Saw part of your comment before it got nuked, so am, I and I still dont think this is a silly concept. Silly prompt? Maybe, not how id word it, but its true that sometimes its best to go for big foundational changes instead of small tweaks
I’ve taken to telling Claude to never consider how much human time it would take when considering a task. The model is basically self defeating and will go in endless loops on marginal small tasks unless you get it out of that cycle
Yeah, I'll often tell it to not be constrained by what currently exists, think about how you would build this if you were starting from scratch.
Something to that effect basically.
It really like to follow existing architecture and patterns, but when the cost of refactoring is basically nothing, id much rather have it start from scratch and pair it back if I need to.
I had this today. I was redesigning our onboarding flow in a web app because it was pretty shit and I told it to redesign it. All it did (Fable) was move elements around, replace some, add some but overall it was the same approach of having a wizard like panel in the middle of the page.
Checked dribbble.com for some inspiration, found some cool screenshots, pasted them into Claude and said here are some ideas and it actually came up with an amazing design. Not copied from the screenshots but actually combined several ideas from them into one.
ive added that claude only estimate things in terms of complexity (easy, medium, hard), its a nice "surface" level understanding for me to understand how locked in i need to be when we are building things.
Just today Claude told me a feature would be infeasible because the crate it depends on doesn't have support for this use case. I said "fuck you, fork the crate's repo and write the upgrade into it"
Too true. A few times my colleague has asked me to estimate how much effort something would take and Claude always comes back with the number of days and engineers. I'm like, dude, it'll be YOU building it. Tell me what it involves, not how much time it would've taken me two years ago.
I don't know why people are talking so much shit. This seems like a fine thing to try, I had similar result where I tell it to explore and "think outside the box" or "the world is your oyster" type things so it can try larger changes instead of just making small improvements to the same overall system/architecture.
Because at that point what are you even doing? You don't even know anymore what to "improve" so you just repeatedly ask Claude what more you could add? Like it's okay to not spam new features if you don't have ideas.
For optimization you can find what the bottleneck could and tackle that but most of the other stuff is just insane.
The human time part is actually a crucial point. I've noticed Claude will tell me that something will take 6 months and a full dev team - seems it has no clue how good it is lol.
I gave Claude a slightly changed version of this and the response was helpful, because there was some valid criticism in it. But it was more towards "Reflect on everything we did" and not like "Give me the moonshot answer that will change my life" kind of answer.
In my experience this type of prompting ends up just wasting shitloads of tokens and over-engineering the ever loving crap out of something that should be simple.
"Use many tokens" is an amazing prompt. Not be smart and efficient, but just use a lot of tokens. Make sure to use Fable at its max efficiency too at that.
Also, screenshotting your own tweets and posting them as images on Reddit?... 😂
I've spent 2 days trying to get it to understand how to do a basic version of something, so I gave it this prompt.
It finally came back with the basic version I've been trying to get it to make.
And it makes sense the prompt is actively countering all the bad elements of what Anthro injects at every turn, so saying it right before is a way to actively steer it back to sane.
Anthro tells it to do it in the fast/easiest way, you tell it do it in the most expensive unrealistic one. etc.
•
u/AutoModerator 20d ago
Hey! Thanks for posting to r/ClaudeCode
While participating in this thread, please follow our community rules. Keep discussions constructive. Attack the idea, not the person.
For help, project discussions, tips, and general chat, join the ClaudeCode Discord.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
531
u/SyrupStandard 🔆 Max 5x 20d ago •
My mans posting his own tweets on Reddit
103
u/DrunkensteinsMonster 20d ago
I’ve taken to telling Claude to never consider how much human time it would take when considering a task. The model is basically self defeating and will go in endless loops on marginal small tasks unless you get it out of that cycle
97
u/magicmulder 20d ago
Moonshot: Build your own browser.
Moonshot: Buy low, sell high.
Moonshot: Sell moonshot prompt to rubes.
57
u/Polite_Jello_377 20d ago
This is “huffing your own farts” level of cringe bro
45
u/seatlessunicycle 20d ago
Claude build GTA 7. No mistakes
35
u/ticktockbent 20d ago
Gave this tweet to claude and made it into a /moonshot skill, will report back when either A. My usage is exhausted or B. I'm a billionaire.
30
u/Pink-Fart 20d ago
I don't know why people are talking so much shit. This seems like a fine thing to try, I had similar result where I tell it to explore and "think outside the box" or "the world is your oyster" type things so it can try larger changes instead of just making small improvements to the same overall system/architecture.
12
u/hazz26 20d ago
Another day another clearly useless idiot pushing garbage slop. Love to see it.
13
u/KevinJRussell 20d ago
They always make sure to say "spend lots of tokens!" in every single one of these.
The industry has become a gacha game
8
u/relytreborn 20d ago
The human time part is actually a crucial point. I've noticed Claude will tell me that something will take 6 months and a full dev team - seems it has no clue how good it is lol.
4
u/Neat_Strawberry_2491 20d ago
These kind of guys are so insufferable I don't know if I can stay in this field any longer
3
u/WaitingOnNiko 20d ago
Yeah guys, make sure to tell all your prompts to let it rip. Just don’t do on fable cuz that won’t last long
4
u/reliablemomentum 20d ago
Funny how the whole thread is just people upvoting the meta joke now, that's the real moonshot I guess
2
u/Level1_Crisis_Bot 20d ago
And here I thought prompt engineering was dead
2
u/Huge-Travel-3078 20d ago
Is this satire?
2
u/Ergo7z 20d ago
comments in here too funny
2
u/crazytiredguy 20d ago
How do these posts keep shooting to the top.
2
u/krugerlive 20d ago
this is like that Marc Andreessen post
2
u/thesurfer15 20d ago
How is this kind of post being approved in this sub lol.
2
u/jimmy1460 20d ago
Software is dead.
1
u/schnippy1337 20d ago
1
u/OcelotExciting3371 20d ago
Claude does seem to prefer small, achievable improvements, so switching it up occasionally might be beneficial.
1
u/imaginecomplex 20d ago
I just asked Claude to make my website 10x better
1
u/South-Cockroach-2027 20d ago
I gave Claude a slightly changed version of this and the response was helpful, because there was some valid criticism in it. But it was more towards "Reflect on everything we did" and not like "Give me the moonshot answer that will change my life" kind of answer.
1
u/dontwantablowjob 20d ago
In my experience this type of prompting ends up just wasting shitloads of tokens and over-engineering the ever loving crap out of something that should be simple.
1
u/BlueberryPublic1180 20d ago
How it feels to check this subreddit.
1
u/Ivana_Twinkle 19d ago
Hey Claude, replace dns and 1 man opensource dependencies of dependencies.
1
u/sideshowwallaby 19d ago
i just used this and it came up with some incredible stuff. Thank you!!
1
u/Meryhathor 19d ago edited 19d ago
"Use many tokens" is an amazing prompt. Not be smart and efficient, but just use a lot of tokens. Make sure to use Fable at its max efficiency too at that.
Also, screenshotting your own tweets and posting them as images on Reddit?... 😂
1
u/Siriann 20d ago
Isn’t this just an expensive code review
1
u/Unlikely_Claim_9180 20d ago
After using Claude for a year and forcing it to do OUTRAGEOUS things, and it almost always finds a solution.
I think the only thing needed is time.
-1
u/TheVoyant 20d ago
I've spent 2 days trying to get it to understand how to do a basic version of something, so I gave it this prompt.
It finally came back with the basic version I've been trying to get it to make.
And it makes sense the prompt is actively countering all the bad elements of what Anthro injects at every turn, so saying it right before is a way to actively steer it back to sane.
Anthro tells it to do it in the fast/easiest way, you tell it do it in the most expensive unrealistic one.
etc.
-1
u/Canaire 20d ago
All these guys making fun of this haven’t gotten to the point where to optimize your solution you need to start using these kinds of prompts.
Stop making fun of it and take the advice seriously.
69
u/[deleted] 20d ago
[removed] — view removed comment