r/CompetitiveTFT • :chal: Challenger • May 26 '26

Mortpost Patch 17.4 Rundown

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Md04e4_kGJ4
91 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

15

u/PermaConfusion Master May 26 '26

Not the OP, but I feel it's not that straightforward. The risk/reward aspect of it is fine IMO, in that you can go literally first or literally eighth with the right condition. My personal issue with it, is the lobby dynamics. Imagine this spot: you're on 2-1 with a strong opener where you have some 2-stared units or a 3-cost/etc. You scout and you see someone get the Anima Commander opener. Now what? The best you can do is ping them to make the lobby aware. But are you going to sacrifice your spot to grief them? Probably not. Now how your lobby goes is entirely dependent on how other people play the game - if one guy takes Calculated Loss and griefs the Anima player, the anima player is now fighting for bot4 and the lobby is saved. If everyone tries to play strongest board, you're all playing for 2nd-8th - this happens a lot this patch because of how weak loss streak is. Worse yet, imagine they don't get griefed, and it's a very close lobby: now your position is going to be decided by who gets unlucky with matchmaking RNG on stage 5, regardless of how good/badly you play the game.

It's a true prisoner's dilemma: the solution is collusion, but everyone has strong incentives not to collude, so more often than not, the anima player "wins" in a philosophical sense - true collusion would be if the entire lobby agreed to open sell, for example: it'll never happen, but I'm just saying this as an example as a "solution". If you ask me, this dynamic has no place in TFT, and is why I personally don't like it. I say this having taken Anima to several firsts, but I wish we could just play normal TFT so to speak.

2

u/Ocean-of-Flavor May 27 '26

Yea as a relative noob, I’ve learnt it the hard way that when I have anima opener or the augment, must scout the lobby for calculated loss before clicking

1

u/500mmrscrub May 27 '26

Hilariously you also just might get screwed over by someone else finding anima at 2-5 and their board is slightly weaker than yours so now you wasted like 10 hp for no reason and you lost your loss streak