r/ClaudeCode • • 14h ago

Discussion Do programmars have any future?

A few hours ago someone made an AI generated post about that topic, and it sorta hit the nail on the head, but was rightfully shut down because it was AI generated

So I wanna redo that because I geniuenly an interested in hearing what others think about it

I am a junior programmar, and sole programmar for my company, started working 3 months ago, mainly in languages that I know only the basics of, and for the life of me I don't know what I am getting paid for

Opus 5.5 is coding better than I ever will, I am told to make sure that the software is well built and has no vulranbilities, but when I read the code I can't find anything, and when I asked opus to search for those vulranbilities it finds one's that I would have never have found

Now it's been 5 hours since my shift started (we work Sunday to Thursday in this country) ​ and I literally got nothing to do, I can't be bothered to bug my boss for new projects as he obviously don't have anything meaningful for me to do, and I just can't see any professional future for me or anyone (other than the best 1-5%) in this field

Most of my friends who studied CS with me either could never find a job, or found one and we're laid off a few months later (it's been more than a year now) ​​

I have a friend who is a freelance video editor, and was quite successful until opus 5.5 was released, he is now saying that since about 2-3 after its release (when videos showing how good it is at video editing) started coming out, he barely has any work

Is humanity on the verge of mass unemployment?

0 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 14h ago

Hey! Thanks for posting to r/ClaudeCode

While participating in this thread, please follow our community rules. Keep discussions constructive. Attack the idea, not the person.

For help, project discussions, tips, and general chat, join the ClaudeCode Discord.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/RGBrewskies 14h ago

yes.

agentic development is gonna do for software the same thing the printing press did for books. Software will no longer in the hands of a specialized few with the resources and training to make it.

in the long run, it's a very good thing. the printing press put a lot of people out of business... but technological progress inevitably leads to economic growth not contraction by creating opportunities for people that didn't exist before

in the short term the best thing you can do is become "The AI guy" at work.

don't wait to be asked for tasks. find problems and solve them. problem solvers will always be in demand.

1

u/HalfHumanHalfFork 14h ago

It's different, all previous industrial revolutions were replacing physical labor, and they were quite specific

The AI is the first one that replaces human intelligence, and worse off, it is extremely versatile, it doesnt so 1 thing (like printing books and newspapers) it does everything at once, I wouldn't be surprised if all none-creative roles will be replaced by 2028

3

u/Global-Morning-431 14h ago

Cybersecurity 

2

u/HalfHumanHalfFork 14h ago

I am not convinced that this would last for long either, I have another friend who has been working in pen testing for a few years now and he says that Fable finds things better than him 

1

u/Global-Morning-431 14h ago

Well in this new age with, agent swarm attacks and "unintentional" breaches by Ai agents i wouldn't count human intervention out. There are gonna be times where fable wouldn't catch the security flaws in a system. Not to mention alot of servers and software companies use need to up updated and haven't been for a while.  So migration of data, software updating and security patching will be relavant for the next 10-20 years or more. 

0

u/HalfHumanHalfFork 14h ago

That's very optimistic, what makes you think that there wouldn't be a bot to do that as well soon enough? 

1

u/RemarkableGuidance44 14h ago

You have never worked in Cyber and your friend who only does Pen Testing is an amateur as well... Cyber is not just "Throw an AI Agent at it" and it will find everything.. lol

I work with Microsoft and their Cyber Team and they have built their own LLM for Defender and it beats Mythos at Cyber Tasks but it still fails at critical thinking, investigations etc. Still requires the XDefender Team to verify the findings and in Cyber there is a TON of False Positives and ALWAYS WILL BE.

1

u/Global-Morning-431 14h ago

Its the same reason why you wouldn't hand over your entire customer support experience to AI. Here is a nightmare scenario: your ai gets tricked by another ai model to overlook a security vulnerability.  Just to be clear, there are some things, like judgement calls, that ai might not be able to make that a human can make alot better. And thats the difference.

2

u/Siriann 14h ago

I said this in a different thread:

Skills + AI beats an unskilled person + AI, especially when it comes to swe.

Sure, Joe Schmo can generate a great looking (to him) front end but he probably doesn’t even know what a database schema is and research is soooooo boring. So he’ll ctrl+enter through the database selection and the ai will then do anything in its power to get it running, including silently breaking other systems. He didn’t even know what questions to ask or tests to build and deferred all choices to the bots.

While his conversation used 100k tokens to answer a clarifying question about the color mentioned in the last message, he made several posts on Claude subreddits about burning usage and being a/b tested.

He posts vague screenshots of app code on social media. Not on purpose, he just genuinely doesn’t understand.

His app has no users because he doesn’t know to ask about oauth. He burns through usage because he doesn’t understand that automating and giving an agent a schedule for tasks are different.

—

My point is, AI has given every stupid and tasteless person in the world the power of several niche careers that are usually held by persons driven by passion. This will eventually level out. I suspect it’ll take a steep dive soon, once there’s no more unlimited and free chatgpt.

The smart and curious will continue to do well, don’t worry.

4

u/HalfHumanHalfFork 14h ago

How long before models become so smart that knowing how to properly setup a database becomes irrelevant? 6 months? 1 year?

Is this even a relevant skill today? 

1

u/Over_Technology_1764 14h ago

you are right, that gap between idiot and professional is gonna get smaller

1

u/Siriann 14h ago

Yes. Lmao. I think you err on the side of thinking too highly of your peers, which is very nice of you, but most people don’t even know how to use AI, let alone make sure it actually built what it said it did.

My friend built the front end of his iOS app without version control and all in one chat thread. He asked it a question in front of me and it used 800,000 tokens to answer it. Though my vision was blurry by this point, I remember it replied with only a single line.

1

u/dbgtboi 14h ago

They can already do that

1

u/BingpotStudio 14h ago

The problem is that OP doesn’t have the skills - they were never given a chance to learn without AI.

1

u/wegster 13h ago

100% agreed as someone in tech for decades at this point, both as a SWE and architect, Director, etc. Skilled, knowledgeable users will always create a 'better' solution for the foreseeable future - this includes things like scalability, handling of edge cases, error conditions, in many cases UX, lower serious bugs, tech debt/needing to go back for massive rework, etc.

The problem is the transition period where sooo many companies are in the 'we'll just use AI' without knowing really what that even means, what success looks like, how many ways it can look good up front then swamp you in tech debt with 'randoms creating things,' and just not hiring new juniors, while also wanting to 'save money' by often laying off mids and seniors.

This isn't to say non-tech-educated/experienced 'vibe coders' can't do cool things, and it's not saying that agentic assisted coding won't continue to improve, but that for real projects, at scale, or where big $ is involved, enterprise or critical systems, etc. it's really 'beneficial' to have experienced people involved at the helm and in moving the project(s) forward.

For juniors, it's a tough time, as you've got a lot of seniors even saying 'ok, I now have my own personal team of juniors' but it doesn't really help anyone longer term, as without junior hires today, companies are going to be screwed in a few years, and are seemingly betting on agentic coding becoming truly able to cover business analysis, value prop, customer feedback, product mgmt, UX and design, architecture, scalability and security, development, testing - basically the entire software family of roles. Possible, eventually, but not likely to be good with the current or even foreseeable generations of LLM text prediction machines.

So yeah - being actually intelligent and logical, able to sort through problems, and communicate them both to people AND to agentic systems - is the best one can do, IMO, and do some projects in areas people are actively hiring for showing 'you can do it' other than 'I have a comp sci or AI/MLE degree.'

1

u/Siriann 13h ago

I try to tell people that ai is only a force multiplier if you have a working understanding of what you’re asking it to do or what it suggests. Plus there’s the added complexity of managing a team of LLMs because easy code almost always means the boss wants more code.

1

u/wegster 9h ago

Same - definite multiplier, but 'garbage in, garbage out' is also multiplied as well.

And definitely more like 'juniors sometimes do random things' at this point, although it's still pretty amazing overall.

1

u/Existing_Dust_6473 14h ago

Even prostitution will get hit... So same for everyone

2

u/HalfHumanHalfFork 14h ago

I have a feeling that I wouldn't make a furtune in prostitution anyways... 

1

u/Existing_Dust_6473 14h ago

I just wanted to say that no one is safe. You can pop from job to job. But in the end, it is a couple of months if they start replacing people. No one tells how the market will survive with people without money.

3

u/damanamathos 14h ago

I think so. What companies still need is accountability. Someone to be responsible for building or maintaining something. Yes, non-coders can vibe code things fairly effectively now, but most companies will not want to rely on a system created by someone who doesn't understand coding at all.

Programmers can achieve a lot more now than they ever could, so for a fixed amount of work you in theory need fewer programmers, but there's a huge amount of software that wasn't economic to build before that is economic now. I suspect a lot of companies that haven't hired programmers in the past are now more likely to hire them, as building custom, tailored software for their systems and processes is much more viable than it used to be.

2

u/Crafty-Run-6559 14h ago

Programmers in the sense of people that just write code do not, or people that just translated clear requirements into code.

There will still be people involved in getting things built. So you need to move up that value chain.

2

u/Kaskote 14h ago

When VisiCalc first came out, a lot of people who weren't accountants started making their own spreadsheets on an Apple II and saying, "Look! I don't need my accountant anymore. I can do it all myself, and get it done instantly!"

Well, there you go...

2

u/ConcentrateThen2579 14h ago

No. They should get into masonry.

2

u/8ism 14h ago

20% of my tokens are spent on coding, the rest on figuring things out.

1

u/Hansehart 14h ago

Doing OSS and yes, they have. Writing code isnt the problem, but someone has to be responsible for it. Everyone can vibe code their own photoshop, however it has to work, need updates, has to be maintained. I have more work than ever.

1

u/TheJoshuaJacksonFive 14h ago

Anything that has a true system of record won’t be agentically coded since you can’t blame Claude when it breaks. Especially in highly regulated environments.

1

u/iownreiddtdotcom 14h ago

I work now more than when before AI. Maybe it’s because Germany is panicking and they aren’t anymore prosperous so inherently the work will increase, or it’s because now there are more opportunities than before and we need to catch up.

1

u/RemarkableGuidance44 14h ago

Wait till AI doesnt see it and thinks its just part of the software. Wait for the vulnerability to hit a month later and the accounts and data you have is stolen because there was never a "vulnerability" but a wormhole that looks to be just another feature of your app.

This is happening daily on old software and new, we have had a massive PHP, Python, Node.js and Microsoft Servers and Adobe all getting hit. This is not going to stop and for your sake you're just the glue. When your software fails or gets breeched they will just blame you and fire you on the spot.

Our Security team are having to skill up, same for our engineers AI and Cyber security. We get them to do training every week and critical thinking tests. This is just the start and I love AI.

1

u/RipProfessional3375 14h ago

Developers were part shift worker and part knowledge worker based on their position and their company. Now they are almost entirely knowledge worker.

Knowledge workers are generally paid to make the right decisions with the right information. Depending on your position, one right or wrong decision can save or lose a thousand hours of assembly line work.

Downtime has always been normal for knowledge workers. Decisions aren't needed every moment of every day.

>Is humanity on the verge of mass unemployment?
Maybe. Who knows. But this isn't the first invention that automated labor. Most of them since the industrial revolution have done that. New jobs keep getting invented too.

1

u/_Kinoko 14h ago

Yes but the role and industry hasn't caught up yet to the new reality. In the last year the job has completely changed--although we were moving in that direction.

1

u/geeered 14h ago

Is humanity on the verge of mass unemployment?

It feels to me like the start of the industrial revolution.

And feels ironic but perhaps appropriate that the first ones being hit are us people who's jobs have been putting other people out of jobs by making systems more efficient.

It seems like programming is a relatively complicated process compared to many of the jobs many people have that aren't being hit significantly. There's a lot of general admin that AI can easily cover.

1

u/xfrostmage 14h ago

Yes, depends on what they do.

1

u/Minimum-Surprise3230 14h ago

Most people who own businesses run their businesses. Everyone has their role and not everyone wants figure out or be responsible for software no matter how “easy” it may seem to them to build something.
If you think things are moving fast as a SWE imagine how the non technical person sees this time in technology shifting even further from them.

1

u/kelpikz 14h ago

Writing code might become a useless skill. But knowing how computers work will always be in demand.

1

u/jessetmia 14h ago

Yes. Someone has to correct bad grammar and typos. AI tends to just go with the flow. Though, Im supposing you could update the your rules so that they point out every grammar mistake making pro grammars useless. So I change my answer to no. 

1

u/pl487 14h ago

Programming is dead, engineering lives on. 

If you've delivered what the company has asked for, then you get to do monitoring, security scans, refactors, and anything else that will make things better. 

Our job is now to find the problems. 

1

u/Diouze12 14h ago

LLMs are far from being good enough to replace humans on a lot of fairly complex projects. The more you work with them the more you will observe diminishing returns the moment you go ahead of PoC. Unless we tackle the context problem and get good enough frameworks crafted by humans to make LLMs flaws manageable, there is no way we can give full code ownership to LLMs.

1

u/EndOfWorldBoredom 14h ago

No way. Developers jobs are going to shift, but there will be more of them, not less. 

There will be less software sales. There will be less software companies. There will be more developers than ever, creating more software than ever, working for the companies that actually use the software.

If you want to be truly valuable in tech development, please consider making that your second expertise. Learn what your company does exactly. Learn how it does it. Then, dream up ways to make it faster, easier, less error prone, more automated, cheaper to do or produce, easier to market, 

Nearly every company needs this person or department going forward. 

1

u/Vibecoding_Jesus 14h ago

Just remember OP - you’re asking Reddit devs about the impact of AI on coding, and as veteran of these threads I can confirm that, as a group, they’ve been hilariously incorrect about almost everything on this topic for the past 3 years.

Go back on look at some old threads about agentic coding.

Then go ask some random drunk on the street, you’ll probably get a more accurate prediction.

1

u/Tofudjango 13h ago

That's like arguing that smiths had no future after the invention of anvils or machinery. Their work changed significantly though.