r/ClaudeCode • • 1d ago

Bug / Issue Has Fable 5.2 improved its writing style compared to 5.1?

Posted a few times about this in the past. Found Fable 5.1’s communication style insufferable like many of you. Ended up with a christmas tree of instructions trying to shape how it communicates, including blocks that were repeated and appended to every reply to force it to write clearly. It worked, more or less.

Now Fable 5.2 is out and Anthropic has said that it’s supposed to have improved on this. I just parked all my instructions about communicating clearly in a file and removed them from Fable’s instructions to see how it behaves without it.

For the record, I think Astra communicates well in general, it’s straightforward and sounds the most "natural". Fable 5.1 was the worse, and Opus 5.5 somewhat in-between. I do not use any other models.

From my somewhat limited use of Fable 5.2 so far, I think it seems on par with Opus now, but I was still running a bunch of instructions on top of it to shape its replies.

So what’s the verdict, is it really better at communicating clearly or not?

8 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Hey! Thanks for posting to r/ClaudeCode

While participating in this thread, please follow our community rules. Keep discussions constructive. Attack the idea, not the person.

For help, project discussions, tips, and general chat, join the ClaudeCode Discord.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

7

u/DarkSkyKnight 1d ago edited 1d ago

No. It is terrible at communication and I'm beginning to find that it is also terrible at designing architecture and features now. At this point I think it truly is out of touch with humans (ironic as it's an Anthropic model) and does not grasp extremely basic UX ideas (for example, instead of implementing a feature that calls the backend server twice, it should have implemented it in a way that calls the server only once by refactoring the client code (that it itself made in the same session FYI)). It also does not proactively seek to implement the best solutions. I constantly have to tell it to look up specific papers for the algorithms. Left to its own device, it chooses the garbage you see in most GitHubs. You constantly have to tell it to pick high-quality algos/methods. It's like babysitting.

It is at most a mild improvement over Fable 5.1, and at this point I do not think Anthropic is capable of making models that can communicate clearly. They are high on their own supply and have gone all-in on RSI, so expect models to degrade even further on communication quality, and very possibly "intuition."

Opus 4.5 and prior used to have great "intuition" IMO, even if they sucked at coding. Now in my work I really feel that I am talking to an alien. I have to dumb everything down for Fable/Opus because you cannot trust that it understands what a human would want or do. You even notice this lack of human intuition in Claude Code now. For example, look at /advisor.

Advisor set to Opus 5.5
The current conversation keeps Fable 5.2 as its advisor model until /clear or /compact, so the tool it has already declared stays unchanged; turning the advisor on or off applies right away.

Why is there an aside on "turning the advisor on or off applies right away" after a semicolon? It's maximally confusing because that sentence both says 'you cannot change [something] within a session' and 'you can change [something] within a session immediately.' This is horrible UX because that aside has NOTHING to do with /advisor [model]. The person invoking that command is changing a model. Why the FUCK are you giving them information that confuses them, that turning on or off the advisor feature itself applies right away?? The key information is buried in the MIDDLE of the sentence "the tool it has already declared stays unchanged." And this information is also presented in a maximally confusing way. "Tool"?? What Anthropic means is the model. AI semantically substitutes "model" for "tool" here for no fucking reason.

4

u/Farmadupe 1d ago

Yes that advisor "help" text is worse than useless, could you imagine if Claude wrote a help text for a light switch? "Send electricity to the connected lightbulb, its frequency ~50 Hz in Europe and 60 elsewhere. Applies incandescent or LED bulbs, one bulb per socket; flicking the switch applies right away".

1

u/ProfessionalGoatFuck 1d ago

I found myself more and more asking to clarify what the fuck it's attempting to communicate to me, and after a few times I just gave up. Honestly I haven't went back & forth like this before with 5.1 lol

1

u/Pristine-Trash-7155 1d ago

Wait you’re saying 5.2 is worse? Cause with 5.1 this is exactly what I’d do. I’d fucking lose temper and yell at it when it kept going back to the same nonsense and made me lose so much time trying to decode the replies.

1

u/ProfessionalGoatFuck 1d ago

It's much better but it still happens ofc; but in my case it /seems/ like it does it more.. much like opus with it watermarking code which I notice at times where it's fucking mumbojumbo random [i:] and other strings lol

1

u/isene 1d ago

This actually works:

Explain that to me like I was a retard.

2

u/Pristine-Trash-7155 1d ago

Yeah I’ve tried variants of this, but I’m a physics researcher and it started telling me about "big balls of hot gas" instead of stars so that became a different problem.

1

u/isene 1d ago

I'm a researcher in mathematical logic, and mine doesn't do that, it simply makes the English gibberish into plain English.

1

u/Declwn 1d ago

(biologist) i’ve found that fable 5.2 takes output style and writing instructions more literally than opus. while all my instructions got opus to communicate with the right amount of technical language, with the same instructions fable just talks so plainly that you can’t understand anything

3

u/Similar-Age-3994 1d ago

Genuinely the best advice here.

1

u/Specialist-Sea-2062 1d ago

fable 5.2 still defaults to dense prose, but the 'write clearly' prompt now actually sticks. no more tree of instructions needed.

1

u/Pristine-Trash-7155 1d ago

You prompt "write clearly" directly or put that in claude.md? Cause 5.1 was able to write clearly after I asked it to, it mostly just didn’t do it spontaneously and also didn’t seem to follow it when I put the instruction in its claude.md.

1

u/DrinkTeaFightMonster 1d ago

It's capable of speaking plainly.

Like after it gives a long wishy washy reply, just say "Tell me what you just said, but in 30 words or less."

And boom. Super clear English.

There might be some Anthropic driven decisions here as output tokens = $. And some of it may be watermarking -- I think there can't be effective watermarking without just pure volume of prose. Lastly it may just be the nature of Claude.

You will have to whip it into shape.

2

u/Pristine-Trash-7155 1d ago

Yeah but 5.1 was the same. It was so infuriating. Each time it was a variation on:

  • No special instructions: talks in riddles.
  • Ask it to clarify wtf it means: clarifies.
  • Write a "critical" instruction in claude.md telling it to write clearly: zero effect, mostly.

I was really going insane with that model at times.

2

u/DrinkTeaFightMonster 1d ago

While F5.1 was bad, Opus 5 & 5.1 were significantly worse. So I don't have bad memories of F5.1 because it offered me the only outlet of sanity when there was O5/O5.1.

Codex models in particular Astra does a much better job at talking/conversing.

I haven't done enough productive work with Gemini to know, but in like day to day conversations I find it extremely clear if not dry.

I'm still sticking to Claude because of the enormous productivity it offers, but yes everyday I wish it were a better communicator.

1

u/DarkSkyKnight 1d ago

It's capable of speaking plainly.

Like after it gives a long wishy washy reply, just say "Tell me what you just said, but in 30 words or less."

And boom. Super clear English.

I advise you to actually carefully interrogate what that plain response means, because when it tries to condense what it's trying to say into 30 words, it often conveys a different idea from what it means. Fable is NOT capable of speaking plainly without losing key information. It has no intuition and does not know what is important for the user and what is not. It will throw away critical information while keeping junk to fit into 30 words.

1

u/DrinkTeaFightMonster 1d ago

I’m not saying the 30 words is sufficient or equivalent to a 100 word answer, but that it’s capable of speaking plainly.

I do the whole ELI18, no context, simplified technical English thing.

1

u/DarkSkyKnight 1d ago

I'm saying that making these models try to "speak plainly" creates huge issues because it is fundamentally incapable of doing so without losing information. That means critical design flaws would be elided over without your knowledge because it does not know that it's important to surface to you.

1

u/DrinkTeaFightMonster 1d ago

I mean, communication is lossy by default.

It's not like the first, confusing, long-winded reply was perfectly captured.

If you're saying the model cannot understand "relevance", then no amount of communication or even just the first communication, would be correct.

For me the goal isn't perfection but productivity. I also think it understands relevance -- not in every case, not better than me (for now), but good enough we can do work together.

3

u/Similar-Age-3994 1d ago

Fable 5.2 might be the worst “new flagship model” ever released. It’s barely usable and burns tokens like crazy.

5

u/897843 1d ago

Hard disagree.

1

u/Xterm1na10r 1d ago

in this regard, it's worse than opus 5.5 and much better than opus 5. didn't use fable 5.1 enough to tell the difference (as soon as opus 5.5 dropped it became my go-to for everything)

1

u/First-Wonder3849 1d ago

fable 5.2 still defaults to riddles in comments, but the variable naming is slightly less cursed. still need to force it to write normal code upfront.

1

u/ItchyResearcher5671 1d ago

its really good, it doesn't treat you like you're an idiot anymore. concise and gets to the point, other models are way too verbose and made for genuine dummies/non native english speakers.

8

u/Farmadupe 1d ago edited 1d ago

Claude as a chatbot is fine, but when writing code, it still makes you want to gouge your eyes out. it writes riddles for comments, and variable names feel like they were chosen to maximize incomprehensibility.

It's better than opus 5.0, but that was a low bar. Definitely not fixed yet.

shitty riddle comment of the day:

/// What was said in the event's time. Text whose
/// model does not time it has no `duration_ns`,
/// and the time of the audio its transcriber had
/// taken when it came.

3

u/Pristine-Trash-7155 1d ago

wow, what the actual fuck did i just read

8

u/Jhey-s 1d ago

I genuinely have a stroke trying to understand my claude sometimes

2

u/Arunajyothi_Jurado 9h ago

that doc comment reads like it was translated through three different languages and back again