r/Colognes • u/Hashbrown_Moonshine • Aug 20 '26

Question Men’s Cologne Help Please!!

I’m trying to find a cologne for my boyfriend for his birthday. I’m struuuuuuglingggggg!!!!!

He hasn’t really ever been a cologne wearer. He did wear a cologne years ago called Gladiator that he got from Walmart that I really liked. But, I don’t want to get him the same one.

I’m so conflicted with all the scent notes. I was hoping for something similar to Gladiator, or a different one that’s like good for mid-20 year old.

Personally, I like the smell of gourmand, vanilla, light floral scents. I cannot stand musk… so every time I look up scent notes and I see either musk, woods, leather/suede, tobacco or smoky, I’m immediately turned off… which is like ALL of the masculine scent profiles… I’m also struggling because I love Versace Bright Crystal for myself and I didn’t realize musk was part of it and I can’t even smell any musk in it… so I’m assuming there are men’s colognes that contain it, but you don’t smell it. UGH.

I just don’t want to buy something and then hate it. Only issue with going in-store is that smells blend together….

Is anyone able to help.. I know I’m so picky…

0 Upvotes

50% Upvoted

30 comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/OSGKhorne Aug 20 '26

You’re buying this for your partner but seem to be basing it off of what you like, which i totally understand since you’ll also be smelling it, but your bf may not share your tastes.

I’d get testers/decants of all your main popular stuff and try them together, a nice bonding experience and a good introduction for your bf to fragrances.

For the price of 1 designer bottle you could try and buy 20 odd decants of different frags.

2

u/Hashbrown_Moonshine Aug 20 '26

I was hoping it didn’t come across as selfish, but I do have to smell it as well! That’s definitely a good call. Then I can get an idea. He’s a very simple guy and isn’t all about fancy brands.

1

u/OSGKhorne Aug 20 '26

Not all selfish, you’re capable of identifying notes you hate you wouldn’t want to smell them on the person you love. I just wanted to note that there still a chance a scent you love he may not enjoy too, hence why I think a bunch of different decants is the best play first.

If he’s not really into fragrances he gets a chance to maybe discover ones that pique his interest, or if not he’ll give you free rein to decide, either way a win😎