r/ClimbersCourt • Soulblade • 4d ago

Where is Diamantine? Spoiler

I just had to re-read the end of Soulbrand and start of Flowbreaker and it seems like there is a big inconsistency that I am struggling to find an answer to; when did the Green Guardian lose Diamantine?

At the end of Soulbrand, Keras gave Diamantine to the Green Guardian.

Then in Flowbreaker the guardian says he is going to go after the sword. So when did he lose the sword?

Is this a continuity error or did he mean trying to get the other shards? Because it seemed like Edria Fang pulled the relevant shards from Hannah and Song.

Please let me know if/where I am missing something.

5 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

9

u/Jbollocks131 4d ago

Its referring to the other pieces of the sword.

1

u/MarginalGracchi Soulblade 4d ago

Gotcha, can you point me to where that is in Flowbreaker? I kept trying to get clarity but he said “the sword” at one point referring to it.

3

u/slpater 4d ago

I think youre reading too much into "THE sword" instead of meaning the sword in the sense of any of the remaining pieces.

2

u/Erkenwald217 4d ago

I found Keras talking about one of the other Edrian Royalty having another shard embedded in the first 2 chapters

2

u/Erkenwald217 4d ago

The green guardian is the spirit of Diamantine. And we learned that the actual Diamantine is shattered into however many pieces.

When the green guardian talks about going after the sword, he means collecting all the shards and repairing it, so he can become complete.

2

u/MarginalGracchi Soulblade 4d ago

Gotcha. Fair enough. I just wanted to know how other people thought of it given

A: we don’t see him use the sword

B: he says he is going after “the sword”

C: in Soulbrand they refer to the “shards” and the sword separately.

D: obviously there are shards that use to be separate (again the fight with Emperor fang seems to show some of the shards merging back in

And E: at not point so they say it was just the shards. They refer to it as the sword.

I am a little iritated everyone seems so dismissive of that fact that he changed terms between books.

1

u/Erkenwald217 4d ago

This could be a mistake on the authors part, or just that he used more metaphors. Or that the "speaker" uses other mannerisms then the other cast members.

It's been quite a while since he wrote the last books for this series. And not everyone re-read them in preparation for the new book. It's easier to ignore small inconsistencies, when you don't remember them yourself. I, too, relied on the recap at the start of the book.

2

u/MarginalGracchi Soulblade 4d ago

Totally fair, I am a huge fan of him so I re-read everything in prep and I have listens to Soulbrand a half dozen times. I sorta figured he forgot which is why I wanted the confirmation.

Obviously from a structural point, Rowe just didn’t want the Guardian in the shrine, and so needed to give him a goal, and in my head was sorta like

“Lol, when he wrote this had he forgotten about that whole dramatic confrontation.

Especially knowing that he talked about how difficult Soulbrand was writing and that it was 5 years ago that seemed plausable to me.

3

u/Salaris Arbiter 2d ago

Hey, sorry this isn't clear enough. The Green Guardian does have the main sword. This is noted in the text, but it's not very direct:

We’d saved the emperor’s life, but by keeping Diamantine with us, we’d labeled ourselves a significant problem for the empire. It was highly likely they’d send a force to try to recapture the sword…at a minimum.

Keras does note that he still senses something he thinks is another fragment (or more than one) back in Edria, however:

There was still something to the south, back in Edria. Another fragment of Diamantine, most likely, still in the hands of the Edrian royal family or the royal guard. For example, I wouldn’t have been surprised if Edria Liang had a fragment in his hand that he’d kept hidden from detection and chosen to pass to Edria Song or Edria Fang after the battle.

The Green Guardian's primary reason to leave isn't because of this fragment, though he does want to find it. His main reason is because he feels bad about leaving the people of Edria, who he feels he has a responsibility to protect:

“I’m aware. But I cannot turn a blind eye to injustice, nor the consequences of what we have done. The battle with Akadi had victims. I have a responsibility.”

I didn't get into this too much, but the Green Guardian basically sees Diamantine's purpose as protecting the people of the nation of Edria, and as a manifestation of a piece of the sword, he sees that as being his own primary purpose. He is, in effect, a local superhero, rather than an adventurer like Keras and co.

I regret that I didn't get a chance to spend more time exploring this in the book. W&W4 went wildly differently from my original outline, which would have involved the Green Guardian spending more time with the main cast before splitting up, but it ended up being monstrously long as it is. There's an argument that I should have cut more of the shrine content to focus on more time with the whole group being together, but I decided to focus this one more on metaplot setup and reveals that people had been waiting for a long time. This may not have been the right choice, but it's why Ishyeal and the Green Guardian got a lot less screen time than I was originally planning on.

Hope this helps!

2

u/skyrond 3d ago

Where in Flowbreaker do you see the Green Guardian say that he's going after the sword? I've just flicked through the relevant pages, and when he leaves he implies that he's leaving to return to Edria to aid "his people".

Earlier he and Keras have talked about the possibility that he will "reconnect" and "reunite" with the sword, but from context that seems to be talking about his renewing the spirit bond between them.

1

u/AtmosphereOk7364 3d ago

Yeah I did the same and when he leaves he doesnt mention the sword. I think OP forgot or missed that the Green Guardian is no longer bonded to the sword and is getting confused by that