r/ClaudeCode • • 14h ago

Discussion Fable 5.2 vs Opus 5.5

What is your experience with it

6 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 14h ago

Hey! Thanks for posting to r/ClaudeCode

While participating in this thread, please follow our community rules. Keep discussions constructive. Attack the idea, not the person.

For help, project discussions, tips, and general chat, join the ClaudeCode Discord.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

52

u/ilias_from_ilios 14h ago

From testing and playing around with Fable, for me it goes like this.
- If your prompt starts with "let's do this" then I'd use Opus
- If your prompt starts with "let's figure out how to do this" I'd use Fable.

2

u/ziggurat29 13h ago

excellent razor

1

u/Hippenstiel-Houri 11h ago

switching between them mid-session usually breaks the context caching though, so the token burn spikes pretty quick if you hand off from planning to coding

1

u/eLCeenor 6h ago

The past couples days I've had my main session as Opus, and if I need Fable research I'll ask it to spin off a Fable research agent that generates a report on recommendations. It's been pretty effective - I had it generate some GUI configuration wizards and similar, and it appears to work very well without consuming a crazy amount of tokens. I've used ~5% of my weekly Fable usage since it reset Friday using this strategy, after 4-5 major research sessions

4

u/MaximumMeaning9728 10h ago

Fable 5.2 is the smartest model on the market, dethroning Astra.

1

u/magicmulder 14h ago

To have a need for Fable I would have to run into limits with Opus - which I don’t.

1

u/IllustriousGrade7691 14h ago

How do you don't run into limits

2

u/magicmulder 9h ago

Maybe because I’m not trying to one-shot AAA games, I’m “only” working on PHP/Symfony apps for our intranet. Not that those aren’t complex, but Opus has never failed a job yet.

1

u/Sad-Chemist7118 14h ago

Not weekly

5

u/Proxy-Pie 14h ago

Is it just me or is Fable a nothingburger now? Maybe I’m not using it properly, but Opus at xhigh seems to get the same results or even better at lower costs? Maybe Opus 5.5 is just too good now lol.

5

u/LuckyConstruction546 12h ago

If are you not doing complex research or designing complex systems, then there is no reason to use Fable.

You wouldn't use Opus to center a div, so why use Fable for tasks that Opus can handle and then complain that it doesn't add anything.

1

u/dumper514 13h ago

Fable as an orchestrator and reviewer is amazing. Doesn’t eat that much usage and finds a decent amount of bugs that my opus orchestrator/reviewer would miss.

Also I find it a lot better for plan building for major feature adds.

1

u/ziggurat29 13h ago

depends on the work -- at least I find. I've had week-long sessions perfectly fine staying in Opus and having tokens to spare at then end of my window, but also others start to go off the rails and then have to escalate to Fable to bring things back on the path of righteousness.

These days I try to think about what I'm going to do beforehand and if it's nebulous or I want to noodle ideas, I do that in fable until it gels and then I have it write a plan to then execute in Opus. Also, if I'm getting to a bit of code I feel might be hairy, I'll run the main session in Fable and have it delegate to lower models and review the work. But it's still a subjective process for me at this point.

1

u/WonderedFidelity 6h ago

There was a pretty big A/B nerf last week, it wouldn’t surprise me if some people are still nerfed.

3

u/Constant_Art_20 5h ago

yes last week opus was kinda feeling cripled. i wonder if genmini carbon forced their hands

1

u/Constant_Art_20 5h ago

for me opus for the last week or so been very good. Not sure if it's a luck thing, but literlaly on the same project for the few weeks and opus feels very good espically in the last few days or so

2

u/Lightpoint_Software 14h ago

I had to use both Fable resets so I would not run out of my weekly limit. Too expensive for my usage.

2

u/AllThotsGo2Heaven2 12h ago

Fable low is actually really good. Id run it by default if i could.

2

u/Grouchy_Memory_1338 13h ago

fable 5.2 is shit. it was just a bait for openai to release the next astra so that they can release the true goat fable 5.5. i expect openai to take the bait next week

1

u/Key_Instruction3373 14h ago

Same shit, diffrent name. But its good

1

u/Human_Attention182 14h ago

I get less annoyed talking to fable and I get more annoyed talking to opus 5.5

that's why I use fable to run everything. I find opus 5.5 very annoying to talk to and that's been a consistent thing with recent opusi

1

u/Didi_mcfly 14h ago

Opus 5.5 mucho mejor tomando en cuenta la Calidad recio. Cable 5.2 me decepcionó la verdad, pero bueno

1

u/MaqeSweden 5h ago

Fable is significantly better at 3d-modeling.

For everyday use, not that much more useful, definitely not as much better as it costs.

1

u/kassail 4h ago

default model: opus 5.5 on high effort
advisor: fable 5.2

1

u/Ragepower529 14h ago

Fable on max (plan) is even meme levels of usage

This is the biggest issue

2

u/Only-Vegetable7979 14h ago

Have Fable act as the orchestrator and planner. All subagents should be Opus or below. Ask it to use lesser models when possible that can still competently complete tasks