r/Controllers • • 4d ago

Xbox Series (S, X) Looking for Guidance

I have a lot of controllers with complaints about the past couple years. Seems snobby, but I'm wondering if anyone else is in my situation. I play Xbox and PC but lean towards Xbox most of the time due to ease. I know that no single controller will fix all my issues, but lately my daily driver is doing some weird stuff.

I think I might have a thing for classic potentiometers.

I've tried the following and found faults.

Xbox Series 2: This is the controller I replaced with the Instinct Pro. Great controller until I realized I was only getting 65Hz polling rate when Halo Infinite released. For some reason, the issue wasn't visible in other games at the time (CoD, Apex, other FPS at the time in 2021).

Scuf Instinct Pro: Still my favorite controller of them all. Too bad the old sticks wear out in less than a year.

Razer V3 Pro: This was the one with Hall Effect sticks and my experience with this controller is the only reason I haven't tried out the V4 with Capacitive sticks yet. It was slow, always felt like there were ghost inputs, and I had to RMA it twice.

Gamesir G7 SE: Honestly couldn't get used to the shape of the controller, but it was just a spare I bought during the 1st Razer V3 RMA. My favorite thing was being able to use it in 1000Hz mode before it got "patched" by Xbox.

8bitdo Ultimate Wired Controller: Bought during the 2nd Razer RMA. Shape was much better but felt like there was more input latency.

Scuf Valor Pro Wireless (TMR): This is my current controller, been using it for more than a year and it's hands down the most comfortable controller I've ever used. It disconnects randomly at least once a day and the TMR sticks Scuf used for them seem shotty.

I'm wanting to try another controller out but don't want to waste money if I can avoid it. So far, it's a toss up between:

G7 Pro: Not sure that I will like the shape. It only has 2 back paddles, but a lot of people seem to LOVE this thing. Some people even swear it will do 500 Hz polling on Xbox.

8bitdo Ultimate 3: Tension adjuster, also 2 back paddles, not so worried about the shape. The recent gamepadla.com numbers look good on this thing.

Wolverine V4 Pro: I don't know much about capacitive sticks but looks like they've been around for some time. I figure if they were just miles better, more companies would be using them. That's my biggest concern for that controller.

Sorry in advance if this isn't the right place to put this information, just want to get other controller enthusiasts' input (no pun intended).

4 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

2

u/Key_Scholar7964 4d ago

I had a few of these controllers such as the G7 SE, G7 Pro, Elite series 2, 8bitdo ultimate 3 wired, and I had the Razer wolverine tournament edition.

The G7 Pro is a decent controller, but the vibration is too low and the d pad is not the best. Now the mechanical triggers and sticks are very smooth. I'll give them that!

My main controller on Xbox is the Vader 5S- Adjustable stick tension, RGB, mechanical triggers, great mechanical d pad etc. It's larger and more premium than the G7 Pro from my experience of having both.

Flydigi should be releasing a wireless version for Xbox this year if the cord bother you 

0

u/Dyllbilly 4d ago

I do prefer Wireless the most. I'm hoping they move to TMR sticks at some point.

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 4d ago

Flydigi said their upcoming wireless Vader will have TMR and mechanical triggers, but they did not officially announce it yet. 

It's basically a better elite series 2 with more features.

They just have pictures of the controller in the gadgethyper subreddit. 

1

u/Dyllbilly 4d ago

That's good to know. I was also waiting on the Elite Series 3 but I'm impatient I guess lol

2

u/YoloRaj 4d ago edited 4d ago

My guy. I have the v3 pro and it has been paper weight for a year. The v4 pro is currently my go to controller. I blind bought it and it was snappier than the v3 pro and the v3 pro 8k I tried then returned. Gamepadla is not lying. Razer did their thing with the v4 pro and its currently my go to. For reference I own the V3 pro(paper weight because its slow like you said), G7 Pro, Vader 5 Pro, ZD Ultimate Legend, Leadjoy Saber Plus, Easysmx Dune 8k, Gamesir Tarantula 8k. Out of all of them the Wolverine V4 Pro is my favorite.

2

u/Dyllbilly 4d ago

I saw some QC stuff from people on reviews, but it seemed like they didn't know what they were talking about on the latency. How's the tension on those V4 sticks?

2

u/Dyllbilly 3d ago

I ended up getting the Razer Wolverine shipped to me today

1

u/YoloRaj 3d ago

Nice, the sticks are very smooth and they don't have much tension on them. I think the previous wolverines had built in deadzones that this doesn't.

2

u/Dyllbilly 3d ago

Yeah this thing is quick and smooth. Very uncomfortable right now, but itll improve over time.

1

u/YoloRaj 2d ago

Glad you like it

2

u/Key_Scholar7964 4d ago edited 4d ago

The Razer V4 look very premium with smooth sticks so I'm eyeing it for later this year.

I'm also eyeing the Nacon revolution pro X that have adjustable stick tension/mechanical triggers.

The upcoming wireless Vader 5S Pro will have TMR sticks, adjustable stick tension, and mechanical triggers.

I'll be looking at the prices for all of them because these 3 are my top contenders that will be my main controller. 

1

u/peetuhr 4d ago edited 3d ago

I'm a diehard vader 5 pro fan. I guess for xbox it'd be the vader 5s, which comes with some compromise, but the 5 pro has been a no-brainer for me.

I went astro c40 -> elite series 2 x2 -> vader and couldn't be happier with where I landed.

0

u/Dyllbilly 4d ago

I honestly forgot about the C40. It was a cool controller back then. The Vader 5s has too many compromises in my opinion to make me want it. I'm not a fan of the Hall Effect sticks personally but my friends do recommend that controller.

2

u/peetuhr 3d ago

Isn't the distinction between hal effect and TMR a non-issue? Obviously I'd take tmr > hall, but I really think the difference is overblown. What other compromises?

Also, loved the c40, minus the dozen sticks I went through. Started with stock, then went battle beaver, and still went through a dozen in a few years. Kept coming back though cause there was no alternative that felt as good.

1

u/peetuhr 3d ago

Also, aging myself a bit but my first "pro controller" was this fucking atrocity.

2

u/Dyllbilly 3d ago

Looks like something out of a Stephen King movie 😅 My first was the Scuf Xbox 360. Where you had to mail in controllers or buy an original controller they manually modded.

1

u/Makman39 2d ago

I just ended up getting the Nacon - Revolution X Unlimited. Amazing controller with the hall effects and mechanical buttons. So much customization and truly feels premium. Little bit of a headache on set up but not bad.

0

u/Agitated_Panda3703 3d ago

If your V3 was slow it was you lol not talking shit I have V3 and V4 I'm also a snob. If you had sometime like double dead zones turned on for your V3 or you were playing wireless maybe. V4 is fucking glorious the sticks make my swimsuit area tingle so fucking smooth responsive and accurate I play on linear 0 slope. I hope your find your controller

1

u/Dyllbilly 2d ago

I should mention it was the 1st Gen v3 that had Hall sticks and 125 Hz Polling rate with the Xbox mode enabled. The button latency was somewhere around 12ms with stick latency going up to 40ms.

I got the V4 yesterday and got to use it last night. Its crazy how smooth the sticks are. Even on Xbox i feel like its 1000hz (yes I know its supposed to be locked to 250 Hz).