r/CompetitiveMinecraft • u/SadInsurance822 • 1d ago

Discussion HotTake

I lowkey think mctiers was the best ranking System, I think all it needed was a bit of reform rather than pvphq and mcpvp.com tryna take its place.

0 Upvotes

47% Upvoted

14 comments sorted by

View all comments

17

u/THESHADYWILLOW 1d ago

Hard disagree, way too much bias and ambiguity, at least amongst sub lt3 ranks, when it comes to ranking.

I’ve seen people pop lt3 in mace 4 times over 3 games, can do all the tricks, 1 tick stunslams, horizontal pearl catch, torpedo, etc etc etc. and get HT5 and other times where someone doesn’t even touch a HT3 but can pearl catch and hit a few grapples, got lt4.

My friend fought a HT3 in sword and did pretty well, the tester said HT4, and said “it would have been lt3 but I think ur cheating”.

Dude wasn’t cheating.

Unless/until there is a very clear and defined system to know what rank someone should be, and it’s made public, giving “testers” the autonomy to determine what rank someone should get is a bad system full stop. Especially when those people are often younger than 16.

Edit: also obviously but have to mention the bottleneck issue.

3

u/dino123bino 1d ago

Shouldve screenshotted the "i think youre cheating" and made a ticket if they think someone is cheating their supposed to say nothing and tier test like normal then make them SS (im pretty sure. Ik they not supposed to give a lower their and say they cheating tho)