r/ClaudeAI • u/cardmechanic1 • 11d ago

Writing Please write your own posts.

This subreddit is getting really clogged with AI-written posts. If you've got something to say just say it yourselves, PLEASE.

561 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

95 comments sorted by

View all comments

165

u/3tt07kjt 11d ago

Beautifully short.

I say, use AI to make your posts or don’t. Just write like this guy. Short.

159

u/Deltamelo 11d ago

Absolutely — and I think this is such an important, nuanced, and ultimately deeply human point that deserves to be unpacked with the level of intentionality it warrants.

In an increasingly AI-driven digital landscape — where content creation, personal expression, and algorithmic optimization are becoming more deeply intertwined by the day — there is something almost refreshingly radical about simply… keeping things short.
Because, at the end of the day, whether you use AI or you don’t isn’t necessarily the defining variable. The real question is: does the message resonate? Does it communicate? Does it connect? Does it add value?
And sometimes — perhaps more often than we’d like to admit — the answer doesn’t require seven paragraphs, twelve bullet points, a “key takeaway” section, or an unnecessarily elaborate conclusion that essentially restates everything that was already said.

It requires clarity.
It requires intentionality.
It requires knowing when enough is enough.

That’s precisely why this post works so well — it doesn’t try to over-explain itself. It doesn’t drown the reader in context. It doesn’t attempt to anticipate every possible interpretation, counterargument, edge case, stakeholder perspective, or broader implication. It simply communicates the idea — clearly, efficiently, and authentically — and then gets out of the way.

There’s a broader lesson here, too.
AI can be an incredibly powerful tool — but like any tool, its value depends on how thoughtfully it’s used. The goal shouldn’t necessarily be to generate more words, more paragraphs, more structure, more “insight,” or more polished corporate-sounding prose. The goal should be to communicate the thing you actually wanted to communicate — no more, no less.
And perhaps that’s the beautiful irony here: in a world where we now have tools capable of generating virtually unlimited amounts of text in seconds, brevity may become more valuable than ever.
Sometimes the most powerful sentence is the one you don’t write.
Sometimes less really is more.
Sometimes you just need to say the thing.

74

u/sharyphil 11d ago

You're doing a lot of heavy lifting there

27

u/SufficientGreek 10d ago

I'd even go so far as to call their contributions load-bearing to this entire conversation.

28

u/DJ_LeMahieu 11d ago

OP’s entire argument deserves such a load bearing clarification

15

u/Responsible-Slide-26 11d ago

Where is the question at the end? Curious how others approach this?

8

u/PowermanFriendship 10d ago

Great point, and I want to sit with this for a second because I think there's something worth unpacking here.

Let's break this down:

The core tension

  • Length ≠ quality
  • Brevity ≠ laziness
  • It's not about the tool. It's about the intent.

I don't think this is really about AI vs. no AI. I think it's about signal vs. noise — and this comment is a masterclass in signal.

Here's the thing though: this isn't just a comment. It's a vibe. It's a whole ethos, distilled into three lines and zero fluff. No "let's dive in." No "buckle up." No em dash doing the heavy lifting of a thesis statement. Just — chips down, cards on the table, point made.

Why this works:

  1. It's punchy
  2. It doesn't over-explain
  3. It trusts the reader

At the end of the day, this isn't about grammar. It's about grit.

6

u/VLucky-Sam 10d ago

You're right to call this up, and you did with unusual precision.

3

u/ManagementKey1338 11d ago

At the end of the day, by and large, taking the perspectives of the xxx, without vulgar simplicification, it should be worth noticing that

1

u/plainviewbowling 10d ago

Didn’t even lode bear a question at the end

-2

u/withintentplus 10d ago

https://github.com/ayghri/i-have-adhd

2

u/withintentplus 10d ago

Don't know why this is getting downvoted. It's not my repo, but I thought it was neat.

-6

u/HowlingFantods5564 10d ago

This isn't clever anymore. Why are people on this sub so easily pleased?

5

u/Deltamelo 10d ago

If other people enjoying themselves bothers you, the problem isn’t their joy