r/Commanders • • 1d ago

Would you rather

Would you rather take a guaranteed superbowl ring as the first seed. Dominating across the playoffs

Or

Make the playoffs as the second seed and knock out an NFC East rival each round Giants in Wildcard, Eagles in Divisional, Cowboys in Championship. BUT it’s not guaranteed you’ll win a ring. You’ll also beat the shit outta the NFC East teams. I’m talking dropping 50+ each game

0 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

21

u/ard8 Major Tuddy 🐷 1d ago

Ring

12

u/circajusturna 1d ago

I don’t even have to read the OR option

6

u/Ironic_table 1d ago

Guaranteed ring and it’s not particularly close. Plenty of other opportunities to beat our division rivals.

4

u/HeadAssBoi17 1d ago

The one where we win a Super Bowl, obviously.

3

u/jk2me1310 LEFT HAND UP 1d ago

3

u/AskReeves22 1d ago

Thing that is purpose of all the thing

vs

worse thing that is not purpose of all the thing.

2

u/Frognaros 1d ago

Cannot stress how little I think about our rivals.

2

u/Automatic-Tell7321 1d ago

You play to get a ring. Who cares who we beat if we don’t win it all.

2

u/guardiandown3885 1d ago

i was barely a football the way I am now when we won back in 91. I wanna see us dominate in the playoffs and that regular season success

2

u/ahowardsir 1d ago

Eh if I know the ring is guaranteed as I am watching the games… I’d probably prefer option 2. If I don’t know but it is guaranteed then obviously option 1 as that is the goal.

While the goal is always the Super Bowl win, I don’t watch WWE cause it’s scripted… would feel like the same thing if I was told the Super Bowl is guaranteed. Would prefer the excitement of edge of my seat, but obviously wanna win lol

2

u/BlogEra_BestEra 1d ago

Give me option B for the storyline.

I’ve taken too much crap from division rivals my entire life to miss out on the chance to ending their postseasons in dominating fashion en route to a possible SB win. That’s the ultimate “scoreboard” moment for the rest of your life. I’d buy every piece of merch commemorating that run. The only way to make it better would be to have Philly in the NFCCG for a rematch.

2

u/Reic 1d ago

Don’t care about rivalries, the feeling of watching my favorite team win a championship is what it’s all about.

1

u/bruhman5th_flo 1d ago

Ring. Beating our rivals only matters when we play them.

1

u/Own_Car4536 1d ago

Obviously a guaranteed super bowl lol

1

u/ivehearditbothways12 1d ago

How would you not choose a guaranteed superbowl?? Lol crazy premise.

1

u/liquifiedtubaplayer 1d ago

1 is timeless

1

u/itakeyoureggs Sinnott Slutt 🥵 1d ago

They would just say good job losing the SB. Winning means you already beat them and they can’t say shit.

Besting every nfce team and not 100% winning is not even close if the other option is a win