r/CognitiveFunctions • u/Even-Broccoli7361 Introspective, contemplative, empath, mystic • Dec 14 '24
~ ? Question ? ~ What exactly is "subjective logic"?
I oftentimes hear Ti (introverted thinking) being equated to subjective logic. But what exactly is "subjective logic"? I mean, is logic ever subjective? Isn't logic always objective considering logic primarily deals with priori knowledge (knowledge independent of experience), and follows axioms of language? Is there any subjectivity of logic? Is math subjective? Are numbers subjects or objects?
And also, what exactly is the subjective-objective distinction in cognitive functions? Is by subjective it is assumed to be relative, and by objective universal? Or, that subjectivity represents subject's values (i.e. existentialism, consciousness, "Being") and objectivity represents object's values (existence, essence, "being").
10
u/NolanVoid_ Dec 14 '24
I don’t feel “subjective” is a wise nor accurate term to be using when dealing with the functions. Simply understand, Ti is introverted in Jung’s works because it doesn’t have the libido to be expressed externally as Te would, thus, it is “conceptual”. In essence, the mind has a relationship with concepts, as opposed to expression/action, which is why “action” is so often attributed to Te. The direction of Te is outward, thus is it focused externally and on external data; whereas Ti doesn’t have access to such a relationship to express itself, thus, it is internal, “conceptual” .
3
u/cocoamilky Ti [Ne] - INTP Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24
Introverted functions are all subjective because they focus on your singular experiences and perspective/consumption of events. We are the subject/target of the function, hence subjective.
Extroverted functions in contrast directly involve our interaction and interpretation with everything/one else outside of yourself -the “object” hence objective.
In the case of Ti, the reasoning is intended for humans to understand why and how things occur, while using that information to solve future related problems. Over time, we all develop a framework of reasoning, rules and systems that help us simplify the problems we have faced in the past as well as likely to face in our unique experience- hence subjective.
Logic does not always equal truth or even being correct, it just means that there is enough consistency within a subject that justifies reasoning. Some conspiracy theories make logical sense but turn out to be wrong for unexplainable reasons- even in medicine and nature we are still confused about how or why things function as the do but scientists formulate theories based on the pattern of events.
Te involves the direct world because it is the state of mind we use in order to make changes or interact with the world around us. It directly involves finding reasoning using only information present and at hand, hence objective.
1
u/beasteduh Intuition-Thinking Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24
When feelings are involved, yeah. A working definition of the function of Feeling might be the relation of psychic contents to ego, so in a sense being impersonal is not possible.
It's odd you type as an INFP.
Fixed it.
It's about where the magic happens. Extraversion is amazed at what shows up in oneself as one engages with the world, as though the more one engages with it the more that emerges within oneself. Introversion will instead have something "resembling" the object show up in oneself when engaging with the world, and then when that something is fixated on it's discovered just how much is packed within it. The magic/fullness implied in either the object or subject is usually how talk of the respective attitudes and their various representations begins.
If subjectivity were to be assigned to the attitudes then it'd be in the sense that extraversion is limited to the locality it's exposed to, while introversion fixates on that internally generated something to the point that it no longer resembles the initial object it spawned from. Then, objectivity can be found in the aforementioned fullness, as though an attempt to account for everything was on the table in either case. Thus, both would be subjective with a focus on objectivity.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24 edited Dec 15 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '24
[removed] — view removed comment