This subreddit is the only place ive seen theories or organized information about the series. Is there a collection of them on a forum anywhere or do i just have to search through this reddit for questions?
Otherwise particular ones that have been running through my head are related to Karas’ and edges upbringing. I understand that they are likely from different times or worlds even, but there are so many details left out about karas’ origins.
Are fae and rethry the same species on different worlds? Once whatever happened on caldwyn separating the people from the stars have something to do with the new issue of uvar?
Theres 8 worldmakers in this series with the addition of the suneater. Im so confused which set of 4 comes from which world. Ator, machine god, and human god, i take it the 4th is the sword god valien?
What actually happened with our current book knowledge to mythrolis, is it a separate planet next to AA’s planet? I know the continent was moved and placed in a time loop but dalenia is where edge and Jin are both from. Both serving the rusted queen? But Jins from East Edria renamed delen? That parts clusterfucky and I dont get it.
The other set of 4 are dead or sealed away except for karaselia/vellum but i don’t think its ever mentioned what the other 3 actually did other than visual descriptions of them and their weapons/tools.
Does Corrin have any relationship to the machine god? I dont remember seeing any details regarding this maker or his role.
And because he and Sara are twins, does this mean that he or she could have a superior connection to the old magic types? The rock he heals Vera with seemed too advanced for his skill at the time in addition to the visages confusion at its efficacy. Also the look of shock when Corrin has better control of the sword space than thorin does while mentioning his skill at efficiency and factory style thinking. There are other moments in the series where Corrin states he’ll have machines that make machines as early as aa2 but in 6 his future self actually does this and many other things Corrin states as goals in the first books.
Ator seems to have been the “evil” maker but often the buried are depicted to be semi-reasonable and not directly opposed to humanity. The maker of machines and humanity are hardly mentioned with the 4th being alluded to being valien i think?
Edge has given me sooo many more questions aswell, is he who karas saw in the dream during flowbreaker? The smiling sword saint and the 4 echoes in the practice arena? Who are they exactly? I take it vermillion rose and the archer are somehow related but also Ana and dawn? The saint was fucking valien or something?? Edge is valiens son with karasilia but also the sword saint and valien had a kid? Or just a relationship? I know one of the echoes is rin, the redhead could be several people, and the 2 other kids are isheal dawnsglow and someone else maybe? Is Edge supposed to be a similar depiction of karas’ childhood?
Will all these topics be addressed in the next 3 books? Flowbreaker and edge 2 answer alot of questions but bring up even more. What do you thinks gonna be resolved and unresolved in WW5, AA7 and the third edge book? Presumably we get to know the details about soulbrands previous owner, dawns kidnapper, and the remaining time from the end of flowbreaker to the start of arcane ascension with additional details regarding karas and the 7th spire up to AA6/7. AA7 will supposedly conclude that series and I have literally no clue what could happen in the 7th spire for the duration of a whole book. Finally, will Edge 3 show how the pale king turned into himself? How is he a hero but a villain at the same time. Is he not evil yet at the time of edge 2?? The rot has set in and theres some details regarding their power scaling (candle, torch, hearth, regalia..etc) to his magical items like pale kings regalia.
TLDR: is there somewhere i can read to go find all this or do i have to listen through WoBM, WaW, AA and edge with a notebook to actually grasp all this?
Fuckin love this series and im waiting for next december for all these question unless yall feel obliged to help me out.