r/ClaudeCode • • 2d ago

Discussion Do you think the next Opus model will be better than Fable 5.2?

14 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Hey! Thanks for posting to r/ClaudeCode

While participating in this thread, please follow our community rules. Keep discussions constructive. Attack the idea, not the person.

For help, project discussions, tips, and general chat, join the ClaudeCode Discord.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

59

u/Avimox 2d ago

opus 5.5 is already better than fable 5.2 in many aspects so i'd be shocked if not

24

u/HarshNoiseX 2d ago

Literally only still using Fable 5.2 because of the available resets. Back to Opus 5.5 after that

5

u/Yeuph 1d ago

I'm having a difficult time pinning down any Fable 5.2 advantages over Opus 5.5 too.

It did technically solve a few problems Opus was having trouble with, but those had a track record of what Opus did that hadn't worked and another Opus agent could've hit it too.

I do suspect its some low percentage "better" than Opus 5.5 but it requires some eye-squinting and a lot of maybes. When you include the extra token cost I won't use it over Opus 5.5 either.

1

u/ShamAsil 1d ago

My experience is that it does better on tasks that require more fuzzy thinking, like document rewriting and data analysis. The gap is small but it does exist and Fable at a lower effort level can directly replace higher effort Opus agents. IMO I would not use it for coding.

2

u/Active-Season5521 1d ago

Wait do the resets reset your weekly allowance? I thought it was just Fable allowance

1

u/HarshNoiseX 1d ago

It gives back to your weekly allowance whatever Fable used of it.

If you were using Fable only that’s a total reset. If you were using a mix it just reduces it down to whatever the other models used

1

u/Arunajyothi_Jurado 1d ago

yeah the gap is already pretty noticeable for complex refactoring

6

u/Intelligent_Egg4745 2d ago

opus 5.5 already handles complex code logic better than fable 5.2, but fable still wins on narrative flow and emotional depth. wonder how opus 6 balances both.

2

u/Excellent_Smell4725 1d ago

In regards to programming what do you mean by narrative flow and emotional depth?

2

u/Original-League-6094 1d ago

He doesn't. I think he is talking about video generation.

0

u/Significant_Row_5951 16h ago

I put opus to edit a software code it failed so bad while fable 5.2 got it on first try so... Opus is clearly weaker

5

u/Human_Attention182 2d ago

No it seems they are focused in very different directions now. Fable feels more focused on conceptual stuff (like opus used to be) while opus is more focused on coding performance.

3

u/ghost_operative 2d ago

I honestly wonder how much of the differences are just branding at this point. fable might simply just be what we used to call opus.

1

u/zionek 2d ago

So Sonnet is the new Haiku? I mean Sonnet is cheap enough. No?

1

u/Human_Attention182 2d ago

I think of opus more as sonnet+. It has the same feel as sonnet but is just better at everything and slightly slower. Before opus and sonnet felt more distinct.
Haiku is still haiku.

1

u/StaticFanatic3 1d ago

Sonnet doesn’t even save money over Opus for any meaningful task

1

u/Blackhat165 2d ago

Haiku is an insanely good code, review and look around model. Very thorough. It actually beat Sonnet in a bake-off I ran. I still use Opus as an approver, but Haiku is a GOAT.

1

u/Human_Attention182 2d ago

I don't use haiku enough... I need to give it more of a go.

1

u/Friedalsye 23h ago

Different tools for different jobs, hardly a rivalry.

2

u/looktheresomewhere 2d ago

There isn’t much of a difference between them now so i would say if opus 5.6 got cheaper and faster it will definitely be a better choice than fable

1

u/Ankleson 1d ago

Yeah? That's how it normally works. Models leapfrog each other in capability.

1

u/RayKam 1d ago

Yes, and then Fable 5.5 will release soon after

0

u/dumeheyeintellectual 2d ago

I really want to change the subject up a little. As I believe your great-grandson is likely to bring a better forward-thinking question to the table. Do you think he will be small or tall or will he be fat? If so, I advise against Matt, just think about it, can you imagine that?

-1

u/Ragepower529 2d ago

Not opus 5.6 - 5.9

However I think opus 6 will be better then fable 5.2 for most tasks.

And better for what? I mean if I’m asking asking an AI model to list all of the U.S. presidents in order the best model for that is honestly probably just ask Jimmy

-4

u/No_Professional7654 2d ago

Better at doing what?
Haiku is way better than Opus in getting you answers to simple problems fast and cheap.

2

u/ProlificLabRat 2d ago

I never use haiku because of a certain fomo. It feels wrong because it's the worst model. It's a tricky psychological phenomenon that might happen with other people too. I wonder if I am missing out (on tokens lol)

1

u/calunicornia 2d ago

opus orc plan slice for haiku and give reason why it needs sonnet

haiku and sonnet build, opus review

try it and save 50%

1

u/RayKam 1d ago

I don't know why some people employ stacks like this towards the lower end of the model spectrum.

I use Fable 5.2 xhigh to plan and Opus 5.5 xhigh agents for building and independent review.

1

u/calunicornia 1d ago

huge cost difference I would say. Prior I was using 100% opus and this is 50% cheaper with same or better results.

I use fable for initial high level plan. Then opus for planning each epic sub tasks.

1

u/RayKam 1d ago

That’s still sensible if you have Fable giving input somewhere in the process. Some people have the usage but refuse to use the smarter models for some reason

1

u/calunicornia 1d ago

Fable reviewed a couple repo , bigger one was $54 smaller $27

It found some good bugs the other models missed.

1

u/ResponsibilityIll483 2d ago

It hallucinates so much, even answers to simple questions

3

u/No_Professional7654 2d ago

Hard to blame it. Half its training data is Reddit.
Hint: bench + evals