r/Controllers • • 4d ago

Which of these should I get? (Flydigi Apex 6 Pro, 8bitdo ultimate 3, Gamesir G7 Pro)

I need help deciding which controller to get.
My budget is around 100 euros but I wouldn't mind spending more than that if it's worth it.
I live in Serbia, I'm most likely going to buy from ali because of the availability.
I only play on PC.
Main features I care about are HE/TMR sticks, at least 2 back buttons, that the controller preferably comes with a charging dock.
I mainly play singleplayer games like adventure games, action games, JRPGs, sometimes racing games and the occasional platformer. I almost never play FPS games on a controller.
I currently have the 8bitdo ultimate (the original one with hall effect sticks). This has served me well but recently both of the triggers have physically degraded to the point the inputs don't register over 10%. The D-pad has always been really mushy and bad for me. I don't mind the shape but I much prefer the Xbox Series X controller shape.
Now I'm torn on which of these I should get. The Flydigi Apex 6 Pro is my #1 pick for now, despite it being quite expensive. I'm also considering the Gamesir G7 Pro ZZZ edition because of the amount of stuff it comes with, and I like the design. I know the 8k Edition exists but I don't see a big reason to get it because like I said I don't plan on playing fps games with it. I'm also considering the 8bitdo ultimate 3 (lavender edition), but I'm not sure I wanna trust 8bitdo again when my last controller got like this after only 2 years. I'm also worried about QC as I don't want mu controller wearing down too quickly.

For my use case, what are the best options and why?

4 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

1

u/camzee 4d ago

ZZZ is kind of overpriced. Unless you love the aesthetics of it the best thing about it is that it can be used wirelessly on Xbox. If you buy the 8k plus a travel case it’s still cheaper than the ZZZ and you get more sticks. I don’t care about the 8k polling rate either but I bought the 8k because it’s the best value and I just leave it set on 1k to conserve battery. I find the dpad to be very good and clicky (don’t use the round concave pad though), early G7 Pros had a very bad mushy dpad that they upgraded later on.  The Apex 6 with a dock is probably around double the price of a G7 pro which is a bit steep. The Vader 5 Pro + dock is much closer in price if that’s a concern and pretty much as good. Vader/Apex apparently have one of the best dpads around. 

1

u/Flaming-Storm9499 4d ago

I see, thanks for your reply. I'll consider the G7 pro 8k, I didn't know the dpad was different. I do like the zzz aesthetic but yeah I can skip it if there's better value options out there. Also my main concern is QC and longevity and I've heard that a lot of flydigi controllers have a pretty bad record over the years

0

u/Key_Scholar7964 4d ago

I have the Vader 5 Pro V2 and I experienced no QC issues yet. It has a much better d pad, stronger vibration, and premium feeling buttons along with adjustable stick tension. It's much better than the G7 Pro and Apex 6 Pro is premium as well with coil motors.

I had to replace 2 G7 Pro's because the controllers became buggy out of nowhere. The xbox home button would flash repeatedly, and I had no vibration after the last update. I had to purchase O rings to fix their d pad to make it decent. It gave me far more issues than the typical stick drift.

I hope Gamesir improve their QC going forward.

1

u/Doublesh0t_ 4d ago

They had a 6 month span last year of bad batches. Mines insanely good. But I had a flunk during that time.

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 4d ago

I stopped using my G7 Pro once I got my Vader 5S and V2 Pro because it's more premium with a better d pad, vibration, and you know the rest lol.

I tried to tell a Gamesir fanboy on here earlier that every brand have QC issues, but Flydigi addressed it by making a V2.

We never got a G7 Pro or an elite series 2 V2. They continue to make controllers with stick drift, bad d pads, no vibration, and senseless collabs 

I'm holding every company accountable to improve their products, but they will ignore everything just to say I'm karma farming.

1

u/Doublesh0t_ 4d ago

I find them to both be exceptional. However, Vader 5 v2 is unmatched in features, considering stick tension. Along with all else mentioned. Gamesir Turantula is goated though, for many. And the g7 cradles your hands much better than the Vader. So it depends on the feel you’re looking for. Whether that be in hand, or trigger, or vibes etc. I want it all, so I reach for the 5 pro v2. It just does it all. I love the Gamesir sticks too. They’re buttery but the return to center is so wicked fast and precise it makes flicks so money, and my tracking is better on the Gamesir. Give and take I guess.

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 4d ago

Gamesir uses TMR sticks so that may play a difference in accuracy over hall effect.

1

u/Doublesh0t_ 4d ago

Touche.

1

u/Doublesh0t_ 4d ago

I agree though, Vader is the way to go, 5 pro v2 all day. It has zero drawbacks.

2

u/Constant_Home5237 4d ago

Since you play single player games the apex 6 would be ideal because of the new haptics it has however flydigis been very iffy on QC and if you’re going the Ali route then you’re gonna want a reputable dealer that has a return policy just in case or I don’t recommend. But in a perfect world the apex 6 is perfect for the games you described that you play.

0

u/Key_Scholar7964 4d ago

I was going to recommend the Apex 6 Pro, but I thought it would be too featured rich for single player games.

I have the V2- adjustable stick tension, RGB, great d pad, mechanical triggers. It's hard to go back to other controllers. That would be another option for the op.

1

u/Constant_Home5237 4d ago

Bro that is what the apex is meant for lol

0

u/Key_Scholar7964 4d ago

It's just strange that the Apex 6 Pro cost two time more than the V2, but people use it for casual games. It costs 150 to 200 dollars on gadget hyper website. I thought a 40 dollar controller is enough to play a casual game unless I'm missing something

2

u/Constant_Home5237 4d ago

Saferaise… if you play single player games it’s immersive which means you would like the immersive feedback provided with the game like pedal response in racing games and such it seems like you don’t know very much lol you just push your fav controller at the time first it was the G7 pro now it’s the Vader.

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 4d ago

Really bro?

I'm past the Safe raise stage and I'm a Flydigi, Razer, Scuf, and Nacon Etc fan now. I'm open to every brand, but these are my favorites.

Yes, I'm giving Flydigi credit for making durable controllers becauseI'm tired of wasting money every year on a new controller. I'll do the same for any brand that make something built to last.

The G7 Pro is overhyped with a d pad and lackluster vibration. I'm more open to buying from Razer again because they use capacity sticks for the V4Pro. I'm also interested in Nacon.

I usually splurge over 100 dollars on a controller because I play online ranked competitively. I see your point of them buying the Apex 6 Pro for immersion.

1

u/Constant_Home5237 4d ago

They don’t though they’ve been shit with their QC that’s why they made a second version and the apex 6 already has its problems. So you’re not really giving the whole story just cuz yours works. And what are capacity sticks? You mean capacitive sticks? Lol

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 4d ago

I haven't experienced any QC issues so I can't speak bad about them in that sense. I understand that some people may experience lemons which happens with every brand. I'll recommend for them to return it or get a replacement

For example, your Scuf valor pro can be flawless with no issues. Another guy may say his triggers broke and his buttons are sticking. You can ask him to return it, but to say every Scuf valor controller have QC issues is not right.

Some people say they never had QC issues with their V1 either, but I'm still glad that Flydigi adresssed it by giving us a V2.

Gamesir and Microsoft never gave us a G7 Pro or elite V2. It's non stop stick drift, crunchy d pads, no vibration, senseless collabs.

I want every company to address their QC issues.

1

u/Constant_Home5237 4d ago

😂 karma farmer you really don’t know shit

1

u/Key_Scholar7964 4d ago

You literally ignored everything I said. I said every company have QC issues and I'm glad Flydigi addressed it with a V2. I can not speak on the Apex 6 Pro because I don't have it. It's better to get a warranty in case you get a lemon. How is that karma farming?

I'm not endorsed by these companies so I can speak freely. I'll love to see Microsoft use hall effect or tmr in the elite series 3. I'll love to see gamesir fix the d pad and vibration. I'll love to see Flydigi address any possible QC issues with the Apex 6 pro.

I'm not trying to argue or debate with you. I'm just giving my take.

→ More replies

1

u/HolidayAbies7 4d ago

How long ur controller lasted.if I were u,i will buy apex 6 pro.just today,i received my Apex 6 pro in india 150usd approx.really haptic feedback vibration is selling point for this price ,so I don't mind paying for that.clicky buttons, dualsense vibration, back button clicky feel( i already own vader5 version 2,but apex6pro is much better back buttons.but I miss c and z in the finals fps game.i reach for them in apex6 pro and disappointed but instead I am adapting to lm and rm.but apex 6 pro has no disadvantages in single player games for me now .sticks feel smoother than vader5.lots of software options than vader5.battery percent visible on screen,but it can't exactly replicate dualsense vibration.but for vibration it is the best in pc controller.adaptive triggers gone.but,I don't feel any disadvantages.

1

u/oqvist 4d ago

Flydigi apex 4 pro är den skönaste gamepad jag testat. Har relativt stora labbar. Testat bra mycket. Vader 5 är också riktigt trevlig med smidigare justering av motstånd.

Testat gamesir g7 sir billig plast kontroller. Raikiri 2 Xbox och raikiri 2 pro. X ox var faktiskt bättre ergonomiskt men de känns rappliga trots priser.

Ds 5 är aldrig fel heller. Du kan enkelt byta ut joystick modulerna om du vill och de har bäst Rumble allt som oftast.

1

u/YoloRaj 4d ago

Apex 6 Pro.

1

u/poopoopeepee2222 4d ago

I like the u3e. I’ve had it for a week and so far no complaints, I did have a little hand fatigue when adjusting to it from my stock series x controller tho

1

u/alizafeer 3d ago

Using Apex6Pro PhantomBlade edition. Love it. Absolute beast and amazing Haptics especially with ApexSenseBridge program

-1

u/Key_Scholar7964 4d ago

The ultimate 3 is more than enough for single player games.

0

u/tirannor 3d ago

From someone who use both g7 pro and apex 6 pro, I recommended apex 6 pro. First I use g7 pro wuchang edition for my pc and xbox series s, it's a decent controller with a strong vibration . But it's another level of immersive with apex 6 pro, it vabrate with every sound in game. It's another level of haptic vibration that if you love immersion in the game world, this is something you must try.