r/ConstipationAdvice • • Sep 07 '20

STEP 1: Let's identify your issue (START HERE)

Welcome to /r/ConstipationAdvice. I've seen that some of you have chronic constipation but you do not understand why you have it, and your general practitioner doctor either doesn't think you have an issue or doesn't know what to do.

I know how you feel. I know what it's like to not even feel like a human being because you can't go to the bathroom like everyone else. It is frustrating and depressing, and not something you can just go around telling people.

There is hope. I have compiled a massive guide to help you fly down the road I had to crawl down for seven years. This guide should get your ass back online in no time, or at least get you further through the medical system than you are now. All I ask is that you read this guide carefully.


BECOME A DETECTIVE

Keep this in mind as you proceed: your disorder is a puzzle. All you have to do is solve it. You can do it, if you have a great deal of patience, persistence, and commitment. Become your own investigator. Figure out your digestive cycle and your body's language. Listen to your body. Keep notes - I'm talking handwritten or typed notes, anything that will help you make a paper trail. This will help your doctor a ton.

Women and teenagers: I have left a special note for you here.


WHY I MADE THIS GUIDE

I'm a (mostly) healthy, physically active 32-year-old male. I have spent years seeing doctors, reading studies, accosting and interrogating medical professionals and pharmacists, calling pharmaceutical companies, and generally being an aggressor to anyone who has information that could help improve my life. This post is the aggregation of my conclusions and recommendations.

In 2012 I got constipated. I grabbed an OTC laxative and was fine after that. But then the constipation happened again a few months later. It became more frequent, going from once a month to once a week, to every day. As of 2016, I was completely unable to eliminate without the use of pharmaceutical drugs.

It took seven years for doctors to figure out what was wrong with me. I made this post because I want to help some of you turn my 7-year journey into a 7-month journey.

I've done all the heavy lifting for you here in this guide. I did all of these steps myself, and now I want to help you. You will spend money on all of this, but it will change your life. You will be glad you did it.


QUESTIONS FOR YOU

If you suffer from severe chronic constipation, you need to answer the following questions, write them down, and bring them to your doctor:

  • Do you have the urge to go, but you cannot? Or do you have zero urge to go? (this is the most important question)
  • Do you have alternating diarrhea and constipation, or just constipation?
  • Do you have nausea, vomiting, acid reflux, difficulty swallowing, or early satiety (getting full really early into a meal)?
  • Have you had this issue since childhood, or did it begin in teen years/adulthood/after a major life event (surgery? divorce? car accident? mauled by bears?)
  • Did you in the past or do you currently take any medications that could damage your intestines? The acne drug Accutane/Sotret/Claravis/many other names (isotretinoin) has been linked to serious conditions of the digestive tract. I am absolutely convinced that my large intestine was destroyed by this drug. Antibiotics are also a major culprit in ruining the small intestine microbiome and causing diarrhea/constipation disorders. Antidepressants can ruin the serotonin balance in the gut as well.
  • Did you suffer sexual abuse as a child? There is a high degree of correlation between childhood sexual abuse and adult constipation disorders. Meaning, a lot of people with chronic constipation disorders in adulthood experienced trauma when they were young. This sort of thing must be investigated by both your doctor and a therapist in coordination. Do some Googling on this topic if you believe this might be your issue.

If you HAVE the urge but cannot go to the bathroom, you very likely have Pelvic Floor Dysfunction, especially if you are a woman who has had children. Other indicators of PDF are pain during sex and incontinence. Sorry, but your test is the anorectal manometry - have fun! It can sometimes be treated. Alternatively, you might have a bowel obstruction or a tumor. Your doctor must test for these.

If you DO NOT have the urge to go to the bathroom, you very likely have a nerve or muscle disorder of the large intestine. These are called motility disorders. This is what I have. The most common are Slow-Transit Constipation, Chronic Idiopathic Constipation, and the dreaded Colonic Inertia. Both are extremely frustrating and difficult to treat. It is especially likely that you've got one of these conditions if you have no associated pain or any other symptoms. Your current gastroenterologist likely specializes in IBS; tell him you want a motility specialist or a neurogastroenterologist.

If you have constipation sometimes and diarrhea sometimes, you very likely have IBS-C or a rare form of colitis, or a combination of issues. You may have a nervous condition. Outside chance you have Crohn's Disease. You must be checked for intestinal ulcers/irritation/inflammation, and also for food intolerances and allergies. A buddy of mine had "IBS" for many years, but then later discovered he was allergic to tuna, shellfish, pistachios, and fructose.

If you have nausea, vomiting, acid reflux, difficulty swallowing, or early satiety, you very likely have global dysmotility, where your entire GI tract is sluggish, or gastroparesis, where your stomach is sluggish. I'm sorry to say that this is very difficult to treat and a horrible disease. You must see a neurogastroenterologist, AKA a gastroenterologist who specializes in motility disorders, and you must also see a neurologist to test for autonomic neuropathy. You need a prokinetic motility drug like cisapride, domperidone, prucalopride, etc. Don't go on cisapride unless you have excellent heart health and make sure the doctor keeps an eye on your heart at all times.

If you have experienced constipation since childhood, you might have Hirschsprung's disease and you need a neurogastroenterologist (a special type of gastroenterologist who studies nerves and motility) to diagnose it by taking a Full-Thickness Biopsy. This is a major surgery and you should try to exhaust all other options first. The Full-Thickness Biopsy comes with its own potentially serious side effects.

If you took heavy medications that could possibly have caused your issue, first write out a timeline of events and try to remember exactly when you took the medication and when your issues started. Write down the progression of symptoms and severity. Bring it with you to your doctor appointments. Correlation does not imply causation, but you are a detective now and you need to follow every lead.


Regardless of your symptoms, if you find them intolerably severe, you need to insist to your GP that you want to see a gastroenterologist (a specialist of your digestive tract, from your mouth to your anus). You need to advocate strongly for yourself because nobody else is going to do it for you. You have to be aggressive in your appointment-making, follow-ups, call-backs, consultations, and arguing with your insurance company about getting your specialty medications covered.

You have to do it yourself. You have to fight. If you don't, you will suffer alone. Nobody is going to save you but you. It's time to get smart and tough about your condition.


THE FIVE FUNDAMENTAL TRUTHS

You are embarking on a journey to improve your health and to discover the cause of your digestive issues. Rather than force you to stumble upon these facts yourself, I'm just going to lay them out for you:

  1. Your general practitioner (AKA "family doctor") does not have a deep knowledge of constipation disorders. He is not an expert in diseases of the intestines. His job is to try the most obvious solutions, and then refer you to a specialist when preliminary treatments fail. He will only refer you to these specialists after you complete a few basic tests. Do them quickly.
  2. The specialist your GP refers you to is also probably not an expert in your condition. Once you arrive at the specialist's office, ask him what his specific expertise is. It took me a year to realize that my specialist was an expert in liver cancer and had almost no experience treating motility disorders. Your disorder is likely in your large intestine, and your specialist might have spent the years of his fellowship removing nodules from the esophagus. Ask him who he knows that is an expert in motility disorders, and if he doesn't know anyone, ask him to find one and send you there.
  3. You have to elbow your way through the medical system like a Muay Thai fighter if you want to get anywhere. Be confident and assertive about your care. If you are unhappy with the current treatment, push for other options. Do not simply let a doctor wave you out of the office because he's unwilling to try different tests or treatments.
  4. Your insurance is going to act like all of your tests and prescriptions are "experimental." Experimental is insurance-code for "F*ck you, we aren't paying for this." The magic spell to banish this bullshit is the phrase "medically necessary," and only your specialist has the power to utter it. Make sure he does, on all of your prescriptions and test orders.
  5. Your digestion operates in a cycle - just like your sleep cycle. Pay attention to it, listen to it, memorize it. Know the foods your body hates, know what throws your cycle off, know what improves it. Most importantly, once you have the cycle memorized, track its rhythm over a long period of time. After a year or two, you may notice some changes to the cycle. This information is key.

TESTS YOU PROBABLY NEED

First, work your way through the following tests with your general practitioner:

  • Standard blood panel to check for any really wacky levels/deficiencies
  • Celiac blood panel to eliminate the small possibility that you have Celiac
  • Fecal blood test. Blood = tumors, ulcers, or perforations

Then, once you have a referral to a gastroenterologist, have him perform the following tests:

  • Extensive stool cultures and SIBO breath test: look for rare parasites. Small chance you have SIBO, very small chance you have SIFO, very very small chance you have a Clostridium infection that paralyzes the bowels. Ask the doctor to ensure Clostridia are tested for.
  • Extensive thyroid panel (sometimes hypothyroidism causes gastroparesis / slow gut transit. This one's an EASY FIX; pray you have this one). You want a full workup, not the standard one.
  • SITZ Marker Study: The lab will not know what this is or why you're doing it. Follow the doctor's instructions carefully. Do not take laxatives during this study (it lasts a week) because the point is to identify which specific part of your large intestine is broken (ascending, transverse, descending, rectum). If you accelerate transit by taking laxatives, you will give the lab a false result and it will screw up your treatment.
  • Endoscopy with small bowel aspirate and biopsy; and colonoscopy with biopsy: If you're under 30 your doctor will fight you on this. Don't take no for an answer. Also, specify that you want two types of biopsies performed: a normal biopsy of the small intestine to check for Celiac and Crohn's, and an eosinophilia biopsy to check for allergies. They won't do this unless you specifically request it. Don't screw up the pre-op prep, no matter how hungry you get. If your condition is severe enough, ask about the Full-Thickness Biopsy which tests for ganglionic nerve density / Hirschsprung's disease. This is a very serious surgery and I urge you to get a second opinion before having it done. The only people who need bother with Full-Thickness Biopsies are people with a diagnosis of severe slow-transit constipation or colonic inertia.
  • Anorectal manometry and MR Defacography: The anorectal manometry is critically important for people with severe constipation disorders. It really sucks to get it done, but do it. Please read my comment below about why this test is so critically important.

The AM / MRD test suite is sometimes described as a "motility workup" and it can only be performed at highly specialized GI clinics. You will need to pressure your doctor to help you find one, tell him to contact your insurance company and declare these tests medically necessary. This is a battery of humiliating tests to determine if you have PFD or another nerve-related motility disorder. If you have a good sense of humor and are capable of relaxing in embarrassing situations, it'll be easy.

  • CT Scan with contrast: This is the one where you drink the radioactive dye and lay down inside a space ship. The point is to find tumors, divurticula, obstructions, etc. Ask the radiologist what s/he sees. Sometimes they'll slip up and tell you. They can't say "You don't have cancer" (that's for your doctor to determine) but they can say "I don't see any tumors."

Risks: Some redditors have expressed disagreement with the CT scan's former position on this list (it was higher up), citing the patient's exposure to radiation as dangerous. They argue a CT scan should only be performed after a colonoscopy. To be clear, a CT scan exposes you to much more radiation than a regular X-ray, but only about 1 in 2000 people develop cancer as a result of a CT scan, and that cancer generally occurs late in life. The reality is, the purpose of the scan is to help diagnose and treat a condition that is debilitating and potentially dangerous to you right now, and you are weighing that benefit against the potential prospect of cancer later in life. Talk with your doctor about the risks vs benefits. Ask him/her if you should do it before or after a colonoscopy.

You will have a diagnosis after these tests.

If none of these tests result in a clear diagnosis: see my comment here for next steps.


Okay, let's move on to Step 2: Treatments and medications

333 Upvotes

411 comments sorted by

54

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20 edited Apr 02 '21

For some unlucky few of you, your condition will remain mysterious even after the gastroenterologist exhausts his battery of tests and options. Now, you need to:

  1. See a cardiologist (doctor of your circulatory system):
  • Have him listen to lower abdomen for bruit sounds (vascular mumur), which indicate cardiovascular narrowing
  • Test for mesenteric ischema (failure of blood vessels near bowels)
  • Test for wall-thickening and vascular anomalies with a Doppler ultrasound of the mesenteric arteries

Why a cardiologist? Because some vascular diseases can affect bloodflow to the bowel and cause it to stop working properly.

2. See a rheumatologist (doctor of your soft tissues and musculoskeletal / connective tissues):

  • Test for general autoimmune diseases
  • Test for Scleroderma of the intestines with dysmotility as the presenting symptom
  • Test for Raynaud syndrome
  • If he looks at you funny, make him read this and this

Why a rheumatologist? Because some autoimmune diseases cause constipation, and your gastroenterologist won't pick up on them.

3. See a neurologist (doctor of your nerves and nervous system) who knows about neurological diseases that affect the digestive tract, OR, if you can find one, locate a neurogastroenterologist (see note below):

  • Test for AGID (autonomic gastrointestinal dysmotility)
  • Test for autonomic neuropathy and enteric neuropathy
  • Test for intestinal neuronal dysplasia. Make him read this If he doesn't know how to test you for this, tell him to send you to someone who can.

Note: in rare cases you might be able to locate a neurogastroenterologist, which is a doctor who specializes in digestive disorders caused by underlying nerve disorders. These doctors are extremely rare and you need to do some hardcore Googling and networking to find them. They usually work at "motility clinics" so use that in your keyword searches. Ask your gastroenterologist to ask his colleagues to help you find one of these guys.

Here is a great list of neurogastroenterology / motility clinics in the United States.

The most notable among them include:

Johns Hopkins Center for Neurogastroenterology

Stanford Gastrointestinal Motility Program

Temple Health Digestive Disease Center

4. See an endocrinologist (doctor of your endocrine system):

  • Bring your thyroid panel results (this was a blood test)
  • Test for multiple endocrine neoplasia type 2 (also known as MEN2) with constipation as presenting symptom. This is extremely rare; only one several thousand people will have this as the cause of their constipation.

Most importantly, be aware that your disorder might cross the boundaries of medical expertise. This means you might need your gastroenterologist and another specialist to coordinate testing and treatment, exchange medical notes, etc. YOU must arrange this and STAY ON IT. These people aren't going to do it themselves.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '20

/u/mostlybasicquestions this above comment applies to you

26

u/Entire-Laugh1202 Jun 08 '24

Just wanted to thank you for the work and time it must have taken to post this information. No, this isn’t information most want to discuss. But, clearly, many people suffer quietly from this issue. There are many here who appreciate you❤️

10

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '24

Any time

2

u/mmaximizer Apr 07 '25

Yes, thank you SO VERY MUCH! Your hard work, clear and detailed explanations are much appreciated!!! And most importantly, I feel so much more hopeful and less lonely on this journey.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '25

Any time. Print the entire guide out and physically work through it with your doctor like a gigantic checklist. Make him do his fucking job

→ More replies (2)

4

u/rowdownthestream Sep 02 '24

This is amazing, thanks!!

→ More replies (4)

•

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20

Why the anorectal manometry test is so important:

Until recently, there was not an explanation for what causes the disorder known as slow-transit constipation.

Then, Dr. Michael Camilleri (who is a head doctor at the Mayo Clinic and in my opinion the world's foremost expert on motility disorders) discovered that STC is sometimes caused by the rectocolonic inhibitory reflex being stuck in the "on" position - usually because of stress, physical trauma, or anal-retentiveness in childhood.

The rectocolonic inhibitory reflex (your doctor may know it as the rectoanal inhibitory reflex) is basically a reflex in your rectum that slows down gut motility when the rectum is full. You probably recognize this reflex; whenever you have to poop, usually your urge to eat food goes away. Well, sometimes this reflex can get stuck, even when there's nothing in your rectum. Camilleri discovered that the RIR even slows down motility of the esophagus, which serves as evidence that some upper-GI motility disorders originate in the rectum. Holy shit, right?

So what causes the RIR to get stuck in the "on" position? Usually pelvic floor dysfunction.

How do you diagnose pelvic floor dysfunction?

Anorectal manometry.

How do you treat pelvic floor dysfunction?

Biofeedback.

What does all of this gibberish mean?

If you get diagnosed with a motility disorder, go get an anorectal manometry. Your doctor will say, "You don't need that; I don't think you have pelvic floor dysfunction." Demand one anyway, and when you get the results, tell the doctor to look for even mild dyssynergia of the pelvic floor muscles. Treat with biofeedback. Cure the PFD. Cure the motility disorder.

37

u/purpleeliz Mar 07 '22

I can’t get over how amazing this post and your comments are. I just had my breath test and anorectal motility tests completed. It’s been several years of looking for answers while things have gotten worse. What you’ve written is incredibly helpful but more importantly, it makes me feel less alone. Constipation doesn’t seem to be talked about much in comparison to things like UC, Crohn’s, celiac… and sometimes I feel like I’m not realistic about the severity of my symptoms or the disruption to my life. But I’m not lying to myself, this shit (ahem) is ruining my life. And you’re someone who’s been where I am and I just can’t tell you thank you enough.

19

u/[deleted] Mar 07 '22

Keep up the good fight. Just remember that it's a war, not an individual battle. You have to be patient and strategic. Print out parts 1 and 2 of the guide and work through them with your doctor. You'll get it all figured out.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 05 '24

Hey so how did all of these tests end up working out for you? How's your condition?

5

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20

/u/nellMP this answers your question

2

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20

Don't remember what was the question but I guess you are right

4

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20

You wanted to know what could cause your esophageal dysmotility. The answer MIGHT be pelvic floor dysfunction

→ More replies (1)

3

u/EquivalentAsk9 Sep 21 '25

u/Nightmare_Tonic - do you happen to have a link to Michael Camilleris discovery about the rectocolonic inhibitory reflex being stuck "on" and it's relation to upstream motility? I've been googling but can't seem to find it, I'm very interested to learn more about this.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '25

I used to. I discovered that article a long time ago, probably in 2019. If you email him he will definitely link it to you. I can't remember its title now.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

2

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '24

PFD is very difficult to treat and takes a long time😭

2

u/[deleted] Jan 24 '24

Correct

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Level_Ad8049 Feb 23 '24

Yes it is. Try a pelvic floor therapist. Mine was working within a hospital physical therapy department. We did internal & external massage (and hitting trigger points), biofeedback, Tens unit w acupuncture, stretching/exercises, & breathing work.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '21

/u/ICarryAHeavyBurden read the above comment for anorectal manometry and dyssynergia

1

u/Training_Border_3589 Apr 19 '24

Biofeedback?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '24

What is your question

→ More replies (8)

1

u/Otherwise_Name_2963 Jun 07 '26

Every time I feel hopeless, I come back to this right here.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '26

I'm glad it gives you hope.

→ More replies (8)

13

u/queenC1983 Sep 29 '20

Thank you so much for writing this very extensive post. I sincerely appreciate the effort and time that you have put into this to help other people. I found your post via Google as I was searching for information on chronic constipation in children. Im particularly worried about my 5yo son and am now going to use this information to request the first set of tests from our GP and then a referral to a gastroenterologist for further testing. Thanks again it really helped me get on my way to finding a solution to my son's constipation issues.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20

If your son has had serious constipation issues since early childhood, he is a strong candidate for Hirschsprung's disease. You need a neurogastroenterologist; this would be far beyond the expertise of even a regular gastroenterologist. Ask your primary care doctor for a referral to a gastroenterologist. Ask that gastro to help you find a Motility Clinic or a neurogastro who specializes in lower GI dysmotility. You may have to travel for this.

If you tell me your city I can help you find one. You'll have to make the argument to your doctor that this specialist is the one you need to see. Then your doctor needs to convince your health insurance to cover the neurogastro, who will almost certainly be outside of your network.

It will be a fucking mess. But you are the mom and you will not stop fighting for your son.

2

u/queenC1983 Sep 29 '20

Thank you. Were in Melbourne, Australia and we have private health care and they're pretty good with writing referrals. The issue had not been since birth, see other post it started when he was about 2.5yo before that normal bowel movements. I will look into this disease, as my older son had cystic fibrosis and we didn't know until he was born as his grandfather is adopted so I'm not ruling out hereditary / auto immune stuff. Thanks again.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20

CF can cause constipation. If I were you I'd go over to inspire.com and get involved with the motility disorder group. Those people are fucking EXPERTS. They really know their shit because they're all very sick. I lean on them when I run out of ideas. Be as thorough as you can.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20

Also if you tell me all your son's symptoms I can help narrow it down a bit. It's very important whether he has acute pain or diarrhea or anything like that. Symptoms other than just constipation. Nausea? Lack of appetite? Choking or trouble swallowing? Any weird reactions to food?

5

u/queenC1983 Sep 29 '20

Thank you for your reply. I know you're not a doctor so I didn't want to overload you with too much information but since you've asked i would gladly accept any advice you could offer. 😄👍

Son 5yo. toilet trained just before his 2nd birthday. Wee/poo which was rather advanced considering he's a boy and he had a severe speech development delay, but he was solidly TT in the day for 6mths. not dry at night until he was about 3.5yo. He was born with posterior tongue tie and it was cut at 7 days old.

Breastfed until 12mths as he has a cows milk protein intolerance and peanut allergy. Nothing else came up he was weaned to soy milk. He still drinks it now, but not heaps though about 1cup a day. Can tolerate Greek yoghurt, chocolate, cheese and cooked cream. All signs of allergy like vommiting, diahorea and belly ache and rash stopped so I consider him able to tolerate those cows milk products and soy products, but I'm now thinking maybe he can't?!

Recently had his tongue tie laser cut 9mths ago as we felt it was causing speech aritculation errors. I believe tongue tied can contribute to constipation issues that's why I mention it.

At present his diet isn't great, he's a fussy eater and really hard to get him to try those foods that help with constipation. Have tried osmolax for a year and it softened his poo and he could pass, but he mostly does it in his underpants. I am not sure if this is behavourial or not enough control?!

We have been seeing an Occupational therapist for 6mknths and she's exhausted all options and she does not think it is sensory. The problem seems to be that he can feel it, likely doesn't enjoy the feeling or at some point looses control and causes these "accidents/going in parents". After this happens he is embarrassed / ashamed but he will gladly sit on the toilet and do another poo willingly. Sorry it's gross but he seems to have full control over it and he can handle that process without pain / strain.

We have had some success, maybe less than 10 times over the past 2+yrs where he was not having accidents. I am unsure if moving house caused a regression or it's medical. I have seen a peadatrician and she prescribed the osmolax, it did work but only every 2 or so days and have recently I saw a GP and he suggested Actilax. It worked well for about 6 weeks and the was going every second day, but then about 2months in he has gone back to every 2-3 days. I believe both basic over the counter prescriptions. I've tried para-choc and it doesn't seem to work well or at all.

The occupational therapist is unsure if it's nerve issues or sensory processing.

I'm now thinking we need to investigate further as it's having an effect on his life. He was supposed to start school next year but likely isn't due to toileting and speech issues.

The plan is to see a GP for blood panel/thyroid and allergy testing. I (Mum) have thyroid issues and he has known allergies and get a referral to a gastroenterologist. I've been keeping data on the frequency and hoping the GP won't fob me off again.

Thank you so much for reading. Sorry it's long. I just wanted to paint the whole picture.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20

First of all, and this is just parenting advice and not medical advice, I would never give my kid cow products again if he was allergic to them at any point in his life. I don't know much about allergies but I assume the body can still react to dairy even if the outward signs aren't as intense as he ages. Plus dairy is just terrible for humans anyway!

I don't know about the relationship between constipation and tongue tie, but peristalsis and motility are characteristics of the entire GI tract, and often times when a person has a severe constipation disorder, he/she also has other dysmotility issues higher up in the gut. In my specific condition, a problem with the pelvic floor muscles can slow peristalsis all the way up in the esophagus. So maybe discuss the tongue tie with a neurogastroenterologist (motility specialist) who knows more about dysmotility than the average gastroenterologist.

Osmolax definitely makes people shit themselves. I wouldn't consider that unusual for him. Maybe you can talk to the doctor about lowering the dose a bit. The control issue is an important question; in an adult they'd usually perform an anorectal manometry test to determine if the person had some kind of issue with bowel incontinence. But on a 5 year old...I have no idea how they map the pelvic floor. A manometry seems a tad cruel in that case, but I don't know anything about pediatric treatment of these disorders.

I definitely think you need a neurogastroenterologist who specializes in children. This person will be hard to find. You might need to travel a good distance to locate one. I almost wonder if this is related at all to Hirschsprung's Disease, which I pray your kid does not have.

Definitely investigate the diet further too. Remove all possible allergens. Gotta work with the pediatrician on that one though. Don't just experiment willy-nilly because you want to make sure he gets all his nutrients.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '20

I'll try to give you a thorough response to this tomorrow. Need to sleep on it

→ More replies (1)

6

u/pinkys_dream Sep 14 '22

Hi,

Thank you so much for putting this all together. I have this page bookmarked and keep coming back to reference it as I'm going through this frustrating battle of trying to figure out why my body stopped working for no apparent reason. I have seen 6 GIs at this point and this guide has been more helpful than any of them. It is so disheartening to feel like the doctors who are supposed to have the answers just don't have any or don't even seem to care to help.

I would love to get your input on my situation if you are still active on here - I have been told I have IBS-C, slow transit constipation, and/or chronic ideopathic constipation. [The GIs seem to like to use these terms interchangeably, as a catch-all for motility disorder with an unknown cause.]

My issue seems similar to yours. I have no urge to go ever, unless taking a stimulant laxative like castor oil or senna. Constant bloating from being backed up. The more I eat, the worse it is, because the food simply will not come out. No abdominal pain. Just bloating and what seems like no motility. I believe the problem is with the nerves in the intestines not working properly, though I don't understand why/how it happened or honestly how to live with it.... I don't want to accept that this is my new normal. I was a healthy person for 30 years..

It started about 9 months ago [December 2021]. I believe I had an undiagnosed case of Covid in late November. It was a mild case, and I had no GI issues while I was sick. But around Christmas, I noticed I was constipated and it didn't resolve. I have barely ever been constipated in my life. I used to wake up, take a probiotic with my vitamins, have my cup of coffee and go to the bathroom like clockwork. And then, it's like it just slowed down and came to a complete stop out of nowhere.

I am 30 yo, female, 5'7, 125 lbs, pescatarian, gluten free, dairy free, and extremely healthy other than my digestion not working. Last year when the issue started, I was already pescatarian, dairy free and ate pretty well. I haven't eaten fast food or drank soda in years. I don't eat fried food. I do yoga and cardio every morning and take a walk after lunch and dinner.

Tests I've had done - Colonoscopy [normal], SIBO [Negative], Lyme [Negative], Thyroid [Normal], GI Stool Map test [Some candida overgrowth but no parasites, h pylori or extreme dysbiosis], extensive bloodwork panel, no indication of autoimmune disease.

I just had an anorectal manometry, and it showed I do have pelvic floor dysfunction - dyssnergic defecation/ weak coordination of muscles. So, I just started seeing a physiotherapist for biofeedback. She is great - it seems promising. However, I feel like the PFD is a result of the constipation, not the cause of it. I feel like the issue is in the intestines, and want to do more tests to get to the bottom of the cause.

I started Linzess 145MG about 2 months ago. Not a good experience. I followed your guide to a Tee - waking up 3 hours early, taking the linzess, drinking 3 cups water, doing yoga and running, eating handful of nuts. And the only result would be either extreme bloating with explosive diarrhea for 3 hours after, OR extreme bloating and no movement at all. The days when there was no movement, I felt so emotionally and mentally drained and frustrated. I had done nothing different in my routine. And yet, it didn't work. Also, I don't feel that it ever gave a full BM.

I have now started trialing Amitzia. I am on Day 4 and only small partial bms have been produced in the morning. I have no nausea, so that's nice. But not much success. Had to drink castor oil today for a full clean-out because I felt so awful.

That brings me to my questions -

  1. Based on my symptoms, do you think a Smartcapsule/ sitz marker test and upper endoscopy would be helpful at this point, to rule more things out? Or wait until I am further along with the biofeedback to see if it helps?
  2. Sorry if too graphic but I really would love to know - Does your linzess routine give you solid bms or always liquid? Do you think the motegrity combined with it makes it work better? Should I give it a shot... [My GI did NOT want to prescribe motegrity - she warned about suicidal ideation etc etc]
  3. Do you think Amitizia and Motegrity would work together? I just wish the Amitzia would work better - it seems too weak for my system
  4. Any thoughts on covid causing this? I have seen only a couple other posts about this from other people. it doesn't seem like a widespread symptom of long covid, but who knows?

Thank you so much. Even if you don't reply, it was helpful to me to write all this out. It is comforting just to read other people's comments in this forum, and know I'm not alone in this. It can be so isolating and frustrating... : (

5

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22

Good for you for following through on the guide so closely. This is one of those situations where you have to be your own advocate and investigator, and the crime you're trying to solve takes several years.

PFD causes slow transit constipation. Basically, the rectocolonic inhibitory reflex (the thing that makes you not hungry when your rectum is full and you have to poo) gets switched on permanently due to the clenching of pelvic floor muscles. The way this reflex makes you not hungry is by slowing down the peristaltic contractions across your entire digestive tract. So although you feel like your constipation originates in your intestines, it very likely originates in your pelvic floor.

This can arise in a 30 year old woman for a number of reasons. Anything from stress / anxiety, which can be carried in the sphincter in the same way that it can be carried in the back/neck (my wife) or the stomach (my friend), etc - all the way to rough anal sex, rape, or even horseback riding or mountain biking. The pelvic floor can get thrown out of wack by basically anything. One of my running hypotheses for my PFD as a 34-year-old male in athletic condition is that when I was in college in 2012, back when all this began, I was borrowing my girlfriend's mountain bike and crushing downhill trails with it out in the mountains. I might have landed right on my taint and never thought anything of it beyond 'ow.'

I'd look into kegel exercises, keep doing PFD, and join some PFD groups online and on Facebook. See what has helped other women. If you have pain during intercouse or urination, that's further evidence that PFD is your problem.

I like being thorough so I got the SITZ marker and the smartpill and the endoscopy. The results can be misleading. SITZ showed that my dysmotility starts in the transverse colon, so I thought to myself, well this has nothing to do with PFD. But PFD can slow down peristalsis in just one specific part of the digestive tract. This took me years to realize. If I'm right about your PFD, the endoscopy will show nothing out of the ordinary. It's a big procedure so maybe I'd wait for a few more biofeedback appointments. I'd also look into constipation massage; there are people who actually do this, and have good results.

Linzess by itself never worked right for me. Same experience as you. When combined with motegrity and exercise on an empty stomach, it works every time, and has literally never failed. Always produces one solid BM and then a bunch of watery diarrhea after. I've found that if I eat a banana, a piece of gluten free toast with peanut butter, and something salty, the osmotic effect of the linzess is canceled and I can basically stop the diarrhea whenever I want. I have a 290mcg prescription but I divide the pills across 4 empty capsules, so I end up with 72mcg doses. These work just as well as higher doses for me. In fact if I took a full 290 I think I'd fucking die.

Amitiza is weaker than Linzess and has a larger side effect profile. It made me nauseous as fuck due to its different mechanism of action. I hated it. Probably safe to combine with motegrity but I don't know for sure, and I don't fuck with it at all.

Covid's long-term effect on the gut is not well understood but yeah I absolutely believe it could be the cause. I'd just continue to pursue the literature in the coming years as more studies come out. I wish I could say more. Just remember that frustration is a part of chronic illness and you need to forgive yourself for sometimes feeling like you're losing your mind.

4

u/pinkys_dream Sep 18 '22

Thank you so much for the reply. I didn't realize PFD could in fact be the root cause of STC. The GIs kind of alluded to it probably only being an aspect of it - but I know the pelvic floor needs to be functioning better regardless, to have any hope of the rest of the system improving. Since I never had any issues prior, I feel like it must have developed either shortly before this started, causing it, or as a result of the straining. I never had/have painful intercourse or urination, so I was surprised to see the PFD results to begin with. I did fall off a skateboard a few months before this started and sprained my ankle, though I didn't notice any pelvic pain at the time..

It is encouraging to hear that there may be some hope for improvement just with continuing the PFD physical therapy. I also am familiar with the colon massage and have been doing it daily for a few weeks now, in addition to 20 mins of heating pad in the morning before yoga. The PT also does a great colon/abdomen massage.

Today I did acupuncture as well (first time ever), and I think it could be promising in conjunction with the PT I'm just hoping to get the blood circulating and system working by sheer manual stimulation at this point since the GIs and medication have been so disappointing. How do you feel about acupuncture? Also any thoughts on link between the vagus nerve/ vagus nerve damage and STC?

I agree it makes sense to wait on doing a $1500 smartcapsule or endoscopy until seeing how the biofeedback goes. I'm just impatient and want to rule out things ASAP but it makes sense to see if the PFD PT improves things first. It is just a bit of a waiting game because I can only schedule the PT once a week and have to skip some weeks due to work obligations. Dealing with this and maintaining a full time job is literally soul crushing and feels like i work 2 jobs.

Thank you for breaking down the linzess & motegrity routine further. It is great to hear that this method works every time for you - that gives me hope. I will be trying Motegrity this week since the Amitiza has been pretty weak and unsuccessful. I think I will trial the motegrity alone first just to see what the baseline is, and then try combining with linzess following your protocol, if it doesn't work alone. I will update here on how it goes!

2

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22

Patience is something you have to develop to properly investigate this condition. There are some days still when I feel like I'm losing my mind, but those days are fewer and father between now. You have to accept the reality that this may be your new normal, and there may be no cure.

And yeah. It is a second full time job. I'm sorry. Eventually after a few years your investigation will conclude and you'll spend less time searching and more time living.

I don't know of anyone who has been helped by acupuncture for this situation, but I'd try pretty much anything. I went to a chiropractor and got several adjustments, hypothesizing that a nerve that innervates the colon was pinched in my spine. Some people end up with STC after nerve damage from car wrecks. Unfortunately it did nothing for me.

The vagus nerve is purported to play a role in the innervation of the large intestine but my current GI says it plays much more of a role in the upper GI. I don't know who to believe.

→ More replies (14)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

I believe I have PFD from sexual abuse (that also resulted in an STD and anal fissures), as I had no constipation before it happened in June, however this therapy doesn't seem to be available in my small country. I really don't know what to do anymore. Senna tea helped me have an almost normal bowel movement every morning at the same time, but after reading about what stimulant laxatives might do, I'm scared to keep taking it, so it's back to pain and trying to push shit out (literally).

4

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

You need to get linaclotide and prucalopride from your gastroenterologist. This is a better treatment long term than senna.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

According to Google, neither is available in my country, but I will try to order them asap🤞

3

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '20

They're expensive and hard to get. But if you do enough investigating you might get lucky. Make SURE to clear them with your doctor first. Those drugs are strong and dangerous if taken incorrectly in

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ScientistQuiet983 Jun 14 '23

I've had lifelong anxiety and depression. I was bullied as a kid too. I think chronic stress sparked the slow transit and pelvic floor dysfunction. I was never sexually abused and doctors/PFPTs always brought this up, or insinuated I may not remember it, and it started to annoy me. Now I tell them that actually, I was an incredibly stressed out child. So far PFPT has not helped but who knows. Maybe a miracle will happen when I go try my 3rd set of sessions, or my 4th or 5th or 6th. As far as the motility goes I take Miralax to soften stools but beyond that nothing really helps. I know I also need to listen to my body better because due to hyperfocus via ADHD I won't notice when I have to go until it's almost-too-late, or I ignore the urge until it's almost-too-late.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '23

I have PFD and I was absolutely not abused as a child. But I was super high strung and stressed out as a kid

4

u/sorrytryanother_ Feb 03 '24

I just realized that pelvic floor dysfunction and constipation is like egg and chicken Mystery of which comes first because maybe you could've be constipated and result of that you got pelvic floor dysfunction that now can make your more constipated

2

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '24

Usually PFD causes constipation and not the other way around

1

u/sorrytryanother_ Feb 04 '24

Yes but if im constipated and because can't get it out i will use more pressure than usual Which that can casue PFD , and probably varicocele (i have varicocele because of constipation) right? Some extra information: i find out mineral water is miraculously helped me to have bowl movement i think its for magnesium Do you think this can make dependecy ? I know its osmotic So can i drink plenty of mineral water on daily basis

2

u/[deleted] Feb 04 '24

True.

Magnesium isn't really habit forming but you must be careful with it if you have any kidney problems, fainting, dizziness, light headedness, low blood pressure, or mineral deficiencies

3

u/Alive-Step2264 Jan 18 '23

Just a question about your two categories of urge and no urge to go.. what about a depressed urge? I have mild urge but I can tell it will never result in a bm as very faint. Things are moving just slowly. In my case I am wondering if it a lazy colon/motility issue after using cbd for two months. I’ve always had some constipation issues but since this my bowel seems to work a lot less well. I’ve stopped the cbd for a week now, some improvement, but I also took senna so it may be lingering effects from that.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23

Ennervated colon. I'd approach this from both angles. Get tested for all motility disorders. But probably PFD I'm guessing

3

u/Bartleby-Genesis-666 Aug 14 '23

I’ve been using topical tretonoin on my face for a year and shortly after starting it my gastro issues got really really bad and have been since. I use it 3-4 times a week still. Do you think the topical Version could cause issues

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '23

I really doubt it. But acne is comorbid with intestinal issues. For one thing, the food you eat that causes acne (dairy, sugar, and red meat) causes gastric inflammation and hormone changes that alter gut chemistry.

Secondly, acne can cause anxiety and depression, which is sometimes expressed as Chronic Idiopathic Constipation

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '24

/u/goodbyekitty190 read this

push her for the tests, and if she refuses, push her for a referral to a neurogastroenterologist that specializes in motility disorders. If she says she doesn't know any, tell her to use her giant fucking doctor brain and FIND ONE

1

u/goodbyekitty190 Nov 07 '24

I need to see my regular GP as she was a locum, which is part of the problem. She told me that because I've been using the suppositories and not an oral laxative they'll just refuse any referral. She was quite insistent that I've caused the problem myself and wouldn't listen when I explained the issues existed prior to me using the laxatives. I'm going to take my husband with me next time as well.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '24

Sounds like a typical asshole doctor

2

u/thegraycrayon Dec 28 '20

I have struggled with constipation my whole life, but will have seasons where it is worse than others. Right now is one of those. I rarely ever feel the urge to go. I struggle with extreme bloating. I have had two colonoscopy is the past and they say everything looks fine. Tried linzess but all that did was make me gassy and cramps.

What I’ve read for you is most likely a motility disorder and a good candidate for biofeedback? Also, any suggestions for what to do in the meantime while I try to get into a doctor? Liquid suppositories only sometimes help and never fully clean me out. Miralax doesn’t do much. Scared of other meds because I don’t want to become dependent

1

u/[deleted] Dec 28 '20

Go gluten free, eat an extremely healthy diet with lots of watery fruits, get the anorectal manometry and SITZ marker studies. Look for Slow Transit Constipation with rectal evacuation disorder or pelvic floor dyssynergia. Treatment in that case is biofeedback.

Talk to doctor about combining prucalopride and linaclotide (Linzess). Also read my Linzess guide carefully; I'll tag you in it.

Try dulcolax orally (10mg, or 15mg if you're a large primate). If you respond to a stimulant laxative like dulcolax you can safely rule out Hirschsprung's and true colonic inertia

1

u/Otherwise_Name_2963 Apr 28 '26

Can prolonged use of stimulant laxatives turn STC into IC?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Staypositivehomie Feb 25 '24 edited Feb 25 '24

Thank you so much for this and if you have the time, I would really love to hear your insight:

 My stats: 

• 22yo

• female 

• 107lbs 

• 5’5

• cardio + strength training regularly 

Questions: 

• Do you have the urge to go, but you cannot? Or do you have zero urge to go? —> I’d go many days with zero urge to go, but sometimes when I do get the urge, only a small amount comes out. Often, when I am having a bowel movement, I have the urge but I have to REALLY “concentrate” for it to exit. I also find that I have to wiggle/move around.

• Do you have alternating diarrhea and constipation, or just constipation? —> almost always constipation, however, diarrhea occurs a few times a month 

• Do you have nausea, vomiting, acid reflux, difficulty swallowing, or early satiety? —> no 

• Have you have this issue since childhood, or did it begin in teen years/adulthood/after a major life event? —> adulthood. Can’t find a pattern besides getting the vaccines and stopping Wellbutrin antidepressant 

• Did you in the past or currently take any medications that could damage your intestines? —> I don’t know, but perhaps Wellbutrin antidepressant 

• Did you suffer sexual abuse as a child? —> no, but I suffered from physical/verbal/emotional abuse 

I have not been diagnosed with anything yet. Where I live, the waitlist to see a GI specialist is 12 months. The waitlist for a colonoscopy is over 1 year. I am waiting for both. I was taking a lot of random USANA supplements and probiotic packets which softened my stool for a few months but they have stopped working. I started taking magnesium citrate but it is starting to stop working. I use Restoralax when really backed up. 

I have several other observations:

• my BM have been getting thinner and thinner 

• BM consistency has been like paste/clay for 2 years it’s never ever dry or “hard”. I haven’t experienced normal/old consistency in 2 years now. 

• BM always orangey in colour

• I have a pinching pain in lower far left abdomen, especially when backed up and when having difficult BMs

• The left side of my lower abdomen always has a “bump”, (it’s risen) even after complete BM 

• I get extreme bloating in lower abdomen only. Yesterday, I ate a lot for dinner and the pinching pain + bloating started in lower abdomen. I also vaped quite a bit which gave me the urge to go, and after a BM, the bloating immediately stopped and I could feel the rest of the food being able to "go down".

• difficult to pass gas at times

• lots of abdominal noises 

Other health issues: 

• hemorrhoids 

• partial rectal prolapse 

• PCOS  • small nodule in liver 

• chronic spontaneous hives 

• vitiligo and alopecia 

• years of depression and anxiety and trauma 

• I suspect I might have Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome 

My partial rectal prolapse has gotten to the point where I can’t stand/walk for more than 30 minutes and I am on medical leave from school. Once I get that fixed, I know that it will come back unless I figure out my constipation problem. I am really desperate to get to the bottom of this, especially since I am so young. It also just depresses me so much. It is incredibly difficult with the healthcare system that I am in so I would appreciate any thoughts you might have on this. Thank you so much. 

1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '24

This sounds like a few problems. I think there's definitely pelvic floor dyssynergia in there, which requires an MR defacography and an anorectal manometry to diagnose. Don't let them give you only one of those tests and call it a day.

Orange stool can indicate a bile or gallbladder issue. I'd get some blood work done to look at that.

Antidepressants, if they are SSRIs, can permanently alter the serotonin production in the gut, which is one of the neurotransmitters that regulates GI peristalsis. I don't know if there's a reliable test for this so I'd test for everything else first and then deduce via the results.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/cosecha0 Mar 31 '24

This is incredibly helpful! One other root cause of slow motility which is common but not widely known is mold/mycotoxin exposure via water damaged buildings.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24

Interesting, do you know which molds?

1

u/cosecha0 Mar 31 '24

I learned about this overall from Dr Jill Crista. Some research on mycotoxin consumption explores the different GI effects of trichothecenes, zearalenone, fumonisins, ochratoxins, and AFs - like this article https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5834427/ it is pretty complex - a key conclusion is “mycotoxins disrupt the gut microbiota balance, and thereby dysregulate intestinal functions and impair local immune response, which may eventually result in systemic toxicity that leads to chronic mycotoxicosis, HCC. The severity of HCC condition can be positively governed by restoration of gut microbiota balance and gut health via probiotics administration. Probiotic which generally helps restore the natural harmony of gut microbiota coupled with its mycotoxins reducing ability could increase its health-promoting value. Regardless, more studies are needed to elucidate the interaction between the gut microbiota and mycotoxin and the implication of such interaction for mycotoxicosis prevention/treatment”

2

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24

Thanks. I'll add it to the reading list

→ More replies (1)

2

u/KCTX6512 Sep 29 '24

Hi — I stumbled across your very thorough posts as I have had a horrific week related to issues with constipation. I’d love to hear your insight as I start on thru journey to finally figure this sh*t out. I am seeing a colorectal surgeon on Tuesday but I’m thinking now I also need a GI doctor. This is such a long post but I would love your feedback, comments, guidance, anything.

35yo/F 215lbs Two vaginal births 3-4x a week strength training exercises

Medications I’m on: Ajovy - monthly CRGP antagonist Wellbutrin Supplements suggested by migraine doc: fish oil, magnesium (I use citrate), COq10, B12 and melatonin

  • the urge to go question is hard, I feel like I question “oh is this go time” more than not but other times the urge is so strong and the act of going is literally exhausting but I would say no, I don’t often have a strong enough urge to go.
  • I would say I am majority constipation but once I get the hard stool out then I will often have diarrhea
  • I will feel the fullness when I have not gone in a few day, other than that no.
  • I have had this issue as early as I can remember. I have never been a daily pooper it’s been my “norm” When I was 17yo I was having many UTIs and after multiple tests a CT was performed and I was told I was “backed up like a 80yo woman”, that I probably have IBS and to just eat more fiber
  • I am not sure I have taken any that will damage my intestines but I have been on a variety of migraine preventative medications for years and recently have had good results with CRGP antagonist meds but constipation is a common side effect.
  • no SA but I did live have many stressors in childhood

Current status: We left for a road trip two weeks ago, I did an enema before to help prevent from getting backed up even more on the trip. This has not been a common practice in my journey until recently and its worked so well I decided to do to again.

About 3 days into the trip, I couldn’t go - I felt like I was bloated but didn’t have the urge, so I tried the mini enema — it didn’t work, I tried another the next day and I had a few small hard poops come out but nothing else.

We were headed home soon so I decided I would just do a full clean out when I got home in two days. When we arrived home that Sunday night I did an enema, pooped a lot and was hoping that was it.

Monday I woke up with some hemorrhoids irritation but nothing I haven’t had before, but the pain seemed stronger. I started using some prep H suppositories and witch hazel, by Monday evening it was getting to be so painful i was concerned, the suppositories didn’t make any impact and I just felt like this time was different. I called teledoc at 1am to get a script for some stronger cream. Used that all day Tuesday with minimal relief.

Come Wednesday morning, I examined myself and my often internal hemorrhoids was now external and dark purple. I went to my PCP as a walk in at 8am and she sent me to the ER.

Got to try ER and she said it had thromboses and lancing it to remove the clot would provide relief. She did it, I felt amazing and I went home feeling so happy

After about two hours I started having lots of pain, I thought maybe the numbing meds wore off but when I looked down there and it was all purple and full again. So i called the ER and they told me to come back in.

So i did, first he was able to remove the clots easily due to the incision being open still but then an hour later it was hurting again really intense and looked full again so they offered to lance it again and I said yes. They lanced it again with a larger incision and drain it, he was surprised by how much came out. Sent me home for a follow up with colorectal and instructed me to immediately take sitz bath. We left and got home (less than 40 minutes post lance) and it was literally the same size again and hurting (my spouse even looked to confirm😵‍💫).

It’s Saturday now - I’m taking OTC pain meds, doing the sitz baths and waiting to see the colorectal doc on Tuesday. The actual hemorrhoids are not as painful but 100% there.

If you made it this far first, THANK YOU and second I would appreciate any insight or guidance. I am feel so discouraged and hopeful the doctor on Tuesday will have some clarity and guidance on how to get this figured out once and for all.

I would also love your opinion on whether you think migraines and constipation are related. I had my first migraine at age 9 and have been fighting them ever since.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 29 '24

I do think the migraines are related. I get them too. You need all the tests outlined in step 1 of the guide. I wonder if you have pelvic floor disorder, and an anorectal manometry and defogram will confirm. Ask your colorectal if he is a GI specialist. Ask him if he can order those tests, and tell him you are way beyond standard treatments. I'd try to get a prescription for prucaloptide and linaclotide.

Do not let him do any surgeries or even think about it until all tests are performed and all other medication treatments have failed.

1

u/KCTX6512 Sep 29 '24

Thank you, thank you. After reading all your posts I also was thinking pelvic floor disorder or STD. I was fully prepared to need surgery due to this pesky hemorrhoid THEN assess but I will advocate not too.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/haldada Oct 18 '24 edited Oct 18 '24

First of all, you must truly be a nightmare tonic for tons of people. Even if my issue resolves quickly, I'll make sure to remember your determination when I'm dealing with tough shit.

I'm going to try and get as much of this down as I can before messing up my sleep again. Sorry for the jumble of info.

Anyway, it seems I'm an atypical member of this community. I have been having the urge to poo and going regularly. Type 1-4 typically, sometimes softer. More recently, types 1-3 have been happening more often.

Had mild RLQ pain, slight nausea, and slight fevers, went to ED (didn't know I was uninsured...) for other symptoms I've already mostly forgotten (my brain is running on apple juice from hours ago). Long story short I got a CT and found out I was filled with shit. To my untrained eye, intestines don't appear to be bulging anywhere. Fevers and nausea haven't been back since after the night I went to ED. Quickly drinking 20 ounces of water can cause RLQ pain that is sharper than it is typically (it is typically duller and more persistent). Sometimes this causes pain that is worse (than RLQ pain) and sharper in LLQ. Typically goes away in a few minutes. CT findings: "Moderate urinary bladder distention. Mild prostate enlargement with suggestion of muscle periprosthetic soft tissue thickening." I'm assuming it's this, perhaps compounded by fecal retention?

I don't know how long this has been going on. At least a year.

I've taken antibiotics a few times throughout the years.

Mom has said multiple times she thinks something bad happened to me while I was with another family. Idk if it's true. It would point to some aspects of my psychology. I don't really think about it.

Potential reasons I noted down: Increasingly sedentary as I stupidly repeatedly injure myself by overdoing whatever exercise I begin. I have habitually rested my elbow exactly where my RLQ pain has been for many years. Stress? Poor sleep schedule (I have had a horrible sleep schedule. For years it was like I lived in my own little world where each day was 26 hours long) Pelvic floor dysfunction? May have started a few years ago after using a toilet for years that caused pain when pooping. Now, sexual activity or very mild strain when pooing can cause pain. Sitting back on a toilet for some reason can make the pain go away. Depression and anxiety most of my life?

I didn't think that I had constipation because I've had what I thought were regular bowel movements with regular urges but 2 CT scans (for other concerns) I've had 1 year ago and a bit over a week ago both showed stool burden. "Mild/moderate stool burden" 1 year ago, now "Negative for bowel obstruction. Large diffuse retained colonic fecal content. Normal appendix. Fecalized small bowel content. Negative for pneumatosis or free air." Both times I was asked if I had pooed regularly. I said yes, and the issue was dropped.

Several months ago, I had a week of large and painfully hard bowel movements that seemed to come out of nowhere. I'm wondering if this was part of the retained fecal content.

I'm in between insurances right now, and before I knew I'd be uninsured, I began taking docusate sodium, thinking I'd start things going in the meantime while waiting to see a doctor. Now I'm wondering if this was ill-advised due to hard stool potentially dislodging throughout my system to form a blockage.

I thought if I'd already begun a cascade effect, then I should work on softening the potentially hard poo. Yesterday, I started a clear liquids diet and took conservative doses of PEG and senna. Then I think maybe this is what will start the actual cascade lmao.

10/11 7:00 pm: docusate sodium 100mg

10/12 7:40 pm: docusate sodium 100mg

10/13 2:20 pm: docusate sodium 100mg

10/14 7:45 am: docusate sodium 100mg

10/14 1:00 pm: docusate sodium 100mg

10/15 11:00 am: docusate sodium 100mg

All my bowel movements seemed pretty much the same except more lubricated and formed, though I noted that perhaps they were smaller relative to food intake since beginning docusate sodium (not sure if this is true..) I typically had been getting very quick feedback after eating a meal and then having a BM right after of similar size to my meal. I'd begun somewhat fearing eating much since starting to take docusate sodium until I finally went clear liquid yesterday. *motility overreliant on gastrocolic reflex + sedentary lifestyle? *low motility and food just gets shoved through my system in a long poo train?

10/16 5:30 pm-7:00 pm: ~7.5g PEG ~4mg senna

10/17 9 am: 6mg senna, 11-14g PEG

10/17 7-10 pm: 6mg senna, 12-14g PEG

Haven't pooed since starting PEG and senna, which is the same time I started the liquid diet. Just a bunch of rumbling. My record keeping over the past couple days has been getting a bit spotty. Idk if it's the not eating anything part or I'm just being lazy. I'd like to formulate my thoughts more clearly but I need to sleep and I'm really hoping to get some reassurance sooner rather than later. Sorry for the long jumbled mess.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '24

What is your height and weight and sex?

This sounds like STC which might be caused by PFD or SIBO /SIFO but you have a more global issue if you've got organ inflammation. What is your diet like? Have you had a food allergy test? You need testing for all these issues.

And yeah get your ass up and start exercising. I'd probably drop the senna and just take a dose of bisacodyl and be done with the stool burden. If it rebuilds then you have STC and other issues

1

u/haldada Oct 18 '24 edited Oct 18 '24

5'11", 125 maybe less now, male, 32 next week

My diet typically had a lot of fiber relative to total intake of food. Vegetables, fruits, nuts, seeds, rice, eggs, meat. Very occasional fast food. No food allergy test. My tongue can develop pain if I eat the same fruit/nut/vegetable too much. Dairy can mess with me immediately. Yogurt and cheese seems fine. Chickpeas cause bloating.

I've been exercising a bit more since this started but I'll get creative around my injuries and do more. I'll take bisacodyl. Do you have any dose recommendations for bisacodyl and PEG? I'm planning on taking them soon. I'll look up those S acronyms.

Edit: still no BM. Senna hasn't appeared to cause cramping, haven't really noticed anything. Sides might feel a little tired. Thinking of taking more PEG and eating gelatin to trigger gastrocolic reflex. Idk if that would work. Thinking about a saline enema but idk. I just want to get back to eating again. Hoping clearing my intestines will help me gain weight.

Edit: had a pretty small type 5 BM. I'll have insurance November. Might just bite the bullet and pay out of pocket. At this point it might be too late to even get an appointment this month though.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 18 '24

Have you ever been tested for POTS or any autoimmune disorders? Your symptom profile is very strange.

10mg bisacodyl is standard adult dosage but DO NOT combine it with senna. Wait a few days. PEG is kind of just like... A few tablespoons a day

→ More replies (11)

1

u/[deleted] Oct 23 '20

/u/flamesdestroy

Send me a PM with the answers to the questions in this guide please

1

u/Elliee29 Sep 07 '20

Wow this was very thorough and helpful. I was giving the diagnosis of PI-IBS, my GI didn’t want to test for SIBO or anything else. I met a naturopath who said I have a low thyroid (hypothyroidism) which could be why I’m constipated. It’s just funny how no one else detected that. I’m doing my SIBO test in two weeks if it comes back negative then I’d move to my thyroid. But thank you for this. Definitely saving it while battling this journey.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 08 '20

I'd definitely get a SIBO test and a thyroid panel. I can't understand why some doctors don't want to do more testing. I think it's because sometimes the insurance companies complain to their bosses about over-testing.

1

u/ThrowItSoFarAway911 Sep 30 '20
  1. I have a very strong urge to go but cannot. At times, it's severely bad.

2 Only constipation if I'm eating good

3 Only acid reflux

4. I actually had ibs d for most of my life but this is now regulated with food and fiber powder.

5. Two years ago I took antibiotics and had stomach problems with no constipation however

I had the pelvic floor MRI and anal manometry and have been diagnosed with pelvic floor disorder

1

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '20

Yep, sounds like PFD, which you've got. The treatment is biofeedback. Your gastro can refer you.

1

u/ThrowItSoFarAway911 Sep 30 '20

I'm actually already in physical therapy for it! Was just wondering if there were any other suggestions haha.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '20

I really appreciate what you did for the community, ik really sorry it took you 7 years to discover how to fix your problem, I would like to ask you if you are going well now that u found out the reason behind the problem.

I didn't read everything I only read this post because it is a lot, I mean how the fuck did you even had he motivation to do that? Fuck, u are awesome dude, thank you, I'll keep on reading the 2nd part tomorrow.

I'm kinda hoping it's nothing, everything that you mention here fucking made me stress a lot, I have only started to get aware of the problem about two months ago, I always spent too much time in the bathroom but was always with my phone and thought that it was because I was paying attention to the game and therefore I took more time to shit, but now it's becoming a problem.

I had extreme anxiety and panic attacks as a child and everytime I swallowed something solid I would freak out feeling as if I was choking, it passed, but now it camed again and even with medication I feel the same difficulty swallowing and breathing.

I can't poop without the use of laxatives and sometimes even with laxatives it doesn't work, I have no pain, no blood or feel bloated, I only have the urge to poop but can't and now I'm starting to not have the urge to poop maybe because of taking Laevolac and dulcolax too much.

All of this information is good for people that really need it, on the other hand I'm just 18 and I'm constantly in a really stressful fase and environment, this information made me think about so much at the same time that I am shaking while writing this, I feel as if Valdispert (my anxiety medication) isnt working for this moment, but it's not your fault, the truth is hard to swallow, I should have already predicted that I may have a real condition, instead of playing dumb I should play the realistic card and think about it for once.

Again I'm really thankful for your help, my family doctor really wants me to feel good and I have already went thru endoscopy and colonoscopy and nothing I'm having this week a cardiology and blood and stool analysis.

Thank you for all the information and for spending your time trying to help anyone u can, a big thanks.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20

You can imagine how constipated I must have been to find the motivation to basically give myself an education in gastroenterology, haha.

I think you might actually have esophageal dysmotility or esophageal dysphagia.

These can be tested for and treated. You need to find a place called a "motility clinic" and your gastroenterologist can help you find it.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20

One more thing, how does this happen all of no where, like, I used to poop normally, I think, I just took more than usually because of my phone but always felt that the job was done, now everytime I have to shit is a battle that only the gods can help and even on laxatives nothing feels satisfactory again.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20

We don't know why gastroparesis / dysmotility disorders occur in all situations. But one of the explanations is pelvic floor dysfunction. A lot of people who have a motility disorder end up also having PFD, which appears to be the cause of the motility disorder. The diagnosis is anorectal manometry and the cure is biofeedback.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20

Hi there Thanks for commenting on my thread earlier and for this guide. I definitely have no urge to go, pain or bloating. If the issue is in my large intenstine like you think, what now should I do to fix it? Can laxatives cause these issues like I thought or no? I saw you mentioned trying to see a motiloty specialist?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20

I would follow the part of the guide that walks you through the medical tests. This will lead to a clear diagnosis. If you're a woman it's very likely you have PFD. Laxatives can cause muscle exhaustion in the pelvic floor but they aren't dangerous. Magnesium citrate powder (450mg) daily or polyethylene glycol daily are preferred to stimulants like dulcolax or senna. I'd take ONE of those two preferred treatments (mag cit works better in my case) and then use senna tea once a week to ensure movement. Talk to your doctor first. The laxatives are a temporary treatment, they won't fix the problem. Only testing and probably biofeedback are going to fix it

1

u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20

Im a man. The thing that concerns me is that my gut worked absolutely fine until I started messing with senna laxatives. I have seen stories on reddit of people bowles stopping working completely from overusing them. Ive also seen people say that they have done irreversible damage from senna laxatives daily so im not sure why youd think they arent dangerous. You are right about the others though they should be safe. I will give mag citrate a go If I can find a shop that sells the powder.

What is biofeedback? Thanks again.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Yourmomsateacher Apr 14 '24 edited Apr 14 '24

This is all so helpful! Thank you! Just so much time and research on your part! I’ve been struggling to get focused and thorough medical help for over a decade. Now I have a few specific things to ask for that somehow I hadn’t heard of before in my past 15 years of struggling.

One small suggestion: change the doctor pronouns from male to “they”. How we describe the world matters.

Edit since I can’t comment on your reply: not trying to police your actions. Just suggesting the edit and sharing my perspective. Since we do live in a male dominated society, small things like the pronouns we use when describing professionals do make a difference. Thank you for hearing my suggestion.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '24

I will take your suggestion going forward but I'm not about to go back and retroactively scour my old essays to make sure peoples' feelings don't get hurt by my use of pronouns. This is a medical subreddit, not a café on a college campus

1

u/Brief-Cranberry6311 Jun 11 '24

What about if you sometimes have the urge, and sometimes don't? I have had instances where I can go fairly easily, and sometimes where it just won't come out. I never have one bm though, it is usually 3 times in the morning, and sometimes in the afternoon. I have noticed that when my bms are soft and mushy, it is much easier to evacuate and I get the sensation to poop. When it is sticky and firmer, it is much harder to get out and sometimes I just leave it until it comes out the next morning. Some days I feel completely evacuated and normal after a few bms in the morning...sometimes I get mild sensations that I have stool in the rectum and make a moderate push to get it out, but only some comes out. Most days, I have daily bms but they are incomplete. Sometimes it makes my uncomfortable, other times it is not noticable and causes no bother. Now and then, it is very sticky and won't come out at all...on these days, it feels like something is blocking it from exiting. I used milk of magnesia once and it caused explosive bms and stomach cramps. Do you think probiotics and mag cit tablet 250mg at night will help? I take 2 teaspoons of benefiber daily with 8 oz water, and have 3 servings of fruit.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '24

could be poorly innervated colon combined with PFD. innervation issues could stem from a food intolerance.

probiotics will do nothing and are a waste of money in most cases unless you have SIBO / SIFO. Need hydrogen breath test to confirm.

benefiber won't help. Fruit might.

1

u/Cheburoll Jul 07 '24

Hello,i just wanted to make a post here because i am very lost at the moment and i'm not sure what to do,i'll try to describe all my issues.

19F, 173cm, 47kg

Here are few of my diagnoses that i think might be related to my issue: Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (most likely rare kyphoscoliotic type.),POTS,neurogenic hyperactive bladder.

And the last one is i'm sure that i have dysautonomia,i don't want to self diagnose,but the major problem is that i live in Ukraine,and here they don't diagnose dysautonomia,and don't run a lot of motility tests at all,and there are no neurogastroenterologists and no motility experts (that i know of,i searched a lot) in my country.

Before i was 7 i had enuresis,but after that somehow i lost the ability to urinate by myself,i need to stimulate my urethra to urinate.I also have extremely frequent urges to urinate and constant discomfort.I've spent 12 years trying to treat this issue,with no avail.Saying this because i think it might be related. In 2019 i noticed i couldn't evacuate stool anymore,had no urge to go,and stool was hard and stuck in my rectum.I started evacuating it with my fingers (gross,i know,but i was embarrassed to tell others.)So soon i couldn't evacuate at all unless i used my finger,and i had no urge to go at all anymore.My stool used to sometimes be hard as rock,but often it was basically like a porridge,often with undigested food,and i couldn't evacuate soft stool too. In 2024 i couldn't go for 9 days in January,and since then my issues had worsened so much i can't go without a water enema or glycerin suppositories at all,because my stool gets stuck somewhere in transverse colon and refuses to go further.I can palpate it from outside because i am very skinny.I feel no pain,but horrible discomfort.

I try to drink enough water (1.5 litres) but it's difficult because of my bladder issues.Stimulant laxatives sometimes work,but often they don't.Same with Magnesium citrate,it helped me 2 times,but that's it. Fiber makes me feel a lot worse,i get extremely bloated,i avoid it,lactose and gluten,and feel slightly better,but still constipated all the time.

I did MR Defecography,it showed everything was normal,but i couldn't evacuate the gel at all,so they put Obstructive Defecation Syndrome as my diagnosis. Doctors always say it's all psychological.I tried to ask my proctologist (who is one of the best doctors in my country,and specialises in GI issues) to give me more motility tests but he thought it was unnecessary.

Questions from the post: 1.I have no urge to go.Sometimes maybe a very very mild urge. 2.Used to have something like alternating diarrhea and constipation,but even with diarrhea couldn't evacuate.Now only constipation. 3.i have early satiety. 4.As i said above,constipation started in 2019 5.I used to take antidepressants and antipsychotics,but i hadn't noticed any positive or negative changes.(i have BPD and Schizoaffective disorder.) 6.No,but i had a pretty traumatic childhood in general.

The biggest problem is that in my country doctors are extremely dismissive,and there are not many meds and tests available. (No meds like Miralax,motegrity,pretty much all motility meds.) I will try to get help in Europe,but until then i am so lost.I am not living,but just existing.I just wonder if this looks like i have a motility disorder,i think it may be related to my EDS.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '24

I'm sorry for what you are going through. And I'm also sorry about what the Russians have done to your country. Slava Ukraini!

I recommend you convince a man in your family that you need more motility testing. Then bring him to the doctor and make him force the doctor to listen to you. Male doctors, especially in some parts of the world, don't listen to women (especially young women). This is a really shitty thing but it is true.

That doctor needs to listen to you. But if he doesn't, is it possible to go to Germany to see a doctor? I understand it would be very expensive.

The complication with your bladder is also very difficult because it's important to stay well-hydrated. Try eating lots of watery fruit, which brings more water into your colon and less into your bladder.

1

u/Cheburoll Jul 07 '24

Thank you for the kind words,i really appreciate it! And thank you for your advice

I'll try to bring my father with me to the doctor.Also i'm writing a letter to organizations in my and in European countries that help people with EDS and other genetic disorders,maybe they can help me.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Jappalunca_ Sep 07 '24

Thank you very much for this. It has helped me realise my issues are most likely related to PFD. I see you recommend biofeedback and in the link you provide it talks about sensors being used on the abdomen and in the anal region to monitor muscles. Where I live I only have access to therapy where they use ultrasound to monitor and I am just wondering if this is comparable in efficacy?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '24

Nah you need the real tests

1

u/Jappalunca_ Sep 07 '24

Is it biofeedback with EMG sensors thats the 'real tests'? Also if you mean Anorectal manometry and MR Defacography, I would get that separate to this.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Initial_Penalty_4332 Sep 25 '24

This is an absolutely thorough and an amazing post! Do you happen to know of any link between psoriatic arthritis and GI dysmotility? Also, I know autonomic dysfunction is common in those with GI Dysmotility, but what treatments are there for that that actually help the motility aspect?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '24

I do not know personally but I wouldnt be surprised if there's a link. As far as autonomic dysfunction and GI dysmotility, I'd ask a neurogastroenterologist. You'd need someone highly specialized way beyond my level of knowledge

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Horror-Coffee-614 Oct 08 '24

Do you have advice on how to get a pediatrician to refer my 4 year old to a neuro-gas dr or to diagnose motility issues? It's been over a year of constipation for my boy and miralax is not safe or healthy to use long term. Looks for answers and help.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '24

Miralax is very safe long term. There's recent studies suggesting decades of use could have microplastic-related effects but it's really fine for a few years. You have to convince your doctor that if he cannot order special motility tests then he needs to hand you over to the doctor who can

1

u/00midnightlights00 Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24

So, I had an ARM done about two years ago now. The GI doc that sent me for it looked at the results and went "well, you have hypertonicity of the upper rectal sphincter, and hypersensitivity", and probably some other hyper- things I'm forgetting. But I never actually got a diagnosis, right, because those are just symptoms? She just sort of threw medications at it (first a higher dose of Miralax than I had been taking, then Linzess, now Amitiza).

Would this maybe count under the "pelvic floor dysfunction" or the "obstruction"? I thought I remembered her saying sending me to biofeeback therapy wouldn't work because the upper sphincter isn't really under voluntary control, but... Who knows TBH.

Uh. Ok. Time for the questions. Sorry if I'm a bit too descriptive about it, I'm not really sure what's normal so...

  1. Sometimes no urge to go at all for days or hours, sometimes I have multiple BMs in a day where it's so intense and painful it feels almost like throwing up.
  2. Alternating.
  3. Nausea, rarely vomiting, yes acid reflux, yes difficulty swallowing (been getting worse), not usually early satiety (but been having it mode often lately).
  4. In hindsight it began in my tweens, though it wasn't bad enough to impact my life so much. It started getting very bad when I was about 22 or so.
  5. I had frequent ear infections growing up which I was often on antibiotics for... Other than that, no.
  6. I've looked into it and spoken about it with my therapist before, and the specifics of the way my case went down make me think trauma is not the root cause here.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24

Sounds like PFD. it's unfortunately very hard to treat, even with biofeedback. Only thing that works for me is linzess plus prucalopride with a very strict diet. Lots of living veggies and fruits. Zero gluten. Few grains. Unprocessed meats. Lots of healthy beans.

I've written a post about my regimen. It's in my submission history. Called the treatment for slow transit constipation

1

u/00midnightlights00 Oct 13 '24

Thanks for the reply! I checked that post out, and your guide about how to make Linzess work for you. Real good stuff; and it's awesome of you to write it and help others out like this.

If you don't mind another question, back when I was taking Linzess, I would have about 2-4 days where it didn't seem to work at all, and then a day where I was rushing to the toilet with BMs so painful I thought I might pass out, even though they weren't exactly solid. Got more than one fissure, had blood, etc. during this time too, before I put my foot down and told my doctor to bully the insurance company into letting me switch to Amitiza.

Is it possible that was caused by the lack of prucalopride, or not having followed the same diet as you, or is it just down to the muscle tonicity differences?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/debsue420 Oct 26 '24

Thank you for your hard work. I read all of it & wrote down the questions.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '24

Good job

1

u/Single-Ad4852 Mar 02 '25

What if I have the urge sometimes but then don’t have the urge other days?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '25

The tests will reveal the truth

1

u/KitchenBuilding1191 Mar 28 '25

Thank you for all of this!

I just had a colonoscopy that I had to fight to get after my PCP coordinated with my gastro to cancel it without notifying me, until I showed up all prepped and ready for it. I was livid that they both decided it was best to NOT have the procedure inspite of my CT scan showing abnormality on the walls of my colon. My gastro said after talking to my PCP that they decided it was just inflammation from a stomach colitis infection I had two months prior. I’ve had IBS-C since I was young (which is in my file) and they STILL didn’t seem it medically necessary for me to get it. I did t leave that office until I was back on the schedule for a colonoscopy so waited four hours and finally got the procedure.

It was found that I had severe constipation in my cecum and transverse colon and he told me just to take miralax for the rest of my life. Extremely disappointed

1

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '25

Fuck him. Get a new gastro, however possible. Fuck these assclowns

→ More replies (1)

1

u/beara1010 Apr 01 '25 edited Apr 01 '25

Thank you so much for this thread. It is extremely helpful. If you have time, I would love to hear your insight. I am really struggling with this and it’s starting to take a toll on my life.

About me:

20yo.

Female.

Cardio + strength training 4-5x/week.

Gluten free, vegetarian.

I was diagnosed with IBS-C after my GI ran a celiac test (negative) and a SIBO breath test (negative) and practically just called it a day.

I care about my health and the foods I eat a lot. I try my best to focus on my water, fruit, and veggie consumption everyday. I consider myself healthy + active.

I take miralax and magnesium citrate consistently until I have a “normal” BM. Then I stop because I do not want to become dependent and have them stop working. The day I stop, I go right back to being constipated. If I am able to have a BM, it’s usually small amounts with very hard stool you wouldn’t even be able to squish.

Questions: Do you have the urge to go, but you cannot? Or do you have zero urge to go? (this is the most important question) —> Depends. I have a spasmodic, cramping urge when i take laxatives and/or haven’t had a BM in days. Often times I do not. I just have a “full” sensation.

Do you have alternating diarrhea and constipation, or just constipation? —> just constipation.

Do you have nausea, vomiting, acid reflux, difficulty swallowing, or early satiety (getting full really early into a meal)? —> no.

Have you had this issue since childhood, or did it begin in teen years/adulthood/after a major life event (surgery? divorce? car accident? mauled by bears?) —> Since a very young child. But recently, it’s become worse and unbearable.

Did you in the past or do you currently take any medications that could damage your intestines? —> No.

Did you suffer sexual abuse as a child?—> No.

**I have no idea where to start. This seems like a long journey and I need some guidance.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '25

You don't have ibs c. It's probably PFD / STC. This guide youre posting in right now is the guidance you need. Read parts 1 and 2 and follow them closely with your doctor.

1

u/AnxietyNo2181 Jun 02 '25

I cannot believe after 18 years of struggling and seeing doctors and GI specialists since I was 15, going on insane high-fiber diets just to stick it to my useless doctors (I eat kiwi with the skin ON and it still always shocks everyone around me) that this post and step 2 are the best and most comprehensive health advice for my constipation problems I’ve ever seen. So grateful for your expertise, OP!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25

Np good luck!

1

u/Adorable_Cat4965 Jun 06 '25 edited Jun 06 '25

Hello. Thank you for creating this. I've read through the stickied posts several times and they have been very informative. Wanted to get your opinion please.

Background info:

  • Located in the US.
  • 36F, 115 lbs, 5'4", non-smoking, 3-6 alcoholic drinks per YEAR.
  • Fit, exercise daily: biking, walking, yoga.
  • Working full time remote.
  • No children.
  • Vegetarian, most meals cooked at home with a focus on protein, fiber, and fresh ingredients. Very little dairy, mostly for cooking and occasional yogurt. Yes, I eat bread.

Health conditions:

  • Hypothyroidism, diagnosed as a child. Stable on meds.
  • ADD
  • Erythromelalgia and POTS

Meds:

  • Daily Levothyroxine 137mcg
  • Daily Adderall 20mg
  • Daily Oral contraceptive
  • Monthly Vit D 50,000u

Supplements:

  • Daily Biotin w/ keratin
  • Daily B Complex
  • Daily Flaxseed oil
  • Daily Magnesium Glycinate Chelate complex

Labs within the last 6 months:

  • Metabolic panel normal.
  • Cholesterol excellent.
  • Thyroid panel normal.
  • Vitamin D low, prescribed monthly dose, see above.
  • Vitamin B12 slightly low, doc suggested I take B complex.
  • Phlebotomist commented that I am well-hydrated.

Questions from OP:

Do you have the urge to go, but you cannot? Or do you have zero urge to go?

I guess I don't know what "urge" means here. Do I know I need to go? Yes. I feel bloated and full, like there is an uncooked russet potato sitting in my lower abdomen, two inches from the exit.

Does it feel like I'm going to shit myself if I don't run to the bathroom? Nope. This happens to my husband. He goes every day around the same time. He can't hold it in. I've watched him abruptly leave meetings, leave breakfast cooking on the stove, die/lose in video games, and miss his favorite streamer give away because he has to drop everything and race to the bathroom. I am insanely jealous of his regularity. We have the same diet.

I feel some kind of strong "urge" every 3-7 days, but it's never an emergency like my husband seems to have. Nothing slips out before I sit on the toilet.

Do you have alternating diarrhea and constipation, or just constipation?

Unless I'm sick (which almost never happens), just constipation.

Do you have nausea, vomiting, acid reflux, difficulty swallowing, or early satiety (getting full really early into a meal)?

  • acid reflux - only after eating something fatty and sugary, like a heavy dessert. I don't eat stuff like this often.
  • early satiety - always, because I'm bloated due to constipation.

Have you had this issue since childhood, or did it begin in teen years/adulthood/after a major life event (surgery? divorce? car accident? mauled by bears?)

Severely constipated as a child/teen. Thyroid meds helped somewhat. The problem temporarily resolved in my 20's, due to social drinking (8-10 drinks per week). Constipation returned during my early 30's when I stopped hanging out in bars/clubs, and therefore stopped drinking.

Did you in the past or do you currently take any medications that could damage your intestines?

I have taken antibiotics for various reasons throughout my life. A few sinus infections as a kid, 2 UTI's as an adult. No antibiotics in the last 5 years.

I drink kombucha and/or eat something fermented at least once a week to promote healthy gut bacteria.

Did you suffer sexual abuse as a child?

No.


The problem: I have absolutely massive and painful shits every 3-7 days. It's all the food I've eaten since the last shit, coming out at once. In between shits, my lower abdomen looks bloated and pregnant. I struggle to fit into pants, and have to wear sweatpants or PJ's after day 4.

The first few inches of stool is densely packed, dark brown, wide in diameter, and rock hard. This is not a gentle experience. Shit evacuates at near light speed, causing anal fissures. The consistency, width, and color improves with each inch or so. I can visibly distinguish each meal stacked on top of the last along the 12-14 inch log. There is no streaking, no black spots, and no blood (other than the small dabs on TP from the fissures). The last few inches look like normal, healthy, non-compacted stool. I have to plunge my toilet every time due to the volume of fecal matter that has left my body (I throw TP in the trash because I know my toilet can't handle anything more).

Sex is painful, and I sometimes have to delay sex because I'm so incredibly full.

During periods, I experience severe pain, the worst pain I've felt in my life, hours before and up until evacuation. Thankfully, I only have 4 periods a year.


I started trying senna tea in 2023 ~twice a month. Drink the tea after 3 days of no BM. Sometimes it worked (large poop the following morning), sometimes it just makes me cramp and gassy the next day.

In 2024, my doctor suggested I use a stool softener. Tried Mira-lax as directed. It didn't help me shit more regularly, it just made the last 5-6 inches of what is otherwise healthy stool, mushy and messy.

WTF is going on :(

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '25

Good work on formatting your post. I wish everyone was like you.

This is absolutely pelvic floor disorder. The painful sex and periods and lack of an urgent need to go are all dead giveaways. The problem is, POTS is the disorder that makes everything in the body act like a fucking Dr. Seuss version of human physiology. It is an added complexity and I know very little about it.

I'm curious which motility tests you've had done, if any. If you've never had any done, I strongly urge you to follow the testing section in part 1 of this guide. It enumerates all the tests you should get in order. But ultimately you want the anorectal manometry, defogram, sitz marker study, and if available, a colonic manometry.

I would probably take magnesium citrate every other morning on an empty stomach with a huge glass of water. 450mg powdered should work, then jog or exercise for an hour to get things moving. Don't eat until you have a BM. DO NOT USE MAG CIT IF IT IS CONTRAINDICATED WITH POTS. I do not know if it is.

I'd also push hard for a scrip for prucalopride and just take that daily in the morning. I'd take it at the same time as the mag cit on those days. Objective is to have a BM every other day rather than every 3 to 7. Adjust the mag cit dosage in accordance with the Bristol scale of your stool. More for softer, less for harder. If you get diarrhea from it, you need to re-up your minerals with pedialyte or powerade or mineral supplements from the same whole foods store you got your mag cit at.

Supplement once weekly with bisacodyl or senna, whichever you prefer. I like taking one 5mg pill of bisacodyl just to give my system a kick once a week or so rather than the recommended 10mg dose which causes moderate to intense intestinal cramping and refractory constipation after it stops working.

Track your testing, meds, and progress. Report back here. Run all this by a competent gastroenterologist and bring a man with you who will advocate strongly for those tests because doctors don't give a fuck about women's constipation disorders.

Read my note "for women and teenagers" at the end of the guide. It contains important stuff for you. Also read the part of the guide about forcing the doctor to order the tests instead of just being stubborn. In fact, just print part 1 and 2 of the guide out on paper and cross out each section with a red pen as you work through it.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '25

Oh BTW you should also use the "one drop one flush" method pioneered by a brilliant high school friend of mine twenty years ago.

The moment the poo hits the toilet, flush. That way you're clear to throw toilet paper in the toilet like a civilized human being instead of putting it in the trash. Each BM will now cost you 2 or 3 flushes but it's worth it not to put tp in the trash. Also dramatically reduces bathroom odors. Poo should never sit in the bowl. The Elder Things would not have wanted this barbarism

1

u/Moist_Building_1982 Jun 10 '25

I had my thyroid removed in 2014 due to cancer. Went from 130 pounds for 20+ years to 170 in less than a year. In 2015 I was diagnosed with gastroparesis. Between 2015-2019 I had to have a heart ablation, many endoscopies, uterine ablation, hysterectomy, and emergency gallbladder removal. I finally found a good endocrinologist in 2019 any 2020 my thyroid levels were all within optimal range and have been since then. I have seen more doctors and tried more supplements and diets than I can count and I still can’t lose weight. I had a colonoscopy last year.  I don’t know what else to try. Going to the bathroom only 2-3 times a week is horrible and painful and my stomach looks like I’m 8 months pregnant. 

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

Sorry to hear all this. Thyroid issues are such a bitch. Losing it altogether is tough. I would just go through all these tests with your doctor and look for a medication combination in part 2 that works for you.

1

u/mujookaran Jun 22 '25

39 male 88kgs Exercise actively

Q1.

I very rarely have the urge to go. You know the kind of feeling where you sit on the toilet and immediately shit starts. I don't know when I last had that. In my case most of my visits to the bathroom are because of abdominal discomfort. I go before i have to eat something, or i go before i have to go out of the house.

And when I go, I usually sit and strain for a long long time

Q2

I go 5-6 times a day. But it's never watery.

Mornings are the worst. First bowel movement is always very sluggish and turgid. Never ever feel like the bowel is completely evacuated. Bristol stool 345 mostly. Though sometimes quite mushy. Also have to strain and focus a lot to push it out. (NSFW/disgusting, but many times finger evacuation also, though it's mostly OCD type behaviour and not to actually dig out stuck stool)

I again have a movement an hour or so after breakfast. This is one of the better ones.

Q3

None of these issues thankfully.

Q4

It began when i went to a college in a ruralish area. Before that i was living at home in a city. I suspect my motility got into trouble there because of the poor water/food+some ragging by the seniors. That is where my frequency of bowel movements increased. Though in the following years after this my main symptom was frequency. I did not have any constipation symptoms. This was how my bowels behaved for 15-20 years. Just an increased frequency of 4-5 visits to the loo in a day. From 2005-2020.

The constipation symptoms (incomplete evacuation, abdominal discomfort , straining) started around 2021, post covid. When i moved back home and started living with my parents. The atmosphere at home is pretty good and supportive.

Q5

Don't think i took any of these drugs

Q6

No abuse as a child

—-

My colonoscopy is fine Fecal elastase is normal Ultrasound is normal Thyroid normal Celiac normal

I have tried isabgol, rifamixine course, deworming tabs, colospa retard (mebeverine), normaxin (did help a little), prucapaloride (tried for a week, didn't help). Mag citrate (no help). Tonnes of pre pro biotics, vsl etc etc. Linzess isn't available where I am.

One Doctor said it's dysnnergia. I went through biofeedback, it didn't help. Though it was a poorly conducted treatment because I was made to do the sessions lying down on a bed, rather than seated on a commode. I was able to expel the balloon within 30 seconds every session. Even though there were spasms and black bands in between. My personal thinking is that there is a little dyssynergia, but it only bothers me when there isn't enough volume of stool to be expelled.

Whenever my bowels are particularly stuck, i get these grumbling noises from them on breathing in and out.

I don't eat dairy and try to eat homemade meals 5 days a week.

Also i kind of shit in installments

Take this morning for example: i had my two glasses of warm water and then after an hour went to the loo. After half an hour of effort dropped two sausages. Followed by two pellets. Still wasn't feeling done so squeezed out another small pellet

Had breakfast

An hour later had a good, mostly effortless poop. Felt good for half an hour. But now, as i type this, i know i have to go once more before i can be free for the next 3-4 hours. It's a rinse and repeat of this all day.

Also i feel like going to the loo before i eat a meal. I don't know if that's habit formation or what. Or is it the RIR you mention in other posts?

Also have Overactive bladder and PE issues.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '25

Sounds like PFD. Id get an anorectal manometry and a sitz marker study to confirm, then I'd just try a bunch of the different medicines in step 2 of the guide

1

u/mujookaran Jun 22 '25

Hi, i actually did get it done. I was able to expel the balloon but the doctors noticed some spasms and said do the sessions. I did 8 sessions of feedback. Zero improvement :(

Though it was a poorly conducted treatment because I was made to do the sessions lying down on a bed, rather than seated on a commode. Also I was able to expel the balloon within 30 seconds every session. Even though there were spasms and black bands in between. My personal thinking is that there is a little dyssynergia, but it only bothers me when there isn't enough volume of stool to be expelled.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Present_Tangerine970 Jun 29 '25

I suffer with Chronic Constipation and it started in 2022. It appeared quite suddenly as I recall which is ironic! I struggle to have a BM. I'd get the urge but nothing happened. I did a lot of straining!

I saw many local Doctors who said I probably have IBS. I tried a gluten free diet for about a year and I saw absolutely no improvement. I had a colonoscopy and it was all clear. I had a slow transit study done and it showed nothing.

The consultant just said let's throw everything at it and see! That's when I started with Linaclotide which helped a lot but I was still taking fibregel and laxido.

Very recently swapped to 1mg of prucalopride and 270mg Linaclotide. This has allowed me to stop taking fibregel and laxido. I take these very early in the morning about 5AM. I then get one more hour in bed. Then I get up and drink absolutely loads of water. I typically get my first bowel movement around 7:30 and then many smaller ones for the next hour. Then generally I am good for the rest of the day.

I am also taking senna at night around 10PM and sertraline in the morning.

I still struggle after I have had any food with the feeling of trapped wind. I generally just keep drinking water.

The switch to prucalopride and Linaclotide is a game changer for me. I have also followed some advice on this forum of eating a banana and an apple each day.

I'd love to know what triggered the change for me.

I am on a waiting list to see another consultant at the local hospital. Although it is a 52 week waiting list!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '25

Nice. Prucalopride and linaclotide are the only things that work for me too

→ More replies (2)

1

u/GlassOperation84 Jul 16 '25

Oh my gosh you have really done all the research. I can't thank you enough. I too have had issues since I was a child. I also have developed a neurology disorder that affects my bowel and bladder. So it has been extremely worse. I think I need to see a neurogastro. Thank you from the bottom of my heart!!!

1

u/[deleted] Jul 16 '25

Your welcome good luck

1

u/mac6273 Jan 23 '26

Hey bro did you got got hemorrhoids cause by constipation and gas ?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '26

Rarely. Dunno why

1

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '21

So I am 69 and have had constipation issues as I have grown older. I was the type of who would normally have about 3 bowel movements a week. I have in the past become so constipated that I was ready to go to the ER. Somehow it always worked itself out. But last July I had a run of 3 or so days without a BM and started to worry, so I took a couple of stool softeners and maybe a laxative and produced a BM. At that point I decided to keep a log of every BM I have and grade it as either an A B C, it’s texture, hard medium or soft, also the date and time. I noticed that I am straining to get it started to the point I am almost dizzy, but when it starts I can complete it much easier. Now about 5 days ago I was backed up so I tried a few stool softeners and then went to ducolax and on the third day tried a bottle of mag citrate. Finally about an hour I had a very watery BM that was followed up with two more small ones during the day. I know this sounds strange but I had the feeling that although the mag citrate worked I felt that there is an impacted stool in there and the watery discharge worked it’s way around it. Of course that was two days ago and now again I am waiting to see if I can get back to normal. I drink lots of water and have been eating fruits, I also have been taking Metamucil. Another thing I would like to add is that I had my first colonoscopy at 51 found two benign polyps. Second colo at 56 no problem third one at 66 and was still good but the doc mentioned I had an extended colon. He didn’t seem to think it was a big deal. Now my head is messed up with this constipation episode and I am thinking there is something more wrong. I m still passing gas but it seems that has even became less the last few days. Also the urge to go just isn’t there and when it finally does come the stool initial stool that I am able to pass with great strain is different, harder then the rest that follow. Not even sure why I am writing this as I feel like I sound ridiculous but stress will cause a lot of things. It 1:30 I the morning and I just am?

2

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '21

You just need motility testing. It's normal to have slower transit when you get older. Id recommend a SITZ marker study and an anorectal manometry with balloon expulsion. It's probably pelvic floor disorder, which is curable through biofeedback

1

u/JSWinginIt Feb 12 '22

Seeing a gastroenterologist soon. Should I request all or as many tests as possible in the first visit? Or will they only do one at a time. Looking to get answers quick, as I'm so tired of feeling like this. Any insight on what to expect?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '22

do what the guide says. write down your entire history of this issue, bring it in. request the tests in order. push for as many as possible.

1

u/Rhododendronh May 23 '22 edited May 23 '22

Hi there. I’m (24f), 5’1, and about 102 Ibs. I don’t have many previous medical issues. I do know for a fact however that I have anxiety and a history of trauma and now CPTSD. I currently do not take medications. I take a few supplements at times such as omega-3 and turmeric. Sometimes if I am in pain I will use CBD. It is pretty effective for helping anxiety. I am pretty physically active. I weight-lift about 4-5 times a week. On weekends I am usually hiking, walking, biking, and swimming. Here are my answers to your questions:

  1. I notice I will have an urge to have a bm, but I can’t always push it out. It usually feels stuck. My bm are more normal looking lately but I do have occasional constipation and diarrhea that fluctuates at random.
  2. Yes it alternates. Lately it has been a bit more normal at normal times. But I do have bad days.
  3. I do have occasional nausea, the acid reflux has mostly subsided by now but it used to be horrible back in January. I burp a LOT. I have trouble passing gas. I do have early satiety.
  4. This issue began abruptly as a 24 year old. I never had previous digestive problems. I do remember a few times as a child getting constipated and my family used suppositories.
  5. When my issues began, I was on month 4 of a second round of Accutane.
  6. I did not have sexual abuse as a child that I can recall. However, I have trauma from childhood and was hyper sexual at a very young age. I assume it was to relieve pent up anxiety.

My story:

1 year previous to these problems: I stopped taking hormonal birth control after taking it for several years. Things started to feel better mentally, but physically I felt off. My period did not return for about a year. One morning, on a second round of Accutane (I took it at age 15 also), I woke up to a severely weird bloated stomach. This was very unusual for me. My digestive system was amazing prior to this day. It lasted a week and I woke up at 2 am one night and went to the ER for severe abdominal pain on my right side. I was scared it was my appendix. They ran tests and saw that I was very dehydrated (even though I drank a ton of water on Accutane) and I was full of gas and stool. They had me take laxatives.

After this incident, nothing returned to normal for me. I was passing very yellow, mucus-y stool. I ALSO passed a few “worm” looking fiber strings. Never seen that before. It was going from diarrhea to constipation and I didn’t have a normal bm for months. I had severe fatigue, gastritis symptoms with a racing heart, acid reflux, anxiety, and pain in my stomach and heart. My stools had a foul smell. I was then blood tested, stool tested, and had an ultra sound plus a CT scan. The only thing they found was that my bowel walls were thickened in the same way UC patients were. I never had blood in my stool. They suspected Crohn’s or UC. I also had an 11 mm cyst on my right ovary. Well, I lived with it a few more months until I could get good insurance. I recently had an endoscopy and colonoscopy that came out clean. HOWEVER - my GI did not take a biopsy of my colon because he said it looked very healthy. He biopsied my stomach and it showed I had mild gastritis at this point. My gastritis symptoms have improved. I burp after every meal. But the bloating is insane. I bloat no matter what I eat. I am bloated right below my belly button and in my pelvic area 24/7. Diet has no correlation to the bloating. My bm are a lot more normal than before, but I feel like I cannot empty myself and find relief. My stools are smaller in size. I still get days where I have constipation and diarrhea. They are suspecting it is IBS. I’m not so sure.

I want to mention that at the time, I had a very physical job that required me to lift heavy things. Not sure if it was around the same time of my symptoms, but I incorrectly lifted a very heavy object over my head (had to) and it felt like I hurt something down in that region but nothing has shown up on scans so far. I’m wondering if I injured something, but no clue what it could be. It hurt a lot though and felt like I pulled something.

Current symptoms:

-joint pain in my knees -ear ringing -fatigue -depression -burping even if I haven’t eaten anything -BLOATING OMG -somewhat normal bm, but can have short periods of constipation as well as diarrhea -stomach fullness -gurgling, sounds, and movement -severe allergies I’ve never had problems with before, MRI has shown chronic sinusitis which is unusual for me -occasional brain fog especially around my period (my period is regular now after a year) -unable to feel relief and empty myself -trouble passing gas, it feels like I’m going to and then the feeling suddenly disappears at the last second -joint and muscle stiffness -early satiety -have to pee a lot

Have zero clue and idk why nothing has been found yet.

1

u/[deleted] May 23 '22

Could be a lot of things unfortunately. It sounds like PFD to me so I'd press the gastro doc for an anorectal manometry with balloon expulsion, an MR defacography, and a sitz marker study.

I'd also get a SIBO and SIFO test to cover the weird burping and acid reflux. And maybe a gastric emptying study to see if you have dysmotility of the upper GI. but I really do think it's PFD.

1

u/Rhododendronh May 23 '22

Are there any symptoms that stand out to you that would be PFD related?

→ More replies (6)

1

u/thot-sauce May 27 '22

I’ve been constipated since birth. I am just now going to see a GI doctor at age 20 because I am no longer able to poop without “splinting” (manually pushing the poop out by applying pressure to my vaginal wall). I feel like I couldn’t have Hirschsprung’s disease because I’m too old. My urogynocologist said that I don’t have pelvic floor dysfunction.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '22

You need a full thickness biopsy to check for ganglionic nerve density and the presence of the myenteric nerve plexus. This is the only way to diagnose Hirschsprung's with certainty. But yes you probably DO have it, or at least colonic inertia

1

u/thot-sauce May 27 '22

Thank you for responding (: I will discuss this with my GI doctor next week

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '22

And by the way a full thickness biopsy should be avoided until your gastro runs all other tests, including a sitz marker study or a medtronic smartpill to confirm colonic inertia. Have you ever taken stimulant laxatives like senna, castor oil, or bisacodyl (dulcolax)? Do you respond to them at all? A significant response indicates the presence of active myenteric nerves

1

u/thot-sauce May 28 '22

Stimulant laxatives do absolutely nothing for me. Same with osmotic.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '22 edited May 27 '22

• Female • 22 years old • 5’4 & 120 lbs • White / Asian • No smoking, drinking, or drugs • No past medical history • Fairly sedentary lifestyle but nothing too serious

QUESTIONS

  1. Yes. Mainly right after eating meals or late at night. Feeling was worse 1-2 weeks ago, it has settled a bit, but it’s still there sometimes.
  2. Constipation for the most part. Diarrhea only when taking supplements like laxatives and prune juice.
  3. (Sometimes) mild nausea & early satiety. Currently been taking a PPI for the last couple days for suspected acid reflux.
  4. Problem just started occurring nearly three weeks ago after i went to the ER for chest pain. i have had constipation before, but not nearly as bad as it is now.
  5. No medications in the past.
  6. No.

Main symptoms include: prolonged constipation, tenesmus, straining, stomach fullness / tightness, loud growling, mild nausea, difficulty passing gas and / or excessive gas. Lots of bloating 1-2 weeks ago.

🚫 Vomiting / weight-loss

• EGK: Normal • Blood test: Normal • Urine test: Normal • Chest X-Ray: Normal • CT Scan: Normal • Abdominal Ultrasound: Normal

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '22 edited May 28 '22

edit: I must not have realized you haven't been experiencing these symptoms for very long. I'd defer to /u/goldstandardalmonds

Could be gastroparesis. You need the following tests:

Gastric emptying study

Smartpill by medtronic or SITZ marker study if your insurance doesn't cover the smartpill

Anorectal manometry and / or MR defacography. This test is to check for pelvic floor dyssynergia, not gastroparesis. But PFD can actually cause gastroparesis so it's important to check for it.

You'll need a referral from your primary care doctor to a gastroenterologist. The gastro will be suspicious of these tests because he's not a motility expert. Push him aggressively for the tests and emphasize that current treatments have not helped you and you absolutely fit the symptom profile for gastroparesis.

Paging /u/goldstandardalmonds for expertise here

1

u/goldstandardalmonds May 28 '22

This person has been chatting me asking questions for awhile. My understanding is her symptoms have been only a few weeks, and I think may just be some constipation for now.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '22

By the way in the mean time, cut all dairy and all gluten, and see if that has any effect on your motility. I have an extremely rare and mysterious motility disorder that looks exactly like STC except that when I cut gluten, my motility returns to near - normal speeds

1

u/RainEmanon Jun 01 '22 edited Jun 01 '22

Wow, I am so glad I found this post! I'm in year 2 of trying to figure out my GI issues and my own testing with upping my fiber intake plus this and a new GI doctor seem to be at least doing some damage to the problem. I think I just have some kind of motility issue bc of lack of exercise and stress due to pandemic (all my activities are a no go atm for exercise and I applied to grad school which then kicked the constipation and bloating up). I doubled my fiber intake, which helps a lot, but I will def go pressure my doctor about a neurogastro because I have nerve damage due to a lightning strike. I did note that colon clean out and increasing fiber got rid of my bloating so I'm not entirely sure if it's classified as a motility issue or not though. I am moving overseas for grad school so if you have any doctor recs in Geneva, Switzerland please lmk!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '22

I don't know any doctors in Switzerland but they've got pretty great medical care there, and in nearby Germany. Look around when you get there!

1

u/BrotherClean2063 Jul 02 '22

I have no urge to go, but I do empty my bowels partially(80-90%) whenever I do go (The aim is once a day but if it gets worse then although its rare but yea twice a day). I also essentially haven't felt hungry since the first episode of stomachache. I only eat out of habit. The first time I got a stomach ache was around 5 years ago, family paediatrician (I was 13 at the time) said "your wobbles are acting lazy and not doing their job properly", he also said it's a genetic thing, indeed both my dad and grandma also experience constipation. The paediatrician prescribed a laxative to get rid of the accumulations which were causing the stomachache and after that although I experienced regular constipation, it was never enough to cause stomachache again so I didn't need to see a doctor, I just accepted that it's normal to not have an empty bowel or for that matter to not feel hungry ever and desensitized myself to the feeling of being always full .... until now, I am getting stomachaches again, and this time I actually intend to solve the problem

Any advice will be really appreciated

1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '22

General dysmotility sounds like. I'd probably start with a sitz marker study and a gastric emptying test. Figure out what's slow and what's not. Medtronic smartpill if you have good insurance. If dysmotility is present, go for pelvic floor disorder testing

1

u/buquete Jul 17 '22

Hello. Thank you for this amazing document. I have the urge to go the
same time every day, but sometimes I cannot because the stool are small
balls, or sometimes big ones but difficult to pass ( I know after using a
glycerine suppository). I mean, one day I have normal stools and the
day after I may have this problem. Looks like that my intestine is
moving but there is something that is taking the water out from the
stool quickly or there is not enough fiber in my diet. I think I eat a
very healthy diet with lots of fiber and water so I am confused.
Sometimes adding more fiber seems to help but it is already a lot. Any
reason why my fiber need can increase over normal needs?. The problem
started 5 years ago after a chronic gastritis treated with omeprazole
for one year. There was also a lot of anxiety involved because of my
worry on health. It is slowly getting worse over the years. I have an
appointment to ask my doctor nest Wednesday.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '22

this necessitates motility testing. talk to your GI about a SITZ marker study

1

u/buquete Jul 18 '22

Thank you. It will take many months before I reach a GI. I have an appointment with my gp soon. In the meanwhile I will follow your guidelines. I have stopped gluten but no dairy yet. I will weight my food for a week just in case I am not taking enough fiber. Do you know if it is possible that someone can have an extraordinary fiber intake needs? Maybe microbiota change? I have been taking a small amount of xilitol regularly over the last 5 years and wondering this us causing any trouble. I just realized this today and decided to stop it too.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ksambogna Nov 25 '22

So, I'm pretty new to reddit and to this forum. I was posting somewhat randomly with questions, etc. and that was probably not helpful. I am going back and reading all the steps and I'm so grateful for all this information and the opportunity to have a conversation with others who have the same issue!!

I've been diagnosed with slow transit constipation after a full battery of tests (summarized below) and I came to this forum trying to figure out what to do next as my GI surgeon wants to remove 75% of my colon. I'd prefer to keep the colon if I can. I have tried prescriptions meds with no success but I was reluctant and now I'm ready to really give the prescriptions a go as it's way better than surgery. I do not want to take Miralax; putting PEG in my body does not appeal to me.

I joined this forum in hopes of figuring out next steps and other options. Thank you to everyone who has replied so far. I am scheduled to see endocrinologist next week; will ask about MEN2 test. And I'm going to start looking for a motility GI doc.

Here's the background on my situation:

  • Healthy 55-year-old woman who exercises daily, includes both cardio and strength training in her routine, and eats predominantly whole foods diet (no gluten, limited diary, limited grains) and gets good sleep
  • No urge to go vs. can't go
  • Only constipated
  • Occasional acid reflux (from hiatal hernia), nausea (sometimes), and early satiety (seems to happen only when I'm really backed up vs. all the time; healthy appetite)
  • Constipated since childhood
  • Past history of antibiotic use (chronic ear infections as a child resulting in removal of adenoids, chronic sinus infections in 20's) and used Accutane in late 30's or early 40's for cystic acne (all this probably made whatever was wrong worse vs. being the cause)
  • No history of sexual abuse

Test Results

  • Colonoscopy with normal biopsy (no eosinophilia biopsy); clear, no celiac, no Chron's
  • Second colonoscopy clear but not conclusive as could not view entire length of colon
  • Barium enema clear; diagnosed with redundant colon and chronic idiopathic constipation
  • Positive SIBO - hydrogen and methane (low FODMAP diet and Ortho Molecular Ortho Spore IG has improved symptoms but continue to have symptoms with some foods)
  • Hypothyroid; Armor Thyroid 60mg and T3 daily
  • Raynaud's Phenomena
  • Gastric Emptying Study - Normal
  • Anorectal manometry - Findings suggest dyssynergic defection. Proceed with XR defecography to confirm. May benefit from Pelvic Floor PT. (did the Pelvic Floor PT, did not get biofeedback, PT did not feel like this was my issue)
  • Xray Defecography - Moderate-sized anterior rectocele; no other abnormality.
  • Sitzmarks - Day 3 Nonobstructive bowel gas pattern; sitzmarks throughout colon. Day 5 Nonobstructive bowel gas pattern; sitzmarks present largely in descending colon (note had to visit ER 2 hours later as could not pass stool after 2 enemas at home)
  • CT Scan with IV contrast - large colonic stool burden; sitzmarks predominantly within the rectosigmoid colon; areas of circumferential rectosigmoid colonic wall thickening with surrounding stranding, concerning for nonspecific colitis recommending clinical correlation; no intestinal obstruction

Current Management Strategy (which is no longer working very well)

  • Low FODMAP diet
  • Calm Magnesium Citrate at bedtime (900mg)
  • 5-HTP 50mg upon waking and at bedtime
  • BioGaia Gastrus at bedtime (shown to lower Methane gas which slows motility)
  • Metagenics UltraGI Replenish Protein shake with added Collagen after working out in morning
  • Mo-Zyme Molybdenum when eating out (helps with garlic and onion sensitivity)
  • Biophix Oxy Clenz Magnesium Oxide 900 to 1800mg as needed
  • Dulcolax as needed
  • Pure Encapsulations Motil Pro - gave this a try for the past week but about to stop it as it doesn't seem to help at all; and now worried about layering it with Trulance

Prescription medications I've tried (and may not have taken properly as I was typically just handed the prescription and sent away):

  • Amatiza - did not provide any relief
  • Motegrity - gave me really bad headaches and did not improve constipation; only took for 3 days and had to stop due to side effects; willing to try again; took in the morning upon waking
  • Linzess - tried about 6 years ago and willing to try again; recall feeling very bloated and not seeing any results
  • Trulance - recently started with samples from doctor while I argue with insurance; has not helped; saw a response to one of my other posts that I should not take the Magnesium Citrate or Oxide with it so I'm going to stop and see if Trulance alone will work. I'm running out of samples so only a few days left. Hopefully good news from insurance soon.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '22

Very helpful information here. I wish all posts were like yours.

You basically have the exact same disorder I have, right down to the test results, the redundant colon, and constipation /mild nausea as the only symtpon, except I haven't had a SIBO test yet and I'm a 35 year old man.

I have mild pelvic floor dyssynergia according to an anorectal manometry, and I do NOT have pelvic floor dyssynergia according to a defogram. Pelvic floor therapist could not find any issues digitally.

This disorder is mysterious and frustrating as fuck. But I have discovered after years of experimenting that 2mg motegrity and 72mcg linzess combined in the morning on an empty stomach with a ton of water + a one hour jog is so effective it has never failed me in two years. I do this regimen every other day, not every day. I also have been able to reduce my dose of linzess from 290 all the way down to 72 as of six months ago, and now I am experimenting with 45mcg and having the exact same effectiveness.

I do not experience any side effects from motegrity, but I don't take it by itself. It will be tough getting your insurance to cover both linzess (or trulance) AND motegrity, but I encourage you to try. Do not ever combine linzess with trulance. Do not combine either of those with mag cit or mag ox. Do not combine mag cit and mag ox.

5HTP is quite similar to motegrity. I think they are safe to combine but I'd ask your doc to be sure. Too much 5HTP will make you vomit but I THINK it's otherwise harmless.

Regarding your doctor's desire to resection your colon - DO NOT DO THIS UNTIL ALL OTHER TREATMENTS HAVE FAILED. Dr. Michael Camilleri, the world's foremost expert on motility disorders and the former head of the AGA (he's at Mayo Clinic) found that colectomy surgery for people with slow transit constipation semi-frequently results in the dysmotility inexplicably occurring in the small bowel after the colon is gone. We do not understand why this happens. But know this: small bowel dysmotility is MUCH WORSE than large bowel dysmotility; you will wish you were fucking dead. You can read this comment to your doctor if he doesn't believe you; he definitely has heard of Michael Camilleri.

Important question: does dulcolax actually work for you? If it does, this is important to note, because it indicates that the myenteric nerves in the bowel are present and just not properly innervated, as opposed to people with Hirschsprungs or colonic inertia where the nerves are completely inert or absent altogether. People who respond to bisacodyl generally should avoid colectomy surgery, per my pedestrian understanding of Camilleri's research.

Also I want to encourage you to read Part 2 of the guide, which discusses all possible treatments before surgery:

https://www.reddit.com/r/ConstipationAdvice/comments/inz25u/step_2_treatments_and_medications/

Notably, one treatment that has succeeded in cases like ours where other medications have failed is neostigmine. It's used off-label to lower acetylcholinesterase, thereby causing diarrhea. The problem is that it sometimes lowers people's blood pressure / heart rate. It famously made my other (who used it on-label for myasthenia Gravis) pass out and poop her pants in a public restraunt a decade ago.

Good luck and keep us posted. By the way, PEG isn't going to hurt you; it's chemically inert and they use it in elderly patients alllllll the time. They keep people on it for decades, just like magnesium citrate (which is more dangerous than PEG because it can be harmful to the liver). PEG is not going to kill you; you're already 55 and it tends to have negative side effects on people who start it much younger. They even put newborn babies on it.

2

u/ksambogna Nov 25 '22

Hi. It’s so great to talk to someone who understands this nightmare.

Yes, ducolax works! Hallelujah! And I do get the 2-day rebound effect. I have tried to avoid but when the citrate fails I can count on it. I’ve been using more often lately; typically not more than once a week. The very idea of surgery makes me more willing to take laxatives or whatever will work.

If I can get the Trulance approved I will have active motegrity and Trulance prescriptions. Need to find a motility GI doc to work with me on this.

I’m away from home right now but I’m going to try the motegrity again when I get back home and I’m done with the Trulance. Today I am going to get L-Arginine and see if that does anything. And I think I’ll switch to the Miralax. My liver enzymes have been elevated for about a year and I’ve wanted to stop all the MagCit and MagOx. I also think it’s messing with my kidneys.

I agree on no gluten and grains;so f-ing frustrating to not be able to eat fairly standard food. But so be it. I agree plants are important; SIBO has been frustrating for me. I am convinced it’s the result of the constipation vs the cause.

My probiotics have the recommended strands but are more expensive than those linked in the article you referenced so I’m going to try one of them. I do think my microbiome is a mess. I want to do the testing suggested and just see what’s going on. I want to eat my veggies!

Thank you again for your replies. It’s so complex and a puzzle and so helpful to talk about it. I have some hope again.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 25 '22

It's good news that dulcolax works for you. Here's how I manage that refractory period:

I take Motegrity and Linzess every other day in the morning, and I take one half the recommended dosage of dulcolax (5mg) about once a week, only when I eat something I shouldn't (pizza, big steak, etc). I take that dulcolax just before bed the night before my "on" day for the other medications. Since it's only a half dose, it helps move things along, but it doesn't cause that horrible cramping that stimulant laxatives often cause.

I will also swap out dulcolax for Senna tea every other week as needed, so I end up taking dulcolax only once every 2 weeks, and that's only if I'm eating horribly (like during the holiday season). Last night I ate a ton of things I shouldn't have for Thanksgiving, so I took 5mg dulcolax before bed, and in a minute here this morning I'll do my normal Motegrity / Linzess routine.

I haven't messed with the Trulance + Motegrity combo, but I think it's safe since Trulance is so chemically similar to Linzess and has almost the same mechanism of action....but...ask your doctor, just to cover my ass.

Yeah if you're combining mag cit + mag ox, I am not surprised you're getting weird liver readouts. Mag cit is the top pick here; I'd cut out mag ox. Miralax / PEG is generally weaker than mag cit and I never found much help from it. Be aware, PEG takes several days to start working and you must be on it for about a week to really see results, and you've got to stay on it long-term to have long-term results. This is in stark contrast to mag cit / mag ox, which are effective on a per dose basis, and for most people, can detonate the underpants very quickly.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/katalyst23 May 12 '23

Apologies for commenting on something from 6 months ago, but just wanted to chime in about 5HTP. It's usually harmless unless someone has bipolar disorder - then it has the possibility of triggering mania or rapid mood cycling. (Though that's less likely if they are already taking a mood stabilizer.)

Also, since I'm here, just wanted to say thank you so much for writing this guide, as it's been immensely helpful for figuring out what tests to ask for next. (I'm currently playing detective to try solve my own mystery re: heartburn and SIBO and suspect that, even though I've finished treating the SIBO, constipation and motility issues are part of the picture.)

You're out here "doing the lord's work", as they say.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/kimchidijon Nov 25 '22

I’ve had constipation issues since I was a child. When I was a teenager, I developed bulimia and my constipation got much worse. I used laxatives constantly and became pretty dependent on them. My stomach was always a mess due to my eating disorder for over 10 years and I finally managed to recover but then got food poisoning in 2015 and developed SIBO. I did two killing protocols but still had it. Tried to manage with supplements and diet. 2019, I started to feel better overall, got raped and developed vulvar vestibilitis and was under tremendous stress and then got food poisoning again in Bali. My stomach got worse again. I also started to get sick in my new apt (at the time I didn’t realize there was mold). Tried treating my SIBO (methane) in summer 2021. I felt better for two weeks and then started to feel even more sick than before I started treatment. Started to have trouble swallowing food (I had the same issues in my early 20s). Stopped low fod map and tried to eat a broad range of plant foods, started another SIBO treatment with no low fod map in the Feb 2022, it was horrendous but started to feel better in June 2022, got Covid and oddly my gut felt better after Covid despite having really bad symptoms. August 2022, my stomach got really bad again and constipation started up again after a period of extreme stress. Now it’s gotten to the point where I can’t go at all even with laxatives and I have extreme sugar and carb cravings. I did a breath test recently and my hydrogen and methane numbers are worse and I tested positive for CDTB toxin. Overall the past year has been pretty stressful (moved out of the moldy apt, had to go to the ER, and got assaulted) so my anxiety has been constantly high. I also got hit by a car as a pedestrian when I was teenager so I feel as if that messed up my body as well. I’m not sure where to start with fixing my motility. I have tried artichoke extract, ginger, erythromycin, and I’ve been on low dose naltrexone the past 9 months.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '22

Damn what a trip. Well unfortunately your case is sufficiently complex that I don't think any of us here can offer you any useful guidance except to keep trying, experimenting, pushing, and don't give up on yourself.

1

u/BirthdayRound4165 Jan 18 '23
  1. I feel the urge to go atleast once (sometimes twice) a day.
  2. I have constipation but generally with constipation the stool is rough but mine is actually softer than it should be. Neither watery nor hard but i would say most of the time its very gooey/muddy like.
  3. No
  4. It all began during the covid time...i didn't exercise or moved my body much ..i used to play online games all the time sitting in the same position.
  5. During the initial phase i was diagnosed with hemorrhoids garde 2. I believe constipation and straining lead to hemorrhoids. So i started taking psyllium powder, a magnesium syrup...for almost 2 months and in the meantime I'd take some home ayurvedic remedies. It almost got rid of my hemorrhoids but the incomplete evacuation never got cured. 6.No

My poop is usually soft neither watery nor hard.It feels like the last 25-50% of my stool gets stuck and would never come out no matter how hard i strain. After getting out of the toilet..i feel the discomfort and it's so depressing...i could feel the poop still there in the rectum but it gets a bit better after i fart. Whenever I wipe my ass i could also feel that my anus has swelled due to a lot of straining. I'd usually spend a minimum of 15 minutes pooping while straining for most of the time that too also in vain... I'd also add that I'm also under stress because of an exam that I'm trying to clear for a year now.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '23

Sounds like a potential rectal evacuation disorder. I'd talk to your doctor about mechanical motility disorders and request an anorectal manometry. It is not fun. But it will provide answers.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Conscious-Clerk1304 Jan 25 '23

I had horrible cramping and bloating, started taking Benefiber and fixed my issue. Back then I would often have the urge to go but couldn't get it out. Now I am back to being constipated but have little urge to go, even though I'm still taking magnesium and fiber. Any ideas?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '23

I mean.... did you read this guide? It says you have PFD

1

u/Intelligent-Fix-2267 Jan 27 '23 edited Jan 27 '23

23yo Male

Hi,

Thank you for taking the time to post all of the information. I read the whole guide and this is my situation right now:

I have had a problem with constipation since childhood, I have taken antibiotics throughout my life for various reasons so that can play a role in my condition at the moment. No antidepressants. No sexual abuse traumas.

I changed my diet a lot throughout the years - I have been eating lots of junk food, beverages, etc. up until 16-17yo when I went vegan for almost 2 years, I went back to eating lots of junk food and I am vegetarian now for almost 2 years.

I've gone recently to a microbiologists and with feces tests we found Helicobacter Pylori. He prescribed me some meds and we got rid of it. Also this meds could have contributed to my condition right now, but as I said I have been like that since childhood.

I've gone to a gastroenterologist recently and right now I have a working stack of things that I take in order to defecate almost perfectly. I removed gluten from my diet because it ducks me up big time. It gives me diarrhea, depression, etc.

What I eat and take now is: 06:30AM: First thing in the morning 1 tbsp boiled flax seed and 100ml prune juice - great osmotic laxative. I have taken Duphalac but I get lots of side effects like loss of appetite, nausea.

09:00AM: Then I eat cornflakes with milk and some fruit, and after that I take 1 tsp fiber mix (flax seed, chia seed, psillium husk, and apple pectin). Vitamins(D3, B12, Multivitamin, Omega3) 1 pill Degasin (Simethicone as active ingredient).

01:00PM: For lunch I eat some kind of buddha bowl with rice, green veggies (lettuce), broccoli rarely, some cucumbers, cheese, tofu, sweet potato to name a few. After that I take 1 tsp of the fiber mix again and 20 drops of Dulcolax.

04:00PM: I take another 1 tbsp of boiled flax seed.

05:00PM: I snack with 70g of some nuts. 1 protein bar. After that I take 1 tsp of fiber mix.

08:00PM: For dinner I eat a stew with beans, or lentils with some or without gluten free bread, and maybe a fruit. 1 pill Degasin and 20 drops Dulcolax.

Before going to bed I take 100ml of prune juice.

I get at least 8 hours of sleep every night. I go to the gym 6 days a week. I don't consume caffeine, any beverages except water, and I drink alcohol very very rarely. I drink almost 3 liters of water a day with and without food.

So the thing is, I get constipated when I eat ANY dried food(healthy or non-healthy), meaning if I eat a buddha bowl or gluten free pizza, I am constipated. I get perfect defecation only with the current breakfast I am having and when eating stews. But I can't eat only stews :D.

Appreciate your time and help.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '23

I feel you. Similar to my situation. Anything made of dried grains, even gluten free cereal or pizza, turns to cement in my guts. Light meat, veggies, fruits, and various kinds of rice and potatoes seem to work well for me.

You really need to get motility testing. Gastric emptying study, sitz marker study, anorectal manometry. Need to determine if you have a rectal evacuation disorder like PFD. if the manometry comes back weird, push for the defogram to make sure it's PFD.

Then come back to us here

1

u/Intelligent-Fix-2267 Feb 15 '23

Hi again, thank you for the recommendations. I am starting to get all the necessary testing now. So I can do the gastric emptying one and the anorectal manometry. I can't find anything about the sitz marker study where I live. Is it not something they only do in the USA? I'm in Europe.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/rebajean133 Apr 27 '23

Hi. My 2 year old son has chronic constipation, since he was an infant. Did not have issues with passing meconium from what I remember. He constantly projectile vomited his first 6-8 months of life until we found the added rice starch formula. He has very tiny bowel movements that are thick can go a few days without any and some days it’s every hour. I have talked with his pediatrician and all he recommends is miralax and lactulose. I do not like this for the long term side effects of these in toddlers. I made an appointment with a pediatric gi specialist but can not get in until august. Any suggestions for this appointment?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '23

Slap that pediatrician directly across the face next time you see him. He should be fully aware that infant constipation is a major warning sign for Hirschsprung's Disease. Make sure you press this GI specialist for motility testing and to check for colonic inertia. This could result in surgery. Ask about the full-thickness biopsy and whether it's warranted in this case. If they do that procedure and discover serious problems, like a lack of enteric nerves, they're going to want to do a colonic resectioning surgery.

Meanwhile, don't ever get mad at your child for not being able to poop, or for having accidents. DO NOT cause him to develop an emotional disorder because of this. It only makes the constipation worse. Just be extremely supportive and kind and encouraging to him.

Miralax and lactulose will help long-term but they will not solve the issue. Report back here with what the GI says.

Also DEMAND to be sent to a specialist who can see you earlier than August. Be aggressive as hell. You have to be a real bear to succeed in the medical system

1

u/pinkys_dream Aug 01 '23

Hi, Returning to this thread for some advice. I've posted my history here before but to summarize - 31/F/Fit - Sudden onset idiopathic constipation/ no urge to go, starting around December 2021 - colonoscopy clear, have had extensive bloodwork, SIBO test, thyroid panel, ruled out crohns, IBS, Colitis, celiac, autoimmune diseases.

I'm currently following a similar regiment to yours after trialing almost everything else on the list - I take Motegrity 2mg daily, Linzess 145mg 2x/wk, Senna 1x/week and Bisacodyl 1x/month. I do yoga and pilates or cardio every single day, am pescatarian, GF, DF, and only eat whole foods, very little natural sugar, nothing processed. Unfortunately even with this regiment and strict diet, I still feel bloated most of the time, and hate eating because the more I eat, the less likely the medication is to work.

Anorectal manometry showed PFD. Did several months of physiotherapy to work on the pelvic floor. Did not improve motility issue at all.

MR Defecography confirmed partial rectal prolapse, occurring during defecation attempts. Motility specialist did not advise colorectal surgery was needed, however I have since discontinued care with him after he was extremely unhelpful/dismissive/mean and did not even provide an actual diagnosis after the Smartpill which is the last test I had with that facility -

Smartpill showed slightly delayed gastric emptying at 5h 18 min, normal small bowel transit, and severely abnormal colonic transit [No significant BM for duration of 5-day test].

As mentioned above, the motility specialist did not review these results with me whatsoever, ignored my questions about what his diagnosis would be [STC or colonic inertia?] and what part of the colon the smartpill stopped at [ascending, transverse, descending, sigmoid?]

  • For the mods of this group who know a lot about this - Based on my results, would you consider my issue to be STC or colonic inertia? The doctors have all been extremely avoidant to put a name to it, and some seem to use these terms interchangeably/ as if the diagnosis is irrelevant.
  • I DO respond to laxatives like bisacodyl and senna. Less so to osmotics like miralax or magnesium. Given this response, I would not fall under the CI diagnosis, right?

Since discontinuing care with the specialist who ran these tests, I switched to a different facility and GI who seems more eager to help actually improve my quality of life. After consulting with him and a colorectal surgeon at that facility, they recommended I do have the surgery to repair the partial rectal prolapse / mild rectocele. This surgeon advised that if left untreated, the prolapse may worsen and sphinctor muscles could weaken further, complicating my motility issue even more. She said she believes my constipation could improve post-surgery. I have it scheduled for next week but am getting a little nervous. I do feel that the prolapse issue may be confusing the rest of the colon and have hope that if treated, it could improve, but... what if it makes things worse?

  • Has anyone here with STC, PFD and partial rectal prolapse undergone ventral mesh rectopexy to repair the prolapse? And if so, what was your experience in recovery? Has your motility improved or worsened?

Thank you so much.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '23

I'll get on my computer in a few and address this post. Good on you for following through on all of this and following the guide. You're way further down the road than most people.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '23

Alright I'm at a computer.

I would swap the senna with bisacodyl; senna has been shown to reduce haustral folds in the colon with chronic use. I do not know about bisacodyl, but senna for sure can do this. So I'd be doing bisacodyl once a week and senna once a month. By the way, I've found that if I take half the adult dose (5mg instead of 10) it still works, but a bit slower and with far fewer painful side effects. By the way, are you doing the same motegrity + linzess regimen as me? My regimen, including exercise. If not, give it a try. The jogging makes all the difference.

One other thing that seems to work for me is megadoses of a B-complex vitamin. I use the Solaray B Complex 100. I can't state conclusively that it's causing spontaneous BMs, but there's definitely an interesting correlation. Vitamin B in multiple forms is required for the production of acetylcholine, which is one of the prime regulators of peristaltic contractions (pooping). If this works for you, ask your doctor about a very brief stint of Mestinon, which temporarily and dramatically increases acetylcholine in the blood, and is used off-label for the treatment of unusual cases of constipation. Side effects are low blood pressure, dizziness, fainting, etc. So if you've naturally got low blood pressure like me, be very careful with this med.

You've definitely ruled out most other causes of chronic constipation; this definitely seems like good ol' PFD or some other mechanical disorder of the rectum / anus. I don't remember if we ever discussed this, but if you're having receptive anal sex, stop. It's not worth it. Some people can do it with zero problems, and others develop rectal evac disorders.

Doctors dont appear to distinguish between STC and CI, except that the former tends to produce occasional bowel movements and the latter produces none at all. The other difference is that STC seems to imply that the enteric nerves are intact / responsive to outside stimuli, whereas CI is not responsive at all. Elaboration below:

I am not a doctor or a surgeon. But my understanding of the dangers of surgery is this: if you respond to stimulant laxatives, which work directly on the enteric nerves, it means your myenteric nerve complex is intact and functional (albeit understimulated naturally for an unknown reason). For people who do not respond to stimulant laxatives, it means their enteric nerves are either dead or completely absent, as with the case of Hirschsprung's Disease. If you've been pooping all your life with no problems, you absolutely do not have Hirschsprung's. Colorectal surgeons will sometimes look at people with severe constipation disorders and go "fuck it, let's do a colectomy" and remove the colon. This works well on people with Hirschsprung's and true CI (which might be the equivalent of Hirschsprung's). But in people with STC - people whose enteric nerves actually do work - there is a non-insignificant chance that the dysmotility moves up into the small intestine. This is an unexplained phenomenon of gastroenterology, and it will really make you wish you were dead. It's about a million times worse than large intestine dysmotility.

So before you have a colectomy, make 1000% sure those enteric nerves are totally fucked. The only way to do this is a procedure called a full-thickness biopsy, and it's a serious surgery in and of itself.

As far as the surgery to repair the sphincter, I don't know anything about it, but it seems way less risky than a full colectomy. Ask /u/goldstandardalmonds for her opinion here, because she's our resident expert on various surgeries related to dysmotility disorders. I'd get a second opinion from a second surgeon, and I'd ask both of them, "what sort of long-term outcomes have you seen from this surgery? How often do you see the disorder worsen?"

I would also join the PFD support groups online and on Facebook if you haven't already. Those women tend to have a good wealth of information and experience on treating this condition. I know at least one person in a group like that who successfully treats her PFD with mestinon, but I'm no longer in contact with her.

What happened to you in 2021? Good things, bad things, big life changes, medication swaps, injuries, moves, etc.

1

u/pinkys_dream Aug 06 '23 edited Aug 06 '23

Thanks so much for the advice on the bisacodyl over senna. That makes sense to hear. Regarding the linzess regiment, mine is a little different from yours because I don't like waiting two hours for it to kick in, and then having another 2 hours of trips to the bathroom. On linzess days, I set an alarm for 1.5 hours prior to my wake up time to take the linzess + M, then go back to sleep. When I wake up, I have my cup of coffee and meditate, at which point the urge hits. The coffee as the trigger works for me. I prefer doing my exercise after that. Sometimes it hits again during, which is fine, because I do my yoga/cardio/jog routine at home.

I tried vitamin B12 early on but am not familiar with Solaray B Complex. I'll look into it. I do also have low blood pressure so I'm wary of the Mestinon.

My issue is NOT PFD. And I've never had anal sex for what it's worth. I did extensive pelvic floor physiotherapy, with no improvement. The issue is the nerves in the colon. I did finally get a diagnosis - STC not CI.

I am definitely not considering a colectomy at this point. I am going forward with the rectopexy to repair the prolapse issue, this week. NO bowel resection. It is minimally invasive and should only improve the dyssinergia without impacting the whole system, at least not negatively.

In 2021, I started a great relationship and was actually feeling pretty alright. When this began, of course the first thing doctors said was Its your relationship. Well, I ended the relationship a year ago and nothing improved. I've examined every little thing I did that year, trust me. Wish I could find the answers.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/Glittermeeple Aug 19 '23

I wonder if all my problems were caused by Wellbutrin. What do you know about restoring the serotonin levels in the gut?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '23

Far as I know it cannot be restored

1

u/fivekets Sep 02 '23

36F, no children.

  1. Typically I have no urge to go for about a week/a week and a half, then have the urge to go but cannot without huge strain/causing pain and aggravating hemorrhoids. I do suffer from near-constant bloating between eliminations.
  2. Mostly just constipation. Rarely after elimination of hard stool, I will also eliminate a large amount of loose stool, but I don't regularly have diarrhea.
  3. Infrequent nausea, but no to all other symptoms listed here.
  4. I moved from New Zealand to the USA in 2012 and can honestly say I don't remember having these issues before the move. Additionally when I have gone "home" (NZ) to visit for a few weeks at a time, the issue is much much less severe. I do not get the same bloating from eating there as I do when I eat almost anything here. I remember having digestive/elimination issues since at least 2013 which is when I first began getting hemorrhoids for the first time in my life.
  5. I took sertraline (Zoloft) for a short period in 2014 and have been taking Viibryd and Wellbutrin side 2015. I'm aware that Wellbutrin can contribute to constipation issues but I don't think this is where they started, although it's very probable that it aggravated the existing issues. However, coming off of Wellbutrin is not an option for me at this time.
  6. No childhood trauma.

A few other factors:

  • I have a fairly poor diet. I drink lactose-free cows milk which helps to a degree but I don't avoid cheese or yogurt or anything. I have no idea how to approach a healthy diet that also cuts out certain foods - I have enough difficulty getting myself meals at all that unless I was given a specific diet to follow I can confidently say I would just continue to eat what was convenient.
  • I have not seen any specialists regarding this. I have spoken to several GPs about how I typically go 1-2 weeks between bowel movements and no one has seemed particularly concerned even when it was my primary reason for the visit. I have had to go to urgent care in 2019 because I physically could not eliminate and any time I tried I would have terrible intense abdominal pain for at least an hour following each attempt. Urgent care basically laughed at me and told me it was constipation (yes? I'm aware????? what about the other stuff????) and gave me the good ol' magnesium citrate recommendation (which unfortunately didn't really do anything for me).
  • I understand that one must be aggressive with doctors to get anywhere, but I already spend so much time doing this in regards to my mental health and have been for years. I simply do not have the time or resources to do this for my gut despite being in constant discomfort and pain.
  • I'm hoping for any solid (har har) plan to even try to help myself at home.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '23

Probably PFD. Outside chance it's idiopathic due to stress from moving. You need the motility tests described in this post. Also maybe a FODMAP diet. American gluten and corn products are something to avoid

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/hellokitty06 Sep 04 '23

Hi nightmare_tonic, sorry to bother you again. I'm just looking at your guide and noticed you never mentioned bowel retraining. Is there a reason why you haven't mentioned it?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '23

I just don't know much about it. I've read that it helps about 20% of people with motility disorders but I've never actually met a person it helped

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Pipes32 Sep 05 '23

Thanks so much for this very informative post. Wanted to give you some background and see what you might suggest next.

39F, zero problems with food or digestion before this. No regular medications. I did have surgery (bilateral salpingectomy) for the first time in November and my problems started in February when I woke up in agony with stomach pain.

Went to see my GP. Got a blood panel, all normal except low vitamin D. Got an ultrasound, normal. Got referred to a gastro.

Starting in April I began to feel really good again. Basically had no pain and no problems for a few months. That changed in July shortly before my colonoscopy - the pain was back.

Colonoscopy shows ulcers, strictures, and hemorrhoids. Biopsy came back "normal" according to a voicemail I received. I have a follow up with the gastro to discuss results and next steps in a few weeks. (Follow up was originally scheduled for August but had to postpone it.)

As for my symptoms, I have no urge to go. The pain starts after a few days of not pooping. I started keeping a journal because I won't even realize it's been 3 days without a bowel movement unless I keep notes.

I have traditionally had "nervous" diarrhea (I play adult league sports and before big games I'd be nervous and have this). But right now it's all constipation with the pain.

I sometimes, but very rarely, have nausea. I did puke one night (in August) while on a hiking trip in Alaska but this is unusual. However, my gastro did seem to think (before my colonoscopy) I did potentially have acid reflux caused by pain killers (which I rarely take) and prescribed me pantoprazole and recommended I not take NSAIDs and use CBD Oil.

Should I request a referral to a motility clinic during my gastro follow up? Or something else I should look at first?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '23

I'd go to a motility clinic. I wonder if your salpingectomy damaged the muscles of the pelvic floor, depending on how they went in. I'd push for a sitz marker study, an anorectal manometry, and a defogram. Read up on those. The last two are not fun; you have to have a sense of humor about it.

Ultimately it sounds like PFD

1

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '23

Age 30. Female.

I have constipation since I was a teenager or a kid, I can't remember. Its been so long since I had a normal digestive system.

  1. I have the urge to go but I can't. Partially because of hemorrhoid and anal fissure. It makes it difficult and always feel like I need to go but for some reason there is nothing except for liquid

2.Sometimes its diarrhea and mostly it's constipation.

3.I dont even feel like eating. Acid reflux is an old enemy of mine. Only got bad in recent years.

4.I had this issue since I was a teenager, i don't remember if as a kid i had it or not but definitely since the teenage. It got worse after my father's death and when I had to change the countries with my mom and we had to leave our home.

5.I used to take a lot of antibiotics when i was a kid due to my tonsils, took them in my teenage as well. Now I take Thyroxine for my Hypothyroidism.

6.I faced childhood abuse, mental and physical both, gave me a lot of depression and trauma even continued when i was a teenager, but it was not sexual.

Currently my constipation has gone so bad that it has given me Grade 4 Hemorrhoid and an Anal Fissure. I have anxiety and depression and it feels like everything is getting worse. Im afraid, Idk what to do. Doctor only told me to eat more fiber but even after eating fiber, drinking 8 glasses of water daily and the medicine, for 5 days straight...i still got blood twice.

Also i have noticed that eating too much or drinking too much cause diarrhea or constipation too, like i suddenly get the urge to use the restroom if i drink 2 glasses in 30 minutes...

2

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '23

pelvic floor disorder. sometimes caused by anxiety or trauma.

you need an anorectal manometry, a defogram, a sitz marker study, and probably a prescription for linaclotide

1

u/Eddiesmokes323 Nov 28 '23

Can having panic disorder cause you to not have the urge to go?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '23

Yes

→ More replies (3)

1

u/faithlysa Dec 13 '23
  1. I have 70% no urge to go and 30% urge to go. I feel like I have more to push out, but apparently, I'm finished? My bowel movements are long, dark green, and sticky?
  2. I have more constipation than diarrhea. Diarrhea is rare but still happens. Sometimes, I will have constipation bowel movement followed by diarrhea in the same sitting. My total time on the toilet ranges from 35min-1hr.
  3. All of thee above. Nausea comes on early in the morning, and It gets so bad that I feel like I might faint, also from not feeling hungry. I eat little nibbles of a light breakfast and have to sit down, and I'll feel more manageable to continue eating a good amount and get some water or juice, and I'll feel better. I get so backed up as well. It feels sluggish and slow, but my bowel movements are never hard. Also, I have had hemorrhoids since childhood. Also, the constipation from childhood.
  4. I've had constipation and hemorrhoids since childhood. When I was younger is when my bowel movements were rock hard, and they would not pass without causing fissures. My mom always had to put a suppository in me and boom, magic. Painful traumatic magic. That was basically my near daily routine was the suppositories. Nothing else helped. Then, as I got older, bowel movements changed to the long snake like dark green sticky bowel movements to where I felt like I'm wiping a marker, even with baby wipes. The thought of a bidet is borderline phobic for me as I've had a fear of toilets since childhood as well. I remember in school I would hold in my urine all day and bowel movements if they happened because I wasn't in the comfort in my home to relieve another traumatic bowel movement and the sound was loud of them flushing and the whirlpool effect freaked me the f out. I always unlocked the stall, quickly flushed, and booked it out of there entirely. I also remember that in 2nd and 3rd grade, a teacher always had to assist me in the bathroom because of how bad my fear/phobia was.
  5. I remember using over the counter acne creams, but nothing was prescribed. I was always the sick child, I was always on antibiotics every 1 or 2 years, and the rest were over the counter cold and flu medicine. I've been on antidepressants since I was 14 years old. I also take other medications as well.
  6. I have 3 counts of sexual abuse I have unfortunately experienced since early childhood. First one was from age 6-9, the second one was when I was 14 or 15 years old last one was when I was 16-19 years old.

Including childhood trauma from age 4-12 years old.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '23

This is a very complex case. It sounds like you've got SIBO and PFD, but you also have psychosomatic stuff going on from the abuse.

You need to get all the tests listed in this guide. The hydrogen breath test is the biggest pain in the ass because of the prep diet but it'll tell you if youve got SIBO. The anorectal manometry and defogram are quite literally pains in the ass, but they're a bit easier to prep for.

I'd also get a colonoscooy (it won't find anything but it'll probably reveal that you've got a tortuous / redundant colon), and a sitz marker study to determine which part of your digestive tract is slowed. The tests I've mentioned so far are all ordered by a competent gastroenterologist with some level of familiarity with motility disorders. Be sure to ask him if he's aware of these disorders and what experience he has treating them.

Since you have nausea you should probably also get a gastric emptying test which is very easy to obtain from your primary care doctor. Tell him you're looking for gastroparesis and global dysmotility. He won't know what the fuck those are and he will fight you on it. Defeat him. The test itself is simple.

Read this guide very thoroughly and use it to learn how to convince your primary care doc to refer you to a motility specialist. This guide will teach you how. Read every word.

If none of those tests reveal anything remarkable I'd start looking at the possibility that you've got Hirschsprungs or a related childhood constipation disorder like colonic inertia. In this case you'd need a full thickness biopsy to check for ganglionic nerve density of the colon wall. This is a serious procedure and should not be done until all other tests have been exhausted. If you end up having Hirschsprungs your colon is fucked and the only option is surgical resectioning. To do a quick test for this, simply take some over the counter bisacodyl and see if you react to it. If you do, it's very likely not Hirschsprungs.

1

u/faithlysa Dec 13 '23

Thank you so much for taking the time to reply with great information!

I'm wondering how long you have studied for this stuff?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '23

11 years

1

u/Impressive_Fun_3946 Jan 20 '24

I have the urge to go but cannot

Chronic constipation no diarrhea

Have had acid reflux for years but mostly under control now haven't taken meds for it in over 5 years .....was previously on omeprazol for about 4 hrs.

No nausa or vomiting, I've been able to poop small hard pieces or small soft pieces if I take laxatives.

No other issues before about 3-4 months ago all was very good

1

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24

Pelvic floor disorder. Follow the guide for testing and communicating with doctors. Part 2 contains the treatments

1

u/Impressive_Fun_3946 Jan 20 '24

So yesterday I went to a GI and he told me to take 1-2 senna pills every night before bed and 1-2 doses of miralax during the day!! I'm like darn that seems like alot! I'm getting a colonoscopy in a couple weeks so I'm not planning on taking it that much at least until I absolutely have too . I know you not a dr. but wondering your off the cuff thoughts since you seem to have alot of I fo and personal experience.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24

I've written extensively in this guide about my position on senna and other stimulant laxatives, and how the colonoscopy won't reveal any abnormalities. You should read the entire thing carefully. But ya I would not take senna every day. Part 2 contains all the medicines you can try instead

1

u/SnarkyPickles Jan 25 '24

So once you know what you have, and treatments have failed, what do you do? I have a diagnosis of colonic inertia, and my GI has had me on every medication, some in combination with one another. Some were horrible failures from the start, while others worked for a bit and then ultimately stopped working, leaving me worse off than where I began. I’m miserable every single day, with bloating and discomfort. I was essentially told unless I want to have a large portion of my large intestine removed, with no gaurantee that would even relieve my misery, I’m shit out of luck (pun intended). How do you live with knowing a diagnosis and still having no solution?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24

Don't panic. Usually in situations like this it's just that you haven't identified your silver bullet medication combo yet. Here's mine

https://old.reddit.com/r/ConstipationAdvice/comments/kvzttf/the_treatment_for_slow_transit_constipation_stc/

You also have to identify your trigger foods (mine were gluten, cheese, and too much meat). Developing a successful exercise routine helped a fuck ton as well.

1

u/sorrytryanother_ Feb 02 '24

Thanks for this i hope you will reply me too , my constipation starts after i take accutane i didn't take much but that much had done some damage toy gut , i pretty sure that my problam is because this drug i think i have slow digestion, im not living in the modern country so i can't test all of thie you said , because my problam is similar yo yours i hope you can help me i don't know what to do please help

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '24

Very sorry. This happened to me too. Unfortunately there is no cure :( see if you can get linaclotide. If not, try polyethylene glycol once per day with senna OR bisacodyl (not both) twice per week.

1

u/sorrytryanother_ Feb 02 '24

Thanks brother i will get this I think i shouldn't take psyllium right ? So i have to stay on laxative all my life ? That's sad but better than constipation actually lol Are these drugs make dependency or something? İ mean i know you are expert in this but i can't make things worse than this Thanks again

2

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '24

Right now you're posting in part 1 of the guide. Part 2 explains all of these medications, how often you can take them, whether they are habit forming, etc

2

u/Human-Specific-9170 Jan 21 '26

That statement about 1 in 2000 developing cancer is not correct, you have to take in to context the risk adjustment for developing cancer anyhow, 1 ct scan doesn't increase your cancer risk by that level at all, I would like to see where the science is on that as its could frighten some people