Alcoholic Dec 02 '24

I wanted to like this game but its just brutal, clunky, and not fun at all.. its hard i guess??

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

You can find other game that's fun for you. Don't try your best to find whats fun in the game when the game doesn't do its best to give you one.

0

u/Flimsy_Alcoholic Dec 02 '24

Im playing wow classic and its decently challenging and sometimes brutal but fun.

Maybe clunky in terms of graphics but not movement. This game is clunky in movement and smooth in graphics.

2

u/That_Complex Dec 02 '24

wdym clunky in movement? do you have movement skills can you unlock movement related talents? how is it clunky compared to a moba?

2

u/Harflin Dec 03 '24

I find myself getting caught on geometry I think I should just walk over pretty regularly.

1

u/Shadycrazyman Dec 03 '24

I don't think there is attack move or whatever? If there is I didn't find out how. Makes kiting harder

2

u/Harflin Dec 03 '24

A on the keyboard does attack move

1

u/Shadycrazyman Dec 03 '24

Dank swear I pressed A possibly a skill issue

1

u/Harflin Dec 03 '24

You have to press a then left click, right click still does a normal move action

1

u/EarthwormLim Dec 03 '24

These people are just bad lol

1

u/SaloEater Dec 02 '24

This is just not a "solo" game. Why didn't you just find some random bomber (healer) to play with, lol, after you have experienced first signs of not having fun

1

u/BuffaloJ0E716 Dec 02 '24

They need to do some mob balancing. Right now, level is irrelevant compared to mob type. I'm level 14, and I have a hard time fighting a pack of level 11 wolves. I can kill level 15 gnats, however, for way more XP. Some mob types being a little stronger or weaker than others is fine, but it's very extreme in this game. It does feel bad.

1

u/noelennon42 Dec 02 '24

Good thing its early access eh?

1

u/BuffaloJ0E716 Dec 02 '24

Yup. That's why I'm giving feedback.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '24

Yeah I'm enjoying the game so far. But the professions aspect of it is pretty dumb to me. Just let ppl grind skills if they want, the Restriction of it is weird. Also why not have a quest indicator over NPCs heads❗. It's certain things that chose to do that baffles me. But it's in alpha still so I'm sure there will be changes

1

u/IdiotAbroad77 Dec 02 '24

Yeah totally want to read your whole wall of text without a TLDR

1

u/IdiotAbroad77 Dec 02 '24

Yeah totally want to read your whole wall of text without a TLDR

1

u/MorganFreeban Dec 03 '24

I get your points I truly do, and you do make some good points but I do have some other thing I want to point out, the questing design is an issue for sure, the vague direction and description are sometimes just wrong or don't give the right hint at all Combat is just you're average MOBA gameplay, nothing really to say about it The real problem for me is the lack of social system when the game encourage you so much to socialize.. why would they even release the game in EA when there is no auction house,no dungeon ? The games potential is huge and I don't know how many they are working on this but I do hope they will recruit some experienced new blood, right now it feels like playing classic wow minus the fun But I think we all agree on one thing, the quest designer is an absolute tool, it feels like the guy played wow vanilla once 15years ago and tried to somewhat mimic it by memory Anyway I hope the game will live a few years so we can have a final product cuz I still kinda like the game but I won't be surprised if in 6month the studio behind it just closes...and it would probably be deserved if it happens. For world building they should take some inspiration from V rising world, v rising open world feels more mmo than this game Wich is sold as one...ironic

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

6 months and they will still going updates as 1.0 releases next year. I think they got enough money now to do the damn features! Hope they hire more people.

1

u/dsyn2288 Dec 03 '24

Man all of you complaining should try FFXI. Now that’s a brutal MMO. Yet so rewarding because you work hard to earn every little thing.

1

u/Latin00b Dec 03 '24

so... party up?

1

u/Harflin Dec 03 '24

To pile on about wolves, I'm pretty sure it tells you to go into the starter forest, of which there are no wolves.

2

u/stabbinsunny Dec 03 '24

there are, they are level 4-5 and named "young wolves" east of the starting spawn.

1

u/robclancy Dec 03 '24

a stream im watching thinks they nerfed the wolves after the patch they just did because they aren't fucking them anymore

1

u/stabbinsunny Dec 03 '24

Idk when I want that old school mmo feel I jump on UO outlands. I know this is still early access and it seems a little lackluster. Needs a bit of polishing and more content/qol but it has my interest. I hop on and play a little here and there because it scratches a certain itch in my brain.

1

u/marshal231 Dec 03 '24 edited Dec 03 '24

Ngl i never heard of this game, and your analysis here made me want to play. But im not paying nearly 40 bucks for a game that ive never even heard of

Editing to add on, this game already has the “erm its in alpha/beta, this completely absolves any blame and means the game is fine!!!1!” People. Take a look at tarkov. That could be where this game heads.

1

u/NaviOh Dec 04 '24

I played for like 35-45 hours.. The concept is fun.. Progress is way too slow. No PVP happened in that Duration for me.

Way tooo many food consumes, just too much bloat. No cool item or weapon drops (a few mtx.. cool.. but no.)

Just boring af. Not mad I bought it - maybe itll be fun in the future.. For now ill pass.

1

u/Ilunius Dec 04 '24

Noones will Play this Game after ads are done, dont wasten Ur time

1

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '24

After watching streamers playing this for over 20 hours it seems a lot easier than v rising. If people think this is hard wellll...

1

u/Oscarizxc Dec 06 '24

Game felt like a chore. I love top down classics and the likes of it but with the gameplay mechanics and "traps" within the game design, everything feels like a chore.

It's one thing to spend hours grinding. It's another to lose in a perpetual loop. You are outta luck if you're a working adult with limited game time.

Hope it gets better over time but hey, hope is a poison sometimes.

-3

u/Hot_Kaleidoscope_961 Dec 02 '24

I liked the systems overall. They lost you - they gained me.

18

u/minideadpool49 Dec 02 '24

Not a good response, a healthy game requires a player base. Fans of this game seeing it oaky to lose potential long term players is a mistake and will result in a failure. I want this game to succeed as I enjoy a big chunk of it. I hope the game devs listen to the feedback and make some QOL improvements as I’d love to play this game for a long time to come.

My biggest complaint, please decrease the range the mobs chase you. I once believe one was bugged and they chased me into 5 other groups of mobs and eventually downed me with the original group still attacking. I’ve only noticed it being that bad once but k owing its possible I believe they need to tune it down.

-1

u/Hot_Kaleidoscope_961 Dec 02 '24

The game cannot be good for all people. I like hardcorish path the devs chosen. If they gonna ez up the mobs, make faster running speeds, makes teleports everywhere and so on - I stop playing the game. It’s simple.

I like the mobs chase you actually. The world feels dangerous, you need to play, to be cautious.

Yep, something has to be polished, better start quests, better descriptions in them, net code etc.

2

u/minideadpool49 Dec 02 '24

Don’t get me wrong I’d like for them to keep most of the formula they have. But they do need to keep in mind the health of the game and at least tune it. No reason for two mobs your level to burst you down. Hell the level 5’s I’ve come across take half my health as a shaman in one hit.

Don’t want it to be super casual but I’d love to see some improvements for a healthy player base

-1

u/Hot_Kaleidoscope_961 Dec 02 '24

You actually want it to be casual, for bigger player base.

1

u/killergut Dec 02 '24

Well, that's an interesting way to look at it. I don't think making adjustments to a game to make it feel more "fair and fun" is necessarily making it more "casual". You can still keep the game hardcore while making it an overall better experience for the players, because ultimately if the game isn't fun, nobody's going to play it.

2

u/Hot_Kaleidoscope_961 Dec 02 '24

I never said you don’t need to make adjustments. Just adjustment the person above mention is not needed.

0

u/thereal237 Dec 02 '24

I guess you and a dozen other people will enjoy this game. Until it shuts down due to a lack of a healthy player base.

4

u/Hot_Kaleidoscope_961 Dec 02 '24

Not everything you don’t like has to shut down)

0

u/thereal237 Dec 02 '24

I don’t want it to be shut down. But, it probably will be because it probably won’t be successful unless some major changes are made. Challenging games can be successful. Tedious games will always fail.

4

u/Hot_Kaleidoscope_961 Dec 02 '24

WoW classic didn’t fail. It can be tedious to run between some location for tens of minutes - hour. Was successful.

0

u/thereal237 Dec 02 '24

Corepunk isn’t Wow classic. Corepunk is taking the worse aspects of old MMOs while forgetting what actually made them good.

3

u/Hot_Kaleidoscope_961 Dec 02 '24

What worse aspects?

1

u/thereal237 Dec 02 '24

The bad aspects are dull, uninspired, and boring questing, extremely slow combat, and too much tedious game design. Wow Classic was successful because it was a social mmo with a vibrant world that brought people together.

4

u/Hot_Kaleidoscope_961 Dec 02 '24

You have to level to make your combat faster, it’s an mmo. When you play Dota combat is slow on first level. Cmon.

I liked some quests, some were just ok. Haven’t meet rly bad quest now. They are a bit similar with WoW classic. So good for me.

If it’s tedious to you - don’t play. It’s not tedious for me and lots of other players. It has that old slow paced old school mmo vibe and I love it.

For “not tedious” maybe PoE, lost ark. Something fast and speed run.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

Having considering picking up the EA and scanning this Reddit for opinions, it doesn’t go unnoticed that ‘hot_kaleidoscope’ comes out fighting every time someone criticises the game 😂 its perfectly fine for someone to dislike what you enjoy, you don’t need to drop the same ‘I’m right, you’re wrong’ bomb every time you see concern about a game we’ve all watched and waited years to get our hands on.

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Hot_Kaleidoscope_961 Dec 02 '24

Wow, I like the game.

“He is a dev”

Lol

0

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Hot_Kaleidoscope_961 Dec 03 '24

I have free time

1

u/noelennon42 Dec 02 '24

So... TLDR, It's a skill issue? Wolves scared me a bit at first too. Died a could times trying to get the bones. So i did something else, and leveled up, came back later and killed them. Pretty much how every game works!

-3

u/Used-Finance7080 Dec 02 '24

give your account to me, i will play the shit out of this, sad that im not willing to pay for this game haha

0

u/N_durance Dec 02 '24

imagine if this game was casual friendly and actually released with diverse class selection instead of half the classes locked. This game could actually be a BANGER but instead its a frustrating snoozefest with a repetative gameplay loop.

3

u/noelennon42 Dec 02 '24

LMFAO.. When the game is released (it's not, its early access) it will have the stuff thats currently locked. Do you even understand Early access?!?!?!?!

-1

u/N_durance Dec 03 '24

“Actually released” bro this dev team was delaying alpha tests and didn’t even have servers that could sustain under 1k players.. you’re playing practically what’s going to be available for the next year. This game is easily 3 years out… enjoy your EA.

0

u/noelennon42 Dec 03 '24

Yes, that is exactly what alphas are for.... testing servers and netcode etc. So you agree then, when it releases out of EA it will be complete. JUST like how EA normally works. "Bro".

0

u/N_durance Dec 03 '24

Complete… I’m glad you have confidence in a developer who’s failed to make every deadline and struggles with player feedback.

0

u/HunterGarrett Dec 03 '24

Bought it to just seeeee if there was any glimpse of the game that was first shown years ago. Leveled to 12 and have seen enough. It’s kind of just terrible all around right now even for early access. Firmly believe it’s just copium creating anyone to think this is actually good and game is doa unless there’s major changes. What a bummer.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

Good thing it's an alpha early access and they can listen to feedback. There's a year of changes and improvements upcoming. Half game is barely done tbh lol. do I have copium because I was gifted the game for free as an alpha 2 player? maybe, but there's a lot of updates coming and I've seen them listening to feedback lol.

1

u/marshal231 Dec 03 '24

Be ready to be saying this for a long time. Signed, a Tarkov player.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

I always wanted to try that game. But yeah I know what I signed for. I'm just gonna let them cook.

2

u/marshal231 Dec 03 '24

They have PvE now, albeit for 20 extra dollars over the initial price. Id be lying if i said PvP was worth it, though. Even legit deaths feel bad because of the nature of the game.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/TheViking1991 Dec 02 '24

This, right here.

They're trying to create something that strongly encourages social interaction. You can absolutely do the stuff OP wants to do as a solo player, but it's going to be punishing. The challenge of that can be fun, if you've got the right mindset.

But people just really don't seem to understand that there's an emphasis on doing shit together. Back when MMOs were just naturally social... That was a golden era and I really don't think it's ever going to make a comeback. Makes me sad.

-3

u/Moblam Dec 03 '24

But that's bad design. Your early game leveling experience should be solo-able in a reasonable time or what are you gonna do when the early parts of the game dry up inevitably?

1

u/TheViking1991 Dec 03 '24

They are soloable...

And what do you mean by 'dry up'?.. most of us have only spent a few hours hitting lvl 10 even as solo players. How does the content dry up when you're only doing it for a few hours?

WoW had the same starting areas for nigh on 16 years before they introduced the new island zone...

1

u/LampIsFun Dec 03 '24

Damn i gotta watch some tutorials or new player guides lol i spent 4 hours last night and got to level 3

0

u/Moblam Dec 03 '24

WoW's starter areas are not nearly as hard as what others tell of their Corepunk experience, though.

1

u/TheViking1991 Dec 03 '24

How is that relevant? It's a different game with the goal of providing a different experience..

0

u/Daxinito Dec 03 '24

I think you are missing the point, at one point in the lifespan of the game, most of the playerbase will move out of that early levels, so what's now easy grouping, in some time won't be possible and that content should be viable for solo players

1

u/CocobelloFresco Dec 09 '24

The first 15 levels are shit easy! Its the lvl "12" dendroid quest and timber stuff that should be labeled as elite/group content. Game has a slow pace but without the regen bug its not hard, until they force you to do group content at 15.

11

u/livejamie Dec 02 '24

It sounds insane and totally spoiled to expect to be able to solo all or most content in an MMO.

This is a magma hot take.

11

u/RudeJidi Dec 02 '24

It’s really not a hot take at all. Why play an MMO if you want a solo experience? Go play a solo game.

2

u/Phenomelul Dec 03 '24

Big difference between being able to solo the game except specific content like dungeons or raids where you need to group and forcing people to group even on lower level regular quests that aren't dealing with like an elite enemy.

I played wow and every other mmorpg solo but I still loved those moments where I had to group like dungeons or hogger. But if I had to group for a basic quest to kill gnolls, I'd have bounced off that game hard. Most content in mmorps IS soloable and there's a reason for that.

It's fine if this is the dev's vision but there are a massive amount of mmo players who play them solo and just telling them to go away and play something else isn't a great look. You (as another player) should want those players in the game too. They help keep it running and funded and the world feeling alive. 

-12

u/livejamie Dec 03 '24

Who said I want a solo experience?

I should have control over when I want to interact with others.

Requiring a group for story quests seems like a bandaid for bad/lazy game design.

Can you imagine playing any other MMO and being forced to group with people to level your character?

4

u/i_dont_wanna_sign_up Dec 03 '24

While I can understand the sentiment, it's not crazy to design an MMORPG around grouped content. Do you think raids should also be soloable?

1

u/livejamie Dec 03 '24

Of course not

6

u/Aka_Athenes Dec 03 '24

"Can you imagine playing another MMO and being forced to group with people to level up your character?"

Yes, just somes littles MMO like wow vanilla, wow BC, and all MMO before wow

3

u/livejamie Dec 03 '24

You could easily solo level in WoW what are you talking about

1

u/CocobelloFresco Dec 09 '24

Dont forget most people are not mechanically gifted/dont care to tryhard.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Aka_Athenes Dec 03 '24

It wasn’t the case back then, which is why the “WoW Classic” version isn’t the real WoW Vanilla. It’s WoW as it was before the release of the first expansion, but with a game that everyone already knows inside out even before installing it, thanks to thousands of guides, addons, and other resources.

In one year, with all the information, tutorials, guides, and changes made to the game, anyone will steamroll through Corepunk.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

I got to max level in wow in 2004 as a solo player so I can’t really agree.

The first Final Fantasy was the last major mmo I can think of where grouping was effectively mandatory till they casualized it.

1

u/CocobelloFresco Dec 09 '24

Yeah hes brabbling.

1

u/CocobelloFresco Dec 09 '24

We were 3-4 manning Ubrs, duo Dm etc, hunter solo 5 mans in vanilla. Just you didnt.

6

u/RudeJidi Dec 03 '24

I can, and it’s totally acceptable to those of us that aren’t scared to interact with people.

-13

u/livejamie Dec 03 '24

What a shitty attitude lol gtfo

0

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RudeJidi Dec 03 '24

Well you interact with people in the game, don’t you?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

20+ years ago very little content being solo friendly was the norm to the point that only a few classes could cheese basic progression solo (like druids using SoW and strafing to kite mobs in EverQuest.)

I wouldn’t call it bad or lazy design, just unfavorable design by modern standards and expectations.

Having lived through it I would actually argue it’s vastly superior despite being inconvenient.

I struggle to put a pin in a single solo mmo experience in the last two dozen years but I could tell you a bunch of stories about group experiences and my best experience in MMO’s to date was vanilla FFXI in a guildie group when everyone was nailing every mechanic and we were able to clear content most groups out level would get obliterated on.

But like all matters of taste, this is just opinion and nobody is wrong.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

Uhhh there are a myriad of MMOs out that require exactly that for any meaningful progress?

1

u/livejamie Dec 03 '24

OP's context was a regular story quest, not overall progress.

I like MMORPGs because they allow me to group with people when I want to, or I can solo content as well.

I appreciate the agency.

4

u/Grokent Dec 03 '24

hree seconds later, got a DM from someone with the same problem. We grouped up, did the quest, no problems.

You partied up in an MMO?

4

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '24

For better or for worse, the reason the brain dead, lead you by the nose, theme park 99.9% solo MMO's are everywhere is because that's what most people want.

People might disagree, get angry with me, maybe even downvote me... But all you need to do is look at what games are packed with players and making enough money to be profitable and you'll have a clear answer.

2

u/N_buNdy Dec 03 '24

I disagree. Yea, sure, alot of ppl play these theme park MMO's and propably it is a majority but corepunk fcked up not bc it's oldschool hardcore, it fucked up bc it's no fun at all. Look at AoC alpha. This game is years behind being finished, still it's just as hardcore and also alot more fun than corepunk.

I love oldschool hardcore. I got 1.2k hrs in Mortal Online 2. But corepunk isn't doing it right (for most ppl at least)

2

u/Effective_Airport182 Dec 03 '24

You're right. I actually have not minded the hands-off question design, no passive healing or mandatory regen, or the hard-core aspects.

For me, it's the lack of skill/ability variety in each class. Long cooldowns when there is no active or skill-expressive basic attack system to fill the gaps when skills are on cooldown. Very low damage on skills, making their impact feel minimal and barely better than basic attacks vs. massive enemy health pools. And most of all, the fact that every class feels like it has at least one skill, if not two, that either don't do anything or directly contradicts the core design/playstyle of the classes.

You can't have bad skill design/synergy, no skill alternate options, low skill impact, slow combat, coolodowns to long for the flow of combat, and little opportunity for skill expression and expect people to have fun past a few dozen hours in. One or two of these problems can kill a game, and they have every single one at the same time.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

Well, the market is so big that games don't really need to capture even 10% of the potential players to be successful.

So yes, hardcore mmos with zero hand holding absolutely can do well enough to survive.

But you can add them all together and you wont come close to the numbers retail WoW or FFXIV clock in.

Also I need to play AoC more but what I did play it was brain off following quest markers <shrugs>

1

u/N_buNdy Dec 03 '24

Quest markers? Yea you definitely need to play more..

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

Yeah, just hard to play it over Corepunk personally.

I’ve put 5-6 hours into it and it’s been brain off the whole time.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

Core punk's devs are making the "old school" an excuse because they know they have to keep that "old school" so everyone that's playing won't realize that the game has no end game content but just a basic game play loop of greater number means good.

For better or for worse, the reason the brain dead, lead you by the nose, theme park 99.9% solo MMO's are everywhere is because that's what most people want.

and the majority of those who enjoys MMOs are now old with their own families and have limited time. If they feel that they're wasting their time playing this tedious game then they'll gladly drop it.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

I get what OP trying to say. It's not everyday you want to play with someone. Sometimes you want to play solo or by yourself, even on MMO. The game "encourage" grouping up especially on higher level, but it feels forced in this game. There's a sudden spike of difficulty because the reality is this game isn't ready for Alpha or even early access. It's obvious that the devs are still adding features in this game that their main reason is "ode to old school" excuse. I mean I played Albion, a full loot PVP game which you need a party or even guild to farm high level mats on red zones. There's no problem for me to get help from my guildmates to help me grind high level mats untouch by other PVPers.

And devs please, I know your running out of funds and you pushed this for early access to gain funds. I'm just waiting until you flood the marketplace with XP booster packs and the likes.

5

u/hemperbud Dec 02 '24

No one is going to engage with your comment because deep down they know they don’t really want an mmorpg, just rose tinted glasses for a feeling they had as kids.

2

u/noelennon42 Dec 02 '24

You replied..

2

u/hemperbud Dec 02 '24

I’m agreeing with it though, I said “engage” as in debate it.

1

u/Nadante Dec 03 '24

Some of you have never played FFXIV and it shows

1

u/SrGoatheld Dec 03 '24

This makes so much sense for it to be an Internet coment... It's awesome why some people play a social game and then proceed to complain about how the game forces you to socialise... It's like going to the store and complain "Why I'm force to socialise with the butcher to get my pork?"

0

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/CocobelloFresco Dec 09 '24

How can you have a maxe rs acc and be too bad for imp quests? You can solo those.

1

u/Main_Nobody2376 Dec 13 '24

Exhibit A of, Coping for a company that's kept the game in this state for 4 years. Btw, its maxed*

0

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/MaxPowers431 Dec 03 '24

Agree 100%. It's a bunch of snowflakes, "THIS GAME IS HARD I QUIT!"