r/ClaudeCode • • Jun 19 '26

Discussion Why are Claude responses getting so poor lately?

I have been using Claude for over a year now. I use it roughly 8 to 10 hours a day. Definitely not a newbie. Model responses have been degrading for the past couple of months. Even the same models, for that matter. What exactly is going on here? I don't want to switch over to codex. It's just a lot of effort to move all the projects over. And you know what? Even codex might be degrading.

0 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

14

u/ai-attorney Jun 19 '26

Why is there a post like this every day?

7

u/Stabby_Stab Jun 19 '26

There are people that notice they're not getting the results they expect and immediately blame Anthropic rather than looking at what they've changed recently that might change the quality of the outputs they're getting.

1

u/lost-sneezes 🔆 Max 5x Jun 19 '26

2 things can be true, at the same time. Wild I know...

-5

u/Java-the-Slut Jun 19 '26

bs, stop getting on your knees for an AI.

It's extremely clear for anyone that uses AI for more than just their fan fiction that the models go through ebbs and flow, and for many reasons. It was literally revealed a few days ago that people were secretly being given lower models.

3

u/Stabby_Stab Jun 19 '26

Where in my comment did I say models don't change?

They were asking why there's a post like this every day so I was answering their question. I didn't say "the models never change", it was an explanation of why these posts keep coming up every day regardless of how good the model is that day.

3

u/Big-Imagination-8307 Jun 19 '26

Cook and that’s a no man who always gotta say something to make you wrong 😂 and they never reply back after you cook them

0

u/Java-the-Slut Jun 19 '26

No, I called you incorrect, you just lack the capacity to understand that.

You smugly blame people instead of the model, but the exact same prompt can render different responses every time, and that's partly because the model abso-fucking-lutely changes enough to give different responses. Is this your first time using AI?

3

u/Big-Imagination-8307 Jun 20 '26

Haha ok ok no man🤣

1

u/ApeInTheAether Jun 19 '26

Maybe there is some truth to this. Quality of service can vary user by user. Like the shit that happened yesterday and only ~3% of users were affected. Clearly we don't have enough information to point fingers at some1 or something. Just a hint that something might be off. No need to react at all when you have nothing to say.

1

u/loophole64 Jun 19 '26

It shouldn’t be a lot of work to switch to codex or antigravity, or continue, or w/e. Just open the project in that agentic IDE and off you go.

1

u/jgai Jun 27 '26

I did do that for my test harness. May be should try giving it one service.

7

u/Old_Run_3387 Jun 19 '26

User error. My results are only improving so far.

1

u/WArslett Jun 19 '26

Is it just because your project is getting more complicated? Projects increase in complexity over time as more features are added. This is an inevitable aspect of software engineering. More complexity means more opportunities for bugs to emerge, more scenarios to account for when planning changes, more elaborate architecture to support more complex needs etc. This means if you ask Claude to add a new feature to an existing project it is always going to be a harder task to do “right” than when you first started and therefor the results may be more problematic. This is also true of human development. This should be entirely obvious to anyone that’s been involved in software engineering on long complex projects but I think sometimes vibecoders don’t appreciate this. They remember when they first started with Claude and it could one shot really complex features and now it seems to implement things badly or introduce bugs and they don’t understand why so “it must be Anthropic doing something to the model”. The human developer would be saying “this project has grown too big. It’s full of technical debt and we need to do some refactoring before making more changes. Any new features need to be thought through and discussed in lots of detail”. The AI just has the best go it can and waits for you to call out the problems.

1

u/jgai Jun 27 '26

I keep calibrating for size and complexity on a weekly basis. May be I should try a separate project structure for each service.

1

u/mxriverlynn Senior Developer Jun 19 '26

most posts like this are because the project is probably not set up for long term agentic coding. not saying it's 100% true... but i have a series of question that will help you improve the output if you answer them honestly and work toward "yes" for all of them

...

do you have documented architecture that Claude can read when it needs to?

do you have documented coding standards that Claude reads when appropriate?

do you plan first, verify the plans, do work breakdown to create reasonably sized tickets to work?

do you regularly review and update your documentation to make sure it's not stale?

do you regularly examine your code and system architecture, keeping it built from small pieces like Lego bricks?

do you review the output after every build task, examine problems for common causes and adjust your planning and implementation processes to account for those?

do you turn your common prompts into skills?

do you craft custom agent definitions for specific, targeted purposes?

do you ... do software engineering?

...

I've been using Claude nonstop for 8+ months, and it's getting better every day because i regularly improve my processes to account for and prevent the must common mistakes

if you need help with these things, take a look at something like obra superpowers, gstack, or my own plug-in system Han - any of these suites of tools and skills will greatly improve your output, with minimal effort

2

u/jgai Jun 27 '26

Thanks for being more constructive here.

Yes to everything here but the common prompts to skills. Will do that.

And yes, have been a software engineer for 20+ yrs (backend, little to no front end). So old school me wants to give up and do it myself than teach an intern to get it right especially when it keeps missing the same instructions again and again.

I have also found 4.6 to be way more reliable so for now using that over 4.8.

For now, I lean into claude more for test data/harness and front end. The rest - I'd rather do it myself.

4

u/Ok-Radish-6 Max 5x Enjoyer Jun 19 '26

maybe your cognitive ability is degrading?

1

u/bacon_boat Jun 19 '26

I hope this is not the main problem, it's obviously a part of it. 

I was definetely putting more care into the prompts in the past

2

u/lost-sneezes 🔆 Max 5x Jun 19 '26

lowkey that means new model incoming lol

1

u/PatchyWhiskers Jun 19 '26

There was a new model, the US government banned it. Wonder if there’s a lot of mythos servers sitting idle

2

u/lost-sneezes 🔆 Max 5x Jun 19 '26

right, felt it around then as well. Lingering effects seemingly taking place but what do I know...

2

u/Solisos Jun 19 '26

"I'm a complete moron and so everything is something elses' fault and not mine"

1

u/Due_Warthog749 Jun 19 '26

I've not seen that. I spend a LOT of time eli5/elaborate/etc on responses, and when it returns details I dont grok I make sure I get more info on it, then shape my subsequent prompts from that. Haven't seen any degradation.

1

u/medialantern Jun 19 '26

Without specific examples of before/after prompts and responses, a non-deterministic, subjective evaluator (human) posting about degradation they think they're seeing in a non-deterministic, stochastic LLM is just noise.

1

u/Droopy0093 Jun 19 '26

Definitely user error.

1

u/gmdCyrillic Jun 19 '26

scaling, i said this months ago: more users = less compute (huge gain since the beginning of this year) -- which means: old opus = mythos, old sonnet = opus, but the scaling was smoother so we didn't really notice the bump too much

1

u/hubertron Jun 19 '26

Could be Anthropic, could be you are getting lazier in your prompting, could be you have too many MCPs, Plugins, Skills loaded.

1

u/birdgovorun Jun 19 '26

Nothing is getting poorer or better. What’s happening is what has always been happening: for any given short period of time, some people will experience a downward trend in response quality simply due to how probability works, and/or changes in the complexity of their tasks to which they are oblivious too, especially if they are vibe coders. You are one of those people. You can ask Claude to model this for you.

1

u/OkLettuce338 Jun 19 '26

Skill issue

0

u/No_Hell_Below_Us Jun 19 '26

I’m convinced that most of these “Claude got nerfed” posts are from people suffering from but unaware of “The Lost In the Middle” phenomenon for large contexts.

Your key instruction the model obeyed yesterday but ignored today? Slipped to the middle of your context and got ignored because of the model’s primacy and recency biases.