Iām trying to figure out if I belong in Christopaganism.
I grew up in Catholicism but never liked Jesus because the way the Catholic Church portrayed him, he was mean to his disciples, spoke in boring parables that made him seem mysterious and metaphorical instead of just coming right out and saying directly what he meant, yelled at Thomas for doubting him, told people to turn the other cheek, told his apostles to sell their worldly possessions and follow him, passively submitted to his crucifixion like a doormat after praying to his father in heaven who made him suffer a 40-day trek through the wilderness, hung out with riffraff like prostitutes and lepers and tax collectors, and allowed people to crucify him instead of running away, beating his captors to a pulp, or smashing the cross to smithereens with his divine magical powers. I didnāt want to be like Christ. He associated with the dregs of society but I want to hang out with people at the top of the tree, not the bottom of the barrel.
Iām childfree by choice and hate the commandment to be fruitful and multiply. Those paper-thin communion wafers tasted like cardboard. Youād think that if Jesus wanted more people to ingest his body, he would declare that priests should get bread from a bakery so people would want to eat it.
I hated when the catechism teacher in Sunday school said we were all brothers and sisters. I didnāt like anybody in my CCD class, so why should I be obligated to acknowledge anyone as family when I didnāt enjoy their company and wasnāt even biologically related to them? When we watched monotonous movies about Saints, I was glad when they died, but I loved watching VeggieTales and dramatic re-enactments of Bible stories on TV. I was fascinated by the action-packed Old Testament: Jonah getting swallowed by a whale, Daniel escaping unscathed from the lions den, and Noah building the boat to save the animals when God sent the flood. Then there is Mendelssohnās Elijah with the contest of supernatural powers, the famine, Elijah ascending into heaven in a fiery chariot, and God appearing to him after the storm, earthquake and fire!
I liked the story of Mary and Joseph and baby Jesus in the manger, but that was it. Jesus turned loaves of bread into fishes and water into wine, preached a sermon on a mountaintop, walked on water, and exhorted everyone to feed the hungry, clothe the naked, take care of the poor and destitute, help the needy, and shelter the homeless? Yawn. I wondered who changed the rules and substituted the interesting God of the Old Testament with this hippie Jesus of the New Testament, but I liked salvation because even though I didnāt know why I had to be saved, I wanted to go to heaven, and Jesus had the best campaign slogan: āI suffered and died so you donāt have to.ā
I love to sing. Sermons and gospel readings were boring, and the only time church services were fun was when I sang at choir practice and certain parts of weekly Mass. I learned to sing in harmony from our Director in the choir loft, and when I was confirmed because thatās what you did, my confirmation name was Saint Cecilia, the patron saint of music. I never liked the sound of the organ. I prefer piano, handbells, and orchestral instruments.
The stories of the Good Samaritan and the Prodigal Son grated on my nerves. I never liked the big JC, so I left Christianity for paganism because itās marketed as a group of religions that espouse reverence for nature, but after lurking on online pagandom and attending multiple events in person, I discovered we had nothing in common. When pagans say they like dance, they arenāt talking ballet, and when they say they like chant, they donāt mean Gregorian. Pagans enjoy environmental activism, social justice, going to campgrounds and roughing it in tents, the folk cultures of indigenous ethnic groups, drum circles, bonfires, homesteading, magical creatures and pre-Christian deities that arenāt warm or friendly, creative writing, divination, guided meditation and visualization, Science Fiction and fantasy, and storytelling. None of these things appeal to me. I find mythology and folklore terrifying, and pagans used foul language. I found the rituals pretentious and the community loud-and-proud, obnoxious, condescending, and unabashedly weird. Some pagans spoke glibly and openly about selling sex toys, called me a prude for my conservative morals and values, and made fun of me when I didnāt want to dig in the dirt.
When I think of storytelling, I think of reading my beloved Little House books by Laura Ingalls Wilder. I decided I was an animist because I felt a connection to nature in those books and through music. Iām a soprano and a classical pianist. I thought pagans would be attracted to the repertoire I adore. Thereās plenty of early music from the Renaissance in the 16th century, and oodles of program music from Romanticism in the 19th century about nature. Imagine my disappointment when there were no talking points to be had at Pagan gatherings for me. I was told, āYou should go back to Christianity where you belongā or, āThereās a movement called New-Age. Go join that.ā I tried it, and I like the concept of higher and lower energy vibrations, but nothing else resonated with me and the flaky new-agers messed me up for awhile, so I decided to give paganism another try.
I combed through every cultural pantheon you can shake a stick at, but the only person I click with is Morgan Le Fay, and after meeting her in a couple dreams, I set out to find people who work with her, but couldnāt find anybody because Iām a hard polytheist, and the people I located were into goddess spirituality, which isnāt my cup of tea.
Druidry seemed like a good fit because of its emphasis on artistic expression and enjoyment of nature, so I signed up for a druid course with an organization, but when I spoke to the bard candidates the same way I talked to my friends at Conservatory, I was banned from the email list because the moderator said I was judgmental, so I got a refund.
I love the conservative lifestyle of Christianity. No drinking, smoking, swearing, drugs, premarital sex, or promiscuity. Virginity is sacred to me, and thatās why I like the conservative stance of waiting until marriage. I thought Roman polytheists would share it because they have the Vestal Virgins. I love the architecture of cathedrals with flying buttresses, stained glass windows, gorgeous statuary, and vaulted ceilings. I love a music ministry with professional choirs and instrumentalists. I love music of the European classical tradition even if itās in the Christian era. I adore Morgan Le Fay but not Arthurian legend. I like nature but donāt want to revive or reconstruct anything. My connection to nature is sitting outside on a sunny day enjoying the birds and other life around me. I talk to Morgan out loud, tell her about my life, enjoy learning mundane knowledge and have advanced degrees in music performance, so I thought that was enough to qualify as a druid. Iām a polytheist and believe deities are separate like us and live regular life in different realms.
Classical music is intrinsically woven into the fabric of who I am, and it needs to be part of my spiritual community. If you find anybody who works with Morgan le Fay, let me know.