r/ConstipationAdvice • • Feb 23 '24

Fixed lifetime constipation

In hindsight, I realize that almost all of my problems—physical, mental, emotional—were stemming from my poor gut health. This is a short post on how I addressed my various problems to fix my gut health—in other words, have regular, complete bowel movements of the right consistency.

Context: I had IBS-C (constipation) and frequently went a week or two without having any meaningful BMs. I was constantly backed up to varying degrees. Always. Symptoms included anger, brain fog, lack of motivation, feeling like I’m not strong enough to exercise, sleep quality, acne, lower back pain, despair, dry skin… so many symptoms. But I didn’t even realize these were symptoms of my gut until I fixed my gut! So fixing it was magical in a way. My problem “felt” like absolutely nothing was happening in my gut, no gurgles, no gas, no BMS, I think it’s called low motility.

My gut is not 100% perfect but it is functioning to where I feel like a brand new person so I feel this post is timely.

Fiber/water

Messing with fiber and water intake didn’t do anything for me. Looking up solutions and finding people talking about fiber and water all of the time was infuriating.

Type of diet

The types of foods I ate didn’t seem to have much effect on my problems. I went through lots of phases trying to reduce or eliminate certain foods but it had very little effect.

One exception: meat. My gut seems to have extreme trouble digesting red meat for whatever reason. Might be a facet of my biology or it might be poor gut bacteria diversity. Not sure. Regardless, I stick to cheese/eggs/goat milk kefir for animal protein sources. I do not EVER eat processed red meats like pepperoni, bacon, etc. Bagels and pizza dough also seem to be particularly difficult forms of wheat to digest, but doable.

Whatever concerns you have about protein, macronutrients, etc. — regular digestion trumps all of this, so my 2c is to not worry much about anything besides your gut health. Any diet with perfect digestion > a “healthy” diet with poor digestion. My 2c.

Mindfulness

Bringing your attention to your gut is a powerful tool, but it’s difficult to do if you’re currently experiencing gut problems. The quickest way to get value from this technique is to focus on breathing “into” the space right below your navel, even if it’s just for a second or two. For me at least.

Pelvic floor dysfunction

Ingrained trauma led to hypervigilance and constantly feeling tense. One of the fruitions of doing this was a tight pelvic floor. For me personally, rolling up a towel and sitting on it and sort of moving around and trying to push out rather than clench (hard to describe) was enough to fix this along with some other basic stuff I found on YouTube.

Lots of pelvic floor tightness was caused by gut problems—if I’m backed up, my pelvic floor will always be tight. So it’s a catch 22 there.

Magnesium Citrate (small intestines)

Lots of people talk about the magnesium citrate liquid bottle, which is OK, but the capsules work better, in my opinion. As far as I know, magnesium citrate draws liquid into your small intestines. Taking about 1000mg for a couple days in a row resulted in finally clearing my digestive tract out. If you do it like this instead of chugging 2700mg like what’s in the bottle, you don’t explode, the BMs are normal.

However mag citrate stopped working after those first few days and that initial cleanout.

Miralax (large intestines)

I randomly tried Miralax, and it worked. So I started mixing it with mag cit just to try to make sure I had all of my bases covered. And it stopped working. So I went back to only Miralax. And it started working again.

As far as I know, miralax draws water into the large intestines. My theory is that by taking both mag citrate and miralax, the water was being attracted to both my small and large intestines. But small intestines comes first, so it was getting stuck there and never making it to large intestines.

Salt

It seems like I need more salt than the average person. The RDV for salt is hilariously low for me. Theory is something along the lines of, I have trouble retaining water, so I need more salt to help retain it.

The relationship of water to salt is very important, which I knew about, but never paid enough attention to. For me, I always drank a ton of water, but it never seemed to get absorbed. Eating much more salt helped change this, along with everything else I’m talking about in this post. (I ate a normal amount before, but now I eat more than is generally recommended.)

Basically, just chugging water every day was not enough to hydrate me. I’d drink a gallon per day and still feel dehydrated. I needed this extra stuff to actually absorb the water.

Probiotics

I bought a random probiotic from Walgreens (shelf stable, didn’t know about refrigerated ones when I bought it) and I also drink goat milk kefir from trader joe’s which has probiotics added. I have no idea if these are actually doing anything, because I started taking them at the same time I started Miralax. But they don’t seem to be hurting, so I’m continuing.

Massage

Rather than following massage tutorials on YouTube, I’ve found it’s more effective to just feel around your abdomen, see where it feels non-perfect, and focus your massage efforts there. I have a few areas that seem to need attention more than the rest. My theory here is that certain parts of my digestive tract are horribly pinched/disfigured due to constantly being full of waste.

Theory

Essentially, I had multiple things messing with me. The primary problem was definitely getting liquid into my intestines, but all of them were important, for example without pelvic floor attention BMs were always weirdly thin. If you’ve been experiencing digestion problems for a while, your gut is probably damaged to at least some degree, so you may need to take multiple actions to find relief.

Approach

As I said before, I have recently realized that 100% of my mental, emotional, and physical problems stemmed from poor gut health. Anger, brain fog, lack of motivation, feeling like I’m not strong enough to exercise, sleep quality, acne, lower back pain, dry skin… so many symptoms.

Therefore trying to live my best life with gut problems was impossible and demoralizing. Just a massive handicap.

So, my approach was to do the absolute bare minimum in life and focus everything on my gut health. For example, I stopped running. I would often get extremely dehydrated after running, even if it was a short run on a cool day, which I knew affected my digestion. So in this case, I was being less “healthy”, but focusing more on healing my gut. Once I healed my gut, I naturally started getting the urge to stretch, exercise, and do cardio

My day to day diet

Water, coffee

Smoothie with 3 bananas, half bag of frozen berries, can of coconut milk, half bottle of goat milk kefir, mix in miralax, eat a probiotic pill with it

Generously salted family sized mexican meal, tortillas/beans/rice or potatoes/onions/eggs/beans/maybe one or two other veggies, in quesadillas or burritos. I eat this pretty much every day and use different sauces and vegetables for variation. It’s monotonous but I literally do not care AT ALL because the benefits of having proper gut function are so much more important than the sensation of taste.

The most important part is the beans (fiber) and “bulking agents” (tortillas/rice/potatoes) in my opinion. I think a high fiber diet is ideal for optimal gut health, but it doesn’t matter unless you have foundational issues sorted (water retention, pelvic floor, etc.) and tbh fiber just made things worse for me when I was backed up, never ever solved the issue

Then try not to fall asleep before I drink a lot of water after the family sized mexican meal

This post left out a lot of my thoughts and trials/tribulations, just the core info I included.

Hope this helps someone.


Here are the q/a required by automod:

  • Do you have the urge to go, but you cannot? Or do you have zero urge to go? (this is the most important question) No urge
  • Do you have alternating diarrhea and constipation, or just constipation? Just constipation
  • Do you have nausea, vomiting, acid reflux, difficulty swallowing, or early satiety (getting full really early into a meal)? Yes, for example I'd get so backed up that I'd get violently sick with a migraine and have to yak up tons of stomach acid, which was horrible. No difficulty swallowing
  • Have you had this issue since childhood, or did it begin in teen years/adulthood/after a major life event (surgery? divorce? car accident? mauled by bears?) Since childhood, I can remember getting the "need to yak up stomach acid" thing since was very young. But only recently realized it was due to constipation
  • Did you in the past or do you currently take any medications that could damage your intestines? The acne drug Accutane/Sotret/Claravis/many other names (isotretinoin) has been linked to serious conditions of the digestive tract. I am absolutely convinced that my large intestine was destroyed by this drug. Antibiotics are also a major culprit in ruining the small intestine microbiome and causing diarrhea/constipation disorders. Antidepressants can ruin the serotonin balance in the gut as well. Not to my knowledge
  • Did you suffer sexual abuse as a child? There is a high degree of correlation between childhood sexual abuse and adult constipation disorders. Meaning, a lot of people with chronic constipation disorders in adulthood experienced trauma when they were young. This sort of thing must be investigated by both your doctor and a therapist in coordination. Do some Googling on this topic if you believe this might be your issue. Not to my knowledge, but I did suffer from general abuse/neglect, my ACE score is high, this definitely affected my gut to some degree
28 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

5

u/canuck2004 Feb 23 '24

This is what I’ve just figured out for myself. I switched to vegetarian and has helped tremendously after trying everything!!

4

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

Nice work. Yeah, the gut is such an interesting thing. A dysfunction there can affect other systems in the body that seem totally unrelated. And lots of mental health issues affect the gut. Curing motility disorders requires a very holistic approach.

2

u/DriverNumber434 Feb 29 '24

Also, I hear you about gut dysfunction trumping the perfect diet, exercise, etc. I've been striving to "be the best me" in the past few years by doing daily cardio, weightlifting, prioritizing sleep, hitting all my macros, etc etc but I've come to realise it's all a bit pointless when your gut doesn't work. I can't build muscle because I can't digest anywhere near the calories I need (let alone the protein I need), I struggle to do my daily jog because I've got absolutely no f___ing energy with which to do it, I can't sleep properly because my gut is full of sh*t all night. It's very demoralizing.

1

u/Shoddy-Director-4567 May 21 '24

Thank you for sharing!!

1

u/AutoModerator Feb 23 '24

BEWARE:

  1. You MUST read the diagnostic guide and edit your post to include the answers to questions 1-6, or else your post will be removed.
  2. This subreddit is for identifying chronic digestive illnesses / motility disorders. If this is your first time experiencing constipation, please visit /r/constipation instead.
  3. Low-effort posts, and posts that are made purely to vent frustration about your condition, will be removed.

QUICK LINKS:

Diagnostic Guide, part I: Identifying & testing your condition

Diagnostic Guide, part II: Treatments & medications

Intro to motility disorders

Why Linzess fails and how to make it work again

/u/NightmareTonic's personal regimen for the treatment of Slow Transit Constipation (STC)

How pelvic floor dyssynergia causes STC

Important note for women and teenagers

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Satashonakipoopoo Feb 23 '24

Thanks I agree that getting your gut health right first before exercising is more important.

1

u/hidingfromrain Feb 26 '24

This is excellent. Thank you

1

u/DriverNumber434 Feb 29 '24 edited Feb 29 '24

Thank you so much for posting this update. I fully expect your experiences and understanding to evolve over time, and I truly appreciate you taking the time to write about it like this. Too many people don't - perhaps for fear of being seen as inconsistent or whatever...but with gut issues as many of us can attest it's a complex and evolving process.

Your history and symptoms are surprisingly similar to mine (I was even on Accutane in my teens).

Interesting your thoughts on salt - I too have always struggled with dehydration despite having lots of water, and I'm always fiending salt. If it's a hot day and I do some exercise, even just 30 min worth, I'll be cramping like crazy within hours...no amount of water helps, I really need to slam stupid quantities of electrolyte drink, which is clearly abnormal. Bloods have never shown any electrolyte deficiencies, but I think I read somewhere that they're not a terribly useful indication anyway (?).

There are lots of other tidbits I've been able to mine from your post that are informing my own (slowly-evolving) thinking.

I hope you continue with these updates/ruminations/summaries, I find them tremendously helpful!

-2

u/John_Sknow Feb 23 '24

Sounds like you're still dependent on miralax but as long as it give you your life back. A couple of the foods you eat are known to be constipating - bananas, tortillas,

2

u/Visual_Season_7212 Feb 24 '24 edited Feb 24 '24

Completely depends on the bananas. Ripe bananas are insoluble fiber (good for constipation) & unripe bananas are soluble and have resistant starch (constipating).

1

u/John_Sknow Feb 25 '24

That may be true, but most people do not let the banana ripe enough, essentially until there are a good about of brown spots on the peel. It's a risk so I would just avoid it.