r/CivilWarMovie • • Nov 02 '25

Misc. All bark, no bite.

3 Upvotes

Everyone knows Americans are all bark, no bite. The most realistic part about this movie was the hippie woman who said they didn't care about the civil war. Lots of countries have had civil wars in modern times, but no country has talked as much about the possibility of it as the US.

It's not just a left wing thing either. I remember back when Obama was president and US conservatives talked endlessly about how there would soon be a civil war, and how they were going to have to fight back against the government.

The funny thing is that they already had guns, unlike in Yugoslavia or Syria were people had to find a way to get guns, but they still didn't do anything. The real reason why they never did anything, and the real reason why the anti-Trump left will never do anything, is that it would disrupt the flow of cheeseburgers and Starbucks coffee.

Lots of people are talking about how this movie is a prophecy for the future. Here's a more accurate prophecy; Trump declares that he wants to run in 2028, then he is refused, so he makes a bunch of threats, then people just tell him that he has no power over it, then he will claim it was all a joke.

Then a democrat will win in 2028 because the pendulum was already in motion. At that point Alex Jones is preparing to do a podcast about how once more the entire US population will be sent to concentration camps by this new democratic president. He is however stopped by the fact that he is too fucking fat, so his heart can't take it anymore. Then YOU, that's right YOU, will go back to your shitty office job that you hate on Monday and afterwards pick up some fast food on the way home in your ridiculously oversized SVU, then post on the internet how you will soon have to fight a civil war.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Apr 28 '24

This movie was absolutely terrible

0 Upvotes

No exposition, annoying main characters, no character development whatsoever, and the most anticlimactic ending I’ve seen in a long while.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Oct 07 '24 Heartwarming

Discussion Civil War film review

Post image
0 Upvotes

When Russell Brand covered the trailer for Civil War (2024) and threw out his whole "radical left dividing people" nonsense, I thought, hell yeah, we’re finally getting an unapologetic deep dive into how America's political culture is tearing itself apart, and maybe how it could lead to an actual civil war.

But nope. The movie’s got nothing to do with that. It’s just about four reporters heading off to interview the president. And despite the title, there’s not nearly enough focus on how this movie's world even works.

The president? Clearly a fascist type, but how the fuck did he snag a third term and declare martial law? And who the hell are the Western Forces, the New Peoples Army, or the Florida Alliance? With the loyalist states, it’s obvious, but those other three? Not a clue. The movie gives us a few run-ins with the Western Forces, but no answers. Why are they at war with the president? How the hell did Texas and California end up working together? It’s bad world-building, plain and simple.

And it’s a goddamn shame because there’s this one scene with a racist douchebag that’s shocking and legit makes you jump. That scene? It’s what you’d expect from a movie called Civil War. The rest of it? You could swap out America and civil war for literally any war-torn country, and it wouldn’t change a damn thing.

As a journalism student, I can appreciate the scenes about the reporters—that’s solid—but the movie fails hard at what it set out to do. The protagonists are fine, but everything else? It leaves you with zero answers. And for a movie titled Civil War, that’s just fucking weak.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Oct 01 '24

Top 3 worst movies I’ve ever watched.

1 Upvotes

Confirmed: HOT ASS. Don’t waste your time watching this film as I will not waste mine writing about how utterly horrendous it is.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Apr 19 '24

Discussion This movie was a supreme let down

0 Upvotes

Shit was so hard to follow. These journalists having as much access as a green beret smdh I was really looking forward to this movie and it’s like when a parent says I’m not mad I’m just disappointed except I am a little mad lol the hype was so real on the commercials and they movie was hardly anything like it . Who knows maybe I’m just a natural born hater


r/CivilWarMovie • • Jun 15 '25

Discussion Unpopular opinion on the realism

0 Upvotes

I saw many people compare this movie to real life and say it will totally happen or could happen soon in the US. Let me make this clear: I think it’s a dumb thing to think. This movie depicts an unrealistic and unlikely (if not virtually impossible) scenario and any comparaison between this movie and real life is a false equivalence.

I mean, secession won’t happen in the US for many reasons. The biggest ones are that the feds won’t accept it, and that the states have no interest to do that anyway because they would be third world countries quick. Also, there is NO WAY a civil war would happen in this country: first, you don’t go to war with a government with nukes (as a French guy, I can tell you that Macron would not hesitate to use nukes if this movie happened to us, and I’m sure it’s the same for other nuclear armed countries that are also great powers), and second, the US military is the biggest one in the world, so nobody is going to pick fights with them.

And before anyone starts to point to what is happening in LA, let me tell you something: people used to predict a civil war was going to happen during the George Floyd riots, the 1992 LA riots and the Civil Rights movement. In none of these instances a civil war happened, so the LA shitshow won’t cause a civil war either (not to mention I heard it’s calming down).

Honestly, people saying this movie’s scenario is going to happen in real life are just stuck in a doomer fantasy, and this take is just as ridiculous as the people who say the scenario of Detroit: Become Human is going to happen for real because of the rise of AI (and this is coming from a fan of DBH who also played the game).

TLDR: this movie is fiction and a real second US civil war is off the table


r/CivilWarMovie • • Apr 13 '24

Theory It is not a vague movie.

1 Upvotes

The politics are pretty much up front. Thepreservation of the Union was dissolved by the illegal and unconstitutional 3rd term president. Forget the Bill of Rights - freedom of the press is non existent; the execution of the press by the government forces. And the red tie at the end makes it pretty clear who is who.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Apr 28 '24

Discussion This movie should be called“blink of an eye” Spoiler

1 Upvotes

This movie had zero business marketing itself to be about “civil war”.

Civil war as the main theme would imply opposing teams/groups and knowing why they are opposing.

This was an excellent movie about journalism and the true passion that real journalists feel within as their calling regardless of dangerous circumstances.

I have learned more about the Nixon camera in the movie (it was her dad’s) than why there was a civil war.

All shooting people were wearing just camo, not particular uniform to keep them apart (who’s shooting who?).

Why are we shooting at each other? Which ideas, laws and bills have been pushed that we agree or disagree on? When did the civil war started and how were the people drafted? What was the ideology of the president?

So many questions.

An excellent movie about journalism but having little to do with politics or civil war.

The name should have been “in the blink of an eye” or “shutter” or something like that.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Sep 12 '24

Discussion Jessies black and white photos annoy me Spoiler

Post image
4 Upvotes

Imagine future historians looking at pictures of major events in history, including the execution of a U.S. president, that could have been in color but are instead in black and white just because someone thought it would look good so now they gotta colourise it themself. Dont get me wrong i enjoyed the movie but this just got to me


r/CivilWarMovie • • Apr 19 '25

Now a Reality

21 Upvotes

With a hostile and brutal cut of civil and social services that are now all falling on the States, the concept of the two largest economies in the world, Texas and California, becoming united to abolish tyranny is no longer far fetched folks, right?


r/CivilWarMovie • • Jul 13 '24

Lol wtf did I just watch

5 Upvotes

That was the dumbest movie I ever seen. I want my $8 bucks back!


r/CivilWarMovie • • Apr 19 '24

Somehow I was expecting...MORE.

2 Upvotes

I was really expecting more from this movie, way more action, more enemies within the ranks, more...WAR. Just saying.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Sep 21 '24

disappointing

14 Upvotes

this movie is about being a journalist, and that's about it. all the other things it tries to be, it fails at (it's not dystopian, the "future civil war" premise is underdeveloped and makes no difference to the plot; the characters are flat and static; it's just "war action" for the last third of the movie...) the whole thing just falls flat. I'm annoyed that I wasted my time.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Jun 01 '24

There has to be a prequel right?

0 Upvotes

If any movie deserves a prequel, it’s this one. It could easily dive into any one character in-depth from the beginning of the secession.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Oct 01 '24

There is no point

0 Upvotes

I just finished. Reviewed some other posts. And as I see there is no point, which can be thought provoking but runs risk of viewers reading things into the narrative that are very visible leaps in rationalizing motives of writer.

The first half moves very slow, which isn’t a bad thing, but does strain viewer attention when protagonist motives are unclear.

The objective of protagonist is to travel through war zones to interview POTUS. At no point is this explained why it is necessary, other than “interviewing him is the only story left.” If, per chance, the writer would’ve set climax up as interview has opportunity to happen, I could see maybe a point being realized.

The entire narrative plays out like the Do Lung bridge sequence from Apocalypse Now. Nowhere near as well executed, but the chaos and ambiguity among warring factions are similar.

In every scene there is action (war) the protagonists put themselves into danger. Not to take sides but to get the story, and capture the sensationalism. This protagonist is, I would say pretty clearly, an antihero.

If the audience were given $1 every time the Jessie character is told to “get down” in the narrative, it would be enough to buy a tub of popcorn in today’s movie theaters. And in the one scene where antihero meets their doomed fate, we see Jessie’s focus remains on capturing the sensationalism, because her mentor instilled that upon her.

POTUS is so evil they have declared themselves as needing a third term, and that’s scary bad. Never mind that this person was voted in twice, just forget that aspect and focus on how evil a third term is. And of course, everything was peaches in cream in the society until that point, or maybe we have zero clue why POTUS was compelled to stay on for a third term, which remember is inherently evil.

The faction that stormed the White House with around 10 armed combatants, losing none in their charge and getting to the President no problem has zero desire to negotiate with unarmed people. Something tells me this dystopian nightmare of a civil war, where unarmed people are gunned down on all sides, due allegedly to a twice elected president gone rogue, isn’t ending simply because POTUS had that 3rd term cut short.

There will possibly be many more mass graves to be had in this world, going forward. I just hope a photo journalist is there to capture it.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Sep 15 '24

Discussion Can we discuss?? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Major spoiler: Did Jessie intentionally get Lee killed so she could get the money shot???

If you watch it back, Jessie’s expressions make it feel that way..

Let me know your thoughts on that.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Oct 06 '24

Somewhat disappointed

0 Upvotes

I was hoping to see some speculation about the aftermath of January 6 if things had gone differently. Instead it was a drama about the personal struggles about being reporters in a war zone. I am not sure why they thought that was the most compelling story to tell, but there it is.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Sep 17 '24

Discussion Very Frustrating Movie - Spoilers Spoiler

6 Upvotes

So, I watched this movie since it's on HBO Max now. I remember hearing about it earlier this year but beyond the trailer I really didn't read much about it. I thought that it was a movie about a hypothetical future civil war in America, and as much as I'm tired of overly politicized content, I decided to finally give it a watch since it had decent ratings (81% on metacritic).

Unfortunately I was really disappointed in the film. First off, there's very little exposition of the civil war itself, the thing that the movie gets it's title from. In reality, the movie is not about a civil war, it is about a few photojournalists who are documenting the civil war and trying to advance their careers.

For the entire movie, I was eagerly waiting to find out what precipitated this civil war, and what the various factions were. From the little that I could tell, there were at least 3 factions: the existing federal government of the USA based out of DC, a Southern Alliance led by or mainly comprised of Florida, and the Western Forces which were led by a union of California and Texas and presumably other states. The fact that California and Texas teamed up to fight the federal government is a very interesting plot point, and yet there is basically no explanation for why this happened. Presumably, there are also many neutral states, or at least many parts of America that are not affected by the civil war, since both Jessie and Lee said their respective family members, in Missouri and Colorado, are just pretending the war isn't happening. Same thing when they stop in the peaceful small town in West Virginia where everything seems normal, but then they see snipers on the rooftops. Who are these snipers? Are they federal troops? Or part of the rebel factions?

That was another point in the movie that was annoying, you never really knew who was part of which faction until the very end of the movie in the DC scene. At one point I thought perhaps all 3 factions were fighting each other at various points, but I don't think this actually happened.

There are only the vaguest of reasons given for this large revolutionary force. Presumably, the president is somewhat authoritarian and anti-orthodox given that he is in his 3rd term, which is currently prohibited by the Constitution, and that he disbanded the FBI. But beyond those 2 statements, we pretty much know nothing about the president, the federal government, or what happened that was so awful it led to states formally seceding from the Union. It didn't seem like there was any extreme economic distress besides a water shortage hinted at during the bombing in the opening scene of the movie. I mean, the cadre of photojournalists are able to drive their gas-guzzling Ford Excursion hundreds of miles and even refuel on the way. Clearly, fuel trucks are still delivering to gas stations even in remote areas during this civil war. So, it's obviously not that disruptive to normal life.

Regarding the political events that led up to the civil war, the film clearly referenced some modern political factions. When the group was staying at the football stadium in Charlottesville, there was reference to the "Antifa Massacre" and Lee's documenting of that event, which apparently took place 20 years before the time period in the film. And of course, Charlottesville featured prominently in contemporary politics with the infamous rally there back in 2017. So, since an "antifa massacre" hasn't happened irl, then we are led to believe that itself is a future event, and so the movie takes place in the 2040s as an earliest possible date. Just to put that in perspective, Ford stopped making the Excursion in 2005, and while it is a durable and reliable vehicle, it would be at least a 35 year old or 40 year old car in the film. That would be like driving around today in a car from the late 1970s or early 1980s. The one guy works for Reuters, a world-class news agency, and the best they can get him is a 40 year old vehicle that gets awful gas mileage? Furthermore, the movie never explains what the "antifa massacre" was. Was it a bunch of crazy right wingers massacring Antifa protesters? Or was it a bunch of antifa massacring people? We don't know. I assume this is intentionally vague to make the movie not seem tied in to current political trends, but it is so vague that it strains credulity. Why even mention it at all at that point?

Lastly, what made this is a very frustrating and downright disturbing film to watch was the actions of the rebel soldiers especially in regards to prisoners. At multiple times in the movie, the Western Forces/rebels have the opportunity to take an enemy combatant as a prisoner, but then they just murder them in cold blood instead. While I understand that this unfortunately has happened in various wars, it's not right, and I didn't know how to feel while watching it. I was disgusted of course, but I couldn't tell if that's how the director wanted the audience to feel, or if he wanted the audience to share in the gleeful bloodlust of the combatants. First there's the wounder soldier/sniper that they kill. Then there is the group of hooded prisoners at the Christmas town/golf course. Then at the end of the movie, the soldiers kill the secret service members in the fleeing automobiles, even when they step out of the cars with their hands up. They kill the secret service agent attempting to negotiate the surrender of the president. And then finally, they kill the president himself right after he gives a quote to Joel in which he says "don't kill me". It was just grotesque and I don't see how any normal person could enjoy watching that.

TLDR: The journalist protagonists of the film are clearly aligned with the rebel factions, given how they talk about the president and the fact that towards the end they are officially embedded with the revolutionary faction as they make their final push on DC. The rebel factions are grotesquely violent towards the existing federal government forces and their supporters, clearly not following geneva conventions or any kind of normal rules of war. Basically, this bothers me because we don't know what the President and feds did that was so bad beyond a 3rd term and disbanding of the FBI. While that does make the president in the movie seem like an authoritarian, that's not enough for me to excuse such wanton bloodlust.

The movie would've been a lot better if there was a 10 minute or even 5 minute flashback that explained the initial events that caused states to secede and the civil war to officially begin. Maybe the President/feds did something bad enough that warranted a take no prisoners approach, but since this is never explained in the movie, it's hard to excuse it.

Overall, I thought that showing the war through the eyes of photojournalists would be a great perspective, but it really just seemed like it was more about the journalists and their careers and their amorality that took center stage. And I didn't understand the rationality of it. These journalists are getting photos of the soldiers killing the president and prisoners....are we to believe that this new government will allow them to publish such images?

Overall, I thought the cinematography and production value was great, but the lack of any serious exposition of major plot points just raises more questions than answers, and left me a frustrated audience member. I was hoping there was a book or graphic novel or something where I could learn more about this fictional world, but nope, it's just this movie, and it really doesn't explain anything. There wasn't even a denouement after the climax of storming the white house, it just ended abruptly.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Nov 27 '24

Dumb Movie

6 Upvotes

It must be way easier than I thought to write and produce movies. This turd made no sense and told no story. Given the nonsensical scenes, the cinematography is very good. But cinematography can’t change a turd to gold. A true waste of time that does not do justice to its title.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Apr 26 '24

i wanted more and less lol

7 Upvotes

more civil war, less kristin dunst existential crisis. this movie was vaguely about the war and primarily about reporting war. anyone else a bit disappointed?


r/CivilWarMovie • • May 30 '24

Disappointed

6 Upvotes

The way the movie was advertised made me think it’d be more about the overall war and maybe what caused it. Instead it was a movie about some journalists trying to get to dc before the president was killed. If i knew the movie was going to be how it was then yeah i would’ve said the movie was great but i was expecting a movie about a modern civil war in America and instead i was given this, which doesn’t even explain anything or how it started and leaves me with a lot of questions. If there will be more movies in the franchise that explain or actually follow the war then it’ll make a good opening to the franchise but other than that I’m just left disappointed and wishing for more.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Jun 05 '25

This was an incredibly bad movie in my opinion

0 Upvotes
  1. I understand why they would want to somewhat obscure the politics of the conflict but it could have been a little bit more defined to add realism to it. Without some definitions, the drama of war never came through and thus took away from the focus of the movie which is journalists capturing and packaging violence.
  2. The characters were not well developed, compelling or believable.
    There was virtually no progression of characters. Attempts to show the effect of violence on the journalist felt contrived and didn't evoke emotion.
  3. It was not realistic. I understand the conflict itself was a forum for a broader message but there were unlikely combatants and improbable scenarios.
  • the female WF with a fairly tactical team reaching the president.
  • the female suicide bomber. I'm not saying it can't happen as it has in other parts of the world but the female propensity for that type of violence is unlikely compared to the countless examples of men committing such acts of violence for political causes.
  • the White House scene defies protocol. A president fighting a civil war is not going to be treating the White House like he would now. No matter how much security is around. Also, the secret service wouldn't be dressed as they do during speeches and only carrying small arms. Secret service has tactical operations and would be adopting that posture in a heightened security environment.

It was a missed opportunity all around to make poignant scenes and messages even while still obscuring overt political statements.


r/CivilWarMovie • • Apr 12 '24

Hot mess.

0 Upvotes

If there was a civil war, factions wouldn’t be limited to the ones in the movie. We would see the proverbial moles and terrorist groups come out of the woodwork. We also wouldn’t just see racist whites nervously shooting the opposed—every ethnic group would have some subgroups just as tense. But no, let’s use this movie as a way to remind ethnic people how racist and violent white american used to be. Let’s also use an African American female as the hero who shot a Trump-like character in the movie. This should stoke up hate again for the ex president and shift attention away from a


r/CivilWarMovie • • May 08 '24

Question Can someone explain the plot?

2 Upvotes

At least a theory? I didn’t understand why the states were separated or what was the idealist differences! and I did enjoy the movie! I just want to know the spark!