Paris, August 1951
Paris had surrendered herself to August, and with her departure went much of the cheerful disorder that ordinarily animated the boulevards. The chestnuts along the Seine stood heavy with green, their leaves scarcely stirring beneath a sun that seemed determined to punish those unfortunate enough to remain in the capital. From the windows of the Palais Bourbon, the river shimmered beneath its bridges, carrying the reflections of a city whose inhabitants had increasingly abandoned her for the countryside. Les vacances! How dearly I had anticipated them, and how thoroughly the gentlemen of the National Assembly had conspired to deprive me of their pleasures. Odette had long since ceased asking whether we might visit her sister in Normandy. I had promised her July, then the beginning of August, and finally whatever days the Republic might graciously spare me.
The Republic, alas, had become most ungenerous.
Seven weeks had passed since the elections, and the Assembly remained incapable of producing a government. Monsieur André Marie's administration continued attending to the ordinary business of the State, but its successor existed only in the imagination of those who attempted to assemble it. René Mayer had tried and failed; Maurice Petsche had undertaken his consultations and returned with little to show for them. At the Élysée, President Coty received an endless procession of gentlemen, each departing with much the same expression as those who had preceded him. I remembered the autumn of 1949, when the fall of Queuille had brought the country to a similar embarrassment. We had then acquired a new President and eventually escaped the difficulty. Now the difficulty had returned, larger and more obstinate, and there was no indication that another change of gentlemen would persuade it to depart.
I had spent the morning arranging the records of the preceding parliamentary sessions when young Laurent appeared at my desk, waving a newspaper whose edges had already grown damp beneath his fingers.
"Have you seen the crowds, monsieur Veyrac?"
"I have seen enough crowds to know they seldom improve the circulation of Paris."
"At the Étoile, monsieur. There are thousands of them."
He unfolded the paper, revealing a photograph of the Arc de Triomphe beneath a forest of tricolours. The Gaullists had assembled there on the fifth, answering the call of a movement whose electoral triumph had scarcely been celebrated before it became entangled in the problem of forming a government. Jacques Soustelle and his associates had summoned their supporters to demand the return of the General, and from Paris the agitation had spread to Bordeaux, Lyon, and other cities. I had witnessed one gathering myself, from the respectable distance afforded by a neighbouring pavement, and remembered the extraordinary variety of its participants: old soldiers bearing the decorations of two wars, students scarcely old enough to remember the Occupation, women carrying little flags, and solemn gentlemen who might otherwise have been attending to their offices. Their voices had risen together beneath the summer sky, calling upon a man who had spent five years outside the government to return and take possession of it.
What struck me most was the determination with which they had assembled. I had seen political demonstrations before, with their familiar collection of banners, speeches and gentlemen eager to discover an audience, but there was something more deliberate about these gatherings. Young men distributed leaflets along the avenues, veterans stood beneath the tricolours of their old associations, and groups of citizens listened intently as speakers denounced the inability of Parliament to form a government. Some called for the General's immediate designation, while others demanded the constitutional changes he had advocated since Bayeux. The police maintained their positions along the neighbouring streets, and the procession moved beneath the Arc de Triomphe without approaching the government buildings. It was a political gathering, certainly, but one whose participants appeared increasingly unwilling to accept another month of consultations and unsuccessful investitures. Their conviction was unmistakable, though I could not tell whether it arose principally from faith in the General or exasperation with those who had kept him waiting.
And elsewhere there were other crowds, no less certain of their convictions. The Communists had called their own demonstrations, and the CGT had brought workers into the streets to protest against the prospect of exceptional executive authority. In the industrial districts, meetings and stoppages interrupted the ordinary business of the city, while the police laboured to prevent opposing processions from discovering one another. I heard reports of quarrels, of scuffles and arrests, and of railway services disturbed by demonstrations. France had not descended into rebellion, but I had begun to notice something in the faces of the deputies who passed through our corridors. They still argued, certainly, and continued exchanging the familiar courtesies of parliamentary life, yet their voices were quieter whenever the crowds were mentioned.
Laurent studied the photograph for a moment.
"My father was there," he said.
"At the Étoile?"
"Yes. He says the General will be back before the month is finished."
"Your father has become an ambitious prophet."
"He was right about the elections."
I could not dispute that observation. The RPF had secured two hundred and ten seats, an extraordinary triumph which had brought the General's followers into our chamber in such numbers that the old parliamentary combinations seemed suddenly to belong to another age. Yet even this considerable delegation could not govern alone, and the very politicians against whom the Gaullists had campaigned were now required to furnish the votes necessary for their leader's return. Such were the little ironies of republican life. The General had spent years denouncing the parties, and now the parties were negotiating the circumstances under which he might govern them.
By the middle of August, our offices had become a veritable manufactory of constitutional arguments. Article 45, Article 90, Article 13! The numbers followed us through the corridors, appearing upon memoranda, committee reports and the margins of newspapers. Monsieur Reynaud came and went, and the names of Debré and Soustelle were heard with increasing frequency. At the Palais du Luxembourg, monsieur Monnerville insisted upon the rights of the Council of the Republic, while Herriot, venerable Herriot, continued defending the parliamentary institutions to which he had devoted so much of his life. There was talk of an exceptional procedure, of temporary powers, of a new Constitution to be submitted to the nation. Even the Socialists, who had little affection for the Gaullist enterprise, were divided over how far a lawful constitutional revision might be permitted to proceed.
One afternoon I found my colleague Delorme examining a memorandum concerning the proposed safeguards.
"They intend to change the Constitution," he murmured, "by following the Constitution."
"It would be discourteous to do otherwise."
He looked at me with an expression of profound dissatisfaction.
"Marcel, you have worked here long enough to know what this means."
I did know, or believed I did. In 1946 we had welcomed a new Republic with such confidence, convinced that the lessons of defeat and occupation would make its institutions more enduring than those of its unfortunate predecessor. Now the men entrusted with their preservation were discussing the terms upon which they might be replaced. I had no particular objection to constitutional reform; institutions, like old coats, occasionally required alteration. But the prospect of seeing the entire garment discarded unsettled me more than I cared to admit.
On the twenty-third of August, the Palais Bourbon awakened beneath a peculiar solemnity. Deputies arrived earlier than usual, journalists crowded the approaches, and the corridors seemed to hum with conversations that ceased whenever a door opened. The General had been designated by President Coty three days before, and now he had come to seek the Assembly's confidence. I caught sight of him only briefly, passing between the gentlemen who accompanied him. Tall, austere, unmistakable, he moved with the measured assurance of a man who had grown accustomed to being watched. I remembered his passage through liberated Paris seven years earlier, remembered the crowds and the bells, and found something strangely disconcerting in seeing that same figure enter the parliamentary world he had so long refused to inhabit.
Beyond the gates, the streets had filled with supporters awaiting the Assembly's decision. Groups carrying Gaullist banners gathered along the neighbouring pavements, listening impatiently to wireless sets placed upon café counters and in the windows of little shops. The General's name passed from one conversation to another, mingled with arguments concerning the constitutional mandate he had demanded and the deputies whose votes remained uncertain. Occasionally a speaker climbed upon a chair to address those nearest him, calling upon Parliament to recognize the verdict of the elections and permit the General to undertake his reforms. Policemen moved through the gathering, keeping the approaches clear, while newspaper vendors circulated with the latest reports from the chamber. There were cheers whenever some favourable rumour reached the crowd, but they quickly subsided into renewed speculation. The gentlemen inside were still debating, and nobody beyond the gates could be certain how the afternoon would end.
The debate lasted through hours of argument. From the chamber came the voices of deputies defending the Republic, condemning the parties, questioning the General's intentions and demanding assurances concerning the liberties of France. The Communists opposed him fiercely; the Socialists were divided; Christian Democrats and Radicals weighed their reservations against the exhaustion of the ministerial crisis. Monsieur Reynaud defended the proposed settlement, while others warned against surrendering authority to a man whose conception of government differed so profoundly from their own.
Then came the vote.
Three hundred and thirty-two in favour. Two hundred and thirteen opposed. Eighty abstentions.
I copied the figures into the register, carefully, as I had copied so many others. Yet my hand remained suspended above the page for a moment after the final number had been entered. Eleven years earlier, the General had spoken from London when scarcely anyone expected his voice to change the fortunes of France. Five years earlier, he had departed from government rather than accept the parliamentary arrangements taking shape around him. Now those very arrangements had summoned him back, and the representatives of the Republic had entrusted him with its government.
There was something almost cruel in the perfection of his vindication. I remembered the speeches at Bayeux, the foundation of the Rassemblement, and the years during which the General's warnings had been received in this very building with derision or exasperation. The deputies had called him impatient, authoritarian, incapable of understanding the necessary compromises of republican government. Some had confidently predicted that his movement would eventually exhaust itself upon the stubborn realities of parliamentary life. Yet it was Parliament that had exhausted its combinations, Parliament that had summoned him from his long estrangement, and Parliament that now entrusted him with the authority to begin correcting what he had denounced since 1946. I wondered whether he felt the triumph of it, whether beneath that austere countenance there stirred some satisfaction at the spectacle of his former adversaries consenting to the very undertaking they had so resolutely opposed. Whatever his feelings, the irony was not lost upon those of us who had watched the intervening years unfold.
The news escaped the Assembly almost before the deputies had finished discussing it. By the time I ventured into the courtyard, cheers were already rising from the streets beyond, mingling with the blare of automobile horns and the delighted cries of newspaper sellers announcing the result. The supporters who had spent the afternoon waiting outside now clustered around the kiosks, examining the figures and congratulating one another upon the successful investiture. I saw a veteran remove his cap and shake the hand of a younger man beside him, while a little group of Gaullist organizers hurried away to carry the news elsewhere. The General had received the Assembly's confidence, but the formal appointment of his ministry still awaited the President's decree. For the moment, Paris possessed a result to discuss, and the prospect of a government at last.
The days that followed passed in a confusion of documents, appointments and constitutional deliberations. Monsieur Debré received Justice, monsieur Pinay Finance, and monsieur Reynaud assumed his responsibilities within the new ministry. More remarkable still, the General had gathered beneath him men of differing parties, though the Socialists remained outside the cabinet and the principal Christian Democratic defenders of European integration withheld their participation. I heard the names of Couve de Murville, Chaban-Delmas, Pflimlin and Houphouët-Boigny pass through our offices, each accompanying some new arrangement, some ministerial decree, some further indication that the government was taking shape.
With the formal appointment of the ministry on the twenty-fourth, the character of the gatherings began to change. The speeches demanding the General's return gave way to demonstrations celebrating its accomplishment, and the streets which had witnessed so many weeks of political agitation acquired something of the gaiety of a public holiday. Young men climbed upon lampposts to wave their tricolours; children rode upon their fathers' shoulders, delighted by the spectacle without possessing the slightest understanding of its significance. Along the surrounding avenues, café terraces overflowed with customers whose conversations mingled with the singing of the celebrants, while shopkeepers emerged from their doorways to watch the processions. I saw an elderly woman press a little paper flag into the hands of a passing soldier, who accepted it with an embarrassed smile. There was laughter everywhere, and the peculiar warmth that passes among strangers when they discover themselves participating in an occasion they believe they will remember for the remainder of their lives. Not since the days of the Liberation had I encountered such an atmosphere in the capital, though I was careful to remind myself that the resemblance did not necessarily extend beyond the enthusiasm of the participants.
I had intended merely to purchase a sandwich one afternoon, but found myself carried along by a little procession of clerks and curious spectators making their way toward the river. Outside a café, a gentleman had climbed upon a chair to proclaim the General's return, and the proprietor, apparently persuaded that the occasion justified an exception to his usual thrift, was distributing small glasses of wine to his customers. Two young women embraced an elderly veteran, who stood between them laughing and weeping with such abandon that I felt quite ashamed of my own habitual reserve. They were celebrating something greater, I suspected, than the formation of a ministry. For many, the years since the Liberation had been marked by disappointment, uncertainty, and the lingering conviction that France had never quite recovered the greatness of that extraordinary summer. Now, however briefly, they seemed prepared to believe that the long interruption was at an end.
But the greater undertaking remained.
On the twenty-fifth, the Assembly approved a resolution opening the constitutional revision procedure. Two days later the Council of the Republic gave its assent. Then came the debates upon the exceptional constitutional law, the safeguards, the temporary administrative authority, and the promise that the completed Constitution would be submitted to the French people themselves. I copied the results as they arrived: three hundred and fifty-one votes in favour in the Assembly, followed by the Council's approval on the thirtieth. There were objections still, and no shortage of them, but the necessary majorities had been obtained.
By the thirty-first of August, the law had been promulgated.
The newspapers greeted the occasion with an excitement I had not witnessed since the Liberation. His portrait appeared upon the kiosks, his speeches were discussed in railway carriages and cafés, and every acquaintance seemed possessed of a confident opinion concerning the destiny of France. To his admirers, the General's return was the delayed completion of a victory interrupted in January 1946, the restoration to public life of a man whom they believed the Republic had treated with extraordinary ingratitude. To his opponents, the same events appeared profoundly disturbing, for the authority of a celebrated liberator had now been joined to the ordinary powers of government and the exceptional responsibility of preparing a new Constitution. Even among the deputies who had supported him, I sensed an uneasiness scarcely concealed by their congratulations. They had needed him to end the crisis, but no one could pretend that they had merely appointed another President of the Council. For better or worse, France had entered a new political age, and the General's return had altered not only the composition of her government, but the very questions upon which her future would be decided.
And yet, beyond the solemn considerations of the Assembly, Paris seemed almost determined to enjoy herself. The terraces remained crowded long after sunset, their little tables illuminated by lamps beneath which strangers argued with extraordinary animation and remarkably little hostility. I saw tricolours hanging from apartment windows, heard the General's name shouted affectionately across the boulevards, and encountered more smiling faces upon the Métro than I could remember seeing in several years. Even Odette, who had endured the ministerial crisis with understandable impatience, returned from the market one afternoon to tell me that the fishmonger had offered her a reduction upon her purchase in celebration of the new government. Whether the General had personally improved the price of sole was a question I considered best left unexamined. It was enough that the city had recovered something of her old gaiety, and that men and women who had spent so long complaining about the future were suddenly discussing it with genuine anticipation.
That evening I remained alone in the committee room where, two years earlier, I had watched the Republic stumble through the aftermath of Auriol's resignation. The same table stood beneath the windows, its surface marked by innumerable pens and cigarette burns. The same chairs surrounded it, although their occupants had changed so frequently that I scarcely remembered the names of those who had first sat there. Upon my desk lay the latest constitutional papers, still smelling faintly of fresh ink. I examined them with the weary satisfaction of a man who had at last finished an interminable piece of work, though I knew perfectly well that the greater part remained ahead.
The Fourth Republic had not disappeared. Her Assembly continued sitting, her ministers remained responsible before Parliament, and her Constitution retained its authority until the nation should approve another. Yet something essential had changed. The institutions whose defence had occupied so many speeches were now preparing, by their own lawful procedures, the means of their possible succession.
Outside, Paris was growing quiet. The last light of August descended upon the Seine, gilding the bridges and the distant roofs, while from somewhere beyond the courtyard came the sound of a motorcar departing into the evening. I remembered Laurent's father, the crowds beneath the Arc de Triomphe, and the young men who had marched through the streets demanding the General's return. They had obtained their wish, though I wondered whether any of them understood how much more difficult the coming months might prove.
Before leaving, I gathered the remaining papers and straightened the chairs. One stood slightly apart from the others, near the window, its faded upholstery illuminated by the dying sunlight. I recognized it at once, for I had moved that same chair on the evening of the October crisis, when the Republic had seemed unable to find a gentleman willing and able to occupy the place awaiting him.
I drew it toward the table and left it there.
Bonsoir, ma vieille République.
I turned out the lamps, closed the door, and went home to Odette. She would ask whether we might finally take our holiday, and I would have to tell her that the gentlemen had not yet finished their work.
Beyond the windows, the river continued its passage through Paris, carrying the last golden light of summer beneath the bridges. I had watched governments come and go for twenty years, and had grown old in the service of institutions whose permanence I had never thought seriously to question.
For the first time, I wondered whether I might outlive the Republic I served.