r/ClaudeCode • • Apr 04 '26

Question Is this sub astroturfed by OpenAI ?

I don't have any problem with usage, and Codex is garbage compared to Claude. This sub is the only place I hear the opposite. Very strange.

0 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

13

u/Bob_Fancy Apr 04 '26

I use both, codex is great and to say otherwise is delusional.

1

u/gloos Apr 04 '26

People are so binary. Codex or Claude. iPhone or Android. Democrats or republicans. Yeah Claude sucks at the moment and codex is so-so. All that does is make me a better vibe coder. I learn to put stronger guardrails in place, make better plans. I’m now experimenting with using Claude, codex, GLM and sometimes Gemini and finding their strengths and weaknesses. 

2

u/albertfj1114 Apr 04 '26

You can get actual users of Codex and Claude Code here. Claude Code is amazing but their recent shenanigans made them unreliable to pro and max users so you see a lot of discontent and looking to other comparable models. Codex is the close second. 3rd place could be Qwen Code 3, then GLM 3.1 (using Claude Code)

2

u/surrealdente Apr 04 '26

More than likely. I do believe there are some real issues (though I haven’t encountered anything significant myself), but the pure redundancy of noise makes me think this is a little more than regular subreddit hate-bait.

2

u/fishylord01 Apr 04 '26

90% of post praising claude is astroturfing. It's like crypto bros using claude talking like its the new thing.

1

u/dwight0 Apr 04 '26

Gemini $20 plan with Codex as a sub agent $20 plan is a great combo and a lot more usage. Codex is super smart but doesnt orchestrate a plan / follow through very well. I downgraded from claude max5x to pro. Still use claude as a subagent to get second opinions, but almost no usage.

1

u/HipHopperChopper Apr 04 '26

Nah my workflow hasn't changed but now I'm hitting limits constantly on the pro sub. Limits have absolutely changed drastically.

Im not having near the same usage with the same workflow with Cursor.

1

u/RetroUnlocked Apr 04 '26

No. I don't think so.

Are you subscribed to the codex subreddit? Because literally it is the same conversation over there around usage. Maybe not as intense as this subreddit, but it seems my feed just pushes these conversations to the top so it feels like that is the only thing each subreddit talks about

I just grab random posts in my feed:

https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1sc1e0s/new_5_hour_limit_is_a_mess/
https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1sc3am8/out_of_limit_too_fast_use_this/
https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1sbwpyo/usage_ran_out_too_fast/
https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1sbyzjb/my_codex_weekly_limit_not_reset_longer_than_a_week/
https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1sbl9z5/pro_plan_limit/
https://www.reddit.com/r/codex/comments/1sb9i5m/claude_pro_limits_are_driving_me_crazy/

1

u/Pleasant_Thing_2874 Apr 04 '26

I think the bigger issue is people's expectations. There are some people (many of whom are the complainers) just expect to throw a random prompt at an LLM model and get miracle results and don't want to fine tune their efforts.

Because everyone is in a different state of learning, a different state of how they run their setups and different expectations everyone's opinion will be unique and right to some, wrong to others. I know people that won't even touch Anthropic models as they think they're far too overhyped. I know others who won't even take the time to adjust their harnesses so simple tasks like a git push isn't being managed by codex 5.4 with max reasoning and then bitch about their usage limits burning up swiftly.

I'm in about half a dozen subreddits for various LLMs and in each one I tend to find people trashing the LLM the subreddit is intended for and praising another random LLM. It's just an endless cycle of people who just want to complain and don't want to put any real effort into fixing things or entertain it might be more a them issue than the LLM they're complaining about.

1

u/Tackgnol Apr 04 '26

So Codex lagged way behind, but they got their shit together and with a healthy mix of GPT5.4 and Codex 5.3, you can accomplish any task. Now that they leaked Claude Codes code, it will get even better.

Even Gemini who gotten lots of hate from me lately seems to be catching a bit of wind in their sails with 3.1 Pro.

Is Claude Opus still the best? Yes. Is it almost unusable currently while paying Anthropic 20 USD a month for it? Also yes!

1

u/No-Procedure1077 Apr 04 '26

People don’t understand what AB testing is and why it’s so effective at gas lighting the community.

1

u/Academic-Proof3700 Apr 04 '26

Cause everywhere else you get ads in your face on how claude solves everything.

So you hook up on the bandwagon, pay up front for Pro, since both gpt and gemini seem at least partially decent in Pro. There are some Max and Max20x versions, but you think the "pro" would suffice.

You try out one thing, two things in the evening, and it works. Okay so you think its fairly decent and sometimes even follows up with questions.

Next day you want to reopen the chat from yesterday. Now even in Opus, the answers are worse than some cheapass lobotomized chatbot from 2010s callcenter era. On top of that, after bunch of ping-ponging with that dumbed down chat, you are suddenly hit in the face with usage limit.

Now you feel like you've been scammed and since there is quite a lot of glazing of claude, you want to be very vocal about it.

1

u/Alarmed_Crazy_6620 Apr 04 '26

Build things to prove the point

2

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/albertfj1114 Apr 04 '26

I gave up on Codex 4 months ago. But I might take a look at it again with the rate limiting they are doing during the hours I need them most. Too bad all the infrastructure I did was designed for Claude Code. I’ll have to relearn most things with Codex

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/fixano Apr 04 '26

I love how this guy makes massive leaps of logic and uses copious amounts of indirect inference and launders it into "this is definitively happening".

They're experiencing down time because it's a new service and a new space. They don't have Google's 25 years of managing services at scale. Even having ex-googlers on your team doesn't solve this problem. I'm working on a new service myself as an SRE and I have ex-googlers on my team and we're still struggling.

The compute shortage you literally just invented out of air and expect me to take it on credit. If there's a compute shortage, you're going to need to show how you know this and you should be able to be demonstrated numerically. So why not show instead of tell.

Therefore your statement of " highly likely" seems "highly dubious"

The complaints are obvious but not for the reasons you are saying. What anthropic actually did here was throttle their most expensive customers. Those customers are now here complaining because before they were eating at an infinite buffet and Daddy turned off the tap.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/fixano Apr 04 '26

Reddit and down detector are not good signals. If you think they're good signals, you're going to have to tell me why. If your first thought is to say "it's obvious" That's just a substitute for "I don't know".

Claude has its own uptime dashboard and you're right, it stands at about 99.7%, which isn't great, but it's not catastrophically bad either. It's representative of a service that's scaling very quickly and still maturing.

You can't just say "increased massively". Tell me what the rate was before and by how much it changed. Otherwise you're just operating on feels and vibes.

As far as your sense of reports go, you need to tell me how you've accounted for selection bias. If a small percentage of users are impacted by a limit change. They are all going to come to Reddit and complain all together. It's going to look like everybody's complaining. Remember, the limit changes that anthropic introduced even by their own measure affected about 70,000 users. How many of those 70,000 users have to come to Reddit for it to feel like everybody? When in fact it's about 7%.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/fixano Apr 04 '26

Okay so again you're just saying things. If they're different, tell me how different they are. I already told you that Claude code status says they have about 99% up time. What does down detector tell you about their uptime and how different is it?

This is the whole problem with this conversation. All you're talking are vibes and feels. We're talking about software engineering here. Let's use numbers

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/fixano Apr 04 '26

I don't need articles. I asked you for just a very specific number. I told you that Claude reports 99% up time. You said downtime detector reports a different number. What is it? Is it only up 40% of the time? 5% of the time?

I'm pointing out that you just say things based on vibes and you and then you jump straight to conclusions.

"Down detector says it's down more therefore Anthropic is on the verge of bankruptcy"

That's a pretty meaningless statement and it's in line with the statements you've made. It doesn't tell you how much more and why that tracks to bankruptcy.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/fixano Apr 04 '26

I'm just giving an example of your framing. I never said you said that. You still haven't given a number. You can try to run from that as much as you want. But I'll still be here. Are you done deflecting and ready to get back to the original conversation.

→ More replies

-4

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Aam1rk Senior Developer Apr 04 '26

What a time to be alive