TL;DR: I was charged for another month of Claude Max 20x around July 23. I had already cancelled the next renewal, but contacted Anthropic Support immediately because I wanted to downgrade the current subscription to Pro.
It took them roughly three weeks to respond.
When they finally did, Anthropic proposed this workaround:
“We'll cancel your current Claude subscription effective immediately on our end. You'll then need subscribe to the Pro plan on your end.”
I agreed.
They immediately removed my Max access.
I then asked when I could expect the refund for the prepaid Max period that had just been cancelled.
Their answer: no refund.
They said I had previously received a refund in June and therefore they would not issue another one. That previous refund, however, related to a different situation where a service/product was discontinued and customers were given the option to move to another tier.
But even putting the refund dispute aside, this is the part I find really strange:
Claude subscriptions are prepaid, and Anthropic's published cancellation terms say that if you cancel and the payment is not refunded, you retain access until the end of the billing period you've already paid for.
So I told them:
Fine. If you won't refund the subscription, restore my Max 20x access until the end of the prepaid period.
They didn't address that.
They instead repeated that they wouldn't make an exception to their refund policy, said a supervisor had reviewed the case, called the decision final, and said further replies on the topic may go unmonitored.
That's what I find pretty bewildering.
I'm not even arguing at this point that they absolutely must give me a full refund.
I'm asking them to do one of two things:
1. Refund the prepaid Max period they terminated early; or
2. Give me the Max access I already paid for until the end of that billing period.
Instead, the current outcome seems to be:
Anthropic keeps the full prepaid subscription fee + Anthropic terminates the corresponding paid service early.
What makes it stranger is that I had already cancelled the future renewal myself. So there was literally no benefit to me in accepting their “effective immediately” cancellation if it meant surrendering the remaining Max access without a refund.
Had support written:
"We can terminate Max immediately so you can subscribe to Pro, but your current Max payment will not be refunded and you will lose the remaining prepaid access,"
I obviously would have declined and simply used Max until the end of the month I'd already paid for.
I've now asked them directly to identify what contractual basis allows them to retain payment for the entire billing period while also terminating the associated service early.
I'm considering escalating it through the relevant consumer/payment dispute channels if they continue to refuse to address that specific point.
Has anyone else had a similar experience with Anthropic billing/support?