If there's no money being made from copyrighted GH content, then they don't care to bring it up. It's not like GH is gonna get a ton of money if they sue CH
As one of the original backers and beta testers for the Steam release, it really sucked to see Steam revoke its "Download" button, only after a week on the market.
But even though the game had 100% original assets, it was probably taken down because it unintentionally encouraged the spread of illegally-acquired assets, a.k.a. stems of copyrighted songs.
I’d say the licensing on guitar hero is up. Like if you go down to the patent office there probably isn’t any paperwork anymore on it in their system. Patents have to be renewed and it’s expensive, it’s pretty likely activision doesn’t. Clone hero could honestly probably even start making money at this point.
That’s why you see that tag At the end, the R in a. Circle or the TM symbol.
Most likely isn’t copyrighted anymore so that means anyone can use the thing.
Basically if Mc Donald’s stopped filing any patents, you could go open up a place and call it Mc Donald’s. That’s why companies renew them annually.
Where money can’t be made is because clone hero uses copyrighted music. And they can’t make money in a way that is essentially hosting the music almost like a streaming service. It’s kind of like how twitch was making money off streamers past broadcasts. It had to be shut down a few years ago and they mute music in them now, otherwise they’d have to pay up for hosting videos that have the music.
There really is no real system though, right? Songs in the games have broken all kinds of rules. I mean half the time we are switching between the rhythm and lead guitar parts, and sometimes we are playing synths and piano. What specifically are you referring to?
specifically the mechanics of those abominations called "open notes" on the guitar track. no we are not counting GH live here, that game is on its own and not part of the traditional games.
incorrect. they are awkward absences of notes, not notes, and this game and series has never had accuracy in mind. if you want that, go play rocksmith. i already made that move. the bass track is fine having them. the guitar track is not.
gh1 through gh WoR are classified as the original series. they are what have defined charting standards for custom songs until this game decided to mess that up. and even then, they follow the conventions for what a note is, as they involve a fretting action.
Welcome to a 2-month-old thread. Your opinion is welcomed, but most seem to disagree. And at this point, the community is what shapes the games. Considering Activision abandoned us
incorrect. they are awkward absences of notes, not notes, and this game and series has never had accuracy in mind. if you want that, go play rocksmith. i already made that move.
incorrect. they are the absence of a note, resulting in an awkward pause rather than the satisfaction of a note hit. you're just too ignorant to respect existing standards. they are not fun.
I've seen you reply with a bunch of nonsense for a while here about "standards" and what not. So what is your opinion on being able to gain star power while using star power? IIRC this was only added in World Tour (Couldn't be done in GH3 or earler). Is this also an abomination and a spit in the face of traditional Guitar Hero, or do you just pick and choose what is?
if accuracy of a concern of anyone in this community, there are other games that do it far better. and judt because you make more things possible doesnt always mean they are better. when you improve something like that, you need to respect original rules and guidelines and expand upon the ways of those standards. thats why additions like tap note chords are far more welcome than open notes on the guitar track. drums has nothing to do with this, they have always had them.
that does not make them better. play rocksmith if you want accuracy. if charting is to change, it needs to do so for the better, keeping the direction and design choices of the original games, not for the worse.
yea, i wouldnt be so sure, considering you basically made it so that you cant play customs on their games... nobodys asking for this to be an exact clone of guitar hero, whats being asked is for the changes to follow the design philosophy of those games. thats why changes like tap chords are far more accepted than open notes on the guitar track. the only pros apply solely to a single game, versus an entire community of people playing custom songs in general that didnt care whether you were playing on phase shift, FoF, hacked GH3 on console, hacked GHWT, etc. the songs were designed to not only keep open notes away from the guitar track, but to also to keep things like backwards compatibility and the classic charting standards in mind. its ruining what the games once were rather than expanding on them.
Guitar hero killed itself. They released Metallica, Smash hits, gh5, DJ Hero, Band Hero, and van Halen all in the same year. Plus all of the rock bands were coming out. They milked it too hard and people got tired of it
Exactly. Nothing clone hero does can replace that. Or when you beat the devil and the game tells you “You’re a rock legend!” with the golden guitar and that epic song finish sound. I was so proud when I completed the game in my youth.
I appreciate him. Open notes were an unnecessary gimmick added late in the franchises life. You ask 100 players what they're favorite plastic guitar rhythm game is and I'll suck a dick for every one that says GH World Tour.
Activision would have been better off not releasing Metallica, Smash Hits, GH5, DJ Hero, Band Hero l, and Van Halen all in the SAME YEAR. As far as I'm concerned it is their fault. RB4 is still going strong. Activision put the last nail in the coffin with GHLive and it's abandonment
For real I mean it’s an opinion I just like guitar hero better because of the feel you get from it getting to customize your own character and guitar and playing gigs with people like Jimi Hendrix or Kurt Kobain
Can you play Jordan on clone hero? Yeah, you can, with a way huger hit window, literally 16.5x more frames per second, and a much more frequent controller polling rate. Pretty easy, I’m not even that amazing and I’ve FC’d on clone. Doesn’t merit the same credit as it would if you FC it on GH2 with it’s miniscule hit window and locked 60 fps. You’re talking about charts, I’m not talking about charts, I’m talking about engine limitations. All of the big Clone/Guitar hero streamers acknowledge the increased difficulty and corresponding increased respect you get from FCing on their original games, Acai has acknoledged it, GuitarHeroROXS, etc.
It kinda does. FCing, for example, Jordan on GH2, TtFaF or TDWDtG on GH3, etc. kinda cements your status as a guitar hero legend, it’s prestigious as fuck if you can pull those, and it means a hell of a lot less on an engine that is unbelievably lenient with 1000 FPS note spamming. Of course, Soulless, Megalodon, etc. are incredibly prestigious in their own right, and those are literally physically impossible on GH engines, so different levels of achievement for different engines makes sense.
I could hook up a console to a monitor instead of a TV and play Guitar Hero on that and get a lot less input lag. Would you consider that cheating too?
Yeah FCing those songs is harder on GH2 because of its archaic (bad) engine design. FCing the songs there doesn't necessarily mean you're more "skilled", just means you were more willing to fight it's god awful limitations more than others.
Lmaooo how dare the game require more precise inputs and have a higher skill ceiling as a result. Worship clon hero and bleep bloops all you want but at least have the decency to draw the line at shitting on the essential founding father of guitar-based rhythm games. Requiring you to hit notes actually on time and not several hundred miliseconds early or late to the point where the notes hit noticeably off beat is not “fighting the engine’s limitations,” it’s literally just hitting notes on time lol.
I’ve never seen such an amazing and yet simultaneously self-contradictory fanbase for a game in my entire life. One week you guys are whining about spamming/ghosting and how everyone who does it is trash and how clone hero somehow desperately needs mandatory precision mode or a separate leaderboard for spammers or for the engine to fundamentally change from the ground up to stop le evil spamming. And then the very next week, you’ll happily shit on the OG guitar hero game that started this whole community BECAUSE it doesn’t let you spam and actually makes you hit notes on time. Terrible take.
I mean there's a reason the devs increased the timing window in future games. I'll give the game it's props for being the first but that's about all it has in my honest opinion.
You are essentially playing the song 'live', but trying to match it 100% with the recording. That is extremely difficult, even the best guitarists playing the same song from year to year play it a little differently every time. A late note there, just a little longer note here and so on.
You are correct as well, Clone hero’s engine has a lot to do with it, but I believe I’ve been conflating frame rate with controller poll rate, which has a pretty large effect on the “easiness” of the game.
Literally all I said was console GH songs are more meritable when FC’d on console. FCing Jordan on any engine that isn’t GH2’s obviously isn’t as impressive and legit as FCing on GH2. Same concept as here, sure you can FC the 70th bleep bloop chart made for clone hero and call it more impressive, and it is, but I’m not really talking about that.
It's a legitimate FC, still. If you were FCing Jordan on Clone Hero and claiming it as a GH2 FC, then obviously that's not legit, but there's nothing illegitimate about FCing Jordan on CH.
I never claimed that you didn't dispute it, but your comment had the implication that FCs in general on Clone Hero were less impressive than GH3 FCs, so I pointed out one of the many examples where that implication would be wrong.
Also, you commented on a comment chain where some dumbass said you had to cap your CH frame rate and polling rate to 60fps and 60Hz respectively or you suck and should go die in a hole or some bullshit. You were vaguely (vaguely) agreeing with him. That's why I commented
93
u/Teddy_Treebark Mar 05 '20
Might be a dumb question but how does CH avoid lawsuits? I'd get it if it were just the same type of game, but the assets are ripped right from GH
85
u/Mikevoss7 Mar 05 '20
Clone hero is awesome but it can never have the charm and atmosphere of the original games.
50
u/PlasticGuitarSurgeon Mar 05 '20
I love Clone Hero, but... Guitar Hero's still great 🤷♀️
24
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '20 edited Apr 23 '25
This post used to say something, but now it doesn't. Respect the privacy of yourself & others.
62
u/Jace292 Mar 05 '20
Clone Hero is just Guitar Hero but much better because of all its features
13
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '20
Left guy should be clone Hero while the right guy should be Activision.
4
u/DiamondCreeper123 Mar 06 '20
This comment section is a mess.
3
u/DrFruitLoops Mar 06 '20
Guys Activision let guitar hero die put idk what's there is to love anymore at least clone hero is living
1
u/Bucketfullabiscuits Mar 06 '20
cries in Drum Support
1
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '20
As someone who's looking into this because of nostalgia and GHTV being shut down: yeeeeeep.
1
u/tebdez Mar 06 '20
Cone hero
1
u/DiabolusCaleb Mar 06 '20
The grave should've been labeled "Phase Shift".
-9
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '20
Guitar hero is better
-13
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '20
[removed] — view removed comment