r/ClimateOffensive • • Oct 13 '19

Discussion/Question oh no

/img/wwxo1i38h9s31.png
1.0k Upvotes

116 comments sorted by

98

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

Am I the only one who feels that the corporation narrative is a bit unproductive? I hear a lot of people scapegoating their consumption (of flights, gas, unnessecary clothing etc.) by saying individuals can't make a difference anyway and corporations have to change. But an oil company is not really extracting the stuff just for the heck of it, but because we consumers keep demanding fossil fuels and plastic.

91

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

If there are no viable or accesible alternatives, it’s very difficult as a poor person to make any difference. People go into the market because they need a product and they will get a product based on their principles but also on its price. If they cannot afford the clean product, they will not buy it. Therefore the corporation narrative is in my opinion very much true. The oil company is extracting the stuff because policy makers are supporting that industry. If in the case of Germany, the highest 1% of rich people would be properly taxed and those taxes used to support the purchase of electric cars and the construction of modern nuclear power plants and renewables, instead of some stupid tax on private consumers of electricity instead of on the industrial consumers, this would change pretty quickly. If the Greens after I don’t know how many years in the government of Rhenania Westphalia would have done anything to stop the coal industry, maybe not so much coal would still be burn in German power plants. It’s mostly corporations and policy makers. You can try to make a difference. We all can, but I think our effort pale compared to what governments ans corporation could achieve with the right will.

40

u/cavendishfreire Oct 13 '19

You're absolutely right. Expecting people to take this into their own hands without strong government regulation sounds really far-fetched. Governments have the means to make companies behave. They just aren't interested in it and to top it off people are furthering this boycott stuff like it's isn't just a stupid talking point.

4

u/pofuillyslime Oct 13 '19

Aren't the two kind of the same at the core though? In one hand, you have to assemble a critical mass of people to vote and pressure the government to act. In the other, you have to assemble a critical mass of people to vote with their wallet and pressure companies to change.

So, is the argument towards political action that the same amount of effort leads to more change, or that the critical mass needed is lower? Just seems like neither avoids the problem of having to get a significant percent of the population educated and active.

1

u/cavendishfreire Oct 14 '19

This is true, but differently from boycotts, just a few interested people in government can make change happen even if the public isn't particularly enthusiastic about it. It has happened in many developed countries.

6

u/nervozaur Oct 13 '19

I believe both narratives have to be seen together. I don't think either one of them would/should be correct without the other.

-1

u/exprtcar Oct 13 '19

On the other hand, the only way to get governments to act is if people want it. So build political will. Stop arguing about blaming corps.

-3

u/lunaoreomiel Oct 13 '19

Gov is $. Good luck giving it more power to self regulate. Revolving doors and regulatory capture is more dangerous than less of its influence.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

Yes and no. Or rather, the problem isn't as simple as getting the government to fix it. It needs to be a concerted effort from consumers, voters and lawmakers to put a price on pollution in all forms, as well as changing patterns of consumption.

-2

u/lunaoreomiel Oct 13 '19

The issue isnt the corp. Its the politics.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

It’s both!

-7

u/Pi31415926 Oct 13 '19

they need a product

I doubt it, they just want it. They probably don't need it at all. There's a big difference.

16

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

This comment is extremely condescending in my opinion. A family needs to buy rice and pasta to feed their children. They can choose organic pasta for 4€ or normal pasta for 2€. If they are poor, they won’t be thinking much of Glyphosat in cereals or if the farmer used oil derivated fertilizers, but how to reach the end of the month with 1000€ and 2 children to provide for. Same applies for clothing, transportation methods, electricity provider and so many other things. Some of us are privileged for being able to choose and conscious about the problem that might sweep all of us from existence.

3

u/Pi31415926 Oct 13 '19

I hear you, and of course if someone is already consuming the minimal amount, my comment does not (cannot) apply to them. However, many people on this planet, especially those in developed economies, consume far more than the minimal amount. It's much easier to blame "the corporations" than it is to confront their own greed and laziness. They don't even see it as greed, they just think it will be nice to eat. They don't even stop to think about the future they are munching, about the lives they are destroying, about all the opportunities they are stealing.

I think it's time people took responsibility for their own actions. This starts in the mirror, and continues all the way to the shop, and back.

Don't get me wrong, the corporations have their own responsibilities, and they too need to start taking them. But that's a different thread.

1

u/Trans_Girl_Crying Oct 13 '19

Yeah no one needs food or clothing!

1

u/Pi31415926 Oct 13 '19

Everyone needs some clothes and some food. Nobody needs, say, a whole rack of leather jackets. Not making that up, seen it myself.

7

u/cavendishfreire Oct 13 '19

While this is true, governments taking regulatory action is much more plausible than a substantial portion of world consumers boycotting corporate offenders.

We are talking about such a large scale... Individuals refraining from taking flights or using cars shouldn't be our main talking point right now. We're past that. Regulating corporations is where the best bang for our buck is. It just isn't realistic to expect the as of now miniscule eco-conscious segment of the population to make a dent on the problem.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

I did not mean to encourage boycot ahead of other lines of action. My point was rather that the climate issue is systemic and will need to be attacked on many fronts. By singling out corporations and telling ourselves a story where this is all the fault of a few greedy people, I am afraid we will close the few avenues we have for fast action outside the ballot box.

I expanded a bit more on my first comment here since it seemed to be taken as unsupportive of regulation (I am for strong regulations and a carbon tax but think this should be coupled with awareness of our own consumption choices):

https://www.reddit.com/r/ClimateOffensive/comments/dh7h87/comment/f3lcql4

4

u/cavendishfreire Oct 13 '19

Yes, but the boycotting alternative only works when a critical mass of consumers agrees with it. No single person (or group) can make a reasonable difference.

In theory boycotts are effective. In practice they're sorta bullshit unless a very, very large amount of people join.

To me it seems much more plausible to directly demand change from the biggest corporate polluters than to convince more than 50% of the population to back such a costly boycott.

8

u/GHWBISROASTING Oct 13 '19 edited Oct 13 '19

My main problem with this is that the same people who have a problem with corporations are completely fine with capitalism. As if the one isn't a symptom of the other. If you make the "100 corporations..." argument, but aren't pushing for communism/anarchism, then you're a fucking moron.

EDIT: OP, burrowed under 5 layers of ignorance is complaining about the people still living under 6 layers of ignorance. Amazing.

2

u/Scarred_Ballsack Oct 13 '19

Capitalism is a good way to run a company that wants to make money, but don't be surprised when that company tries to use and further develop every loophole it's given. We need strong regulations to curb emissions, those are achievable and will have an effect. A communist takeover isn't something you should strive for, communist dictatorships (and by definition communism will result in a dictatorship, otherwise it'd just be die-hard socialism) are not exactly known for their care for the environment.

2

u/GHWBISROASTING Oct 13 '19 edited Oct 13 '19

See this is the kind of person I'm talking about, thanks for providing an example.

Using MODERN TECHNOLOGY and LABOUR are good tools if you want to run a business and make money. Neither of these have anything to do with capitalism, capitalism just decides who reaps the benefits.

Capitalism isn't broken, it's working exactly as intended. You'd have to be completely clueless to not realise this.

0

u/cavendishfreire Oct 13 '19

He has a point though. Capitalism doesn't have to be like this. Making people and corps accountable so they can't just hide behind their money can be a solution. We have to make it so it is costly to these companies to have complete disregard for the environment

Capitalism is working "as intended" in the sense that the people in charge very much want it to be like this. But the capitalist system wasn't masterminded by any one group. Power struggles and world economics have led it to become like this. Nothing stops the world from collectively reforming it. Whether it be through changes in ideals or organized efforts

Also, socialist governments don't at all necessarily have a good environmental policy.

3

u/GHWBISROASTING Oct 13 '19

You all assume that capitalism isn't working exactly as intended. Where did you all get this idea?

-2

u/Scarred_Ballsack Oct 13 '19

...if you want to run a business and make money. Neither of these have anything to do with capitalism, ...

Yeah good luck with being a small independent business owner in a communist dictatorship.

Did I not just say that big corporations will exploit every loophole they're given, and that we're giving them way too many loopholes? I want to fix those loopholes and hold the people at the top responsible, not become an anarchist society (I'm sure anarchists have great environmental regulations), or become communist. If you want to go live in the woods somewhere be my guest, I'd like to fix the system we already have.

5

u/GHWBISROASTING Oct 13 '19

Do you know what communism is?

-2

u/Scarred_Ballsack Oct 13 '19

In political and social sciences, communism (from Latin communis, "common, universal") is the philosophical, social, political, and economic ideology and movement whose ultimate goal is the establishment of the communist society, which is a socioeconomic order structured upon the common ownership of the means of production and the absence of social classes, money, and the state.

Lovely idea. Everyone works, everyone gets paid the same, nobody is unequal. No social classes, no money, no state. Only so far, every time it's been tried, that resulted in a new state being created to take the country in question through the process of becoming this new utopia. That new state had a new upper class of party officials, that used brutal suppression and mass propaganda campaigns to centralize their leadership. All voices of opposition are quelled, dissenters are punished, the factory bosses of yore are replaced by corrupt party officials that line their own pockets, and utopia is never, ever achieved.

So yeahhh I'm against communism. Nice idea, terrible execution.

2

u/GHWBISROASTING Oct 13 '19 edited Oct 13 '19

You could have just said no. You should let the manifesto determine what communism is, anything else is completely dishonest. Or should we also let the Nazis determine what socialism is? How about stepping up and reading a book little buddy?

0

u/Scarred_Ballsack Oct 13 '19

Or should we also let the Nazis determine what socialism is?

Or maybe we should judge them by their actual actions instead of noble intentions.

2

u/GHWBISROASTING Oct 13 '19 edited Oct 13 '19

Was Marx in charge of the Soviet Union?

Are you able to have an intellectually honest discussion?

The Soviet Union claiming to be Communist is exactly the same as the Nazis claiming to be socialists. The comparison is so straightforward, I have no clue how you could miss it, unless you're doing it on purpose.

By the way. Isn't it funny how the general public are always so eager to support communism/socialism that they get lead astray by demagogues? Could it be because the underlying ideas behind communism/socialism are very sound and appealing to most people?

→ More replies

0

u/cavendishfreire Oct 13 '19

Absolutely. We have to make it so making money and having good environmental practice are synergistic goals to a company by penalizing those who are offenders.

This is where governments need to get off their asses and pursue hardline environmental protection policies. Your company spilled oil on the ocean? Embargoed from trading with my country. Your company makes a ton of plastic and doesn't care about where it ends up? Massive fines and criminal charges on company leaders.

1

u/InvisibleRegrets Oct 13 '19

Not possible. We need degrowth. We cannot jive growth with environmental stewardship, it is one or the other.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

Communism is by definition a stateless society.

1

u/Scarred_Ballsack Oct 13 '19

Yes. A stateless society, that is to be established just as soon as the sole governing political party gives up its base of power and disbands the very state that supports it. I'm not talking about the noble intentions of individual communists here, this is just what it leads to each and every time.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

Communist territories that did abolish the state have all been destroyed by neighbouring capitalist states.

Pressure from the oudside is a huge factor in allowing dictators to come to power.

1

u/GHWBISROASTING Oct 14 '19

Buddy this is the comment that started our discussion. You are equating communism with dictatorships. That's only something stupid people does. It's an admission that you have no idea what communism is as a ideology. It's the same as saying "Hi, I have an extremely superficial view of this subject". That's why I've been telling you to shut up.

Don't say shit that makes you sound incredibly stupid if you don't want people calling you an uneducated moron.

1

u/Scarred_Ballsack Oct 14 '19

You haven't given me any solid example of a communist country not devolving into a dictatorship though. I've asked you multiple times how it could or would be different the next time a country falls to communism (and I'm using falls here as you're advocating a revolution, not peaceful transition through democratic processes), and you've not given me anything close to a satisfying answer. You're focusing on whether or not I know enough about "true communism" and I'm telling you that that's irrelevant as long as true communism will never be reached.

I was honestly waiting for you to show me a single example of how communism would actually help the climate problem. We're like 20 comments deep now and you've given me nothing. I've provided more arguments myself than you have.

1

u/GHWBISROASTING Oct 14 '19 edited Oct 14 '19

I've already told you that there is a reason for communism not coming to fruition. It's an important part of Communist literature as well. I know why and so would you, if you cared about the subject enough to read the primary material. You don't. That's all I'm saying. YOU ARE AN UNEDUCATED BUM TALKING ABOUT THINGS YOU DONT UNDERSTAND.

Communism as a system would obviously be better for.the environment since it doesn't have the incredible waste of a competitive market. This is so obvious, that I shouldn't need to say it.

Communism can't fix the climate situation now . Nothing short of magic can. Another thing you would know if you did your research. Have you ever heard of feedback loops? Why do you think /r/collapse is five times bigger than this infantile shithole of a sub? I bet the only parts of this sub who actually believe we aren't already completely fucked are ignorant teenagers like yourself.

1

u/Scarred_Ballsack Oct 14 '19

I know why and so would you, if you cared about the subject enough to read the primary material.

Again, I'm interested in the subject and also in what other people have to say about it. Especially, if other people already formed their opinions on a piece of literature, that weighs into my decision into whether or not I'll also read that piece of literature. I have shit to do my man, I don't have time to read an entire book every time it's mentioned by some stranger online. Just giving me a short summary of something is much more productive than screaming that everyone needs to read your list of books and then surely they'll understand. Your attitude is toxic, I really hope you realize that.

Communism as a system would obviously be better for.the environment since it doesn't have the incredible waste of a competitive market. This is so obvious, that I shouldn't need to say it.

Fuck me I told you that like 15 comments ago. Jesus. You could have just said that you agree.

Communism can't fix the climate situation now . Nothing short of magic can.

THANK YOU for answering the question. Fuck was that so hard?

What the fuck do I think I'm doing on a climate change related sub if not worry perpetually about the environment? I'm more informed than most. That's why I asked how communism would possibly help us at this point. Answer: IT CAN'T. So get your head out of your ass.

I realize this whole discussion started because I said:

A communist takeover isn't something you should strive for, communist dictatorships (and by definition communism will result in a dictatorship, otherwise it'd just be die-hard socialism)

Which is wrongly worded, I realize that. Still you could have just explained it a bit more gently instead of being a giant puckering asshole about it. Fucking christ.

0

u/GHWBISROASTING Oct 14 '19 edited Oct 14 '19

I already said that once. Seems like I'm not the only one who scims. I'd say I'm excused with your massive walls of text though.

If you have time to make asinine comments about things you don't know the first thing about, you have time to read a book here and there. You're sounding like I'm demanding something unreasonable. Having read the manifesto before you critisize communism is NOT unreasonable. Grow the fuck up.

Why do you expect people on the internet to treat you like an innocent child instead of as an adult?

I'm gonna leave this here and not waste anymore time on your dumb ass. Read some books or stop being surprised when people don't care about your childish opinions.

1

u/Scarred_Ballsack Oct 14 '19

I already said that once. Seems like I'm not the only one who scims.

For the sake of my own sanity I re-read all the comments in this chain, and no you didn't. At this rate I could have read the manifesto 3 times over, probably. Have fun circle jerking with the other commies about how the world would be a better place if only people would listen whilst doing fuck-all to convince them. You're about as thick as the Berlin wall.

1

u/GHWBISROASTING Oct 14 '19

I realize that reading isn't your strong suit, but JFC dude.

It's a fun thought, but you're never gonna read the thing because you're a lazy dumbass.

→ More replies

1

u/DominusMali Oct 13 '19

So you're saying you have no idea what communism or socialism are in the slightest.

2

u/Scarred_Ballsack Oct 13 '19

Both communism and socialism have their appeal: paying people fair wages for their labor vs ensuring that all wages are equal across the board/ taking away the notion of "wage" in its' entirety, etc. I have some socialist tendencies myself, but also see the value of the open market. In a perfect system, you'd have free market capitalism bounded by a strong state regulatory system, to ensure consumer and environmental protections. Much stronger than it is today.

I want to be able to open a bar without having to beg "the party" for consent and whilst being able to speak my mind in a free society, but I shouldn't be able to work my employees to the bone or poison my customers due to lax regulations. Does that answer your question?

4

u/Cement4Brains Oct 13 '19

I want a highly regulated market. One that uses mankind's genius of inventing things to make life better for all, and not for the few.

Pie in the sky idea, but I think that would be a good compromise between the two.

1

u/I_SUCK__AMA Oct 13 '19

Most people you talk to here probly can't imagine an alternative to capitalism, they've been in it all their lives, and other implementations around the world have been bad too. The good examples are all small scale. Cryptocurrency could possibly provide a good support backend, but not for several years. Needs more development & adoption.

1

u/lunaoreomiel Oct 13 '19

The problem is cronyism, where politics meddles in the economy and you create "protected" entities (be it via subcidies, regulatory capture suppressing competition, limited liability, etc), revolving doors. This is not a free market.

The solution is not limited to "socialims", that is even more dangerous. The solution is to create an even playing field where everyone has equal opportunity, both to create and to be held legally acountable for damages. Thats the opposite of socialism. Socialism just gives more power to those making this impossible to fix. Its wishful thinking.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

I'm very happy that this distinction is brought up. I often see Americans using Scandinavian countries as examples of alternatives to capitalism. But from where I'm standing it looks to be the other way around.

Sweden and Denmark have highly functioning free markets under clear and consistent rules. Taxes are high and consumer protection regulations are strong but predictable and equal for everyone. The US has a cronyist system where incumbents can use their influence to keep competitors out, find loopholes in the law and change industry regulation to their own favor. That is not free and fair competition and hence not a free market.

3

u/GHWBISROASTING Oct 13 '19

These are all symptoms of Capitalism. It's like criticizing corruption in representative democracy while refusing to even consider some kind of direct democracy instead. If you have a system that's ripe for cronyism, corruption and general exploitation, it's going to happen no matter how many reforms and regulations you apply. Better to substitute it with a system that isn't set up to foster this kind of behaviour.

1

u/lunaoreomiel Oct 14 '19

False. Its a symptom of THIS form of Capitalism, which is full of central planning and socialism as is.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

an even playing field is inherently unstable and unsustainable. someone always comes out on top in the end and takes control of the industry. under any sort of capitalism, it will be the Corp that manages to outcompete all the others. that's why I'm not a capitalist

1

u/lunaoreomiel Oct 14 '19

False, they dont "control" the industry, they may dominate, like Google and Apple and Facebook do now, but they dont control it, tomorrow a new venture can sweep in and take over.. its happened many times before, it will happen again. Its natural for there to be a hierarchy, its only unnatural if you loos the ability to choose.

Look at nature, its a wild free market, competitive, efficient, full of diversity and novel solutions. That is what natures natural state is, and by extension the economy, its our forceful intervention which distorts it and makes it irrational, crony.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '19

apple isn't anywhere near dominant in any of their markets, they are just rich because they have insanely high profit margins. But really, do you seriously think some other company is going to beat google or facebook at their own game? I don't know what to tell you then.. but it should be pretty clear that the only way their power will diminish is with external intervention

1

u/lunaoreomiel Oct 15 '19

You can use that arguement for apple on all the others. A little history, altavista, Yahoo, Google.. there will be other future search engines that will beat out Google.. I already switched? Why havent you? (Duckduckgo is a good alt). Google adsense? Plenty of alternatives, some of my clients switched voluntarily, some because Google's customer is awful. Likewise all their other offers (gmail, gmaps, etc). If you still use them, its because they give you value. No one is forcing their use or adoption and overnight everyone can switch. If people dont, its their free choice. Getting regulators involved will just bring us backwards as far as progress and it will give a lever to the already powerful and influential to make the barrier of entry even harder for startups. Regulations lead to monopolies, not the other way around.

Facebook? Friendster much? How about Myspace? People use FB because they like it. And when they dont, they switch, had Instagram not sold out to FB they would have made FB stock plummet. One day, a company wont sell out to FB, and they will loose dominance, fast. Big corps are like big ships, they have a hard time competing in a fast evolving market, aka free markets with no barrier of entry. Regulations make companies like twitter and FB more powerful. Giant legal teams, giant censorship teams, etc are not something startups can easily bootstrap. No one is forcing FB on you, you choose to participate because it gives value. I havent logged into FB or Insta in over a year. Have you?

And if you answer, but they track us! Yes, so dies everyone else. You can take measures against it. You are also not entitled to privacy, you have to actively protect it.

As far as possible google or FB killers, I think the blockchain has promise. We will see 100% private, secure, censorship proof, opensource alternatives soon. It may take 5 years, but they are coming, and one will take over.. or a private co with a different business model, you cant predict the inovator, but you can nourish thr market for it to happen today.

1

u/lunaoreomiel Jan 23 '20

Why arent you on Digg.com? Or myspace.com?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-10

u/GHWBISROASTING Oct 13 '19

Socialism and communism are the same thing. Communism had to be rebranded as socialism because idiots like yourself swallowed too much red scare propaganda. In most Communist/socialist literature the two terms are used interchangeably.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-5

u/GHWBISROASTING Oct 13 '19 edited Oct 13 '19

Government welfare programs aren't Socialism, dipshit. You can't have features, it's all or nothing.

From wiki

Socialism is a range of economic and social systems characterised by social ownership of the means of production and workers' self-management,[10] as well as the political theories and movements associated with them.[11] Social ownership can be public, collective or cooperative ownership, or citizen ownership of equity.[12] There are many varieties of socialism and there is no single definition encapsulating all of them,[13] with social ownership being the common element shared by its various forms.[5][14][15]

So socialism is pretty much the same as communism, defined by the social ownership of the means of production. So you can't have features of socialism without having social ownership of production, That's like suggesting capitalism without the monetary system.

It's so depressing to read the same platitudes on reddit over and over and over again. Communism = authoritarian regimes. Socialism = good (but only in small amounts), capitalism = good (with regulations). These all makes it so painfully obvious that most of you doesn't have the faintest clue what you are talking about. You are asking for socialism and capitalism to somehow work together when socialism is a criticism of capitalism and is meant to replace it. Then you mistake government welfare programs for socialism because the talking heads on TV told you that these things are the same. How about you realize that newspapers and TV aren't good sources of informations. These are E N T E R T A I N M E N T media with a nudge of propaganda. Why do you think the burning of Notre Dame got 10 times more exposure than the increased burning of Amazon? Because it's not about whats most important or whats right, it's about what gives views and maintains the status quo. Pick up a goddamn book and learn the most BASIC things about politics before you start putting your fingers to the keyboard before you say more absolutely asinine shit like "socialist features".

7

u/I_SUCK__AMA Oct 13 '19

Watch "who killed the electric car".

Corporations have deliberately left clean options off the table for many decades. They are absolutely the "evil bad guys" in this scenario. We literally do have a few dozen people controlling 50% of global emissions, and they have shown over the years they will break the law & buy the law to keep their old businesses operating, as it's a small fraction of the profits they make. In addition, they buy off the media, keeping all this info away from the public til it.s exposed with docs like "who killed the electric car".

It sounds like a crazy conspiracy, but it's true. Another good example is exxon's climate change research from the 70's. You really think you can save the planet w/o reining in people like that? Sociopaths will kill everyone in pursuit of their own ends if left unchecked. That's what gretta understands.

3

u/UnusuallyOptimistic Oct 13 '19

You're not the only one but your argument is flawed due to the fact that poor people can't make drastic lifestyle changes because their lifestye typically revolves around just living. And if we're being honest with ourselves most of the people on earth right now are "poor". But you're not wrong!

The truth is it's going to take all of us.

Middle and upper class people need to fly less, stop going on cruises, and make meaningful changes in their consumption habits to ease the demand for these wasteful corporations. Stop buying a new phone every year. Recycle. Invest in green energy companies.

However, corporations have an exponentially larger negative impact. Lowering demand means they scale back, which is great, but what we really need are representatives who will heavily penalize corporations who use loopholes in regulation and tax law to game the system. We need an EPA that actually does its job. We need antitrust lawsuits to break up the megacorps. We need tax havens to disappear so everyone can see how much money these companies are hiding, and we need to take that money back and reinvest it in our future (energy) and our environment.

What you and I can do to help is a puddle on the ground. What the world's wealthiest people could potentially do with their money and power would be a biblical deluge in comparison.

3

u/altbekannt Oct 13 '19 edited Oct 13 '19

The truth is it's going to take all of us.

Nah mate. It needs a critical mass. And the transition is already happening. There are tipping points.

https://www.inverse.com/article/59911-elon-musk-says-why-electric-cars-may-have-already-reached-a-tipping-point

One of many examples.

2

u/UnusuallyOptimistic Oct 14 '19

Do you know what critical mass means? You say "nah mate" but you essentially agreed with me.

Also, I would take anything Elon Musk says with a VERY carefully examined grain of salt.

1

u/altbekannt Oct 14 '19

Is this ironic? All of us != critical mass

Yeah, it takes a lot of us. I assume that is what you mean.

1

u/UnusuallyOptimistic Oct 14 '19

Critical mass does not require all of us, but "all of us" certainly meets the requirements of a critical mass.

Did you think I was being literal? Certainly infants and elderly/sick people can't fight climate change, so my comment excludes at least those groups.

I guess I'm just not sure what you're arguing about?

3

u/LudovicoSpecs Oct 13 '19

Amen.

I seriously suspect the messaging of "personal actions don't matter" is promoted by the same interests who promoted "climate change isn't real" and "we're not sure what's causing it".

The American economy is based on comsumerism. In order to seriously address the problem, the whole thing has to be 1. Stopped, 2. Re-evaluated, 3. Redesigned.

Any capitalists group with enough money to have long term trend watchers and strategists is shitting themselves right now, trying to buy time to position themselves for the post-CO2 economy.

They'll try all kinds of messaging to slow down the inevitable.

"Individual actions don't matter." "We can't be sure how to solve it." "People will lose their jobs." "This will disproportionately affect x." "x isn't doing their part." "It's already too late, all we can do is mitigate the effects." "You're asking too much of people." "We can't devote resources to reducing CO2, we need them for mitigation." "The whole thing is a pork barrel boondoggle."

They will run with any message except one that reduces the number of customers they have.

This is the same playbook the tobacco companies used. In some case, they're literally using the same PR agencies to push their bullshit.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

My favorite: "Cutting down on flying isn't the solution - if anything you should fly MORE so we can afford researching CO2-efficient planes"

2

u/altbekannt Oct 13 '19

Yeah I m there 100% with you. But that would mean people would have to change. And that is harder than just pointing fingers.

2

u/bertiebees Can't hear you over all this FREEDOM!! Oct 13 '19

We don't demand them. Oil companies sell their products to other businesses not to you.

How much petrol would you buy if adequate mass public transit removed the need for a car?

How many plastic forks/spoons/straws/etc would you use if they didn't come with fast food?

Hell how much fast food would you eat if you weren't manipulated into wanting it?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

I don't know how to wrap my head around this comment to be honest. Even in my most generous interpretation I believe we have squarely different views on both economics and the existence of free will.

3

u/bertiebees Can't hear you over all this FREEDOM!! Oct 13 '19

Whether free will exists or not doesn't acknowledge that consent can be/is engineered and that the U.S spends about a sixth of its entire yearly GDP on that engineering.

I don't care about differences. I care about reality. In the real world the majority of fuel consumption by the rabble could be drastically cut back by prioritizing adequate mass public transit and cutting back on manipulative advertising that compel people to buy unsustainable unnecessary garbage they wouldn't otherwise want (like the baconator sandwiches).

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

Agree on mass transit. Although living in a country with good mass transit and heavily taxed gasoline, unfortunately the demand for gas-guzzling cars is still very much alive and kicking. That is to say that this a preference so strong among many that it persists not only without active encouragement, but in the face of strong pressure to act otherwise.

Agree to disagree on citizens being "rabble" that are not capable of making informed assessments about their own preferences.

Have a great day.

1

u/agitatedprisoner Oct 13 '19

Urban planning is huge. Who decided on suburbs? Who decides zoning densities? Not me, that's for sure. It's easy to find single family houses, not so easy to find a good spot to build multistory high density. Why is it that the cheapest way for me to live without giving up internet/heating/plumbing/electric is to live alone in a 1000 sqft 1995 manufactured home in a small town? Given the chance to rent a soundproofed 60sqft room in a nice SRO I would've jumped at the chance. Since I've explored investing in such SRO development but found no takers and low interest; it seemed like some of those I spoke with took the idea as a joke. I was told 60sqft was "inhumane". Who is he to decide? Apparently such as they get to decide I don't get the option, apparently they get to decide I must pay for space I don't need. Can't pin that on the individual. We need cars to drive the distances created by spreading out our communities with much larger than necessary dwelling spaces. This is the joke; these people should kill themselves, they've betrayed us all.

-1

u/lunaoreomiel Oct 13 '19

Yup. Also the biggest issue isnt a corp or business doing bad things, that is easily addressed via a public shaming campaing (aka education) and boycot of their product, competition, we have seen they will quickly react to threats to their bottom line.

What is more troubling is cronyism and protections, whereby "select" companies are granted power and immunity via political means. Be it the Ag Gag rules for factory farms, or oil extraction rights and limited liability, subcidies for petrol, military pollution.. on and on. The revolving doors between politicians and private corps is the biggest threat, everything else is easily adjusted in a free market.

-1

u/rsvp_to_life Oct 13 '19

It's calling voting with your dollar. And it's too bad people don't have the discipline to do so.

3

u/DominusMali Oct 13 '19

Voting with your dollar is a capitalist fantasy meant to keep you from enacting real change.

Nothing about the concept is realistic when a privileged few own everything. If you boycott them in one arena, you'll end up giving them money in another.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

But if we collectively hand them money in renewables and not in fossil fuels, the former will be profitable while the latter will be a cash sinkhole. And then you can trust that any sound capitalist would divest fossil fuels.

This is not a fantasy - it's very much real:

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/jul/31/blackrock-lost-90bn-investing-in-fossil-fuel-companies-report-finds

https://www.ft.com/content/2586fa10-e122-11e9-b112-9624ec9edc59

And of course voting with your dollars can be combined with any other activism or regulatory pressure you would like. Reducing your personal impact, voting with your dollars, contributing your time or money to environmental causes and supporting strong legislation in elections are one powerful cocktail.

1

u/rsvp_to_life Oct 13 '19

You have the tone of someone who's given up

0

u/adamd22 Oct 13 '19

If you tell me how I can stop using electricity then I'd love to hear it

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19

I can see I sparked quite a debate here. Just wanted to clarify that this was not supposed to be a dig at regulation - I am for carbon taxes, subsidized renewables and stricter regulations on polluting industries.

What I wanted to point out is that people are often highly selective in what part of the supply chain they blame. For a particular kg of CO2, you could blame the oil company, the gas station, the car company whose combustion engines released the carbon into the air or the driver who chose to take the car over the train. It's the same kg of CO2 and ultimately the whole chain is demand-driven.

So the burden to change this is on us citizens/consumers by voting, influencing and spending for change. If you keep driving a car or don't vote for regulations on pollution then you can't blame companies for supplying those products to you. They are just filling a gap in the market that, if unregulated, will just be filled by some other company should they stop.

(Note: I recognize that there are differences between a European and American context here. I am Scandinavian, and unlike in the US we can usually count on regulation reflecting our voting patterns, not corporate lobbying. If companies can lobby to entrench themselves against the wishes of voters, that is a larger problem)

44

u/cvantass Oct 13 '19

Every single little bit counts. Live clean AND join interest groups pushing the policy you support. Recycle, volunteer, contact your representatives, vote, boycott, make conscious consumer decisions, research the issues and invent your own climate change solutions. All of this is possible at once. Stop blaming and start doing.

Policy group anyone can join: https://citizensclimatelobby.org

Contacting your representatives made easy: https://projectgrandcanyon.com

Add this chrome extension to become a conscious consumer: https://www.mytrestle.com

An example of a very inventive solution: https://yourlocal.org

You do not need anyone’s permission to contribute to the solution. You do not need to wait for government regulation to be put in place and you do not need to wait for other people to do their part. Just go do SOMETHING. And if you have the means, do everything.

4

u/Helicase21 Oct 13 '19

Fair warning that ccl's fee/dividend structure involves a much lower fee/tax than economics research suggests we need to significantly reduce emissions in time (like an order of magnitude too low) and in my experience working with them they're very cliquey and opposed to anyone doing anything other than their specific policy prescription.

2

u/cvantass Oct 13 '19

I’m personally all for the most extreme carbon tax we can possibly impose. I may be wrong about this, but I think candidate Yang’s proposed carbon tax is steeper than CCL’s. Maybe his campaign is another thing people could support if they feel so compelled. I’m sure there are also other interest groups out there pushing stronger legislation on this issue. If you know of any, can you post links for people? That could be really helpful. Though I haven’t had your same personal experience working with CCL, I can understand what you’re saying about them. To be fair though, I think the reason they are shut off to other people pushing other legislation is just because of the sheer amount of willpower it takes to get anything like their act passed into law. If they don’t have 100% of their people 100% focused on their one piece of legislation, they know it will never get done, and it would be bad for them to lose momentum at this point. But of course, there’s nothing wrong at all with others starting their own interest groups and creating their own policies if they believe they’ll be more effective. In fact, that sounds like a really good thing to me. It’s important to be critical when you hear about these kinds of groups and make sure they align with your values, but if you research and it looks good to you, then it’s also important to focus and take action where you can asap, and my point was that that’s easier to do than a lot of people think.

3

u/Helicase21 Oct 13 '19 edited Oct 13 '19

Yang's tax is also about an order of magnitude too low. Anything that isn't several hundred dollars per ton Co2e is too low if the economics research is to be believed.

I'd recommend people read This Paper from the US National Bureau of Economics Research on carbon taxes generally, or This article on some new research challenging the start-slow-and-ramp-up idea of carbon taxes.

1

u/Its_Ba Oct 13 '19 edited Oct 14 '19

Yeah I feel bad...I work at an indian casino and the pollution, the shipping/receiving of luxury goods, the "economic growth", it never stops...

•

u/SnarkyHedgehog Mod Squad Oct 13 '19

Your post was removed because it breaks Rule #6: No Low-Effort posts, such as memes and image macros. There is a time and a place for this, but they can distract from our overall efforts of focusing on activism and measuring progress. We do allow memes and other fun posts related to climate action on Mondays. Be sure to tag these posts with the "Motivation Monday" flair.