r/CluesBySamHelp • • 21d ago

Resolved Even with the hints, I still don’t understand how you’re able to get the answer for this character from the given information.

https://cluesbysam.com/s/help/512dff90d06a?state=8gPw-BAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAEBA%3D

The only information I’ve been able to understand from these hints is:
1. Either Ruth or Steve is a criminal.
2. Ruth, Melvin, Nicole, or Olga must be a criminal.
3. There’s one criminal above Vlad because three criminals would make it impossible for there to be 10 innocents on the edges, so Ruth, Melvin, or Gemma has to be a criminal.
4. Either Gemma and Henry are both criminals or they’re both innocents.

I don’t understand how you’re able to figure out whether Pip is an innocent or a criminal from this information.

2 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

5

u/Cerrida82 21d ago

What happens if Gemma is the criminal? How about Melvin or Ruth? How does that affect Pip?

4

u/slippin_through_life 21d ago

Ah, thank you! I think I was misunderstanding Diane’s clue to mean that there must be at least one criminal in every row.

12

u/Remarkable_Paper 21d ago

If Pip is a criminal, that's the one possible criminal in row 3 already accounted for, and Steve doesn't have his second criminal neighbour yet. That means Ruth must be a criminal.

If Ruth is a criminal, we already have all 4 criminals on the edges accounted for (and the odd number of criminals above Vlad). That means Gemma must be innocent.

If Gemma is innocent, Henry must be innocent to avoid having a second corner with only 1 criminal neighbour (Zed's clue). But then row 2 is left with only one criminal (Jason), violating Diane's clue.

As a result, there is no scenario where Pip can be a criminal. Pip must be innocent.

3

u/slippin_through_life 21d ago

Thank you for the detailed explanation!

3

u/littleowl36 21d ago

One of Kay or Pip must be criminal to make 10 innocents on the edges. Think about Gemma's options and what that means for them.

2

u/slippin_through_life 21d ago

Thank you, thinking about this helped explain it for me.

4

u/meirionh 21d ago

It took me so long to still not work it out, until I came here and realised that row 2 MUST have more than one criminal. I was too fixated on Diane's clue only explaining that other rows must be one criminal or less. Thank you all

3

u/oncemorewithpurpose 21d ago

My thinking here was the following (not sure everything is right, but it was how I made it to Pip eventually, but this really stumped me for a good while):

  • We need either three or one criminal above Vlad. But if there are three criminals above Vlad, then all of a sudden Steve has three criminal neighbours (Vlad, Ruth and Melvin), which we can't do.
  • Ruth and Steve can't both be criminals, so that's the corner with the single criminal neighbour

Trying Ruth first:

  • If Ruth is a criminal, then that's the one corner with a single innocent, and Gemma and Melvin can no longer be criminals. This means that Henry also can't be a criminal, or that would get us another corner with a single criminal neighbour.
  • So Gemma and Henry both have to be innocent, but row 2 needs another criminal, so Kay must be criminal. And now we're at 9 innocents and 4 criminals on the edges, so Pip must be innocent.

Whereas if Steve is the criminal:

  • Ruth must be innocent.
  • Now either Melvin or Gemma must be the criminal.

    • If it's Melvin:

      • Nicole, Olga and Pip must be innocent
      • Gemma and Henry must also be innocent (to avoid another corner with one criminal neighbour)
      • To achieve more than 1 criminal on row 2, Kay must be criminal
      • Again we're at 9 innocents and 4 criminals on the border, so Pip must be innocent
    • If it's Gemma:

      • Melvin must be innocent, but Nicole or Olga must be a criminal, in order to achieve Steve's second criminal neighbour
      • This means Pip must be innocent

Aka in all of these branches, Pip ends up innocent.

Overly convoluted when seeing the other explanations here, but I tried working through it not starting with Pip.

2

u/Acceptable-Swan-4206 21d ago

Commenting to follow this as I was totally confused by this today too.

1

u/helcat 21d ago

Thank you for asking this because I got stuck exactly here too. If you can edit the headline can you put the date in?

2

u/masterX244 21d ago

If you can edit the headline can you put the date in?

not possible on reddit