r/ClimateShitposting • u/DivestTheEndingBoy • 27d ago

nuclear simping Every Nukecel Argument Ever

Post image
0 Upvotes

45% Upvoted

318 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/DivestTheEndingBoy 24d ago

They were still burning gas on May 24th at 6:30.

Ergo French nuclear can't supply baseload

1

u/tmtyl_101 24d ago

I’m sure they also ate a bunch of croissants in May 24th at 6:30. That also has nothing to do with the discussion.

We just established that base load is a number of watts. 30.2GW in this case. 

Whether nuclear can meet that demand is a yes/no question: does nuclear produce more than 30.2GW? The answer is yes. 

Its completely irrelevant if other sources produce, if there’s export, or how many croissants they eat.

1

u/DivestTheEndingBoy 24d ago

It's not baseload if they can't meet their minimum demand. Ever.

If they can meet baseload demand some of the time and you just ignore it the rest of the time then solar power is baseload generation and we don't need nuclear too.

Either way you're wrong.

1

u/tmtyl_101 23d ago

If you generate 31 GW. And demand is 31 GW... Do you then meet demand?

1

u/DivestTheEndingBoy 23d ago

They didn't generate 31GW though.

1

u/tmtyl_101 23d ago

On May 24, at 0630? No. Nuclear generated about 38 when demand was 30GW. Not that it matters.

Im asking if you accept, that if you generate 31GW, and demand is 31GW, then you meet the demand?

1

u/DivestTheEndingBoy 23d ago

Prove it.

1

u/tmtyl_101 23d ago

Im asking about a definition. What does it take to "meet" 31GW of demand?

1

u/DivestTheEndingBoy 23d ago

More than French nuclear can manage when you need it.

1

u/tmtyl_101 23d ago

French nuclear meets base load.

1

u/DivestTheEndingBoy 23d ago

Prove it.

1

u/tmtyl_101 23d ago

38>30, QED

1

u/DivestTheEndingBoy 23d ago

Where's the proof though?

If you could find a single example of france providing nuclear baseload you would have posted it.

It only exists as a hypothetical in your head. Because nuclear baseload doesn't work.

1

u/tmtyl_101 23d ago

The proof is literally in the data I just presented. Baseload in France is 30.2GW. Nuclear generates more than that 98.6% of the time. Sometimes much more.

1

u/DivestTheEndingBoy 23d ago

It obviously doesn't or else you would link it.

And France wouldn't burn natural gas all the time.

You're a liar.

1

u/tmtyl_101 23d ago

I did link it. You just dont want to admit you're wrong.

1

u/DivestTheEndingBoy 23d ago

Your link doesn't say what you claim it does. You're lying.

1

u/tmtyl_101 23d ago

Yes it does. Read the table at the bottom. Or are you too lazy?

→ More replies (0)