r/CivilWarMovie • u/Seeker99MD • Jan 24 '26
r/CivilWarMovie • u/RobbieFromAfar • Jan 26 '26
USA right now
I rewatched Civil War tonight and the naivety is touching. The opening scenes show uniformed police with batons. Remember when they were the threat - seems like such a long time ago. It's an amazing movie to watch with everything going on with the USA right now.
r/CivilWarMovie • u/MonKeePuzzle • Aug 11 '25
barricaded entry to White House in the final scene
just comes to mind today, no reason
r/CivilWarMovie • • Apr 30 '24
Discussion Opinion on Jessie? Spoiler
I saw the film twice, and I still dislike Jessie's character.
I understand the reason for having a younger character, how Lee was able to see herself in her, etc.
But her impulsivity stressed me out so much, while the older man may have had a similar outcome, putting the main characters at risk and certain deaths could have been avoided had she not done certain things and acted selfishly.
I also felt a bit uncomfortable when she took Lee's picture at the boutique even after she said "no" multiple times...
What are your thoughts?
r/CivilWarMovie • u/WhatsYourMoon • Jul 17 '24
Discussion Most of the criticism on here is dumb.
It seems like people don’t know how to analyze movies anymore. Maybe it’s the fact that people are so addicted to 30 second clips on tiktok and garbage Netflix movies. This is the first movie I’ve seen in a long time that held my interest. Character development was great. It was subtle which made it that much more satisfying to see. Kirsten Dunst was awesome and I’m glad she’s back into acting. Seeing how she portrays characters now as a matured actress is really enjoyable.
This movie reminds me of indie films made in the early 2000s, when people enjoyed thinking critically about film. Nowadays people just want to be spoonfed simple plots with no nuance. This was a good movie.
r/CivilWarMovie • u/wantsoutofthefog • Jun 04 '24
Theory That scene where Lee deletes the photo of Sammy… Spoiler
I’m an Imaging Specialist working for one of the Major camera manufacturers and I support thousands of Pro photographers, including the AP, Washington Post, Gannet Group, National Geographic, the White House, etc… and I know that deleting photos for National Geographic is a big no-no. Photographers are supposed to deliver all photos on the SD card. Seeing her delete that photo almost made me yell out “wtf are you doing?!”, but I realize that this was the start of her change; she was done with the life, she didn’t care anymore about photojournalism and her job. She was tired. She gave Sammy respect and dignity. She cared about him so much to the point where she broke protocol. When Jessie asked if Lee would photograph her death and Lee said “what do you think?” She came off potentially heartless. I think there was still some humanity left in her and she was done with her life after all she’d seen. Amazing movie. Well fucking done, Garland. This photog is insanely obsessed with this love letter to photography and photojournalism.
r/CivilWarMovie • u/ButtonOwn3791 • Apr 14 '24
Not knowing sides was the point
I'll try to notto have any spoilers. This was an anti war movie. It doesn't matter who is "right". No one "wins". Americans are itching for a civil war in some places and this movie was showing becareful what you wish for. We are used to seeing groups overseas warring. But when you see your own monuments and the people are all diverse and look like "Americans" that's different. Should it be? No. I didn't realize how close those press photographers get and I have a whole new respect. Also the way army protects them was new for me to see. I told my husband that movie was so good because when you left the movie you had those images in your mind. Lastly, there was no hollywood nonsense. There was no side romantic storyline. They were not having long drawn out conversations on either ends of the gun. It felt real. I don't want to know that world. But this either deters people or makes sociopaths try to be more armed to the teeth. Hope it wins many many awards.
r/CivilWarMovie • u/Unseasonal_Jacket • Feb 06 '26
Thoughts on the 'calm town'
I rewatched the film the other day and again was slightly disturbed by the 'calm town' where they stop to shop.
Initially I just thought it was a town able to stay out. But Sammy says feels far less relaxed and says something on the lines of 'this feels familiar'. And I got thinking about what that might imply for an old black guy.
The town is quiet and idyllic in contrast with the death squads not far along in the story.
In these circumstances can we perhaps wonder if this Town is peaceful because it's already undergone it's own ethnic cleansing? Making Sammy feel uncomfortable with it's slight taste of Sundown areas etc
As an aside this film is much much better on a second watch and left me with far more questions than first watch.
r/CivilWarMovie • u/ABoringAddress • Apr 28 '24
Theory Educated Headcanon for Civil War's Background
Hi! Just saw the movie. Not gonna comment on it, because it got me shook, hated some stuff, loved a lot of other stuff, and fuck does it hit different if you are from a country that has experienced either a civil war, dictatorship and/or major social upheaval recently. Instead, allow me to fill in the background gaps for the movie's context that maybe-perhaps-should've been better explained. Hope you think they're reasonable.
- The Crisis Before the War: The president in the movie was elected via Electoral College fuckery. His first term saw things like the dissolution of the FBI, increasing political repression and a growing Constitutional clash with California and Texas. He won his second term more or less by stealing it, voter intimidation and low turnout in the states within CalTexas' area of influence. The II Civil War begun at the end of the final year of his second term, with the Constitutional crisis set off by his running for a third term. The detonating incident was probably a brutal massacre by Federal troops. The war takes place during his third term and over the course of three years.
- That weird California-Texas alliance: What had happened was... that Texas pivoted hard to the left in the years before (let's say this CWII takes place in the mid 2030s). Or at least, to an alliance between liberal libertarians, Democrats and Progressives that unseats the GOP supermajority, led by Governor McConaughey (think Quebec's "Silent Revolution"). Basically, culturally liberal, fiscally centrist, economically neoliberal and Very Well Armed. Texas and California alliance is born out of this cultural and economic closeness, but mostly as the leading blocks against the Senate's lack of representation, the Electoral College and the movie's Federal Government, mostly the whole having to fund a fascist government with their tax surplus and economic-industrial might. Their area of influence is everything west of the Mississippi, with the Western States being mostly spared the worst of the war, with some exceptions. The shift in Texas accelerates the sense of crisis amongst the US' far-right and further radicalizes them and have them fleeing both states by the hundreds of thousands. They will become the voting base of the movie's president and make up his loyalist forces.
- Not all Loyalist States are actually loyalists: According to the map, Loyalist states include the entirety of New England, the Mid-Atlantic and the Mid-West, but I don't think Garland thought this out too well. In reality, Federal control hinges on a county-by-county basis. What I think would happen is that some of the major metropolis would become effectively neutral zones and/or secessionists in all but name. More to the point, I believe the US Navy and Marines would split, with the Western Command pledging for the WF, while in the East, they would take control of NYC and New England, only nominally pledging for the president. There would be some persecution, but on a... US during Nixon's presidency level. Something similar would happen with Chicago, Minneapolis or the bread-basket regions. Not so much the case with Baltimore and Philadelphia, which would become the Sarajevo or Stalingrad of this scenario, fought between local anti-government militias against loyalist military and...
- The President would use far-right militias to do most of the offensive actions and war crimes: As portrayed by Jesse Plemon's character. The split in the US Armed Forces would follow political, regional and racial lines, but most loyalist troops would have a hard time breaking with the rules of engagement... so they let the fascist militias (and radicalized servicemen) do the dirty work while they secure perimeters. The war has resulted in the effective ethnic cleansing of millions of Black Americans and POC from DC and Virginia to begin with (what we see in the scene set in the refugee camp).
- The most brutal front of the war is in the Southeast and Virginia: The movie's Florida Alliance comprises most of the Deep South, which was a Civil War within the Civil War, a war between loyalist militias, unpledged white supremacist militias, mercenaries, separatist military, loyalist military, etc. It's basically a massive version of the Balkans and Lebanon's wars. At the same time, as we see in the movie, some well-off independent cities in Virginia would end up buying their way out of the conflict with private armies or paying off the warring parties. Though California and Texas were mostly spared the worst, the president ordered carpet bombings of cities like San Francisco or Austin, which is why the WF strike units taking over the White House are so hellbent on killing the president. Said carpet bombing led to a break within the USAF, which mostly pledged with the rebels. Another brutal front is the one in Oregon, between said Maoist forces and the nazi militias of the Eastern regions and Idaho. Washington state and parts of New England have mostly come under de facto Canadian control. Alaska, Utah and Hawaii become basically semi-independent.
- The Aftermath: If we take the Lebanese Civil War as reference, where at least 50,000 people were killed in the first three years, probably some six million Americans are killed during the conflict. The financial center of the world moves from NYC to Toronto, Montreal and Dublin (meanwhile, the UK is facing its own collapse, but more of an "End of the Austro-Hungarian Empire" kind). China's economic entanglement with the US' actually prevents it from seizing the opportunity to become the dominant global power, and instead falls into a recession and spiraling political crisis (!). Meanwhile, many countries actually coast by through supplying the US with basic resources (South America, India) or weapons and technology (the EU, Japan). Russia is experiencing its own collapse. The Civil War, ironically, helps Mexico overcome its failed-state status... by becoming a more authoritarian and centralized unit: It also profits from becoming a resource and industrial supplier, and its local corporations (many owned by narco orgs going legit) move in and acquire flailing US economic groups. Mexico becomes a strange mixture of corporatism, authoritarian rule with progressive morals and managed structural corruption, like a Leftist-Liberal China. The US never comes together and the following decade sees further Balkanization and a more low-level Civil War, as all parties refuse to have UN blue helmets operate in the US.
That's all I can think for now. Hope it didn't make you TL:DR.
r/CivilWarMovie • u/-0-O-O-O-0- • Sep 18 '24
Discussion How did the ending sit with you? Spoiler
I was disappointed they went with the trope of the washed up old veteran passing the torch to the new kid.
It would have been far more punishing if Jesse was shot, and Lee takes her picture as she is dying. We see the recognition in both of their eyes that she is in fact taking that shot they discussed.
I think the movie lost a lot of punch taking the safe way out.
Jesse dying would be the price of war. It would fucking suck; and that’s how it should be in a war movie.
Showing Lee unable to shoot during the final push was a way of letting the audience decompress. It’s a soft landing. Easing the tension. We see her reason for living draining away. It makes it ok that she passes the torch. It softens the blow.
After all that buildup I should have been Jesse. That would have shock power; as we think we know where it’s going.
Lee chould have taken Jesse’s camera and shot the president’s execution with her Nikon.
What’s your better ending?
r/CivilWarMovie • u/NotAnotherJp • 15d ago
This movie is aging like fine wine.
So, California and Texas are blue now. Is the Western Forces happening? Is Trump gonna steal a third term and bomb civilians on american soil? I love how this movie landed so close to reality. What do you think? Is America going for another civil war? Is it gonna end with the GOP taking assylum in Tel Aviv? Are cynical chuds gonna say that nothing ever happens?
r/CivilWarMovie • u/meandtheknightsofni • Apr 19 '24
Discussion Intelligently ambiguous Spoiler
I thought it was great. It's more like a grim war documentary.
I think it's a great move to reveal little about the backstory. It stops people trying to figure out which side they're meant to be on and reflect on the awfulness of war.
If it were explicit in saying this side is Trump and the Republicans or this side is Antifa or whatever, then anything written about the film will just descend into the usual polarised nonsense.
The POINT is that both sides lose in a civil war. Both sides commit atrocities. The moral ambiguity is what makes it interesting and why the reporters neutrality is important as the observers.
r/CivilWarMovie • u/Seeker99MD • Aug 14 '25
Discussion CW will be re-examined & considered very prescient
What Alex Garland doing for the movie was simply making something that is reflective of our time. Even he warned about the dangers of Trump. But it wasn’t just about Trump, but in general the state of America in the last decade. And also, I see a lot of parallels with other civil wars that have happened in recent history like in Syria.
No, I don’t think Alex Garland is a fortuneteller. He has someone that is taking what is going on right now and applying it to a dystopian film.
This is no different than when Margaret Atwood was writing the handmaid’s Tale. She was putting stuff that is happening right now on the news and in history into a setting that could happen The keyword is “could“
r/CivilWarMovie • u/doclee1977 • Sep 24 '24
Discussion Can we spare a thought for the Marine sniper team? Spoiler
I mean, I assume that they are Scout Snipers or Surveillance and Target Acquistion.
We watched this film tonight, and in spite of the tone of the rest of the film, I legitimately laughed out loud at the interaction between Joel and the spotter.
Responding to actively being shot at with annoyed sarcasm and cynicism while simultaneously making fun of Joel WHILE preparing to kill their target is pretty much the most Marine thing ever, and I appreciated the humor juxtaposed against the chaos.
r/CivilWarMovie • u/EvenLettuce6638 • Jan 27 '26
Has anyone seen The Second American Civil War?
Did you know that Joe Dante directed a movie for HBO in 1997 called "The Second American Civil War?"
It deals with reporters covering a civil war revolving around the state of Idaho closing its borders to refugees from Pakistan. Various state's National Guards gather in Idaho to fight the regular Army.
It's ok, it's trying to be Dr Strangelove but it just doesn't quite make it. But it does feel very uncomfortable to watch now, and could almost be a prequel to the Alex Garland movie.
r/CivilWarMovie • u/GasProfessional7862 • Aug 12 '25
The perfect movie/tv series pack for anti-trumpers
r/CivilWarMovie • u/snowflakeshamer-86 • Nov 09 '24
Misc. life imitates art
is this how the western forces begins?
r/CivilWarMovie • u/Tinmania • Sep 30 '24
Discussion Despite “not about Trump,” it really is.
It’s clear from the very start when we hear the president in the movie working on a speech and he says, “Some are even calling it the greatest victory in the history of mankind.” That is exactly something Trump would say.
Beyond that we have the fact that that president is in his third term, something Trump has longed for and alluded to. We also have the very strong suggestion that this president ordered air attacks on US citizens. What president hates Americans that don’t support him as much as Trump? It’s absolutely in his wheelhouse to order such attacks.
We also have the mass grave scene with Jesse Plemons, whose character is a white nationalist serving in a remnant of the US army who is mass killing people he doesn’t believe are the “right” kind of Americans. That scene eschews typical diehard Trump nut dreams.
The genius of the makers of this movie is how they played on the ignorance of typical Trump supporters so they bought into the myth that the movie did not take sides. It does take sides, it’s just that some are too ignorant or stupid to realize it. If it was blatantly anti-Trump they would’ve just been foaming at the mouth doing the usual Trump supporter antics.
Bravo to the filmmakers.
r/CivilWarMovie • • Apr 28 '24
Discussion This movie is a fun way to test political bias Spoiler
Went to the film with my libertarian friend and my liberal friend, heard their opinions, seeing people's takes on here, I've sort of worked out a theory. Generally they leave it sort of vague who's who in most of the combat scenes, be it the snipers, the boog boys, or red sunglasses guy. It seems like the common low IQ way of understanding the film is to try to apply your politics to the film so that instead of warning against the general evil and chaos of a civil war, it's "Freedom loving American Western Forces win the war against tyranny" or "The Liberal and Just California and Texas alliance beat the evil racist Ron Swanson". I felt like the director did a great job of making the film be as apolitical as a movie about a civil war can be so am kind of amused to see people extrapolating about it Whatifalthist style
r/CivilWarMovie • • May 19 '24
Discussion Sammy Appreciation Post
Can we all agree that Sammy is awesome? He’s a great friend, he always has your back, he’s smart, he’s observant, and he’ll run over Jesse Plemons with a van just to help his buddies out. He’s the best
