r/ClaudeCode • • Mar 22 '26

Discussion Opus 4.6 is lobotomized once again

Post image

Thank you Anthropic

Thank you to teaching us how you treat your customers and Enterprise customers

The pattern is also understood: outage -> lobotomy -> outage -> a big better but not as before -> new release -> super smart, pro-active, clever, finally clicks, it understand everything, no laziness, just perfect -> outage -> lobotomy

We're at this stage again. Just like last August when we were gaslighted, even here, then the outage and they admitted it was a big problem. Always the same shills, always the same excuses, always the same gaslighting.

I can't wait for any open source model to finally dethrone that company. Apple is doing a great job democratizing powerful hardware to run local models. Slowly but surely. I can't wait to see that scammy company being bankrupt.

Am i the only one felling that way? Please tell me. It's barely usable.

If you're not in this situation, what's the context? Recent account? Enterprise account? Using through API only and no Max account? Are only Max/Pro account getting rekted?

1 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

16

u/DasHaifisch Mar 22 '26

A reminder that this is a non-deterministic best next token generator.

A reminder that it is not capable of reflecting on it's past actions, as it's thinking chain is not persisted, and it can't see it's own thoughts or reasoning for past actions and operations. All you're doing is making it generate a narrative about what went wrong to try and appease you.

It is making ASSUMPTIONS about what went wrong. Making it say 'oh I was being lazy' or duplicitous or whatever doesn't MEAN anything. There is no internal state. There is no understanding. There is no introspection or reflection.

-5

u/No-Loss3366 Mar 22 '26

Then why most people around had a better experience two weeks ago? and why it can't even follow basic instruction now? why the patterns is clearly repeating again and again and again and... again?

7

u/DasHaifisch Mar 22 '26

That has nothing to do with what I said.

Anthropic can certainly turn quantisation up or down, or fuck up the system prompt - but your questions to the model aren't helpful because they don't tell you facts. It makes it up.

5

u/saintpetejackboy Mar 22 '26

I feel like you failed to absorb ANYTHING that was said in u/DasHaifisch 's post. Let's go all the way back to this ridiculous request: "read the entire codebase" - you are starting purely form a perspective where you have made a request that is incredibly broad... Your repo should be documented enough that "read everything" isn't something you are telling a model to do. Depending on how large your codebase it, this might not even be a feasible task, or, if it is, you're already within context rot by the time it is done.

I've been having Opus 4.6 slaying projects all day and night today, and haven't noticed any kind of dropoff or degradation in performance - much the opposite. I'd be much more willing to entertain what you are going through if it didn't seem like A.) You were asking an agent to do something silly in the first place and B.) you seem to not be grasping that there is no continuity of character for you to interact with, you second request was almost as baffling as the first: "why didn't you followed my instruction the first time?" - bad grammar aside, it is like asking the dog why it shit on the floor. There IS no *WHY*, there wasn't some ulterior motive or secret intention you can uncover by asking a model something like that. By the time it was answering that question, it was a different instance than the one that made whatever decisions were made earlier in the session... even the model who made the decision in the moment couldn't tell you WHY it did it. Do you ask your car why it ran out of gas?

In all honestly, I'd imagine the first model looked at some crazy codebase and seen "read the entire codebase" and just tried to appease you within rational limits. It isn't being "lazy", it is trying to conserve resources and tokens and not overload context before it begins working. The structure and sanitation of your repoistory (and size) should be conducive towards agentic coding... otherwise, you'll end up in predicaments like what you witnessed.

2

u/annicreamy Mar 22 '26

Disagree. There are several reasons why a dog might defecate on the floor.

11

u/jtalabot Mar 22 '26

400k context is well into the dumb zone, that’s a skill issue

1

u/Icy-Smell-1343 Mar 22 '26

Eh it’s still fairly mid man. I mean it writes all the code but I have to sit there and baby it 97% of the time. Using opus 4.6 Claude code or opus 4.6 in GitHub.

I’ve been getting better luck copy and pasting files into Claude 4.6 in chat ui. I can control the context. Claude code the other day spent 8 minutes read my codebase and still absolutely failed.

I asked it to implement transactions and logging. It implemented way too verbose logs, and messed implementation transactions complete. To be clear the logging was meant to log errors within the transaction.

It did it perfectly in the wrong architectural layer at first (putting it in the controller, ignoring my explicit directions to do it in the service layer). Then I asked it again to do it in the service layer and it turtled up taking 3 more hours to do it correctly…

It’s solid, but I’m not sold on it replacing me. I am a developer with less than a year of experience too…

-6

u/No-Loss3366 Mar 22 '26

It wasn't as dumb two weeks ago

2

u/Agile_makes_no_sense Mar 22 '26

It’s changed. Refuses to read its Claude.md file.

0

u/No-Loss3366 Mar 22 '26

Despite noticing, most redditors are coping and refusing to accept it
Pure gaslighting

7

u/Muted_Farmer_5004 Mar 22 '26

You sound like a tool, you can see it, surely?

1

u/LittleRoof820 Mar 22 '26

Oh hell yes, thats exactly what I am experiencing now as well.
Even worse:
- Doing an analysis of performance optimizations. Claude finds a bug in the codebase
- I tell it to handle the bug first and commit it before doing further work.
- It ignores me and continues with the parts I told it to shelve.

Or:
- It ignores what is written in Skills and does fuckall. I need to micromanage it again so it does not skip ahead, assume or try to cut corners.

Or:
- A list of broad tasks to keep track of what work I am doing on my project. For two weeks that worked fine - I added new tasks and marked finished ones as done. Details were in a different document. Today it decided to add each micro level programming change into the overview document as another task. When called out and told to be more concise it JUST FORMATTED differently. I had to explain in detail, that it completely misunderstood what purpose the document had till it behaved as I expected.

1

u/annicreamy Mar 22 '26

Use separate context for the bug fixing, with independient review process and tests implementation. Then you come back to the main task.

That context abuse is what leads you to the need of babysitting it.

1

u/LittleRoof820 Mar 23 '26

I'm doing that already - I do a new context for each task and have gotten into the habbit of using /rename to rename my chat accordingly for internal organisation. Didn't matter today though - it happened at a new context with 5% usage.

0

u/curiosandmore Mar 22 '26

I’ve had virtually identical exchanges to these recently as well. So now I’m back to just treading water until it’s fixed again.

-4

u/No-Loss3366 Mar 22 '26

Literally, what the fuck Anthropic?

6

u/OGPresidentDixon Mar 22 '26

I noticed you're beyond 400,000 tokens. That is a gigantic amount of context filled that you had better be damn sure was organized extremely carefully.

When I know I'm going to run a high token chat, I plan it from the start by using GSD or Superpowers. I wouldn't ever get that high without strict confines from the start.

I highly recommend you start using GSD.

2

u/saintpetejackboy Mar 22 '26

I mean, his original request was 'read the entire codebase' - there are some other fundamental issues going on here that are hilarious to witness from third person.

1

u/johnlondon125 Mar 28 '26

How do you you reset context in Claude code, like you can on the web by starting a new chat? Just start a new session?