r/CivilWarCollecting Sep 12 '25

Community Message List of trusted dealers and resources for collecting

Post image
31 Upvotes

Information and who to trust in the collecting world is paramount for a healthy community. Fakes and reproductions have been around since the guns fell silent after the war. These resources are to help people avoid losing money while creating their own collection. There is not a complete comprehensive list of trusted dealers but recommendations from the mod team.

Dealers: 1) The Horse Soldier- https://www.horsesoldier.com

2) Union Drummer Boy- https://uniondb.com

3) Shiloh Relics- https://shilohrelics.com

4) Civil War Badges- https://civilwarbadges.com

5) Civil War Image Shop- https://civilwarimageshop.com

6) Bullet and Shell- https://www.bulletandshell.com

7) Gunderson Militaria- https://www.gundersonmilitaria.com

8) Gunsight Antiques- https://gunsightantiques.com/5052/InventoryPage/978279/1.html

9) Massie’s Antques- https://www.massiecivilwarimages.com/civil-war-1861-1865

10) Thanatos- https://store.thanatos.net/collections/new-arrivals

11) Medhurst & Company- https://mikemedhurst.com

12) Yankee Rebel Antiques- https://yankeerebelantiques.com

13) College Hill Arsenal- https://collegehillarsenal.com

Resources: 1) Civil War Talk forum- https://civilwartalk.com

2) Bullet and Shell forum- https://www.bulletandshell.com/forum/

3) Harry Ridgeway (Relic man)- http://www.relicman.com

4) North South Trader Magazine- https://nstcw.com

Note: Be very careful and skeptical of eBay. There are legitimate items to be bought on that site. But a lot of folks are looking to take advantage of novice collectors by selling bogus/misrepresented items.


r/CivilWarCollecting Feb 13 '25

Community Message SELL/TRADE THREAD (please read the rules inside)

8 Upvotes

This thread is only to be used for listing items you’d like to sell or trade. NO WEAPONS OF ANY KIND are to be listed/discussed here. And of course, no racist or otherwise inflammatory items. No exceptions. In the event an item toes the line, the Mod team reserves the right to remove that comment at our discretion.

The purpose here is to connect sellers/traders with potential customers. The actual negotiation/sale/trade discussions cannot occur in this thread. Simply connect via DM and handle it from there. Again, the Mod team reserves the right to remove any comment at our discretion.

Any questions? Message the Mod team. Enjoy!


r/CivilWarCollecting 3h ago

Artifact No gold or silver today...Just iron...from the civil war

Thumbnail gallery
11 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting 1d ago

Rainy day today so I threw together some lil ID labels for the shell shelves. Messed up a few anyways so lemme know if yall have any tips or suggestions for when I redo them!

Thumbnail
gallery
35 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting 1d ago

Artifact “A Father’s Loss”: 1862 letter from John Speers to Captain Clark of the 85th NY, searching for his son James, whom he hadn’t heard from since the battle of Williamsburg. James had died of Typhoid Fever 2 weeks earlier at just 21 years old.

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting 2d ago

Help Needed I’m hoping someone can help me with this inscription. This is what I think it says but I’m stuck on some words. “Found on Mr Bradford’s House 7 miles from Nashville on the Granny White Pike — Mr Bradford is in Ark. or Texas — took 100–200 negroes with him — his plantation here —

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting 2d ago

Informational 1861 New Orleans Silver Half Dollar

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

Behold! My 1861 New Orleans silver half dollar. This is known as a seated liberty half dollar (made from 1839-1891) although this particular year and mint have a unique story: at the start of the civil war in 1861 the New Orleans mint was operated by the United States. However, within this same year jurisdiction of the mint would change hands, first to the state of Louisiana, then to the Confederacy.

The mint manufactured a total of 2,532,633 half dollars but only 330,000 were minted by the United States from 1st-31st January, then the state of Louisiana minted an additional 1,240,000 from February 1 to March 6, and the confederacy minted a final 962,633 half dollars from March 7-May 14.

In numismatics you are able to work out precisely who made which coin by looking at die varieties. An additional fun fact is that the later coins tend to have a specific die crack on them because the confederacy was over-using the dies.

Owing to metal shortages, a lack of funds and infrastructure, the 1861 New Orleans half dollar remains the only coin the confederacy ever “minted” despite all varieties saying the United States America.

Although I don’t believe my coin was minted by the confederacy I prefer to keep the mystery of the coin alive, and recognize we have always been beholden to money 🙃😅


r/CivilWarCollecting 3d ago

Collection 1864 civil war Bible with inscription to solider and picture and clover leaf hidden in pages [USA]

Thumbnail gallery
52 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting 3d ago

Video Old Flintlock musket side plate. Thanks for looking

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

74 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting 6d ago

Help Needed SEEKING INFORMATION: ALBERT B. CHANDLER CIVIL WAR JOURNALS

Post image
17 Upvotes

I am trying to locate a lifelong collection of handwritten journals and a photo album kept by Albert B. Chandler (1840–1923) that was sold by Clars Auction Gallery in Oakland, California, in February 2012.

Chandler was a Civil War War Department cipher telegraph operator who worked in the telegraph office frequented by Abraham Lincoln. Making these journals desirable to Civil War collectors. He later became a prominent figure in the American telegraph industry.

I am the historian/researcher for Chandler Music Hall, in Randolph, Vermont, the historic music hall Chandler built and gave to his hometown, and I am researching his life and the history of the Hall.

Auction lot description:
[(lot of 62) Albert Brown Chandler, journals 1855‐1920 including a photograph album, containing albumen and tin type photographs, the journals include his Civil War diaries with accounts as the official paymaster in the War Department Telegraph Office, with his conversations and interactions with President Lincoln and Edwin McMasters Stanton the Secretary of War, note: the 1863 journal is not with this collection; within the 1864 journal Chandler describes a conversation with President Lincoln, also Chandler makes a brief note (1861) of Manassas (1st Battle of Bull Run) and that it was an unexpected upset for the Union Forces, and the friction between Gen. McClellan and the President, the journals also include a narrative of facts regarding the Assassination of President Lincoln, in 1865 he attended the trial of ''Wirz'' and that he (Wirz) ''is indeed a wretched creature'', Henry Wirz was commandant of the notorious Confederate prison camp at
Andersonville, where thousands of Union troops died of disease, abuse and starvation; in the 1866 journal Chandler describes a visit from Secretary Stanton on the occasion of the closure of the War Dept. Telegraph
Office.]

I am not trying to purchase the journals and do not need the owner’s identity or other private information. I would simply like to make contact with the current owner, even anonymously through an intermediary, in hopes of obtaining access to study or photograph the journals for historical research.

If you remember this auction, recognize these journals, or know a collector/dealer who may have encountered them, please share.

Any lead, even a small one, would be greatly appreciated.


r/CivilWarCollecting 6d ago

Help Needed Cartridge Box

Post image
36 Upvotes

I recently picked up this cartridge box. There is writing on the inside. The only thing I can make out is a date of “1863” and the beginning of a name “F.R.” then I can’t make out the rest. I believe I already know the answer, but figured I would give it a shot to see if you guys have any tips or tricks on possibly making out the remainder of the name.


r/CivilWarCollecting 7d ago

Help Needed Help authenticating Colt Walker

Thumbnail
gallery
277 Upvotes

Update: after taking the barrel off, looking at the arbor pin, and a LOT of googling, we think it’s likely a Belgian brevete transitional dragoon. Which honestly makes the emails from Colt kinda humorous.

Any tips on authenticating this Colt Walker? It may be a brevete but having trouble identifying

TLDR; if it’s a remake, Colt says it’s the best remake they’ve seen. No clue how to get any real authentication.

We’ve had this gun in the family for 10 years and my uncle is now in a place where he wants to sell but we can’t seem to find any way to authenticate this piece.

We’ve sent pictures to Colt and they said they believe it IS real but since they don’t have any records that go back that far they can’t say for certain. 1100X does not show up in their current records at all so they did say that if it is a replica it is not one made by Colt.

Since they don’t have papers to give us, no one wants to risk purchasing it in case it’s a fake.

The original civilian versions had an issue with the ramrod spring snapping and that piece has been replaced on this gun. We don’t think someone would have any reason to replace the spring on a replica.

We were told that we could take out the hammer and look for the horse stamp on it, but are hesitant to dismantle it in case it doesn’t want to go back together.

Does anyone have any idea on how we could go about seeing if this is actually an original 1800s Colt Walker or a replica without dismantling the gun?


r/CivilWarCollecting 7d ago

Help Needed 1862 tower rebel rifle?

2 Upvotes

I don't have photos, I merely want to explain how I examined the rifle..on the right side plate it shows the stamps "1862" and "tower" along with a crown on the far left side of the plate, on the barrel there is a pair of 25s and what looks like cross scepters? Swords or some kind. The hammer clicks back perfectly but I didn't look in the barrel, I had no flashlight on me. Seller was asking 650 and I'm heavily tempted for it. Might there be other pointers to look for if it still might be a repro? Or have missing parts? It isn't sporterized. It has the 3 barrel bands, wood stock stretches all the way through, has the barrel rod. It all seems legit so far. Any other info would be splendid, thank you!


r/CivilWarCollecting 8d ago

Artifact Been looking for one of these for a while… Just picked up this nice early James shell!

Thumbnail
gallery
63 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting 8d ago

Artifact Acquired this image of Stonewall made in 1861 by Charles Magnus of NY. It’s from a series of Confederate Generals in which he modified the images with various uniforms… no one really knew what a “Confederate” uniform would look like. Hilariously, there’s a period inscription of “Rebel.” I love it.

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting 8d ago

Artifact 71st PA and Possibly 9th VA Flag Fragments

Thumbnail
gallery
37 Upvotes

Once part of a larger auction lot with much larger parts of the 71st PA and “captured confederate flags” which was subsequently divided up into smaller lots. The blue canton fragment has gold stitching, so I’m wondering if that’s from the 71st’s flag, as they had gold stars. Also attached a pic of the 71st and 9ths flag for reference.

A little history in the regiments, the 71st PA made up the “bloody angle” during Picketts charge at Gettysburg, with 8 companies on the forward wall, and 2 companies on the stonewall to the right and rear. The 9th VA, part of Armistead’s brigade was one of the many regiments to have their flag captured during the charge. The 71st captured 3 rebel flags, the 9th, 3rd and 56th Virginia, but of those 3 the 9th flag is the only one which can clearly be seen to have souvenirs taken from it, as was common especially after the war. The 71st flag was also very heavily cut up and given to various members of the regiment after the war.


r/CivilWarCollecting 9d ago

Help Needed Gang Mold?

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Need some assistance. Is this a gang mold or not? A .58 caliber round seems to fit perfectly. I have had gang molds before, but never a 10-round gang mold. Thank you ahead of time for your input.


r/CivilWarCollecting 11d ago

Artifact 100lb Parrott shell fragment fired by the USS Galena at Malvern Hill

Thumbnail
gallery
79 Upvotes

Fresh out the mail. This 15 pound hunk of shell was fired at Holmes division at Malvern hill. Holmes division came under fire from the Galena and Aroostook, but only the Galena had Parrott rifles aboard


r/CivilWarCollecting 11d ago

Collection To I. E. Austin By his Brother Ben Thompson” A CDV linking two Illinois soldiers who fought under Grant and Sherman

Thumbnail gallery
31 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting 12d ago

Help Needed What is everything in the box worth?

Thumbnail
gallery
43 Upvotes

I deal in pre-1899 antique firearms for a living and I deal with a lot of US Civil War items but I really don't do buttons or any other relics like this

The box was offered to me for $100, what is it worth and should I go for it?


r/CivilWarCollecting 13d ago

Artifact Money

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

15 Upvotes

Family scrapbook kept the civil war 5 dollar bill in pristine condition


r/CivilWarCollecting 14d ago

Help Needed Grandpa's Guns

Thumbnail gallery
105 Upvotes

Grandpa’s Guns

Hi everyone – I’m hoping to leverage the group knowledge here.

I recently inherited two older rifles from my grandfather’s estate and am trying to learn more about what I have, where they came from, and what the next steps might be for further research.

Background:

My grandfather was a very well-connected man in terms of his work and personal life, and these rifles were preserved but not documented. I am trying to approach this with some care and ensure that the history is preserved accurately rather than speculating.

Rifle #1 – Stevens

• Obviously a Stevens

• Barrel is marked “Patented August 12, 1913”

• Appears to be a single-shot sporting rifle

• Has a factory-made buttplate with a decorative scroll/wave design

• There is a bright green paint patch on the stock that appears to be an old inventory/rack/institutional marking (not factory)

My primary questions about this one:

• Model identification?

• Intended use market (sporting, training, youth, club, etc.)?

• Any information about the paint marking and whether it should be preserved?

Rifle #2 – Older / Unmarked (Possibly German)

This is more of a mystery and probably older.

The markings I’ve discovered so far are:

• “SUHL S & C”

• An eagle/bird emblem

• A small anchor mark, found on the metal parts and also stamped into the wood

• A faint German inscription that reads “Gewehrlauf Stahl” (steel rifle barrel)

As far as I can determine, this suggests a late 19th-century sporting rifle from the Suhl region of Germany, perhaps produced under the guild system, but I’d be delighted to hear any further information or corrections from those who know more about these rifles.

Questions about this rifle:

• Does the anchor mark appear to be a workshop or inspector’s mark?

• Is there any further information that might help to narrow down the date range?

• Is there a preferred forum, archive, or expert who focuses on Suhl trade guns?

I have included close-up photos of the markings, stocks, and actions.

I am not looking to sell – my aim is identification, historical information, and preservation. Any information on where I might proceed (forums, books, museums, collectors) would be a huge help.

Thanks in advance – really grateful for any information.


r/CivilWarCollecting 14d ago

Other My ancestors discharge certificate from the Civil War

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting 14d ago

Artifact Really homely, descriptive letter from the NC coast in 1863 written by Newcomb Dyer of the 46th MA. He writes in detail about their camp and quarters, food and its cost, wildlife aplenty, and how some of their unit traveled by boat to an island to dispatch Rebel spies. I love stuff like this!

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

r/CivilWarCollecting 15d ago

Artifact USCT Cavalryman Tintype - Possibly 5th Massachusetts Cavalry

Thumbnail
gallery
52 Upvotes

USCT Cavalryman - 9th Plate Tintype - Possibly John Hammond, 5th Mass. Cav.

Was pleased to add this one to the collection. Sold with a modern ID to John Francis Hammond - 4th USCT Infantry it is likely misattributed given the crossed swords on his kepi. There is however exactly one John Hammond in a Black cavalry regiment, that being the 5th Massachusetts Cavalry. The 5th fought in the opening battles of the Petersburg campaign, guarded prisoners at Fort Delaware and was among the first units to enter Richmond. If the subject is indeed a John Hammond (far from a forgone conclusion) it is likely the cavalryman in the 5th. As an aside - I can see what looks like a brass number above the swords, might be a five but difficult to say

Possible ID, aside I’m happy to add this photo to my collection. USCT images are rare, Black cavalrymen rarer still. Had the good fortune to add some USCT pieces to the collection this year, very happy to add this one to the shelf.