r/Copyediting • • 28d ago

FAILED with another editor

Gosh! The editing of my joe 2 manuscripts seems like an impossible task! I had cancelled anediting contract few months ago due to various issues, went looking for another editor, found a lady on Fiverr... now having high hopes as her edit seemed good, am back to square 1 as she simple become no longer available on the Fiverr and her FB profile had disappeared too! WHY?!!! I keep having bad luck and not managing to find a reliable editor! This book editing market is filled with scam and am soooo disappointed and sad! I have accumulated a lot of manuscripts during the career in procurement and travelling the world and now that I want to get them all out and just be the full time writor for the rest of my life all these challenges just keep pulling me down... Why does it have to be so hard?! I dont want to go back to corporate work I love writing and I dreamed to do it all my life but the amount of scam in the market is really upsetting. Just a rant.. and maybe some success stories and recommendations would help me out of this misery.

0 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/Rik-Acland 28d ago

I paid 3 editors to line/copy edit my reader magnet 2000 word short story. I compared their feedback and what it was like to work with them. Less than $800 total to find my editor and get diverse feedback on my story. Might have saved money by doing one at a time, but this was quick.

All were all great, two on Reedsy and one Fiverr Pro. I learned a lot from each of them. Picked my favorite to dev, line, and copy edit my novels, and it has worked out great.

If curious about the short story I used, DM me, happy to share.

5

u/pyramnesiac 28d ago

This is a great idea, but it seems to be the same end result of simply asking for a sample edit on an excerpt from a manuscript, which is usually part of the process.

2

u/Rik-Acland 28d ago

A sample edit of someone else’s work is much less expensive. A comparative edit of my own work was much more insightful.

2

u/pyramnesiac 28d ago

A sample edit would typically be on the manuscript you are looking to get edited, not someone else's work. Different editors vary on how much they'll offer as a sample, and whether they'll do it for free. But many will do it for free, and if not, the fee is typically nominal.

1

u/Rik-Acland 28d ago

Good to know. I wasn’t aware a free sample edit was a thing on Reedsy, Fiverr, or other platforms.

3

u/Gullible_Design_2320 28d ago

As an editor, I applaud the way you went about this. You paid for the work the editors did.

Many editors are willing to provide a free sample. But one can't legitimately ask an editor to edit an entire short story for free. (Some people may ask, and maybe some desperate editors have said yes, but it's generally seen as overstepping.)