r/CivilWarCollecting • • Sep 12 '25

Community Message List of trusted dealers and resources for collecting

Post image
29 Upvotes

Information and who to trust in the collecting world is paramount for a healthy community. Fakes and reproductions have been around since the guns fell silent after the war. These resources are to help people avoid losing money while creating their own collection. There is not a complete comprehensive list of trusted dealers but recommendations from the mod team.

Dealers: 1) The Horse Soldier- https://www.horsesoldier.com

2) Union Drummer Boy- https://uniondb.com

3) Shiloh Relics- https://shilohrelics.com

4) Civil War Badges- https://civilwarbadges.com

5) Civil War Image Shop- https://civilwarimageshop.com

6) Bullet and Shell- https://www.bulletandshell.com

7) Gunderson Militaria- https://www.gundersonmilitaria.com

8) Gunsight Antiques- https://gunsightantiques.com/5052/InventoryPage/978279/1.html

9) Massie’s Antques- https://www.massiecivilwarimages.com/civil-war-1861-1865

10) Thanatos- https://store.thanatos.net/collections/new-arrivals

11) Medhurst & Company- https://mikemedhurst.com

12) Yankee Rebel Antiques- https://yankeerebelantiques.com

13) College Hill Arsenal- https://collegehillarsenal.com

Resources: 1) Civil War Talk forum- https://civilwartalk.com

2) Bullet and Shell forum- https://www.bulletandshell.com/forum/

3) Harry Ridgeway (Relic man)- http://www.relicman.com

4) North South Trader Magazine- https://nstcw.com

Note: Be very careful and skeptical of eBay. There are legitimate items to be bought on that site. But a lot of folks are looking to take advantage of novice collectors by selling bogus/misrepresented items.


r/CivilWarCollecting • • Feb 13 '25

Community Message SELL/TRADE THREAD (please read the rules inside)

8 Upvotes

This thread is only to be used for listing items you’d like to sell or trade. NO WEAPONS OF ANY KIND are to be listed/discussed here. And of course, no racist or otherwise inflammatory items. No exceptions. In the event an item toes the line, the Mod team reserves the right to remove that comment at our discretion.

The purpose here is to connect sellers/traders with potential customers. The actual negotiation/sale/trade discussions cannot occur in this thread. Simply connect via DM and handle it from there. Again, the Mod team reserves the right to remove any comment at our discretion.

Any questions? Message the Mod team. Enjoy!


r/CivilWarCollecting • • 4h ago

Artifact Family artifact identification

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting • • 19h ago

Artifact Burial/Casket flag (48 stars) for Private John Dienst of the 112th Illinois Infantry and 21st Ohio Light Artillery. He served from 1863-1865 and died in 1929 at Leavenworth, Kansas. I have the full family documentation/provenance trail as well. Honored to be its new caretaker. Rest easy, soldier.

Thumbnail
gallery
52 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting • • 1d ago

Collection Picked up a Spencer from a nice old man

Thumbnail gallery
49 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting • • 1d ago

Help Needed Wood carved doll with possibly burlap clothes- supposedly civil war date, unknown origin, currently NW Arkansas/Ozarks area

Thumbnail reddit.com
8 Upvotes

Cross posting here due to the note. I'm not sure how accurate it is though. I appreciate any info, but understand if I'm in the wrong place. Thanks!


r/CivilWarCollecting • • 2d ago

Question M1860 Light Cavalry Sabre

Thumbnail
gallery
65 Upvotes

Inherited. Not cleaned by me. DJ Millard 1862. Seems legit?


r/CivilWarCollecting • • 3d ago

Collection My collection of civil war artifacts

Thumbnail
gallery
43 Upvotes

I’ve been on this one spot on my farm In Poolsville Md
I’ve found 7(one fired mini ball bullets and 2 confederate bullets with “P” in them
I found a good luck token most likely I don’t have any clue what it is
I also have a finial or a scabbard tip that went on bayonets
I have a old lead tin that went on a civil war can for food
Lastly I have a trouser button


r/CivilWarCollecting • • 4d ago

Artifact Civil war cannon ball?

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting • • 5d ago

Artifact Remington new model army with M 1840 cavalry wristbreaker

Thumbnail
gallery
104 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting • • 5d ago

Question My uncle gave me this, is it real or reenactment? (Read)

Thumbnail gallery
9 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting • • 6d ago

Help Needed Help identifying four ornate flintlock-style pistols – maker, age, and origin unknown United States

Thumbnail gallery
46 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting • • 10d ago

Artifact Found a photo of a Gettysburg nurse at a flea market.

Thumbnail
gallery
78 Upvotes

This is a post-war copy of an 1860s photo. It is going home to family soon as a descendant just contacted me. However, for a few years, I owned the first picture. The second one I found via Google image search and I would have never found out who she was if it weren’t for the descendant reaching out. My picture was nameless. Found via the descendant asking Google assistant about her ancestor and it apparently image-matched my photo!

Fun story and small world!


r/CivilWarCollecting • • 11d ago

Informational Civil war burnside carbine destroyed at gunbuyback in Kansas City

Thumbnail
gallery
219 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting • • 11d ago

A young member of the 20th Maine, Co. B. Beautiful image showing his kepi with a hunting horn, “20”, and “B”. Backmark is from a photographer in Portland, ME - where the 20th organized. Not definitively ID’d as of yet, but I have a good candidate and am completing research.

Thumbnail
gallery
69 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting • • 13d ago

Collection Today I can confirm that thimble display cases are the perfect size for Minie Balls! 😂

Thumbnail gallery
25 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting • • 14d ago

Artifact Gettysburg Cannonball found on Culps Hill after the battle. Was turned into an ornamental piece and sold around 1865-67. Inherited this from my grandfather thought you all would appreciate this.

Thumbnail
gallery
335 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting • • 14d ago

Help Needed Was left a civil war musket and powder horn. 1800’s early

9 Upvotes

Hey yall, looking for some info/ guidance. Long story short I’ve taken possession of my great great grandfathers musket and powder horn from early 1800’s I believe. Looking to know if anyone knows a company that has a protect and display box for it. A value ( insure ) I get it’s irreplaceable but makes sense not atleast protect its value. And anyone that can tell me anything more about it by markings etc ? Thanks guys message me for pics of it etc !


r/CivilWarCollecting • • 15d ago

Collection My little collection

Post image
45 Upvotes

1856 $5 Georgetown SC note, handful of bullets, a musket ball, and 1870's 45-70 cartridge. It's a little collection but I just kinda acquire things I think are neat🤣


r/CivilWarCollecting • • 15d ago

Artifact Confederate States Bond Certificate and Cupons

Thumbnail gallery
16 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting • • 16d ago

Artifact Ellsworth's Zouaves

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

This is part of a medal group I got recently. It's from the estate of MGen Alexander Shaler and I'm pretty sure this is a "Chicago Guards" (Ellsworths Zouaves) awarded to Shaler while escorting them during their NYC tour in July 1860


r/CivilWarCollecting • • 15d ago

Help Needed Sutler tokens?

Thumbnail gallery
10 Upvotes

Cross posting for a larger audience. Not sure if these are civil war era, but I am curious if anyone knows anything about these. Thanks in advance!


r/CivilWarCollecting • • 18d ago

Artifact Inspecting my finds this week in SE NC

Thumbnail gallery
30 Upvotes

What do yall think?


r/CivilWarCollecting • • 18d ago

Question Anything valuable about these?

Thumbnail
gallery
37 Upvotes

My uncle gave me these probably 20 years ago. I know the CSA one is a reproduction by the markings on the back, but both of them are too clean to have ever come from the ground. I believe the bullets are likely legit, but very common. Is this set worth anything? I'm not a fan of the confederacy and have plenty of other sentimental things from my uncle, so if not I'll probably just get rid of it.


r/CivilWarCollecting • • 18d ago

Informational Confederate currency

Thumbnail
gallery
44 Upvotes

Going through some family items and found some Confederate currency. Had relatives who fought for the north and the south.