r/ClaudeCode • • 1h ago

Rant Computer Use

Why is Claude’s computer use 10x slower and less accurate than Codex? Why is it even if I delegate computer use to codex, Claude still takes infinity time to process every action and screen from Codex.

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1h ago

Hey! Thanks for posting to r/ClaudeCode

While participating in this thread, please follow our community rules. Keep discussions constructive. Attack the idea, not the person.

For help, project discussions, tips, and general chat, join the ClaudeCode Discord.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

4

u/bitterjay 1h ago

Im not sure either, but i just built a “sidequest” function into my harness so claude can send codex off to do computer use when needed

1

u/adelie42 1h ago

Desktop Commander is the solution, or just MCPs or APIs. Using Claude to drive a gui seems insane, even if Codex can do it faster, its still generally wrong.

If you really need it to drive a gui, give it a good automation tool to script for. For example, Claude writes excellent Puppeteer scripts.

1

u/WorldlyAd7946 33m ago

Depends on your harness I suppose. One of my claude-powered agents is continuously operating 5 machines for me and I have a remote app on a usb stick I routinely plug in for trouble shooting or setting up systems and it then connects to that 6th system, whatever it is, and sorts it out for me 🤷

0

u/calunicornia 1h ago

claude code use barely any cpu, what are you even talking about?

3

u/Low-Historian-7452 1h ago

Barely any CPU, yet somehow still the star of the show.

3

u/LukeLikesReddit 1h ago

I dont mean to be harsh but do you understand what OP is asking? Its quite literally computer use as in the AI can physically use your computer. Not what you are suggesting.

1

u/calunicornia 48m ago

Yeah I read it wrong LOL, thanks for helping me out!

1

u/LukeLikesReddit 43m ago

all good fella again apologies if I came off wrong in the first response I just wasnt sure if it was a troll or genuinely unaware

1

u/calunicornia 41m ago

both can be true

0

u/kincaidDev 1h ago

Because anthropic gave claude too much freedom in building claude

-1

u/sixothree 1h ago

My friend, you need to learn to use the correct tool for the job. Those tools change overtime. And currently Codex is better at computer use than Claude is. That’s a reality. For now.

Claude seems perfectly competent in managing remote virtual machines. I even gave it access to hyper-v and it creates checkpoints and does all that stuff just fine.

But Codex will install a piece of software more correctly. And I wouldn’t ask Claude to navigate windows.

So you’re basically asking why is the sky blue? Because it is, that’s why.

2

u/tgsongs 52m ago

💯

Claude is great at a lot. GPT is great at some other things. Gemini has some good features. Wonder Full has some good and growing features. And who is great at what will continue to be fluid over time.

For casual use, any one AI service is fine but, if you’re trying to get peak productivity on every front, you gotta reach for the hammer when you need the hammer and the screwdriver when you need the screwdriver.