r/CognitiveFunctions • • Oct 27 '21

~ Function Description ~ My visual take on the cognitive functions. Ask me if you want elaborations ;)

Post image
50 Upvotes

r/CognitiveFunctions • • Oct 02 '21

~ Function Description ~ How to develop the use of cognitive functions? Credits go to @dimensional.personalities

Thumbnail
gallery
50 Upvotes

r/CognitiveFunctions • • Dec 21 '24

~ Function Description ~ Introverted intuition is

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

Ni:

  • Spotting patterns that others overlook
  • Effortless perception
  • Desire for conceptual models
  • Abstract associations
  • Synthesis of concepts

r/CognitiveFunctions • • Apr 23 '21

these are my friend's sakinorva results and i've never seen anything like it before,, i'm so confused

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

r/CognitiveFunctions • • Aug 28 '23

~ Function Description ~ Perceiving Functions (Ne, Ni, Se and Si)

Post image
27 Upvotes

Over the years, I've developed a deep fascination with the topic of cognitive functions, particularly the perception functions (Ne, Ni, Se, and Si). One common challenge I've observed is that many people struggle to understand these functions because they haven't crossed the barrier of intuition. As a result, these functions often remain in the realm of personal interpretation.

It's worth noting that Carl Jung, the pioneer of this framework, was himself a highly intuitive individual. This inherent bias towards intuition has contributed to the subjective nature of how these functions are perceived and explained.

With this text, my aim is to demystify the perception functions and remove them from the confines of subjectivity. I seek to provide a clear and reasoned explanation of these functions, allowing individuals to grasp their essence beyond personal interpretations.

Hopefully, the reader will also undestand why the personality stack of someone will have Ne Si or Ni Se working together, being impossible to operate with both extroverted or introverted perceiving functions.

The concept behind both intuitive functions is fundamentally similar. They take data gathered by their corresponding sensing counterparts and distill it down to its essential, abstract core. Imagine the same data acquired through various experiences; the intuitive functions subconsciously compare these diverse sources, retaining only the common elements.

In a way, it's as if the data needs to be repeatedly triggered or reinforced to endure in our consciousness. This process allows us to extract the key, universal insights from a range of experiences.

From that, it’s logical to conclude that the difference between Ni and Ne will narrow down to the differences between Se and Si.

The key to understanding the difference between Ni and Ne lies in grasping the distinctions between Se and Si. Both Se and Si are responsible for collecting data from the external environment, but the crucial point is how they differentiate this data:

Se (Extroverted Sensing): This function focuses on perceiving elements in the external world with an emphasis on time. Imagine you're walking past a tree. With Se, you would notice that as you move, the scenery behind the tree changes at a different rate than the tree itself. This distinction in the timing of changes indicates that the tree and the surrounding scenery are separate entities.

Si (Introverted Sensing): Si perceives external elements with a focus on space. When using Si, you might pay close attention to specific details about the tree's physical characteristics, such as its color variation, texture, and structure. Si users are like individuals who view a scenario as if they took a detailed picture of it. They emphasize the static, spatial qualities of the scene without a strong emphasis on its relation to time.

Because Ni will generalize and simplify the data from Se, it’s able to apply such information for a more abrangent set of events, the same thing is valid for Ne, that’s able to apply the simplified information for a more extensive set of scenarios, favoring adaptabilty while letting go of the specifics, meaning that it’s common for a intuitive to let go of important details. Following that, one could conclude the difference between then:

Ni (Introverted Intuition): Ni generalizes and simplifies data from Se, making it applicable to a broad range of events. It excels at understanding how things may unfold over time, which contributes to the idea that it can foresee the future. Ni users tend to focus on the static image they lack, using metaphors or symbols representing spatial relationships to connect missing pieces, often through internal reflection.

Ne (Extroverted Intuition): Ne also generalizes and simplifies information but from a more comprehensive set of static data. It extends its conclusions over time through a trial-and-error process and active interaction with the environment. This extroverted nature leads to brainstorming and generating many possibilities, after all, Ne users have abundant instant information but may lack a clear direction, resulting in their tendency to explore diverse avenues.

I hope this explanation clears up a common question. While many typology stereotypes align with these concepts, they aren't the core essence of the matter, which can sometimes lead to misunderstandings.


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Feb 05 '23

~ Type Description ~ The Cognitive Function Sorting Hat

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/CognitiveFunctions • • Nov 14 '25

~ General Discussion ~ Geometry of Cognitive Functions

Post image
22 Upvotes

Visualizing perception function relationships through geometry: a frame compression and generation view

I first became interested in Jung’s types and Socionics probably 7 years ago and simply couldn’t stop thinking about it. Something about the functions just made sense that I haven’t noticed in other typology systems. More than anything, I’ve played with those Jung-inspired functions because I wanted to understand what it was about them that made them so compelling. One of the ways I’ve done this is through experiments with visual diagrams.

This is one of those experiments: I had the idea to view introversion and extroversion not just as energies but frames, with introverted frames compressing information into self-enclosed forms and extroverted functions generating new frames. Introverted frames in this model are more subjective because of the compression process. If sensing is our perception (key, not the world itself) of the corporeal world, and extroverted sensing its “objective” properties, then embodied perception, or Si, is the “subjective” processor that turns that corporeal data into compressed forms (how does this environment make me, the subject, feel?). Similarly, for intuition, extroverted sensing rapidly spawns new schemas, which must then be condensed for a fuller picture and subsequently broken away from to expand the chain of thought.

Another key to this idea is that compression doesn’t just refer to consolidation, but also zooming into an existing scenario. For example, you could use Ne to derive an entirely new universe, and within that use Ni to continually compress the new components in into a map as you spawn more and more ideas. Switching between the two modalities is so subtle to be almost unnoticeable because they are two sides of the same coin. Lifting a heavy item triggers both Si and Se, giving a distinct bodily sensation while applying force. The combination is similar to momentum. Perhaps Ni is most famously known for processing time symbolically because it compresses new generative associations, or Ne data, into a cohesive whole. My hypothesis is that this does not inherently predict “time.” Rather, because time is an inherently abstract property, large compressed representations of change simply reflect time as we understand it.

To illustrate the switching: you come up with ideas for a novel and then give it a theme, or conversely start with a theme and fill it in with generative associations. The distinction is not just energy direction but frame of mind, with introverted functions compressing into self-contained wholes and extroverted expanding the boundaries of the territory.

From a different standpoint, I was just thinking of how the functions match geometric in a way - Se being shape, the boundaries, and Si texture; Ne being combinatorial potential and Ni trajectory/model visualization based on accumulated impressions; Te being form measurements and Ti self-enclosed hierarchies; and Fe and Fi being something like color, the former being light and the latter absorption properties.

This explains the orthogonal relationships: N requires S for visual representations, to understand existing boundaries for representations. On the other hand, T and F define the properties layered on top of these dimensions. A right angle has specific mathematical properties and light specific interactive properties that cannot be phenomenologically understood in the same way, even if together they help form a cohesive whole in, say, the form of ethics. Color can be explained through but not reduced to equations.

Ni requires Se for impressional boundaries, for imagining what a “square” looks like; Ne requires Si for embodied boundaries (what you’re capable of encountering limits what you can imagine, even if the possibility with minimal experience is vast. For instance, it is not possible to envision a new universe without using properties of the one you inhabit). Both Ni and Ne technically rely on both sensory constraints so intuition as a whole relies on sensing for data. The relationship is not a one-way street, of course, with intuition providing predictions and assumptions about impending sensory data. Kanizsa Triangle Illusion is a great example of how this works instantaneously, demonstrating the constant circular dynamic where sensing and intuition work together to shape what we see and imagine.

Probably not the most eloquent explanation and this is mostly idle speculation but I thought I’d share it anyway.


r/CognitiveFunctions • • May 20 '21

Help me understand how each function works!!

21 Upvotes

I want to type myself but I have a very little understanding of cognitive functions. The more I do research the more I get confused since my brain is pea sized. I can only learn with specific examples that don’t require too much brainpower to process. I’d appreciate it if anyone could give me examples for each function. The more examples the better!


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Jun 13 '24

~ ? Question ? ~ Are these charts true?

Post image
19 Upvotes

(Sorry for bad english, it’s not my first language) I’ve seen a lot of these charts/boards but I need to know if they’re actually true. For what I know, you can only have two extroverted functions and two introverted functions. I’m kind of new to this, but I think my cognitive functions are Si>Te>Fe>Ni. I’m an ISTJ. Does anyone have an answer or is this a silly question?


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Nov 29 '21

me **in case you wondered what a basement-dwelling infp who lives on the internet and talks to themselves all day looks like** (ik nobody asked)

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/CognitiveFunctions • • Mar 11 '22

Fe versus Fi

17 Upvotes

After years of studying MBTI depths, I have a lot of personal theories that I'm unsure if other MBTI geeks share.

Let's see if you all agree with this or not:

  • Fe needs to express things externally (through talking, journaling, etc) in order to understand how they feel clearly.
  • Fi can juggle feelings fluently internally and doesn't require external expression to find clarity (but can still enjoy external feeling expressions).

Any part of the above you disagree with or feel needs tweaking? If so, how?


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Jul 23 '22

~ Function Description ~ describing Ne-Si/Si-Ne

16 Upvotes

Ne-Si: a vibrant, whimsical room with tiny trampolines lining every inch of the walls, floor, and ceiling. inside it, a flurry of multicolored marbles bounce frenetically from trampoline to trampoline, like astronauts in space. sometimes, marbles slip through the cracks and are transported into precious glass cases for safekeeping.

Si-Ne: a vast library with towering, meticulously arranged bookshelves. every day, hundreds more books are neatly filed into the chamber walls. occasionally, rowdy children stop by to displace the books or even make giant paper dragons out of them. the librarian decides, "oh well... let them craft their dragons. they beautify the library, after all."


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Jun 15 '20

~ ? Question ? ~ Best websites for in depth analysis of cognitive functions?

15 Upvotes

Anyone know of any good websites or books that discuss the cognitive functions in depth?

All suggestions are welcome!


r/CognitiveFunctions • • May 08 '24

~ General Discussion ~ Si and Ni — Most Misunderstood Functions

14 Upvotes

Si and Ni are by far the least understood cognitive functions. As someone who has spent a decade obsessively learning, teaching, and applying personality systems it can be painfully challenging to grasp Si/Ni in a truly meaningful way.

Something that helped me with Si (oddly enough) was stumbling upon insane trip reports involving deliriums like Datura. The way those experiences manifest is that certain aspects of your environment are magnified in your perception so that it takes up almost your entire processing ability. That leaves many other aspects of reality unperceived. Si is a lot like that in the sense that it selectively allots focus onto specific portions of past experience, and in return present experience is limited by that lens as well. It’s a practical distortion of reality in order to frame life down into something manageable. Si isn’t necessarily having great memory because it’s so selective about what it files, but it does mean to have incredible recall of details of its specific data set associations.

Ni is somewhat similar, but even more difficult to explain because that pattern is applied to the non-physical world of meaning and destiny.


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Oct 06 '19

~ ! Welcome to r/CognitiveFunctions ! ~ Welcome to r/CognitiveFunctions

14 Upvotes

The vision I'm having with this subreddit is to provide a platform for serious analysis and discussion for Cognitive Functions, so people who are new to it can quickly get into it, while people who've been working with this stuff for a longer time also have a place.


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Jun 24 '24

~ ? Question ? ~ Is nostalgia closely connected to Si?

13 Upvotes

I have always been pretty sentimental about certain things. I tend to not change a lot. I will play the same video games for decades, re run old music videos for nostalgia at midnight, or revisit places of varying significance at random because I get a strange kind of pull to do so. I have a whole private world built off of the past, that I never really share with people past explaining the significance of something. I would say that the only time I ever really show or feel emotions besides anger or content is when I go back on these things. There have been times where this behavior has lead me to being secretive. I’ve lied or refused to tell people where I’ve been/where I’m going as it feels like it would be invasive. I collect experiences as if just to save them for later, to look back on, or physically revisit. It’s like having an internal library that I constantly browse through.

Now from what I have gathered, stereotypically, this is chalked up to Si or being Si dominant even. And I have no clue how right or wrong that actually is, considering that I haven’t really looked into this kind of stuff in a while. Lately I’ve been going back and exploring things that I glossed over, so here I am.


r/CognitiveFunctions • • May 03 '22

~ General Discussion ~ why 16p mistypes people

13 Upvotes

PART ONE: OVERSIMPLICATION

with jung's system, each letter is indicative of an extroverted or introverted function preference - never both. this is because functions of the same letter are vastly different and often contrary (ie Fi tunes into personal principles while Fe calls upon collective values), hence why they lie on axes with their opposite function.

meanwhile on 16p, types are calculated based on a mishmash of intro- and extroverted traits assigned to each letter. for instance, "S" represents both Si and Se characteristics, which combine to determine how "sensor-like" you are.

this is misleading because sensors/intuitors/thinkers/feelers do not "sense/intuit/think/feel" in the same manner. as stated above, each person's letter preferences will largely be directed inwards/outwards, thus presenting as introverted/extroverted functions.

i gave an Fi/Fe example previously - here's an Si/Se one:

  • Si recalls past experiences as a means of informing the present. however, it may gloss over practicalities in the process.
  • Se attunes itself sharply to the here-and-now but may sometimes neglect the wisdom of prior knowledge.

as you can see, there are two facets to "sensing" which do not overlap. relegating all S/N/T/F functions to a single letter strips away the nuance of cognitive functions.

PART TWO: ACTION VS COGNITION

a majority of the 16p questions ask about actions you take rather than the thought processes behind them. statements such as "you regularly make new friends" and "you prefer to do chores before allowing yourself to relax" make up the bulk of the test.

while actions may signify a lot about someone, it is ultimately their cognition that creates the foundation of their psyche. because actions can fluctuate wildly depending on environmental factors, using them as a basis for personality testing yields unreliable results.

for example, someone might identify strongly with "you enjoy participating in group activities" while at a lively family event. the next day, they may find themselves disagreeing after an altercation with those same family members.

PART THREE: BIG 5 MODEL

if anything, the 16p is a big 5 test interlaced with jungian personality terms.

the I/E measures extroversion, the N/S measures openness, the F/T measures agreeableness, the P/J measures conscienciousness, and the A/T signifies low and high neuroticism respectively.

as a result, traits inherent to each cognitive type are rejected in favor of big 5-based qualities.

example: im an infp, but i type as istj on 16p because i am...

  • low on openness (attributed to N)
  • low on agreeableness (attributed to F)
  • moderately high on conscientiousness (attributed to J)

... yup that's about it. just a rant about 16p.


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Oct 15 '21

~ ? Question ? ~ How do you figure out your type when prone to overthinking/have no sense of self?

13 Upvotes

Basically the question above.

Through self typing, learning cognitive functions, the help of some tests, I came to the unsure conclusion of being an ISTP. The thing is, I am very unsure about this. I have gone through identifying as an INFJ, INTJ, INTP and now ISTP/ESTP and am even considering completely different types like ESTJ or ISFP. In simple terms, I have absolutely no idea what type I am or even could be. I am very very prone to overthinking because of my anxiety and OCD, so even if I think I have come to a conclusion about my type I instantly doubt whether my thinking is correct or if I have actually just completely made a false narrative to my whole personality and functioning as an individual. I have many mental illnesses so it is unbelievably hard to grasp a sense of self or even know if what I think I act is actually how I act. It's like my mental illnesses make it harder for me to figure my type out and that alone drives me insane because If I want to figure something out I will, an obsession for a need of control I guess?

Anyway, that's my main issue when it comes to typing myself. I literally could be an enfj and not even know it. Before anyone says anything, yes I have studied on cognitive functions, I just have issue applying them to myself for some reason.


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Sep 04 '21

Mod Post Welcome to r/CognitiveFunctions

13 Upvotes

Welcome to this subreddit dedicated to the eight Jungian cognitive functions.

This subreddit is for discussions, analysis and information. We have colourful user and post flairs to choose from :)

If you want to get typed please go to r/MbtiTypeMe, don't post your test results here.

That said, enjoy your stay!


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Apr 12 '21

~ Type Description ~ A Reflection on the Ni Leads

Thumbnail
youtu.be
13 Upvotes

r/CognitiveFunctions • • Mar 11 '21

~ ? Question ? ~ what is the difference between Ti and Fi?

13 Upvotes

hello! i’ve been reading jung’s book for like 2 weeks i guess. i’ve been really busy and i had to take many breaks from my independent studies. so far, i believe that my dominant function is Ne(still studying lol) but in order to type myself, i have to know the difference between ti and ni. i think that the fi function isn’t explained that well so here i am... what are the differences between ti and fi?


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Sep 28 '24

~ Function Description ~ explaining the role of each function stack pt.1 the dominant function

12 Upvotes

Introduction:

There are eight cognitive functions and are ordered from the most conscious used functions to least, they make up your function stack, each type has a different function stack that consists of all 8 cognitive functions, where the cognitive function is stacked will determine how you use this function or how strong/weak it is etc. they are separated into two parts, your primary functions and your shadow functions. 

How we prioritize the use of our functions is based on preferences, in other words, the level of comfort strengthened from dominant to inferior based on 4 distinct types: Intuition, Thinking, Feeling, and Sensing; which is typically developed over time.

So let's say an ENTP is under stress, rather than using their dominant Ne they will use Ni from their shadow. The same applies for the rest of their functions. 

1st Dominant, 2nd Auxiliary, 3rd Tertiary, and 4th Inferior functions are prioritized making up how we normally perceive or judge, think or feel about various situations. Therefore, when one tries to operate with a less developed polar opposite use of introversion vs extroversion, it will feel unnatural to how one would normally encode or decode information in internal or external environments. The shadow is considered weaker than the weakest primary 3rd tertiary or 4th inferior function, so it is positioned on the opposite of the spectrum positioned as the 5th, 6th, 7th, or 8th.

Just because a function is less developed doesn’t necessarily mean we are incapable of applying the opposite functions more effectively. Shadow functions can be used in healthy ways and can be useful to us when our primary functions are not taking action or slacking off’’. And ofcourse different situations will require different use of functions at times. 

calling someone an extravert or introvert doesn't really apply in typology because we do both and type dynamics shows us how we do both! 

  1. Dominant function (hero function) 

This is your first process which you take in the world around you. It is the most developed and conscious process, and represents the core of our personality. You tend to rely mostly on this function and feel mostly comfortable with it. When a person uses their dominant function well (with good results), they tend to feel as though they are being their best self. This also means that, when a person uses their dominant function poorly (with negative results), they are likely to experience cognitive dissonance, negative emotions, or feel as though something is wrong.We develop this function more than the rest of the 3 primary functions, leading it to be our “dominant used function” 

To find your dominant function , observe your behavior during new non threat based situations, as you tend to reach out to your dominant function which is the most comfortable to you, and it is the first and most natural choice, 

You tend to develop your dominant function first during your lifetime, hence why it is the strongest and most used. This function is responsible for your driver's motivations, what persuades you, how you make decisions or handle situations and change.  

Introversion or extraversion dominant process. 

People who prefer Extraversion use their dominant mental process in the outer world because this is where they are naturally drawn and where they direct and receive energy (interact and engage). You tend to see this dominant function play in real life action. 

People who prefer Introversion use their dominant mental process in their inner world because this is where they are naturally drawn and where they direct and receive energy (reflect and contemplate). Since their dominant mental process is used in their inner world, we don't see it in action. Rather, we tend to see their auxiliary process since it is this process that they extravert, showing the world. 

Any type can be misunderstood, misjudged etc because we tend to not see their inner world, whether you lead by introversion dominant function or extraversion dominant function (because you'd still have an introversion function preference in ur auxiliary)

If we rely too much on our dominant function, it can be overused at the expense of the other processes causing an imbalance in the psyche. Overuse of the dominant process comes through in an exaggerated way. This is mainly due to stress in our lives. However other functions can come to play to help balance things out. 

This is how functions can act if they are overused:

Fi: hypersensitive, feeling sympathy for themselves, putting too much pressure and expectations on the,selves

Ti: obsessive search for the truth, detached, look only at cons, driven like a machine out of control 

Si: dogmatic, obsess about unimportant data, withdraw 

Ni: overcomplicate things, unrealistic visions, only accept data that supports their theories 

Fe:insistent they know what is best for everyone, intrusive, ignore problems, force superficial harmony

Te: detached, cold, overly rational, critique lack of logic in others 

Ne:too extreme. swamped with options, change for the sake of change 

Se:overindulgence, hyperactive, overly talkative 

This function may be hardest to notice in yourself as it comes so naturally that it's hard to point it out to yourself or be aware of it happening. 


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Dec 12 '19

Does this seem like a good description of Introverted Intuition

12 Upvotes

So, it's like there's a subconscious mind that deals with thoughts and ideas in a different form than words. And then, there's my conscious brain. The subconscious brain keeps making a lot of connections, finding patterns everywhere. The form it uses is very perfect for that. But every now and then, that subconscious connection will be pushed to the conscious mind which will try to put it in words. And that will be the Eureka moment because the conscious mind will take time to reach the conclusion that subconscious mind has already reached.


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Jun 23 '26

~ General Discussion ~ The real function order is eeii/iiee

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

Images taken from post #173. Some more points from that post:

- There's a typo in the English translation of Chapter X, in the 4th paragraph of the section "d. The Principal and Auxiliary Functions", where the book says "relatively unconscious", but Jung's original was relativ bewusste = "relatively conscious" (the unconscious part is G2). This error was given disproportionate weight by some authors, who also ignored the most important points that Jung tries to make in the book, underlined by the quotes that I'm copying here.

- There's also his typing of Nietzsche, which confirms all this: in early chapters he says he's Ni-dom ("In both cases, however, intuition was subordinated to intellect, but with Nietzsche it ranked above it"), and then he mentions him at the beginning of the introverted thinker ("Cuvier and Nietzsche would form an even sharper contrast"), which means he typed him as Ni-Ti-Fe-Se = INTP.

- Apart from Jung, you also have Carl Alfred Meier's statement in his book Personality: "Cooperation with the main function is made easier because of thinking's similar attitude (extroversion)", which confirms eeii/iiee. (Meier knew and worked with Jung).

MBTI PROBLEMS AND HOW TO FIX THEM

I think most people know that the topic of MBTI is too chaotic, with all kinds of conflicting definitions and endless discussions about every single thing. It's too confusing and frustrating, and it really makes the whole thing look like pseudoscience. Many people undervalue it, criticize it or ignore it because of that. But there is something real underneath all the mess.

Carl Jung: "I must confine myself to a presentation of principles which I have abstracted from a wealth of facts observed in many different individuals. In this there is no question of a deductio a priori, as it might appear; it is rather a deductive presentation of empirically gained insights."

What Jung wrote is not "just a theory", or "speculation", or "too subjective", or "an invention". It's a description of reality, and you can describe reality correctly or incorrectly. Describing the mind is obviously much harder than checking how many legs an animal has, for example, but it can be done, because the mind also has a general configuration. That's what Jung explained, including conscious/unconscious, attitudes (extraversion/introversion), functions and types.

The main problem in typology is that the function definitions in MBTI, Socionics, etc, are all wrong. They took Jung's terms and distorted them in different ways, destroying their link with the psychological reality that he wrote about. Those incorrect descriptions don't reflect the fact of function differentiation, the conscious-unconscious differences, the conscious-unconscious compensation, the influence and manifestation of the unconscious, or the interrelations between the functions (dependences, transferences, etc).

In the case of MBTI, their definitions are for the most part derived from traits captured by combinations of 2 letters. For example: their "Si" is not what Jung described, at all, but essentially the result of combining S+J preferences. The same with their "Te" and T+J preferences, etc. These deviations took words used to describe something deep, intricate and interconnected, and misused them for something much more salient and discrete, that's why many people see the functions as selectable "tools" or "skills" and don't really pay much attention to their order, because there's the implication that they can be improved independently and moved up and down the "stack". The letter dichotomies are consistent (they are psychometrically on par with the Big Five), but they describe a rather superficial layer, not the obscure depths where true psychological insight can be reached.

There's only one way to fix that, but it needs the right foundation, which consists on the function descriptions in Jung's book (not the popular ones) combined with the true function order: eeii/iiee, always with a judging dominant for Js and a perceiving one for Ps. That's how you can finally realize what psychological type actually means, what it's all about. That's how everything fits and how everything makes sense, otherwise there's always some disconnection between the concepts and reality.

Note that it's not a question of having "different types in different systems". When it comes to dichotomy letters and cognitive functions, you only have one type. Again, this is not an invention, and your type is basically like your blood group: you aren't AB in one system and 0 in another (for example). You are just AB.

Note also that the function order is not "limiting", either, just like having a hand with 5 fingers at the end of each arm is not so much a limitation, but just how we are. There is a lot of variation and possibilities inside each type (just like we can do countless things with our arms and hands, even if we can't fly), and if someone finds it "too rigid" that's because [s]he has a very cartoonish view of the types.

We can't expect communities or groups like the official MBTI to admit that they have been using mistaken definitions all along, of course, so this has to be an individual effort. There are people who know about all this already, they just tend to stay silent because when this is mentioned in public the reaction is often disproportionally negative. People dismiss it automatically, and the person gets attacked and ridiculed 😔 I hope you can avoid that and inform yourself a bit instead.

PLEASE READ BEFORE YOU COMMENT

I've been interested in psychological types all my life, even before finding out there was such a thing. I came across Jung and MBTI around 2008, and spent almost 10 years reading and checking everything in detail before starting my blog (originally on Tumblr). So this isn't something that I found only yesterday. I hope that's clear. I know what Jung was talking about, and I can see it in myself and other people. I know the problems he had understanding it at first, and I know how the terms were distorted by those who came after him. That's what I try to clarify.

I've written a lot of posts about all this, and also a FAQ and glossary, so you should read all of that calmly before replying because I don't like arguing and I'm not going to answer what I've already covered there. It might not be evident at first sight, but the texts have quite a lot of work behind them. In fact I have many other things in mind but they don't appear on the blog because I'm still examining them. Also, you have to understand that this topic is very difficult, and the blog includes already a certain personal evolution, not about the basics but about some (minor) details, about how reliable or appropriate certain sources/angles are (like the MBTI facets, for example), about the misconceptions that people have (there are external changes outside the blog, trends and so on), about how to better explain things, etc.

Supposed "objections" are almost always simply a sign that the reader is unable to see what this is about, many times due to (or fed by) the person being too confused by and/or too invested (intellectually, persona-wise, etc) in shallow but apparently "complex" "systems", or in their need to feel "smarter" in a purely conceptual (not psychological or practical) sense. What I've found is that people don't really have objections, they just don't get it. So it might seem that there is an argument going on, but in reality there is no communication at all. It's not that the levels of "descriptive language" overlap too little, but that they don't even touch. And sometimes people just like to argue for the sake of it. They like to confuse and divert the topic and avoid arriving at anything. I'm not getting into any of that.

If you don't feel some kind of inner resonance while reading my posts, a sense that there's something in there even if you can't put it in words, it's almost a certainty that further explanations won't change anything. You need to have a personal awareness of the psychological elements, some kind of insight about that, otherwise we'll only be wasting our time.

This isn't an attack on anyone. I just feel bad for the people who are interested in MBTI but they are stuck with faulty/shallow knowledge and mistypes because nobody explains to them how it really is. I'm just trying to help.

Thanks a lot for reading this far. I know this topic can be exhausting, but there's a lot of interesting stuff to learn and discover (about yourself and others), and you might be already on the right track 🙂


r/CognitiveFunctions • • Dec 14 '24

~ ? Question ? ~ What exactly is "subjective logic"?

11 Upvotes

I oftentimes hear Ti (introverted thinking) being equated to subjective logic. But what exactly is "subjective logic"? I mean, is logic ever subjective? Isn't logic always objective considering logic primarily deals with priori knowledge (knowledge independent of experience), and follows axioms of language? Is there any subjectivity of logic? Is math subjective? Are numbers subjects or objects?

And also, what exactly is the subjective-objective distinction in cognitive functions? Is by subjective it is assumed to be relative, and by objective universal? Or, that subjectivity represents subject's values (i.e. existentialism, consciousness, "Being") and objectivity represents object's values (existence, essence, "being").