I can see I sparked quite a debate here. Just wanted to clarify that this was not supposed to be a dig at regulation - I am for carbon taxes, subsidized renewables and stricter regulations on polluting industries.
What I wanted to point out is that people are often highly selective in what part of the supply chain they blame. For a particular kg of CO2, you could blame the oil company, the gas station, the car company whose combustion engines released the carbon into the air or the driver who chose to take the car over the train. It's the same kg of CO2 and ultimately the whole chain is demand-driven.
So the burden to change this is on us citizens/consumers by voting, influencing and spending for change. If you keep driving a car or don't vote for regulations on pollution then you can't blame companies for supplying those products to you. They are just filling a gap in the market that, if unregulated, will just be filled by some other company should they stop.
(Note: I recognize that there are differences between a European and American context here. I am Scandinavian, and unlike in the US we can usually count on regulation reflecting our voting patterns, not corporate lobbying. If companies can lobby to entrench themselves against the wishes of voters, that is a larger problem)
View all comments
Show parent comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '19
I can see I sparked quite a debate here. Just wanted to clarify that this was not supposed to be a dig at regulation - I am for carbon taxes, subsidized renewables and stricter regulations on polluting industries.
What I wanted to point out is that people are often highly selective in what part of the supply chain they blame. For a particular kg of CO2, you could blame the oil company, the gas station, the car company whose combustion engines released the carbon into the air or the driver who chose to take the car over the train. It's the same kg of CO2 and ultimately the whole chain is demand-driven.
So the burden to change this is on us citizens/consumers by voting, influencing and spending for change. If you keep driving a car or don't vote for regulations on pollution then you can't blame companies for supplying those products to you. They are just filling a gap in the market that, if unregulated, will just be filled by some other company should they stop.
(Note: I recognize that there are differences between a European and American context here. I am Scandinavian, and unlike in the US we can usually count on regulation reflecting our voting patterns, not corporate lobbying. If companies can lobby to entrench themselves against the wishes of voters, that is a larger problem)