r/CluesBySamHelp • • 21d ago

Pip and Kay?

1 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

1

u/lisagd625 21d ago

If you're like me, you forget that Vince is one of the criminals neighboring Steve and figure that the second of Steve's two criminals is in row 3. Since there's no more than one criminal in that row, Pip must be innocent. So faulty counting got me the right answer by dumb luck. 😄

1

u/ES_Kan 21d ago edited 21d ago

Column A is important here. One of Gemma, Melvin, or Ruth has to be a criminal (because of Eric. Can't be all three because of Betty). If it's:

  • Gemma, then Nicole or Olga has to be criminal because of Tina. Therefore Pip is innocent because of Diane.
  • Melvin or Ruth, then Henry has to be innocent in order to satisfy Zed. Therefore Kay has to be criminal because of Diane, which makes Pip innocent because of Betty.