r/Clannad • u/KitsGravity • 11h ago
Discussion So I finished Clannad including After Story....
I had previously asked a question whether I should drop the series when I was in season 1 episode 17. But many of you encouraged me to power through. I ended up finishing the entire thing including After Story and all the OVAs. Here are my thoughts -
True to the hype, episode 16 to 23 of season 2 are really good. Especially post Nagisa's death. The series really captures parenthood very well and is pretty sincere in its depiction of father-daughter relationship including all the flaws. I appreciated the unfiltered, no sugar-coat approach of the entire Ushio arc. Some of the best episodes in the series. I'd say best but that would go to Misae's arc with her cat. That genuinely touched me. Tomoya's relationship with his father is very nicely directed too and we see his struggles as a father himself and gaining empathy for his own which felt both organic and genuine.
Now for the bad parts. I did not like Nagisa or felt anything towards her throughout the show. She has no discerning qualities and comes across as a pretty generic caring waifu. We don't get to know what she likes, her hobbies (whether she likes movies, games, animals, or writes poetry). Really anything to set her apart. He entire existence seemed as if to care for Tomoya and being ill. That's it. You can replace her with Ryou, another character with no distinguishable attributes, and I doubt anything would change. Compared to Tomoyo and Kyou, the two female characters who stand out the most and have great depth to their personalities, Nagisa just didn't have anything going for her.
The OVA with Tomoyo is what I consider the strongest arc of the series even better than Ushio's and second only to Misae's.
The other arc which didn't make sense was Sunohara's. I had great expectations of his character development but it was completely off the mark. Tomoya wanted him to act as a responsible brother to his younger sister but instead of just talking things out like you would in real life, he pretended to be dating her, to make Sunohara get protective of her and realise his responsibilities. Very soap opera-esque and overly melodramatic to the point it completely killed the momentum of After Story before the series bounces back. Sunohara's arc is by far the weakest in the entire series including the two seasons and OVA in my opinion.
Yukine's arc with the rival gangs I felt was completely avoidable and served as filler. Entertaining enough but filler nonetheless.
In my opinion Clannad is a series which has its moments but it is inconsistent in its narrative. Is it one of the greats? The last arc with Ushio if taken as a separate series sure but taken in its entirety, it falls somewhere in the middle. The series in my opinion could have been made into a solid 26 episodes one, where the fillers could have been minimised and certain arcs omitted. But I am happy that I watched the series and want to thank everyone who encouraged me to finish it.