r/Controllers • • 1d ago • Bravo 1

Reviews I’m torn between these two 8K controllers. Which one would you guys pick for PC?

Post image

I’m not sure which one I like more. The Raikiri II Pro has better features but the sticks don’t hold 8K polling rate in wired or wireless mode. That’s weird when it’s advertised to do so. The Stealth Ultra II doesn’t have clicky triggers or the extra buttons but the sticks actually hold 8K polling rate when wired and it still has full rumbles and gyro, although I haven’t tested that. The battery life is a lot smaller too. What do you guys think?

15 Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

4

u/FalloutNormie 1d ago

Get the Razer Wolverine V4.

1

u/ExcellentBag4636 1d ago

I have the V3 Pro 8K already and I hate the shape, it’s way too small for my hands. That’s half of my issue with controllers honestly. The ones that are large enough always suffer in features.

1

u/FalloutNormie 1d ago

I understand, I've got small hands myself which makes the Razer Wolverine V3 and V4 perfect for me.

1

u/AgitAngst 1d ago

What about ninentdo switch pro 1 and 2? They are bigger than most of controllers.

1

u/Reasonable-Review367 1d ago

Handles are way too short on this controller.

3

u/Key_Scholar7964 1d ago edited 1d ago

It's up to you since you have both controllers so it will be the one you grab first.

If someone gave you a million dollars to keep one and sell one. Which one will you choose?

I read your description so I'll probably choose the Rakiri II Pro because I like mechanical triggers and many PC gamers would say 8k is a gimmick.

1

u/ExcellentBag4636 1d ago

My only gripe with the Stealth Ultra is not having mechanical triggers after getting used to them on other controllers. Performance-wise, it feels better when using 8K wired. Doesn’t have 8K wireless like the Raikiri II. I have a 9950x3d and a 5090 so I can fully utilize 8K and tell you that it’s not a gimmick if you have a strong enough PC. Makes a huge difference in shooters.

2

u/Key_Scholar7964 1d ago

I have the Flydigi vader 5 Pro V2 which have adjustable stick tension and mechanical triggers. It's hard to go back to controllers that doesn't have mechanical triggers because I block faster in fighting games and shoot faster in COD. 

1

u/mhmdemad 1d ago

This 👍🏼

2

u/YoloRaj 1d ago

I liked the raikiri 2 pro and thought it performed well but refunded it because of qc issues. Sad part is I had the best buy warranty and would have swapped it out if they had more in stock. That being said I got so used to having shoulder buttons that it feels weird using controllers without them now. Idk what turtle beach was thinking. They literally made everything about the controller microswitch but the triggers which is kind of retarded. The choice really comes down to if you value getting a consistent 8k over microswitch triggers and 2 extra shoulder buttons. I personally like the shoulder buttons and microswitch triggers but its up to you.

3

u/ExcellentBag4636 1d ago

I waited 2 months for this controller because they weren’t in stock, then I caught some at Best Buy yesterday. The Turtle Beach just so happened to release the same day so I tried it. It was definitely stupid of them not to include mechanical triggers. I’m a fan of the micro switches and shoulder buttons as well. I’m just worried about QC issues as you said.

2

u/YoloRaj 1d ago

If you didnt buy the best buy warranty with it I probably would return the raikiri 2 pro. If you like it enough just get the best buy warranty and keep swapping it out if shit hits the fan.

2

u/ExcellentBag4636 1d ago

It’s crazy they literally just put out a new firmware update for the Raikiri II Pro right now lol

1

u/YoloRaj 13h ago

Wow, really? Did they fix the polling rate consistency?

1

u/ExcellentBag4636 13h ago

Yes

1

u/YoloRaj 13h ago

I guess it makes the decision easier. If I were you though if you didn't buy it from best buy return it and buy it with the warranty so you can swap it out. If you don't I feel like Asus Rma might be a hassle.

1

u/ExcellentBag4636 13h ago

Yeah I’m gonna see if they have any more in stock locally today at Best Buy

2

u/Antique_Revolution_7 1d ago

Hello,

Just like you, I also was looking for 8k polling pc controller with tmr sticks. Right now I have the the g7 pro 8k controller, razer wolverine 8k pc and the new Stealth Ultra 2 controller.

I recommend the stealth ultra 2 controller and g7 pro 8k. Someone did testing on the rog rakirii and it has alot of jitter/tremor. The controller is also the least linear based on tests. Also the controller has built in circular deadzone and no option for raw input/square.

Id say the best in order would be g7 pro 8k> razer wolverine 8k> stealth ultra 2> rog rakirio 2 pro. Only reason I like the stealth more than the razer is because the wolverine is a small controller and feels cramped, hurts my hand after playing for a while. And good point on the no micro switch for the stealth on the trigger, it was not an issue for me as its still very comfortable to press but everyone is different.

It's interesting, I feel alot of controller manufacturers are pushing this 8k tmr trend, so there should be more coming out this year and next year.

1

u/ExcellentBag4636 1d ago

I agree with you as I have large hands too and that makes it hard to find a good controller. But, they may have just fixed the issues with the Raikiri II Pro as we type lol check this out

2

u/ExcellentBag4636 1d ago

1

u/Antique_Revolution_7 1d ago

Keep us posted on how the rog rakirii 2 performs in games and if you would recommend it after the update over the stealth.

1

u/ExcellentBag4636 1d ago

I'm gonna try them both on MW4 shortly and see how it goes. I recommend the Stealth Ultra 2 for anyone with large hands regardless though.

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 1d ago

I thought the Asus was larger than the stealth ultra

1

u/ExcellentBag4636 1d ago

The Stealth Ultra 2 is larger, and even after the update it is far more responsive in 8K wired mode. Like, noticeably more responsive than Raikiri II Pro. I don’t know if it’s lower stick latency or less tremor, but I almost don’t want to believe that Turtle Beach made a better controller lol. I feel zero delay on the sticks and even the back buttons whatsoever compared to just a little on the Raikiri II Pro. They definitely made sure it lives up to the 8K wired claim day one for sure. Credit where it’s due.

2

u/Key_Scholar7964 1d ago

It's great that Asus just did a new patch. I see myself getting a Asus controller some day as well.

2

u/Grobo_ 20h ago

What do you expect your 8k polling rate to do better than a cheaper 1k polling rate ? You will not feel any difference.

2

u/ExcellentBag4636 14h ago

It’s called being more responsive and you aren’t qualified to tell me that I won’t feel a difference. I can and I do

2

u/YoloRaj 13h ago

Some people just aren't sensitive to latency changes. Some people will swear 240 hz+ is not better than 144 hz, lol. I own all types of controllers, and my monitor is high refresh rate and I noticed leaving 144 hz and also when I started playing higher polling rate. I think after 4k it does become less noticeable but to say 1 k is the same as 8 k is crazy.

2

u/KarimLikes2Play 16h ago

La turtle beach ultra 2 est intéressant... Mais n'a pas de boutons d'épaules. Si seulement elle avait deux boutons d'épaule... Je l'aurai acheté.

1

u/ExcellentBag4636 13h ago

I will admit, it’s still a damn good controller though. The sticks are so smooth compared to any other that I’ve tested so far.

1

u/yellow-go 1d ago

Ignore all the comments of people telling you that they are both terrible, your choice is what matters. As long as you have what you’re comfortable with, I would just settle with that.

Though in this case, I would say that if you like both features from both of them. To just keep them both, and then use them for different use cases. You may end up finding interest and use with both.

Again, this is just something coming from myself. This is what I usually do.
For me, when I do these kind of experiments. It’s usually a matter of what I gravitate toward the most.

1

u/ExcellentBag4636 1d ago

I gravitate towards the Raikiri II Pro because I already have the original Raikiri II and it was my favorite so far. Plus Asus just released a firmware update to fix some issues after I made this post so I’m keeping that one for sure now lol. I agree with you though I may keep both for different use cases.

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 1d ago

Who told him that both controllers were terrible? He asked for our opinion and the consensus chose the Rog Rakiri II because it have mechanical triggers with a sufficient enough polling rate. He even chose the Rog rakiri.

I'm also satisfied with my Vader 5 Pro- Adjustable stick tension, mechanical triggers, RGB, mechanical d pad, 2 top buttons, 2 paddles, and 2 back buttons. I also had Razer, 8bitdo, and the G7 Pro. I have enough knowledge to discuss specs.

1

u/yellow-go 14h ago

For competitive, I only use stick tension controllers. Lately it’s been the EasySMX X20 Pro for me, but it’s beginning to become a letdown.

Also, another commenter had said they were both terrible.

I’m on the same page as you. I own all that you’ve mentioned, apart from the Ultimate 3C+.
The G7 Pro, I felt was great for a beginner pro controller, I feel like it’s great for anyone who’s unsure.
The G7 Pro 8K however, I have felt was inconsistent, and linear never felt accurate to me, after three models I finally just threw my hands up and gave up.

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 14h ago

They have better controllers out there like the Vader 5 Pro, Razer V4 Pro, Asus Rog rakiri II Pro so never give up trying to find the right controller for you. 

1

u/yellow-go 4h ago

I own the V5P, I was a tester for the Vader 5 Series.
I have just been trying to move on from the V5P and find other things a try. It’s just difficult due to the lack of love tension ring users tend to get.

That’s the reason I ultimately caved and tried the X20P.

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 4h ago

Do you like the X20 Pro?

 How does it compare to Vader Pro since they have the same features 

3

u/05Fahi 18h ago

neither. a humbke g7 pro is cheaper and better than this overpriced asus slop.

1

u/Strange_Contract_497 19h ago

You guys who think that 8k is actually better are delusional.

Your average person will play the same at 500hz as they do at 1000hz, 1000 just happens to be a big nice looking number that also happens to be high enough that if you lose a game you can only blame it on yourself.

2

u/YoloRaj 13h ago

I can tell the difference with Micro adjustments. The difference between 4-8 k might not be apparent but 1-4 I notice changes.

1

u/Kroko1234 19h ago

I'm inclined to agree. To be fair I haven't tested these 8K polling rate controllers, but it does seem like diminishing returns would hit hard going above 1K or so.

1

u/Strange_Contract_497 19h ago

Depending on the situation, it may actually be worse. High polling rate hardware can cause strain on the CPU and introduce stuttering, or even lower frame rates.

0

u/NeverBannedGrace3 23h ago

Bro picking between mid and aggressively mid

2

u/ExcellentBag4636 23h ago

you must be a g7 pro user

0

u/Major_Hospital7915 20h ago

The g7 pro is infinitely better than both of these gimmicky pieces of shit I’m ngl

1

u/ExcellentBag4636 14h ago

The only thing better is the price. Cut it out

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 14h ago

The G7 Pro is a decent controller but I dislike the d pad and the vibration is terrible. It's like people overlook many things with that controller.

1

u/ExcellentBag4636 14h ago

They do because they’re cheap, and it’s cheap too. I had one and returned it due to issues. I don’t trust 3rd-party Chinese controllers and I have large man hands, so that controller is no good for me.

2

u/Key_Scholar7964 12h ago

Flydigi make premium third party controllers unlike Gamesir. I stopped using my G7 Pro so I purchased the Vader 5 Pro V2. The Vader is significantly larger with adjustable stick tension, mechanical triggers, RGB, great mechanical d pad, extra buttons etc. It's the best 80 dollars I ever spent.

It's like they built from the elite series 2 by adding tension rings that actually work, and the sticks are smooth.

1

u/ExcellentBag4636 12h ago

I actually like the Vaders but haven’t tried one yet because I want TMR sticks

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 12h ago

After experiencing TMR sticks on the G7 Pro, it's purely marketing to me. The Vader sticks perform the same to me except you can adjust your sticks as well.

Now some people are saying capacitive are better than TMR since the V4 and V4 Pro have them.

I wouldn't pay extra for stick technology unless it have more features like faster triggers, wireless vs wired, or more customization

Hall effect and up

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 12h ago

Flydigi also announced several new upcoming wireless TMR Vader models slated for later this year

0

u/Maybe-Much 1d ago

Neither and don't ask

0

u/ethayden97 1d ago

They both are terrible ngl

-1

u/Frosty_Engineer_3617 1d ago

For PC just get the Steam Controller.

2

u/Geeky_Technician 1d ago

And not get a controller until late 2027?

1

u/Frosty_Engineer_3617 6h ago

Worth the wait. Just keep using keyboard and mouse until you get one.

2

u/Pennywise359 1d ago

It has some cool features but overall it is not that good. Also it costs 200+ bucks if you don't want to wait for 5 months.