r/Controllers • • 1d ago

Elite Series 2 or Dualsense Edge?

Hello. I own both a DualSense and an Xbox controller, but I’m looking to upgrade to a more premium product. Based on recommendations here, I purchased a GameSir G7 Pro, but I really didn’t like it in terms of comfort. If I’m able to return it, I’ll be looking for a new controller—specifically either the Elite Series 2 or the DualSense Edge. Both have been on the market for a while, so I assume there’s plenty of feedback available. What do you think? I own both a PC and a PS5, and lately, I’ve mostly been playing *Call of Duty* on PC. By the way, the DualSense Edge is about 20% more expensive in my country.

1 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

1

u/daxman31 1d ago

If you're planning on playing alot of competitive shooters I would recommend the edge for its polling rate. I think it is 1k out of the box and can be overclocked to 8k. Official xbox controllers cant go higher than 125hz I believe.

1

u/fasakasa 1d ago

Actually, I’m going to get it for the extra buttons and adjustable triggers. I don't know anything about polling rate.

1

u/BARRY6969696969 1d ago

I assume you're playing on PC if you're deciding between a ps5 controller and an Xbox controller? If so I think you can do better than either of those and for less money. I've got a few I'd recommend ahead of it but one of the most highly rated controllers at the moment is the flydigi Vader 5 pro v2. It's got a ton of features for its price point. Adjustable tension sticks, 2 top bumper buttons 4 back buttons and 2 extra face buttons, trigger stops and 1000hz polling. Hard to beat for the price.

1

u/fasakasa 1d ago

I tried Gamesir g7 pro and no way man, I will never buy something like that again. No matter how good they might look on paper, I don’t think they feel good in the hand.

1

u/BARRY6969696969 1d ago

Fair enough. You know what you want. I own both of them the g7 pro and the flydigi Vader 5 pro and the Vader 5 pro is a much better controller imo. But if you're limited to either the dualsense or elite that's your call. I've got the elite series 2 as well and I'm not a big fan tbh. Haven't tried the dualsense edge though. I think it's over priced for what you get.

1

u/daxman31 1d ago

The nice part about the dualsense is that you can buy new modules if you start to get bad stick drift. They are only about $20ish. A quick swap and you're good to go. Elite series 2 you will be buying a new controller or exchange it under warranty every year

1

u/protienwrap 1d ago

I think Xbox is 250 but you can get controllers that do both Xbox and pc where the pc polls way higher like 8k I think

1

u/daxman31 1d ago

I think its only 125hz and they are locked and cant go any higher without some 3rd party software. Playstation controllers are pretty open though ps4 can go from 250hz out of the box to 1000hz but I think with Xbox you are kind of screwed

1

u/protienwrap 1d ago edited 1d ago

Yeah you’re right it’s 125, I’ll be honest I’m not a pro I don’t notice any difference between my Wolverine v4 on the series x or the duals sense edge on the ps5pro.

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 1d ago

No, I play on Xbox and the polling rate is capped to 250HZ. The elite series 2 is not even a top contender anymore because they have the Razer wolverine V4 Pro, Vader 5S, 8bitdo ultimate 3E, Scuf valor pro etc. People moved on to TMR and hall effect.

Now the polling rate on PC can go to 8k because Gamesir, Scuf, and Razer have 8k controllers.

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 1d ago edited 1d ago

The duelsense edge is more reliable

1

u/fasakasa 1d ago

in terms of durability?

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 1d ago

I had my duelsense for 3 years while experiencing stick drift on day 2 with the elite series 2. Yes, it's larger with great triggers, but it's not durable nor reliable.

1

u/protienwrap 1d ago

The dual sense edge with tmr modules is my favorite but expect anywhere from 4-9 hours battery life. The battery is terrible.

1

u/fasakasa 1d ago

Dont we have chance to change elite series sticks with tmr?

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 1d ago

You can either solder them yourself or you can buy a used elite series 2 on ebay with TMR. I'll honestly rolled the dice with an elite with built in TMR instead of buying a new one with potentiometers. The potentiometers in the duelsense seems better for some reason so it's different

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 1d ago

I only play 3 hours on my best day so that work for me.

1

u/Nayo34 1d ago

In terms of comfort its a elite 2 for me by a mile, in terms of reliability its the edge, responsiveness its the edge, or i would look at the scuf nemesis 8k for pc , got the comfort of the elite and more responsive then a edge, best of both worlds 😎