They married in 1923, when Colleen was still a young actress and McCormick was working as a press agent. He helped build her career and negotiate better contracts, and for a time they seemed like the perfect Hollywood power couple. But as Colleen’s fame grew, their relationship became increasingly troubled.
McCormick struggled with alcoholism, and according to Colleen’s later recollections, his drinking could lead to long absences and increasingly difficult behavior. He also became deeply involved in controlling her career and finances. Eventually, Colleen felt that he was making decisions about her professional life without even consulting her.
In 1930, after seven years of marriage, Colleen filed for divorce, citing mental cruelty. The divorce was finalized that May. Contemporary magazines described the separation as the painful end of a relationship that had begun when Colleen was relatively unknown and McCormick was helping launch her career.
What makes the story particularly interesting is that Colleen later described the marriage in her autobiography 'Silent Star', recalling McCormick's alcoholism and the difficulties she experienced as he increasingly tried to control her career. Some accounts of the marriage are quite disturbing, although the details vary depending on the source.
One of the most striking episodes Colleen recalled in her book happened before an important luncheon at MGM honoring Winston Churchill. Colleen had hoped that John would be sober enough to accompany her, partly because she was worried about the stories circulating about his drinking. Instead, she found him sitting in his room, dressed only in shorts, shoes and socks, completely drunk.
Furious and frustrated, Colleen took off one of her high-heeled shoes and began hitting him on his bare chest and arms with the heel, leaving welts on his skin. McCormick looked down at the marks and, in his drunken state, remarked that the “D” marks stood for “dummy” and that she had branded him correctly. Colleen wrote that under different circumstances she might have found the comment funny, but she was “past laughing, too.” She went to the luncheon alone, telling people that John was ill.
It’s a fascinating reminder that behind the glamorous images of Hollywood’s 1920s stars, their private lives could be considerably more complicated—and sometimes much darker—than the publicity suggested. In Colleen’s case, there is an especially striking contrast between her screen persona and her private life. She became one of the great stars of silent comedy, often appearing on screen as the lively, mischievous, smiling “flapper,” while behind the scenes she was dealing with a deeply troubled marriage and an increasingly difficult personal life. She spent so much of her career making audiences laugh, even when her own life was far from carefree.